News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why the iPad isn't for me by Tichy on Tuesday April 13, 2010 @10:48AM (#1262133)
With respect of iPads for moms and grandparents, I am also a bit doubtful. Since a lot of web sites probably don't work as expected (ie no Flash, among other things), wouldn't that be confusing to the noobs? I am waiting for the first review from an iPad-Mommy.
Re:Why the iPad isn't for me by briancooley on Tuesday April 13, 2010 @11:10AM (#1262217)
My wife is dubious. She doesn't like the lack of Flash. She doesn't like trying to type on the software keyboard.

Her parents, definite technophobes, were intimidated by it. The first thing they wanted to look at was a slideshow on smugmug.com, some pictures of their granddaughter. Also Flash. They looked at me incredulously as I explained to them that you couldn't view the slideshow on the iPad. They tried to use the navigation on the website, but the navigation links were small and adjacent to the shopping cart link. At the height of their frustration, I pulled out my MBP so they could watch the slideshow on it. The thought of explaining to them how to set up their iPad to sync photos gives me chills.

OTOH, my 3-year-old LOVES it. She can use a mouse and a trackpad, but she has to concentrate and make deliberate movements. On the iPad, she flies. She can get to her favorite apps and watch her videos in a flash. There are lots of downsides to having this device in a toddler's hands, and I'd never let her use it unsupervised, but that's an aside from the usability issue.

Re:Why the iPad isn't for me by mortenjorck on Tuesday April 13, 2010 @12:27PM (#1262482)
I still don't understand why Apple ever decided to play up the iPad's web browsing experience. I've written on this at length before, but even apart from Flash, the desktop web is simply not compatible as-is with a tablet interface.

The iPad will make a fantastic browser for the tablet web, if and when that web is built, but today it's a poor substitute for a mouse and keyboard when websites expect those.

Re:Why the iPad isn't for me by necubi on Tuesday April 13, 2010 @03:09PM (#1263020)
I don't think you've actually used the iPad to browse the web. Personally, I block flash on my desktop and rarely find reason to unblock it, so the lack of flash doesn't bother me. Meanwhile, surfing on the iPad is in general so nice that I've been doing it even when near my computer.
Re:Why the iPad isn't for me by zzzmarcus on Tuesday April 13, 2010 @03:41PM (#1263120)
I have an iPad and I don't really miss Flash too much, but I do find other aspects of web browsing much less efficient.

Tabs are much more cumbersome. Instead of just clicking a tab, you've got to zoom out, pick your window and zoom back in. It's a lot more motion.

Scrolling, typing, copying and pasting are also not as simple. Touch scrolling is nice, but it's a lot more movement. Typing and copy/paste are just slower. I still type slower on the large iPad keyboard than on the much smaller iPhone keyboard.

Another problem I have with it is that if I'm filling out a form, for example a message on Facebook, and I need to switch to email to copy something and come back to Safari and paste it in, there is no guarantee that the Facebook message I started typing will still be there. It's a little frustrating.

I'm sure all these kinks will eventually be worked out, but as it is, I still find myself grabbing my Macbook Pro when I'm going to be any "serious" browsing or my iPhone when I'm just looking something up really quickly.

I really like the iPad for some things, but in my experience, browsing hasn't been all it was cracked up to be.

Re:Why the iPad isn't for me by kenjackson on Tuesday April 13, 2010 @03:49PM (#1263139)
It's a great experience for browsing a web page. But here's something I had to do when I had my iPad, which sucked with it, but is great on desktop:

We have a wiki and I needed to move a bunch of comments to work items in our bug database. So on my desktop I would have just have two instances of the browser open and would literally read from the wiki and create new work items in the bug database.

On the iPad this was painful. There's no side by side view (that I could get to work at least), and it seemed to reload the bug database every time I'd toggle back to that page!!! I don't want a reload, just show me the page I was looking at 10 seconds ago!

