If you weren't aware, that is the current standard for involuntary hospitalization, at least in the US. I believe the phrase is "danger to self or others."
CRITERIA.—A person may be taken to a receiving facility for involuntary
examination if there is reason to believe that the person has a mental
illness and because of his or her mental illness:
(a) 1. The person has refused voluntary examination after conscientious
explanation and disclosure of the purpose of the examination; or
2. The person is unable to determine for himself or herself whether
examination is necessary; and
(b) 1. Without care or treatment, the person is likely to suffer from
neglect or refuse to care for himself or herself; such neglect or
refusal poses a real and present threat of substantial harm to his
or her well-being; and it is not apparent that such harm may be
avoided through the help of willing family members or friends or
the provision of other services; or
2. There is a substantial likelihood that without care or treatment
the person will cause serious bodily harm to himself or herself or
others in the near future, as evidenced by recent behavior.
Note that this is only supposed to result in a 72-hour evaluation. It has also been fraught with allegations of abuse by family members, schools, and courts who don't want to properly deal with complex psychological and behavioral issues in more appropriate ways.[1] Full Baker Act is here: http://www.leg.state.fl.us/statutes/index.cfm?App_mode=Displ... The criteria are specifically from 394.463 (1).
Personally, I think we need to set the bar for involuntary intervention higher than being an active threat. If someone doesn't have the mental wherewithal to not lose their coat in the middle of a cold snap, that seems like a clear indicator to me that they need help and their refusal shouldn't be taken any more seriously than their delusions.
I may be biased and embittered on this subject.
But in other situations, the question arises just like in the article. At what point do you want to dose the individual with a sense of reality? If their mentally-ill self is content with the life they lead and "curing" them of it will leave them empty, sad, and hollow (in addition to the side effects of medication), is the arguably a better option?
If you factor in the fact that the hospital won't be there to help him rehab back into society, I can see the decision being difficult to make, as the author mentions.
As someone who went to Virginia Tech I've seen how that "eh, he's/she's not bothering anyone" response can go terribly wrong. And when it goes wrong, the first thing people will ask is why that professional didn't do something when they had the chance.
It's a very fine line to walk between individual liberties and providing treatment to those who need it. If you're schizophrenic and you live on the streets, yell at birds all day, and eat from the garbage, you are not considered a danger to yourself, even though you have a pretty abysmal quality of life and are at serious risk of dying from disease, drugs, homicide, exposure, or starvation. It's a complicated conversation with no clear answers.
The one person I knew personally who broke with reality wasn't religious, and instead seemed to be pulling ideas from her previous goals and highlights of her life. She described a sort of ideal version of her life, the best things she could think of in the moment, regardless of consistency or reality. It makes sense that if one were raised in a religious household, one would talk about being chosen by God or some such instead of how you were getting straight A's in school and getting hired by 5 different places.
http://news.stanford.edu/2014/07/16/voices-culture-luhrmann-...
People tend to think their talking to spiritual things in some sense, but Americans heard God, or angels or demons, Indians tended to hear from ancestors or kin, Ghanaians from various spirits. Indians and Ghanaian found that many voices where helpful and positive. The Americans all found their voices to be violent and negative.
She probably just wanted to calm him down and make him see the world more positive. Eventually it wasn't positive for his opponents and the world. He started to believe he has the direct connection with the God and that therefore anything he does, even the killings and tortures, were directly supported by the God. He turned out to be a "successful" prophet based on the impact he made.
https://wikiislam.net/wiki/Muhammad%27s_Just_In_Time_Revelat...
If I wasn't on guard, prepared to devote thought to the question, I'd have accepted any of those answers - but this article makes it easy to see how those different goals can be in conflict.
If I had to come up with the best answer I could, I think I'd settle on "A psychologist's mission should be to prevent a person from actively harming the physical health of themselves or others, even taking into account reasonable expectations of future harm based on current activities. And additionally to help make any adjustments that the patient requests." So, sometimes it's okay to involuntarily treat, but only if there's a present or soon-to-be present physical danger. Otherwise, only help them with the things they want fixed.
(Note: I once had a long and coherent conversation with a guy who knew he was the messiah promised to the jews, descendant of david, future king of the world. It was an unavoidable fact. Him being a young, black presbyterian had no bearing on the issue. He had lots of evidence, much of it delusional, and much of his reasoning was based on bad information that he was literally incapable of doubting. But in the end, his delusion was immensely satisfying to him, and his life was otherwise boring, banal, and from an outside perspective, depressing as hell. And from what I can tell, as long as he doesn't travel to Israel and get a jewish girlfriend, the more dangerously bizarre parts of his prophecies won't begin, so I just decided to wish him well and let it go.)