Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by ravenstine on Monday October 10, 2016 @12:15PM
(#12677961)
On a side topic, why isn't there a sort of escrow for research groups where they can receive money and return results without knowing who is funding them? Or does such a thing exist? That might be a great way for a person to tell how much credibility a study has, besides the actual methodologies used.
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by mathattack on Monday October 10, 2016 @02:08PM
(#12678782)
Big companies and industry groups wouldn't fund research unless they knew the outcome, or could influence the spin. If it didn't have a positive NPV, they wouldn't do it.
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by cmurphycode on Monday October 10, 2016 @03:45PM
(#12679341)
That's probably true for a lot of studies, but companies with legitimately useful products would still be interested in getting independent validation so they can advertise said study, right? We are jaded by Coca-Cola, but there are actually healthy things and useful medications in the world!
Of course, in reality, the escrow may not be enough to remove the bias, but it's an interesting thought.
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by ravenstine on Monday October 10, 2016 @07:09PM
(#12680499)
What you said is something I had in mind. While nefarious corporations might not even bother, I don't doubt that there are plenty of businesses out there who can hypothesize a high likelihood that a study will work in their favor and, therefore, it might be worth facilitating the research in a way to try and limit their influence. Granted, this is assuming a best-case universe where enough people actually care whether a study was done this way or not. Then again, maybe it's one of those things that should be tried to see what happens.
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by mathattack on Monday October 10, 2016 @07:19PM
(#12680569)
For a pool to work, would they need to offer money funding generic research on a topic, or anonymously fund specific research? The former doesn't allow for much incentive to the corporations, and the latter seems easily gamed.
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by tuna-piano on Monday October 10, 2016 @12:33PM
(#12678119)
Great idea. The fund would list all the studies they need done, as well as the funding, and dole out the money for a small management fee.
They use part of this management fee to invest in their brand, so that studies that don't carry the "neutral-study-guarantee" sticker are treated less seriously than those that do.
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by CWuestefeld on Monday October 10, 2016 @03:40PM
(#12679312)
There's a key difference in the suggestion, compared to the government: there could be many such organizations, each having different priorities and values which would lead to them funding different things. People and corporations interested in making a difference would have a choice.
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by csydas on Monday October 10, 2016 @12:30PM
(#12678094)
Perhaps cynnical of me but I would assume such an escrow would be eternally underfunded. The whole point of sponsored research is to be able to frame the question and by extension the research. It is probably how it should be but I doubt you'd have many companies buying into it.
Perhaps an independent foundation could work hard at fundraising to become such an escrow but they'd have a heck of a time raising capital to cover the research I imagine.
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by SilasX on Monday October 10, 2016 @01:20PM
(#12678467)
The idea is that they would trade "influence over the results" with "credibility of the results" -- the fact that a study was funded by the escrow/filter org means more than "Big Soda-funded study".
Theoretically, this would strongly select for products that are safe but for which no one else wants to fund research into the safety of.
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by Shivetya on Monday October 10, 2016 @11:26AM
(#12677579)
Conflict of interest but its interesting to note both Coke and Pepsi also own major juice brands and these get a free pass most of the time when laws are crafted to reduce intake of sugary food.
so if soda accounts for twenty percent of so of weight gain, what accounts for the vast majority? I would still place my bets on junk foods similar to cookies, chips and such, but cannot discount prepared breakfast and dinners.
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by SilasX on Monday October 10, 2016 @02:24PM
(#12678890)
>Conflict of interest but its interesting to note both Coke and Pepsi also own major juice brands and these get a free pass most of the time when laws are crafted to reduce intake of sugary food.
To play devil's advocate, one reason you might want to exempt "natural fruit juices" from a "soda tax" laws is that the laws are designed to make the product more expensive, enough to scare off consumption into healthier alternatives. But natural fruit juices tend to already be much more expensive to begin with (because you have to actually grow the few pieces of fruit), so they already have a kind of built-in deterrent to overconsumption.
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by kyriakos on Monday October 10, 2016 @12:50PM
(#12678256)
There's conflicting studies about those too. Actually the ones I read that make out artificial sweeteners bad use very large quantities which are tens of times more than what a human could consume.
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by takingflac on Monday October 10, 2016 @01:54PM
(#12678703)
I'll leave deciding if artificial sweeteners are bad for you to the experts, but I do know that artificial sweeteners have a bad aftertaste in my experience.
