All in all, the day trip wasn't worth the feeling of violation.
On the way back a few times I have encountered surly demeaning behavior. Being a border patrol officer would be a tedious job at times and I don't expect a smile but outward hostility is ridiculous. For non citizen encountering this it is a terrible and lasting bad first impression of the US.
Also a NEXUS / Global Entry card makes them far more nicer.
Especially given the strength of the USD over CAD these days
I suppose that's why I'm not!
There are sometimes customs checks though, you are only allowed to bring really small amounts of meat into the country for example.
Once I was stopped, checked thoroughly for about 40 minutes, in the middle of the night. They did some sort of exercise on me, taking away all my money, put them into envelope, then returning back and so on. Went through whole car, backpack, everything. Not a nice experience
Forestry is about the size of tech ($14 billion) which is twice tourism.
To put it into perspective, the BC government spends and collects $50 billion each year.
Financial services, real estate, retail, and other services are big. I doubt tourism is or ever was more than 3% of the economy, except maybe in 1986 and 2010.
I had a friend who worked at the Canadian border in BC a few years back. According to him, the main reason the border exists is to control goods coming from the states so that they can be taxed. A lot of people go south of the border to go shopping and don't accurately declare what they're bringing back.
Until pot was legalised in WA the border officers were on a mad hunt to find weed on every person crossing. They would do so under the guise of accusing you of going to work illegally and any number of other things.
Then after WA legalised BC decided that they would step up their own reefer madness campaign to keep the WA weed out. As if BC needs to import it, but I digress. They even went as far as staging a "COPS"-style programme on television to showcase all the vagrants they catch. It was eventually cancelled, but not before exposing the world to all of the security theatre of the BC border crossing.
The irony of it all is that weed is everywhere in Canada and the US and the BC/WA border is just a shitshow of angry assholes on both sides. It is very unfortunate for the tourism industry on both sides.
Anyway, the court has no records of my being arrested, but somehow the Canadian border police do.
The last time I went up to Montreal on the train I was pulled aside and asked if I'd ever been arrested. I first said no, but then laughed and said, "Yeah actually. 20 years ago."
Then I was told that they were going to let me through that time but don't come through again unless I can show proof that I wasn't charged with a crime.
I haven't been back. Though I have travelled wide and far since and not caught any slack. Seriously Canada. I like you, but you're not that awesome. Ridiculous.
They asked you to prove a negative? This speaks volumes about the mindset of run-of-the-mill border guards and the sensibility of their policies...
At least in principle you might be able to get a court to write a letter saying you haven't been charged.
I was once asked by a Cypriot border guard to prove I couldn't speak Greek. I still can't think of what I could have said/done that would have convinced them. And yes I did ask at the time. And yes it annoyed them that I asked.
As a point of interest, this is actually possible! There is a well-known effect in cognitive science called the Stroop effect [0], in which the semantic value of a word interferes with the main task of having to declare the color of the font. If the task is performed with Greek words and you don't speak Greek, you will be able to enumerate the color of the "ink" without any penalty in reaction time.
Apparently this was used in the 50's to root out Russian spies in the CIA.
(But the absurdity of the border-guard's demands are not lost on me, of course!)
Fascinating though, thanks for the link.
That said, there are electrophysiological markers of semantic incongruency (e.g. table + fork = congruent, cat + rag = incongruent) that work in the auditory modality. If you're interested, the component in question is called the N400 and you should be able to find plenty of references on google shcolar.
I got Nexus because the line to get to the booth is sometimes longer than I'd like (and TSA pre-check is nice).
My experience was rather different - the return trip was always easy and fast, and I don't recall ever having to even get out of the car at the border; they just asked me a few questions and waved me through. Always very polite and friendly.
Crossing into US was much more daunting: you always had to park the car for them to inspect, and then wait anywhere from 30 minutes to a couple hours in a queue to get interviewed by a CBP agent. More often than not, they were pretty rude (not just to myself; I observed other people getting similar treatment). I think there was exactly one crossing where the treatment that I've got was truly professional.
Note that I wasn't a citizen, or even permanent resident, of either country at the time - I had a work visa in Canada, and a visitor/business visa in US.
No idea if this has changed recently; my experience is from 2009-2010.
Also, back in 1998, I went to Canada with my uncle to get a toilet (he wanted a larger liter-per-flush unit than you could get in the US) and the Canadian crossing guards thought that was hilarious when we declared it as a reason for entry. Coming home, it warranted a complete search of our persons and vehicle. Even though we had a receipt.
The treatment has been similar in my 20 or so trips up there: coming in to my home takes significantly longer than visiting a foreign land. I find it exasperating.
For real, crossing into Canada from the US at Vancouver is probably the toughest English speaking border I've dealt with as an American. England, Ireland, the Anzacs, I've never had an issue, but damn, every time I visit Vancouver I budget extra time to deal with immigration. I go through Toronto a lot, too, and never have issues there, but nearly everyone I know gets harassed on both sides of the Canadian/US border up at the Couv.