Long story short, she found out that men who simply go to the doctor every 4-5 months to make sure that everything's fine are happier than those who did an intervention. The reason lies in the fact that you lose self-confidence when you're impotent and incontinent.
Sounds plausible to me and the results had high statistical significance, therefore I agree to your skepticism.
I went to a urologist, got a request for the MRI which the insurance company denied, and so had to follow up with the very unpleasant biopsy mentioned in the OP (including missed work, pain, peeing blood). All for the result to come back completely negative.
That was last year, and as luck would have it, this year's PSA score dropped significantly.
I don't know whether I'd say that I'm not glad to have a definitive negative answer, particularly since my father had prostate cancer. However, this false alarm did cost an appreciable amount of money, time, and suffering.
In my experience it's really hard to keep your mind on the public health statistics of the nation when it's you sitting in the doctor's office.
https://www.verywell.com/the-top-ten-prostate-cancer-myths-2...
http://www.cancerresearchuk.org/about-us/cancer-news/press-r...
> Previous research has shown that around one in four women diagnosed with breast cancer through screening are overdiagnosed*.
But there is a big disparity in information between browsing cancer.org and being a surgeon that has looked at an MRI and biopsy.
It's certainly possible that the intervention saved your life, but I'm highly skeptical. I think it just caused you unnecessary stress and trauma.
"Every old man dies with prostate cancer. Nobody dies from it." is the saying I've heard. Obviously it's hyperbole, but the core is valid.