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by kyriakos on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @02:57AM
(#12682301)
This is completely based on my experience, I find aspartame based drinks to feel more like real sugar while Stevia based drinks really alter the flavor and leave a bitter after taste.
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by brianwawok on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @09:08AM
(#12683996)
I think the long term health effects of drinking water vs not drinking water or pretty well understood. Also the effects of water vs no water on your body.
I cannot say the same for random sugar-like-but-not-really-sugar chemical of the month.
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by criddell on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @09:37AM
(#12684217)
> I cannot say the same for random sugar-like-but-not-really-sugar chemical of the month.
You could just call them sweeteners, non-nutritive sweeteners, or even artificial sweeteners. There's nothing more chemical-y about aspartame (for example) than sucrose, glucose, fructose, etc...
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by brianwawok on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @11:41AM
(#12685404)
Except glucose and fructose are found in the normal human diet, and have been consumed for 100s of years.
Where in nature do humans or animals eat aspartame?
Now that doesn't necessarily mean they are bad, but it does mean they are unproven. You can find enough studies that show negative effects (in weight loss, gut bacteria, etc), that you should at least QUESTION your use of making your food sickly sweet without nutrition.
Logically if your goal is to eat less sugar, again it seems counterintuitive to make everything you eat sickly sweet. Your body doesn't need to have sugar on everything, or in every beverage. Rather than substitute sugar (known bad) for fake sugar (unknown bad amount), you can just.. you know... drink water and eat better?
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by criddell on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @12:25PM
(#12685864)
> Where in nature do humans or animals eat aspartame?
Are you suggesting aspartame is supernatural? :)
I'm not arguing against any of what you said. I'm just suggesting the way you use the word "chemical" makes it sound like you think some things we consume are not chemicals.
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by criddell on Monday October 10, 2016 @01:19PM
(#12678461)
Coke and Pepsi are both trying to sell more of their products so I don't think there's any conflict of interest there.
The health groups, on the other hand, seem to have a big conflict of interest. They should either stop taking industry money OR stop commenting on industry issues.
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by nerdponx on Monday October 10, 2016 @12:31PM
(#12678104)
There's a lot of sugar inside fruit.
Normally you would only eat one orange. A glass of orange juice is equivalent to the juice of several oranges, with little or none of the accompanying fiber to slow down sugar absorption. Sure it's nutritious, but it's also a fructose bomb in a cup.
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by awqrre on Monday October 10, 2016 @11:52AM
(#12677793)
They are full of sugars too, for example this 100% Apple juice that I have is 28g of sugars per 240ml. But most fruit juices that they sell aren't really fruit juices and labels are really deceptive. For my kids, I mix fruit juices with equal part water to help reduce sugars.
Fruit juices are fruits with lots of the good stuff removed but I still consider fruits as desserts and not very healthy...
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by awqrre on Monday October 10, 2016 @01:26PM
(#12678506)
They do but usually the front of the label is a little deceiving and doesn't state the juice content, like "original 100% vitamin C" instead of something like "27% cranberry juice": http://blogs.longwood.edu/shakingitupatbreakfasttime/files/2... ... And I have seen worst... I'll take pictures next time I go to the grocery store... Also, many times you get juice of fruits that aren't even pictured on the label.
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by maxerickson on Monday October 10, 2016 @01:38PM
(#12678586)
I suppose my point is more that you don't need a great deal of information to understand how to buy fruit juice. Just buy the one with a clear claim about 100% fruit juice on the label.
Given that the blends aren't necessarily worse than the pure juice nutritionally, I'm not sure what you do for the consumer that can't tell the difference between "100% Vitamin C" and "100% Fruit Juice".
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by astrange on Monday October 10, 2016 @03:10PM
(#12679138)
Why would fruit be healthy? They're living off the good reputation from the phrase "fruits and vegetables", but fructose isn't good for you and the vitamins are overrated.
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by tkyjonathan on Monday October 10, 2016 @03:42PM
(#12679322)
>I still consider fruits as desserts and not very healthy...
That is literally the stupidest thing I have ever heard about diet advice.
Well done on being fully brainwashed.
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by gozur88 on Tuesday October 11, 2016 @12:36AM
(#12681895)
Eating too much fruit is an easy way to get fat. I wouldn't go so far as to call them "unhealthy" as a blanket statement, but to your body fructose from an apple is the same thing as fructose from cola.
