People stop dieting. That's the problem.
Limiting caloric intake (diet) below caloric output (exercise, etc) is the only effective way to lose weight, excluding literally cutting it off. Just because people struggle at doing so doesn't mean that it's not effective.
The issue with the human body is that psychological effects are actually physical effects and therefore entirely relevant. The human body is not a mere automobile into which you pour gas, you push a gas pedal, and it just goes. That's the entire problem. You can't even treat a cat like that, let alone a human.
The psychological consequences are part of the equation and disregarding them and trying to pretend they don't exist is essentially taking out all the complex variables out and solving a simple equation nobody cares about. Kind of like programming GPS using Newtonian physics and then being surprised it's off constantly. There are more complex laws at stake here and we don't understand them very well. Moralization is effectively a cop out. "They're too lazy, stupid, or otherwise inferior to me to do this theoretically simple thing" is the same as: "I have no idea what's going on."
Limiting caloric intake leads to weight loss. So why are people not limiting their calorie intake? Then consider what kind of people are more or less likely to limit their calorie intake. So on and so forth. The equation becomes a lot more complex and also a lot more interesting.
This is meta, but there really needs to be a better phrase for ideas/models that only seem good when ignoring important details. A good theory is also good in practice because it actually factors in the relevant details.
I get that the wiki article on low carb is rambling, but why HN :?
We could say 100% of these bugs are caused by people failing to consider edge cases, and if developers accurately considered all edge cases then we would have 0 bugs.
To then think that this problem is solved because we can tell a developer "consider all edge cases" even though it has 0 effect on the actual bug count caused by edge cases is absurd.
Also comparing the human body/brain to a car/mechanical device would be incorrect and is probably an apple to oranges comparison.
Additionally, our bodies can make subtle changes in response to caloric intake: If you ingest fewer calories, you may fidget less, possibly lowering your caloric use more than you lowered your input.
Or increasing the metabolic rate. Or decreasing the calorie storage rate.
Besides, the human body has several ways of regulating core body temperature: sweating, restricting blood flow to extremities, goose bumbs, and putting on different clothes.
But I wonder if this translates into different adults saying that they have fast or slow metabolism as an explanation for their weight.
Do you simply mean that I was gaining weight at birth, adolescence, and teen years? I could agree with that.
This is probably true, but a better question is whether this is even important.
One guy said "it's a lot easier for a fat person to become fit than it is for a fat person to become thin."
Generally the press (and maybe scientists, though I'm not so sure about them) seem obsessed with thinness rather than health or fitness.
"Why can’t an average person make those kinds of gains as well? Or even more gains, considering they don’t have the additional challenge of an autism spectrum disorder?"
This betrays a complete lack of understanding of the body of knowledge around intellectual improvement. No one would say "we took this broken Honda and were able to get a 100% improvement in it's speed, and gas efficiency by just fixing the leaky gas hose, if we can make these kinds of gains with a broken car imagine what we do with a new Honda". This would of course be as silly.