News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Police complaints drop over 90% after deploying body cameras by richmarr on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @04:38AM (#12634104)
> ...there's such a presumption of guilt

There's a long catalogue of evidence that the police have been insitutionally racist (and other issues). Specifically in the UK, but I suspect the US has a similar catalogue of evidence.

> Maybe the public...

The conclusion drawn seems like the most realistic explanation. Your alternatives don't seem credible considering the change also occurred when police weren't wearing cameras.

[Edit: "have been" rather than "are" insitutionally racist, evidence is in the past and will hopefully stay that way)

Re:Police complaints drop over 90% after deploying body cameras by the-dude on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @04:56AM (#12634164)
Do you mean not investigating rape rings because of fear of being called racist?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rotherham_child_sexual_exploit...

Re:Police complaints drop over 90% after deploying body cameras by richmarr on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @05:47AM (#12634352)
What's your point? Are you claiming that a significant base of evidence is somehow disproven because of one incident?
Re:Police complaints drop over 90% after deploying body cameras by ptaipale on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @07:59AM (#12634886)
It wasn't exactly "one incident". The Rotherham thing was a systematic failure caused by intentionally engineered race/ethnicity-based policy.
Re:Police complaints drop over 90% after deploying body cameras by the-dude on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @05:51AM (#12634368)
My point is that in Western Europe police is being accused of racism because they employ statistical profiling.

Which is then called racist by its opponents.

Re:Police complaints drop over 90% after deploying body cameras by lostlogin on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @06:00AM (#12634392)
With the track records of the police forces involved, are you surprised people have a degree of scepticism?
Re:Police complaints drop over 90% after deploying body cameras by the-dude on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @06:06AM (#12634414)
What track record of the Dutch police? Do you have sources?

If anything, the Dutch police force is one of most docile of the world. And my feeling is this holds true for the UK as well.

Re:Police complaints drop over 90% after deploying body cameras by lostlogin on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @01:18PM (#12637223)
Excuse the Daily Mail link sorry and the other link is a police murder with the mayor discussing police racism. The Dutch police are very good by nearly all accounts, but it's not hard to find accounts of racism. The UK police have a very long and much worse history of racism with the Met being front and centre (less so now than 10+ years ago though). I won't post a link for them as it is extremely easy to find many many cases unfortunately. Pick you examples with them, beatings, killings, harassment, illegal searches etc. www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3163974/Boy-13-handcuffed-motorcycle-police-officer-run.html

www.nltimes.nl/2015/07/09/hague-mayor-admits-police-racism-chief-breaks-down-over-fatal-arrest/

Re:Police complaints drop over 90% after deploying body cameras by colemickens on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @05:15AM (#12634237)
Oh, a "counter" incident. Institutional racism is officially over!
Re:Police complaints drop over 90% after deploying body cameras by the-dude on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @05:44AM (#12634340)
It is not over, what I pointed at IS racism.

This is not an incident however, this is happening all over Europe. Police are hesitant to reveal real rates of crime, Dutch police advising victims not to press charges because the Northern-African suspects are known to make your life miserable. Calling statistical profiling racial profiling instead etc.

Re:Police complaints drop over 90% after deploying body cameras by lukeschlather on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @09:58AM (#12635518)
Ethnic profiling is bunk. It kind of works in areas like Israel, where there is literally a war on and the goal of profiling is not to determine criminality, but which side of the war you are on.

If you're trying to determine criminality, ethnic profiling doesn't work. It's been proven time and again. It's amazing that we're still having this debate 70 years after the West shed eugenics.

Re:Police complaints drop over 90% after deploying body cameras by Chris2048 on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @10:51AM (#12635962)
> proven time and again ... after the West shed eugenics

Given how you conflate racial profiling and eugenics, I'd be skeptical of what you consider proven.

But you are right, race doesn't correlate directly with criminality - but it does correlate if it correlates with something else that does e.g. religious membership.

Re:Police complaints drop over 90% after deploying body cameras by richmarr on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @11:59AM (#12636484)
> It is not over, what I pointed at IS racism.

Not sure it's either accurate or useful to classify the Rotherham situation as racism.

Re:Police complaints drop over 90% after deploying body cameras by headmelted on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @07:54AM (#12634862)
"The conclusion drawn seems like the most realistic explanation."