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by ptaipale on Monday October 10, 2016 @12:09PM
(#12677923)
I think you misunderstood. Natural juices contain a lot of sugar, and that's what you've got in France, too.
For instance, apple and orange juice contains approximately 10 % sugar.
Juice drinks are then another matter; they are juice diluted with water and added sugar and flavourings, thus nutritionally even worse even though the sugar content is roughly similar.
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by vinylkey on Monday October 10, 2016 @11:46AM
(#12677758)
I'm not sure how one makes a juice with less sugar in it other than watering it down. Putting fresh fruit into a juicer still yields a drink with high amount of sugar.
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by lloyd-christmas on Monday October 10, 2016 @11:50AM
(#12677782)
Fruit juice by nature is almost 100% sugar even with no sugar added. I don't think there would be any difference between France and the rest of the world, unless you dilute it significantly.
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by JoeAltmaier on Monday October 10, 2016 @11:57AM
(#12677847)
They can't win apparently. They contribute to public obesity - they're justifiably slammed. Same if they contribute to public health (conceivably the outcome of a lawsuit might be to compel them to do so; here they are doing it voluntarily) - slammed again, but in a backhanded way this time.
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by confluence on Monday October 10, 2016 @12:02PM
(#12677886)
They can't win because they are on the wrong side of history and they are fighting dirty by using stealth operations to turn the conversation from diet to exercise. As if the average American can, or will, exercise enough to even burn off 1 additional can of soda on top of their already caloric rich diets.
What they are doing is no different from the various operations Big Tobacco did in the past to misinform, dissuade or deflect the conversation on cigarettes.
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by cortesoft on Monday October 10, 2016 @12:15PM
(#12677968)
So you think their should be no more soda in the world?
I understand the health costs of sugary drinks, but personally I want to live in a world where I can have one if and when I want to. I don't drink a lot of soda (maybe one a week), but there are certain situations where I find them really enjoyable. I don't want them to disappear.
I think the quality of life will go down if we get rid of all junk food in the world. I know we do a poor job of eating and drinking in moderation, but I don't think the solution is to just have it not be available.
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by TACIXAT on Monday October 10, 2016 @01:12PM
(#12678413)
I do believe that there should be no more soda in the world. At least, we should wipe it out, get everyone through withdrawal, then reintroduce it.
Sugar and caffeine are addictive. We are given these things from a very young age and have very little say in whether we are addicted to them (not to mention, massive amounts of marketing).
The fewer foods I eat, the better I feel. So many people are hooked on this stuff and aren't even aware that it is poisoning them (obesity, diabetes, heart disease, as well as headaches, mood swings, nasal congestion).
I wouldn't want to be a dictator and deprive people who are making a conscious choice, but I would get rid of it in order to give the people who are trapped the opportunity to experience life without it.
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by cortesoft on Monday October 10, 2016 @03:57PM
(#12679400)
This is always such a slippery slope, though. There ARE a lot of people who are already using soda in a healthy manner; they drink one occasionally, and are not addicted. They, too, would be swept up in any outright ban (no matter how temporary).
Where would it stop, then? Almost everything there is has some people that are addicted to it and use it too much; television, video games, social media, etc. Do we implement global bans to protect the people who are unable to control themselves? Or do we need to do something different?
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by cortesoft on Monday October 10, 2016 @12:42PM
(#12678206)
I wasn't trying to create a strawman. The claim that I was arguing against said "They can't win because they are on the wrong side of history"
So the commenter claims "they can't win". That means that even if they stopped all the PR work defending sugar, they still wouldn't win and they would still be on the wrong side of history.
If they have no way to win, then the only thing they can do is stop existing at all.
If the commenter supports their right to exist as a company making sugary drinks, then there IS a way to win.
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by euyyn on Monday October 10, 2016 @04:01PM
(#12679419)
Then the problem is you jumped ahead too much. The "can't win" part came from what that guy was responding to. Your parent argument was just "no, people won't give them a break because what they're doing with PR and marketing is morally reprehensible". That's it.
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by cortesoft on Monday October 10, 2016 @05:04PM
(#12679763)
If that was the argument he was trying to make, then he should have said "no, they can't win UNTIL they completely stop with the morally reprehensible PR and marketing"
He never once mentions what they could do to 'win'.
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by confluence on Monday October 10, 2016 @12:31PM
(#12678111)
He was very clever with that wasn't he?
