The one way I've thought of current is either having an aggregate table in a "central" database that would be used to collect these kind of statistics. It would be "real-time" but it would be near real-time depending on the frequency of updates. The downside is you have the over head of maintaining a separate data source.
The other option was to just have the software set up to query each tenant at a time and take the performance/time hit. That's not really the best experience and probably violates the idea of data isolation.
One way to do that would be to query each individual tenant database and then combine the information. But this would void the idea of security/isolation. The other downside is that it's slow.
But I think I've been looking at this from the wrong point of view, there should be a central health check service for these assets that collects the status of the assets and then that would be queried by the support person.
Any time you are reaching into the customer datasets that is where you have the possibility of breach via that access and would have to make sure all of those events are audited and that audit records are secure. If it is sending monitoring data to an aggregation service that can be well-defined in contents and much easier to demonstrate that no sensitive tenant information is shared.
It's much easier and saner to setup a server to receive and configure each tenant's host to send exactly what is needed and then analyze who didn't send their stuff at regular intervals for a more direct investigation and everyone can agree on what needs to be done based on that.
When you talk about having each tenant's host do you mean a dedicated application server for each host? The current setup we have is that we have multiple tenant databases but only two application servers providing functionality to them, so there's a switching cost on the application servers because they can't maintain a connection pool to the databases (they also have to know the credentials for the databases.
It seems excessive if you have a 100 tenants to have your infrastructure for serving the application replicated 100 times but maybe we're just haven't quite built our system correctly yet.
As for separation of the application frontend it really is a risk assessment and culture thing. If the team understands that making sure you never cross streams of customer data is a critical requirement which is one of the first viability questions in the design then sharing really isn't too bad. If your team struggles with this or has recurring issues to this end separate application servers make more sense. Generally if you have tenants with data exposing another customer's data is a quick way to have trust in a product evaporate, I know I have had this happen as a customer where I was able to show a bug where I was getting another customer's accounting information in a cloud app which caused me to terminate the contract.
If you guys are minding the soup of the application servers well enough there's nothing say you can't, there are many people that do it.
In this case, how is the business logic (codewise) handled across different states of databases?
We don't support very old versions, mind you, except for security fixes.
Exactly. Unless you're ACV is $100k+ this is strategy isn't really sustainable and might materially impact your gross margins.
EDIT: Further, read the more technical limitations of this approach: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12652021
Why? We have customers with ACVs under $10k (even after adjusting for cost of living/general prices level) with this model. We simply automated the whole process, so the clients can register for our service and get a new database (created from a template) without any manual intervention.
Still, we'll never hit anything close to 1000 customers per server, we distribute them over more servers instead. In fact, that's an advantage of this model over the single-database one: since every tenant is isolated, the model is perfectly horizontally scalable. You can simply fill up servers without worrying about massively distributed databases or datacenter-wide load balancing. Hell, we just migrated across hosting providers with barely breaking a sweat: we simply moved machine by machine without ever worrying about latency between DCs and all that.
Almost all the points above are the precise reason we went database-per-tenant. We also chose this method because our system was self-hosted originally (Single DB, non-multi-tenant) for 4 years or so. Adding columns to each table to separate was not ideal and we didn't want to run the risk of 'forgetting a where clause' at any point.
For those wondering, all of our databases have the same schema. We use Visual Studio Database Projects to handle updates to keep it all in sync.
"Captain Obvious" out!
I had a couple of colleges working for the banking financial sector and they where pretty high strung most of the time. They where a bit more direct in regards to putting money on the table to get shit done.
It was very much not a tech company, although there were a few good people in the org. There was of course a big focus on buying supported packages, and off-shoring as much as possible. I understand buying "non core competency commodities", but the off shoring was dubious.
The custom stuff in my unit was very much neglected, except for integration projects when changing vendors, which of course have to happen when you move some of your dependencies.
Anyway, uptime was VERY important, which also implies a fair amount of risk management/reduction. In fairness, buying external services does make costs much more predictable. However, if you are on the vendor side of this, you need to make sure you build in pricing to cover what will be a very demanding customer.
(they of course did some other ignorant things which made this an issue, as well)
I frankly prefer this approach, since it completely bypasses the problems that come with sharding and distributed deployments, since every customer is completely isolated. I just wish there was more tooling available that supported our architecture.
1. Stronger data isolation. Technically schemas provide the same level of isolation, but they are much harder to explain or defend during compliance audits.
2. More secure backups. Client data can be encrypted with their own key and stored as per their needs.
3. More useful backups. The frequency and retention of backups can vary to meet the SLA requirements (and costs). And we if something goes wrong, we can recover that particular customer's data in isolation without impacting the rest of the application/customers or worry about merging it in.
4. Secure data deletion. Many European customers demand that all their data is securely removed upon termination. This creates a massive problem with purging backup information if everything is in the same dump.
5. Independent load & performance. If one customer is particularly high-load or chatty, we can move them onto a separate server where they don't impact well behaved folks.
6. Easier horizontal scalability. Just move heavy loads to their own servers + read replicas.
7. Direct access to data. Specifically, we can use BI tools that do not understand schemas and even give direct access to clients' analysts.
8.Independent migration paths. Sometimes the customer's timetable does not allow them to upgrade to the newest version right now (e.g. they are in the middle of using the app for a key process this month). We can leave their account routed to the previous version in both the codebase and the data store.
Out of those, the key 3 reasons are: stronger data isolation, better backup strategy, and more predictable compliance story. But that's enterprise: even if we're widely successful, we'll have "thousands" of customers - never millions. And we can manage thousands of databases, so this architecture path is preferable to us within those boundaries.