I'm not sure I agree. I imagine either of us could find evidence of police corruption, institutional racism, or myriad other issues. There are a lot of police in the world.

I'm not excusing racist or crooked police, I'm suggesting that there could be multiple explanations for the drop in complaints.

"Your alternatives don't seem credible considering the change also occurred when police weren't wearing cameras."

And that would seem to indicate that on average, the officer's in question were behaving better, and I expect that's the case. It could also mean that the public was aware of the cameras too, and that word gets around, which is likely in smaller communities.

If I had to guess, I would guess it's the former. But I'm not a police officer, an ombudsman, or a victim of police abuse, so I would be speaking from zero experience.

There's also a long catalogue of evidence that white people as a group have been institutionally racist.

Your own race (just as an example) is none of my business, and obviously I sincerely hope you're not racist (which I very much doubt you are), but in any case I'm in no rush to jump to conclusions about either, which is kind of my point.

Presumption of innocence exists for more reasons than just protecting citizens from the state (although that's an important one). It's because our gut instincts are most unscientific judges of character.

I will say that I'm glad they've found a strategy that seems to have such a strong positive impact on police-public relations, though.

Re:Police complaints drop over 90% after deploying body cameras by richmarr on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @09:36AM (#12635360)
> ...there could be multiple explanations for the drop in complaints

Uh huh, so, this particular study covered 1,429,868 officer hours across the six different police forces in the UK and the US, and found a 93% drop in complaints. Some forces found a 100% drop in complaints.

Meanwhile, here's another Cambridge study from 2012 that shows police cameras reduce the incidence of unacceptable use of force.

https://www.cam.ac.uk/research/news/first-scientific-report-...

Re:Police complaints drop over 90% after deploying body cameras by headmelted on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @09:50AM (#12635458)
I had thought it was clear that I was referring to this discussion, i.e. that the drop in complaints was due to the use of body cameras, but it was not proven why.

Was that not obvious? If not, my bad.

Re:Police complaints drop over 90% after deploying body cameras by hueving on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @07:36AM (#12634776)
Provide citations when you state such loaded things (cops are racist). Otherwise things just degrade people into two sides (each group starting and staying on the side they agree with).
Re:Police complaints drop over 90% after deploying body cameras by geofft on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @11:20AM (#12636188)
A good one is pages 17-19 for this decision from the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court http://www.mass.gov/courts/docs/sjc/reporter-of-decisions/ne... , which cites a "finding that black males in Boston are disproportionately and repeatedly targeted for [field interrogation and observation] encounters" from the Boston Police Department themselves http://bpdnews.com/news/2014/10/8/boston-police-commissioner... :

> Specifically, the study showed that during the given time period, minority neighborhoods do experience higher levels of FIO activity, approximately 1% of FIO’s completed per month, when controlling for crime.

> It also showed that Black subjects are 8% more likely to be stopped repeatedly and 12% more likely to be frisked and searched when controlling for other factors like Criminal History and Gang Membership in Violent Crime areas.

and this ACLU report: https://aclum.org/app/uploads/2015/06/reports-black-brown-an...

> The researchers' preliminary statistical analysis found that the racial composition of Boston neighborhoods drove police-civilian encounters even after controlling for crime rates and other factors. [emphasis in original]

The only "loaded" thing here is your assertion that cops being racist is a loaded statement, and the implication that it needs citations to be treated as a reasonable thing to say. That is the consensus position, common enough to be treated as fact in state supreme court decisions, and the one with the weight of evidence behind it. It is no more "loaded" than a claim that the earth revolves around the sun.

Re:Police complaints drop over 90% after deploying body cameras by hueving on Wednesday October 05, 2016 @11:13PM (#12649959)
State Supreme Court decisions have never been made based on the statement that all police in the US are racist.

You gave links only supporting the behavior in Boston, so the only conclusion that can be made is about Boston. Assuming the demographics of Boston are the same as Los Angeles or Atlanta requires a level of stupidity that would preclude you from operating a computer, so I assume you are being willfully misleading to grind an ax. Take it to another forum or discuss it with a therapist.

Re:Police complaints drop over 90% after deploying body cameras by richmarr on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @07:59AM (#12634890)
I don't intend to spend my day providing citations for statements that aren't reasonably disputed, just in case some random guy on the internet disagrees.

Police organisations (in the UK at least) accept they have a historical problem with institutional racism. This is a well discussed problem.