Everyone should be free to consume whatever they want, so long as they know what they want is killing them, and there are no distortions by the purveyors of such products that they are anything other than what they are - namely bad for you.
You want to smoke? Go ahead. You want to get obese and severely shorten both your life and its quality by consuming caloric dense nutrient deficient drinks/foods? Go right on ahead. It's your life to screw up.
But don't you dare stand there and tell me that letting these corporations that profit from the damage people do to themselves be free to run around going "OH NO cigarettes are totally fine! OH NO diet isn't the issue - just exercise more - here have a coke". Kids are literally dying because of this shit, and I frankly won't stand by it.
What I am against is systematic and dirty propaganda operations that directly harm the national interest for trivial sums of profit by lying to the population through their teeth and in turn inflicting untold amounts of misery on millions of our citizens.
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by cortesoft on Monday October 10, 2016 @12:44PM
(#12678222)
I wasn't clever at all; if you think that the sugary drink companies are fine to exist as long as they don't push propaganda about sugary drinks, then there IS a way to win - all they have to do is stop the propaganda.
That isn't what your statement I replied to said... you said there was NO way for them to win.
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by esturk on Monday October 10, 2016 @07:53PM
(#12680773)
We're seeing that in San Francisco with Proposition V that's suppose to be a sugar beverage tax but the opposition is spinning it into an across the board grocery tax.
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by ravenstine on Monday October 10, 2016 @12:21PM
(#12678006)
This sounds a lot like how many large tech firms operate. I'm not saying that you are wrong, but that it's easy to point out "big" whatevery and forget where our dollar bills come from. Silicon Valley is by no means clean of business practices that include misinformation and "disruptive" anti-competitive practices. Can we really blame Big Soda forever?
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by ravenstine on Monday October 10, 2016 @12:30PM
(#12678096)
@praptak Sure, it is. It just wasn't invalidating what was said. The point I was making is that we don't scrutinize many businesses to the same degree as tobacco, for example, and if we do we certainly don't hold it against them for very long. Why treat Coke or Pepsi differently? I guess one could argue because it has a direct effect upon our health. Even then, I wouldn't necessarily conclude that they are trying to influence their own studies or cherry pick data. I would be suspicious of it, though.
Re:Big Soda sponsored 96 health groups – a big conflict of i...
by chillwaves on Monday October 10, 2016 @12:55PM
(#12678285)
Except there are decades of misinformation that have already happened -- that fact completely undermines whatever point you are trying to make about the innocence of these lobbying efforts by big Soda.
Of course, in reality, the escrow may not be enough to remove the bias, but it's an interesting thought.
They use part of this management fee to invest in their brand, so that studies that don't carry the "neutral-study-guarantee" sticker are treated less seriously than those that do.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Campbell's_law
You pay in taxes, government dispenses research funds, you don't know where the money is from.
Perhaps an independent foundation could work hard at fundraising to become such an escrow but they'd have a heck of a time raising capital to cover the research I imagine.
Theoretically, this would strongly select for products that are safe but for which no one else wants to fund research into the safety of.
so if soda accounts for twenty percent of so of weight gain, what accounts for the vast majority? I would still place my bets on junk foods similar to cookies, chips and such, but cannot discount prepared breakfast and dinners.
To play devil's advocate, one reason you might want to exempt "natural fruit juices" from a "soda tax" laws is that the laws are designed to make the product more expensive, enough to scare off consumption into healthier alternatives. But natural fruit juices tend to already be much more expensive to begin with (because you have to actually grow the few pieces of fruit), so they already have a kind of built-in deterrent to overconsumption.
I cannot say the same for random sugar-like-but-not-really-sugar chemical of the month.
You could just call them sweeteners, non-nutritive sweeteners, or even artificial sweeteners. There's nothing more chemical-y about aspartame (for example) than sucrose, glucose, fructose, etc...
Where in nature do humans or animals eat aspartame?
Now that doesn't necessarily mean they are bad, but it does mean they are unproven. You can find enough studies that show negative effects (in weight loss, gut bacteria, etc), that you should at least QUESTION your use of making your food sickly sweet without nutrition.
Logically if your goal is to eat less sugar, again it seems counterintuitive to make everything you eat sickly sweet. Your body doesn't need to have sugar on everything, or in every beverage. Rather than substitute sugar (known bad) for fake sugar (unknown bad amount), you can just.. you know... drink water and eat better?
