Where in nature do humans or animals eat aspartame?
Now that doesn't necessarily mean they are bad, but it does mean they are unproven. You can find enough studies that show negative effects (in weight loss, gut bacteria, etc), that you should at least QUESTION your use of making your food sickly sweet without nutrition.
Logically if your goal is to eat less sugar, again it seems counterintuitive to make everything you eat sickly sweet. Your body doesn't need to have sugar on everything, or in every beverage. Rather than substitute sugar (known bad) for fake sugar (unknown bad amount), you can just.. you know... drink water and eat better?
Are you suggesting aspartame is supernatural? :)
I'm not arguing against any of what you said. I'm just suggesting the way you use the word "chemical" makes it sound like you think some things we consume are not chemicals.
You could just call them sweeteners, non-nutritive sweeteners, or even artificial sweeteners. There's nothing more chemical-y about aspartame (for example) than sucrose, glucose, fructose, etc...