UK police are currently putting significant effort into fixing the problem.... for example recent work to reduce the disproportionately high drop-out rate amongst applicants from minorities in order to help make the police representative of the community at large.

Re:Police complaints drop over 90% after deploying body cameras by Chris2048 on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @08:40AM (#12635061)
> There's a long catalogue of evidence

> I don't intend to spend my day providing citations

If it takes a day, then I assume the evidence isn't at hand, in which case how do you know it exists?

Do you have first-hand experience of this evidence, or are you just assured it exists by sources you consider "reasonable".

you are also a "random guy on the internet" and since you made the claim, the burden is on you. Some hand-waving "reasonable dispute" doesn't cut it - if it's so obvious, accepted and supported, it should be as easy to demonstrate.

I'd also add you comments about historical racism lack context - i.e timelines, impact, magnitude etc all of which would feed into the main question; Are the UK police racist today? Muddying the waters with vague or unsupported claims doesn't help answer this question, especially given that there are lots of efforts to answer it, and reasonable sources of information in existence.

Re:Police complaints drop over 90% after deploying body cameras by pjc50 on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @09:13AM (#12635221)
The UK's gold standard evidence is probably the MacPherson report: https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachm...
Re:Police complaints drop over 90% after deploying body cameras by richmarr on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @09:15AM (#12635228)
> If it takes a day...

You misunderstand. hueving didn't ask me for a citation for this point, he asked me to provide citations in general. I don't intend to spend MY day (not "a" day) providing citations for every statement I make in general. If people ask for a specific citation fair enough; that's not what happened here.

> Do you have first-hand experience of this evidence, or are you just assured it exists by sources you consider "reasonable".

I worked with the people who ran various RCTs for the police, and listened to them present their findings which were then implemented as policy. So no, not first-hand, no, but good enough for me.

Re:Police complaints drop over 90% after deploying body cameras by Chris2048 on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @10:09AM (#12635611)
> he asked me to provide citations in general

A reasonable standard to maintain IMHO, especially for topics that are "such loaded". Then maybe we disagree on how controversial the claim is? I don't think "the UK police has had problems with racism" is controversial (well, maybe the magnitude is, especially compared to the US), but whether this still applies generally today I think is controversial.

Attempts at improving the police has gone on for quite q while, so I wouldn't assume the question "Have they been successful; Are the police different now?".

> present their findings

Are these findings public?

Re:Police complaints drop over 90% after deploying body cameras by richmarr on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @12:41PM (#12636822)
> A reasonable standard to maintain IMHO, especially for topics that are "such loaded".

Loaded perhaps. Disputed? Not with significant credibility in my opinion.

> but whether this still applies generally today I think is controversial.

I've used the past tense throughout, and even a footnote in my comment on that exact point. Nor have I referred to racism, only to institutional racism which is a very different thing.

A lot could have happened in the 7 years since the Macpherson report, but it's not "controversial" to expect evidence of change before assuming that all the problems have disappeared and everything is now completely fine.

> Are these findings public?

Yes. The one I mentioned was published last year. I don't want to post links relating to clients on here so will leave the googling to you if you're bothered.

Re:Police complaints drop over 90% after deploying body cameras by Chris2048 on Wednesday October 05, 2016 @05:20AM (#12642538)
> Not with significant credibility in my opinion

If you believe anyone who disputed the claim would find it hard to find a credible source, fair enough, lay down that challenge. The question here is can you find a credible source for the claim yourself first?

Even if there where absolutely no credible sources of dispute, the burden would still exist; Or at least, you need enough evidence to dispute.

> I've used the past tense throughout

Maybe I misread the thread;

headmelted: "I'm a little surprised that in the article, and in the comments here, there's such a presumption of guilt on the part of the police."

you (responding to this line): "There's a long catalogue of evidence that the police have been insitutionally racist (and other issues)."

I interpreted "There's a long catalogue" as meaning a presumption of guilt was justified because of past issues.

> A lot could have happened

between "assuming that all the problems have disappeared" and "assuming nothing has changed" is "we don't know". You don't have to assume anything, but when you do (and make a claim) it's then you have a burden to justify it.

Re:Police complaints drop over 90% after deploying body cameras by roninb on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @09:16AM (#12635233)
> If it takes a day, then I assume the evidence isn't at hand, in which case how do you know it exists?