Are you suggesting aspartame is supernatural? :)
I'm not arguing against any of what you said. I'm just suggesting the way you use the word "chemical" makes it sound like you think some things we consume are not chemicals.
The health groups, on the other hand, seem to have a big conflict of interest. They should either stop taking industry money OR stop commenting on industry issues.
Normally you would only eat one orange. A glass of orange juice is equivalent to the juice of several oranges, with little or none of the accompanying fiber to slow down sugar absorption. Sure it's nutritious, but it's also a fructose bomb in a cup.
Fruit and vegetable consumption and all-cause mortality: a dose-response analysis http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23803880
Did I just blow your mind?
It may be interesting to note that I am a vegetarian so I am far from opposed to eating lots of fruit.
For comparison, Coca-Cola "original" has 26g sugar in 8oz (236ml).
Fruit juices are fruits with lots of the good stuff removed but I still consider fruits as desserts and not very healthy...
http://www.fda.gov/Food/GuidanceRegulation/GuidanceDocuments...
That doesn't mean that they aren't sweet, but the labeling should reliably state the fruit juice content.
Given that the blends aren't necessarily worse than the pure juice nutritionally, I'm not sure what you do for the consumer that can't tell the difference between "100% Vitamin C" and "100% Fruit Juice".
How can they say 100% apple juice with added ingredient (even if it is only vitamin C that they are adding in very small quantity...)
Maybe I'm misunderstanding, but why wouldn't fruits as desserts be healthy?
Fruit and vegetable consumption and all-cause mortality: a dose-response analysis http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23803880
For instance, apple and orange juice contains approximately 10 % sugar.
Juice drinks are then another matter; they are juice diluted with water and added sugar and flavourings, thus nutritionally even worse even though the sugar content is roughly similar.
That's like naming your bad guy Darth Funsies.
They are not contributing to public health, they white-wash their image related to the health damage their products do.
If they want to contribute to public health, they should do it with their products.
What they are doing is no different from the various operations Big Tobacco did in the past to misinform, dissuade or deflect the conversation on cigarettes.
I understand the health costs of sugary drinks, but personally I want to live in a world where I can have one if and when I want to. I don't drink a lot of soda (maybe one a week), but there are certain situations where I find them really enjoyable. I don't want them to disappear.
I think the quality of life will go down if we get rid of all junk food in the world. I know we do a poor job of eating and drinking in moderation, but I don't think the solution is to just have it not be available.
Sugar and caffeine are addictive. We are given these things from a very young age and have very little say in whether we are addicted to them (not to mention, massive amounts of marketing).
The fewer foods I eat, the better I feel. So many people are hooked on this stuff and aren't even aware that it is poisoning them (obesity, diabetes, heart disease, as well as headaches, mood swings, nasal congestion).
I wouldn't want to be a dictator and deprive people who are making a conscious choice, but I would get rid of it in order to give the people who are trapped the opportunity to experience life without it.
Where would it stop, then? Almost everything there is has some people that are addicted to it and use it too much; television, video games, social media, etc. Do we implement global bans to protect the people who are unable to control themselves? Or do we need to do something different?
Step 2. Argue against strawman.
So the commenter claims "they can't win". That means that even if they stopped all the PR work defending sugar, they still wouldn't win and they would still be on the wrong side of history.
If they have no way to win, then the only thing they can do is stop existing at all.
If the commenter supports their right to exist as a company making sugary drinks, then there IS a way to win.
He never once mentions what they could do to 'win'.
Everyone should be free to consume whatever they want, so long as they know what they want is killing them, and there are no distortions by the purveyors of such products that they are anything other than what they are - namely bad for you.
You want to smoke? Go ahead. You want to get obese and severely shorten both your life and its quality by consuming caloric dense nutrient deficient drinks/foods? Go right on ahead. It's your life to screw up.
But don't you dare stand there and tell me that letting these corporations that profit from the damage people do to themselves be free to run around going "OH NO cigarettes are totally fine! OH NO diet isn't the issue - just exercise more - here have a coke". Kids are literally dying because of this shit, and I frankly won't stand by it.
What I am against is systematic and dirty propaganda operations that directly harm the national interest for trivial sums of profit by lying to the population through their teeth and in turn inflicting untold amounts of misery on millions of our citizens.
That isn't what your statement I replied to said... you said there was NO way for them to win.