Re:Bill Gross warns financial markets have become 'a Vegas c...
by fma on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @11:40PM
(#12641403)
Cash has no utility either. At the end of the day, cash, gold, silver..are monetary instruments. To say a monetary instrument needs to have utility is a bit ridiculous. Do we want to go back to the days of carrying around bags of salt?
I don't know how many cubic feet $7 trillion of US dollar takes up...but if I have a cubic feet of $7 trillion anything I would take it, convert it and purchase whatever I want with it.
Re:Bill Gross warns financial markets have become 'a Vegas c...
by kajecounterhack on Wednesday October 05, 2016 @12:03AM
(#12641479)
I think encapsulated in the quote (and what the point was) is the idea that Gold isn't going to do much but sit there and retain its value, whereas Exxon and farmland are going to grow in value over time and produce useful things. Befitting an investor's quote.
It's not saying gold has to have utility. Which it actually does fwiw as a commodity.
Re:Bill Gross warns financial markets have become 'a Vegas c...
by fma on Wednesday October 05, 2016 @12:20AM
(#12641528)
With all investments there's no guarantee it will value over time or produce useful things...You can buy Theranos, a company once valued at $9 billion, and the next day it's worthless because you found out it's all smoke and mirrors.
Re:Bill Gross warns financial markets have become 'a Vegas c...
by oh_sigh on Wednesday October 05, 2016 @02:11AM
(#12641855)
It's valuable exactly because all of it in the world only makes a cube 67 feet on a side. Compared that to, say steel production, where the world has produced a cube 1900' on each side. And that was just in 2015.
Re:Bill Gross warns financial markets have become 'a Vegas c...
by downandout on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @10:39PM
(#12641226)
I don't often say this about Warren Buffett quotes, but that is one of the most idiotic things I have ever heard anyone say. If you owned this 67 ft. cube - all of the gold in the world - you would be able to extract any profit you wanted from the vast majority of all electronics sold in the world, along with a long list of other products. Your $7 trillion would turn into...whatever you wanted it to. Buffett is showing his age and publicly admitted lack of understanding of technology.
Re:Bill Gross warns financial markets have become 'a Vegas c...
by HillRat on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @11:32PM
(#12641367)
I think you're taking this a bit too literally. Consider a less extreme case; given a choice between a pound of gold or the current financial equivalent in Berkshire Hathaway equity (about 150 shares), which is more likely to provide higher returns over the long run? Buffet is basically making an optimistic case for the American economy, arguing that gold is a hedge, while market investment is a strategy.
Re:Bill Gross warns financial markets have become 'a Vegas c...
by downandout on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @11:40PM
(#12641397)
Yes, I understood what he was trying to say, but his comparison was too far over the top and inaccurate to not be called out. His wording introduced and failed to account for the idea of someone having a monopoly on gold.
Re:Bill Gross warns financial markets have become 'a Vegas c...
by luckydata on Wednesday October 05, 2016 @12:28AM
(#12641552)
It would be challenging to find a better example of the reason why Buffet is one of the world's richest man and you're spending your time on HN than your own comment.
Re:Bill Gross warns financial markets have become 'a Vegas c...
by fooker on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @10:58PM
(#12641268)
People would just switch to some other material for industrial uses if you demamd an exorbitant price.
Gold, while useful is not indispensable.
Re:Bill Gross warns financial markets have become 'a Vegas c...
by downandout on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @11:01PM
(#12641277)
It would take long enough to effectuate such a switch in all products across the world that you could extract enormous sums of money in the meantime - far more than your $7 trillion. At the very least, industrial gold usage has not decreased in the face of the historically highest market price of gold. You could start at that price, and increase it until you reach the optimal price.
Re:Bill Gross warns financial markets have become 'a Vegas c...
by nikdaheratik on Wednesday October 05, 2016 @01:00AM
(#12641648)
And then what would you do with your gains? You already have all the gold in the world, so what would you buy after that if you want to increase your return on investment?
Re:Bill Gross warns financial markets have become 'a Vegas c...
by jackmott on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @11:23PM
(#12641332)
But something I've learned is that it doesn't matter if it actually has utility.
What matters is if you can predict how insane humans will perceive its' utility.
Which I can't do, so I am poor. (well not poor but I have to work)
Re:Bill Gross warns financial markets have become 'a Vegas c...
by underdown on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @09:59PM
(#12641114)
Gold has lots of utility - just not enough to justify the speculative price.
Re:Bill Gross warns financial markets have become 'a Vegas c...
by jokoon on Wednesday October 05, 2016 @08:48AM
(#12643318)
People argue that gold has value in case of a world war or some kind of apocalyptic economic crash, like a nuke going off in Manhattan.
So ultimately people trust gold because they believe WW3 will start soon.
[1] http://www.minyanville.com/trading-and-investing/commodities...
Gold has no utility. This quote changed the way I think about gold when I first heard it.