Or there's so much it would take to long to paint the wonderfully detailed picture. But in case you'd like to waste a day, here's a few million results: https://www.google.com/search?q=historical+racism+uk+police&...

Re:Police complaints drop over 90% after deploying body cameras by Chris2048 on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @09:58AM (#12635522)
> there's so much

Then only use so much evidence as to support your claim.

Evidence of you claim is only evidence of your claim after it is verified, at which point the work has been done. before then it's potential evidence. You don't know what evidence you have until you investigate it, so again, suggesting that there's a lot is just speculation.

If the claim requires a great level detail, then it's your fault for making an overly broad claim without evidence; again, if the work has yet to be done, you can't be sure what the picture will look like - you can only assume that you are able to prove a "wonderfully detailed picture" of whatever you claim; This is a faith-based argument; you have faith in you ability to demonstrate, and in the apparent quality of evidence, before actually having done it.

A google search isn't research for many reasons (e.g. the bias in focus of a search engine, which is a tool for finding specific information, not building a representative/comprehensive summary of information on the internet; The 'mememtic survival bias' and/or 'publish bias' of what kind of information is most commonly found on the internet etc etc etc).

One relevant reason is just because a url is returned, doesn't mean it's a relevant source (and multiple urls may all have the same underlying source/s); checking those sources would be the job of whoever made the claim. Until this is done you only have a blob of data, not a verified list of sources.

If this hasn't been done, then you don't know, and are just pushing the burden of investigation on me - I'd assume if I find any invalid source among that google search, you'd just tell me to keep looking until I found a valid one? Why do I have to spend my time to support your claim? I should be send on a wild goose chase to find something that you claim to exist...

Re:Police complaints drop over 90% after deploying body cameras by jshevek on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @12:47PM (#12636896)
> This is a well discussed problem.

It is true that this is well discussed, but usually those discussions center on anecdotes and shoddy statistics rather than meaningful evidence.

The prevalence of all of this biased discussion simply leads more people to believe their biased worldviews to be factual when it hasn't really been demonstrated.

Re:Police complaints drop over 90% after deploying body cameras by weberc2 on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @09:31AM (#12635324)
> There's a long catalogue of evidence that the police have been insitutionally racist

At best, the evidence paints an unclear picture in the U.S.: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/256079484_No_eviden...

Re:Police complaints drop over 90% after deploying body cameras by richmarr on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @10:58AM (#12636027)
I'm not convinced that a study that relies on IQ (which is itself a biased metric) and self-reported data (self-reported data is low quality) makes the picture "unclear".

Fryer's "Use of Force" paper would be a stronger argument I feel, but even that relies on very patchy data and doesn't take into account the higher likelyhood of minorities being stopped without cause.

Managing a small law enforcement operation is hard. On a national scale it's a monumental task, and human beings are biased and irrational at the best of times.

Not sure why the US doesn't record statistics on things like police shootings. Given the lack of data, if US law enforcement doesn't suffer from insitutional racism then it may well be through pure dumb luck; as there's no way to compare departments, or tell which policies or initiatives have a positive or negative effect.

Re:Police complaints drop over 90% after deploying body cameras by weberc2 on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @01:45PM (#12637538)
> I'm not convinced that a study that relies on IQ (which is itself a biased metric) and self-reported data (self-reported data is low quality) makes the picture "unclear".

1. I didn't intend to communicate that this paper alone makes the picture unclear. This paper is just one source that indicates no bias in law enforcement.

2. This paper explains why IQ is a reasonable factor

3. This paper explains why this self-reported data is reasonable

4. The data from convicted criminals, victims, and law-enforcement all tell a similar story (African Americans commit crimes disproportionately)

I agree with you that there are huuuuge gaps in our data collection, and this is a really serious problem. Besides the gaps you mentioned, Eric Holder's justice department stopped releasing information on race of perpetrators in 2009 and many large (liberal) cities don't report this information either. This information is obviously critical if we want to determine whether or not we have a racial bias in law enforcement.

Re:Police complaints drop over 90% after deploying body cameras by richmarr on Tuesday October 04, 2016 @06:15PM (#12640021)
1. Sure, okay.

2. Disagree. Even without the cultural references that cripple some IQ measures, IQ tests are susceptible to priming effects, stereotype threat, etc.

3. Maybe Feel free to highlight a specific part you feel justifies that.

4. Similar to what? I thought you said the evidence is unclear.