So if your child was about to jump out a window or run in to a busy street you wouldn't try to stop them?
Even if I were to agree with GP, I'd probably still stop my friend high on ketamine from walking in front of a bus (if he actually exists, that is).
I was going to correct or reply, but I felt it would be more useful to the forum to have folks push the edges and discuss them.
I don't claim to have an in-depth analysis of those edge cases. As a suggested place to start, if the state feels that you are able to live on your own -- provide yourself food and clothing, make choices about your location and lifestyle -- you should probably be able to make the decision to self terminate. Or rather, you are able to do that whether we like it or not, the question is really whether or not we feel we should use force to stop you. I don't think we should.
How do we determine this? What's a sound mind? One may argue that if one wants to die they, by definition, aren't in a sound mind and need mental health services instead.
Once I couldn't get released from a hospital for a physical problem - and they used the same argument. Because they could. (I ended up calling my lawyer who came and reassured them that I was indeed crazy to want to leave, but that their liability ended when I signed the acknowledgement that I might die at any moment.)
I'd assume that if it were to become legal, there would be some sort of evaluation process - the state does like its checklist of criteria met.
https://dredf.org/public-policy/assisted-suicide/some-oregon...
The driver who strikes the person in this hypothetical, for example, would likely be traumatized, feeling all kinds of strong emotions for being involved in another's death. The would-be suicide has no right to impose that on the random driver whose vehicle they want to use to commit suicide.
Even if I did, I might still stop them (or an adult) if I believed their actions were unintentionally putting themselves in harms-way or if they were endangering others (pedestrians below or roadway users).
So yes, I would stop her from running in front of a car.
I firmly believe in the right of anybody, for any reason, to self-terminate. But that's not euthanasia. When we start getting society involved in the business of terminating people who request it? It's another level of moral and utilitarian complexity.
I think a lot of folks are mixing it all together and demanding that my right to self-terminate should force the doctor down the street to help out. These two things do not have to be related. People have been offing themselves for eons. They will continue doing so without the medical establishment.
I don't have any easy answers for what society should do for the mentally ill. It seems obvious to me, however, that we should certainly be able to provide food, housing, and medical treatment to them before we'd consider setting up a system to euthanize them.