Not a good experience.

Re:Why the iPad isn't for me by commieneko on Tuesday April 13, 2010 @06:35PM (#1263566)
The side by side issue for windows, especially browsers is intrinsic in the small screen size. For now, the desktop is the place for activity like that.

However ... Remember all those Star Trek episodes with people sitting at a desk with _several_ pad like devices spread out in front of them; like a paper covered desk? Now imagine a similar situation with several tablet devices that have some type of screen bridging/device linking software. I can easily imagine scenarios where this will be useful. Now imagine combining that _with_ a desktop display.

Frankly, I think there is a big future in tablet and multi-screen devices as adjunct input and manipulation platforms. Dig up a copy of a short anime called _Pale Cocoon_ and watch what the people are doing with the computer interfaces in that show. Whether or not the UI concepts would actually work in real life, the ideas presented are _very_ much worth thinking about.

Re:Why the iPad isn't for me by ubernostrum on Tuesday April 13, 2010 @11:31AM (#1262285)
a slideshow on smugmug.com, some pictures of their granddaughter

I have a feeling that if the iPad sells well, the "why do it in HTML when we could do it in Flash" style of site will die out. It's no consolation right now, of course, but I wouldn't complain if that ends up happening (and, really? Flash just to show some pictures one after another?).

Re:Why the iPad isn't for me by blhack on Tuesday April 13, 2010 @11:40AM (#1262306)
Ehh...I'd say that, if anything, web developers don't want apple dictating how they design their websites. The reality is that the overwhelming majority of people aren't HN readers and really don't care that adobe has changed their CS5 pre-order app to flash. They like going to smugmug and having it just work.
Re:Why the iPad isn't for me by MWinther on Tuesday April 13, 2010 @12:23PM (#1262469)
But apparently, having Adobe dictating the very same thing is fine, then?
Re:Why the iPad isn't for me by blhack on Tuesday April 13, 2010 @12:32PM (#1262502)
Assume adobe released a hardware platform and it didn't support javascript. If somebody were to suggest that the entire web development community was going to abandon javascript in order to allow adobe's platform to reach the saturation required to make it the "standard", then your argument might make sense.

As it stands, the iPad exists in a state that makes it almost unusable for the overwhelming majority of web users (at least as anything more than a novelty, much like web browsing on the iPhone)

Re:Why the iPad isn't for me by sesqu on Wednesday April 14, 2010 @03:09AM (#1264364)
Graceful degradation. People would absolutely suggest that, and charge dearly for implementing it. Companies would pay for some of it, and in 5 years, it would either die out or there would be some sort of "cgi on rails"-framework that automates some minimal version of that, that looks horrendous and sorta-kinda works. Probably ASP.net. Then we'd have hobbyists and ux professionals hand-crafting everything on a lamp-like stack, and everyone else would get along with upgrading backends.

ECMAScript may be google's horse in the race, but it's still just an add-on.

Re:Why the iPad isn't for me by glhaynes on Tuesday April 13, 2010 @01:38PM (#1262734)
Perhaps unusable as their only machine. That by no means makes it merely a novelty.
Re:Why the iPad isn't for me by Tichy on Tuesday April 13, 2010 @02:11PM (#1262843)
But it makes it useless as "the computer for mom".
Re:Why the iPad isn't for me by glhaynes on Tuesday April 13, 2010 @06:56PM (#1263628)
I was responding to a claim that the iPad is "almost unusable for the overwhelming majority of web users (at least as anything more than a novelty [...])".

If mom's savvy enough to use a computer aside from her iPad then she can use that computer to get to the sites she wants to go to that her iPad doesn't support. If she's only savvy enough for an iPad, then she's still better off being able to get to the non-Flash parts of the web than nothing.

Re:Why the iPad isn't for me by qeorge on Tuesday April 13, 2010 @03:48PM (#1263135)
Definitely true. We've all been barking up the "don't use Flash unless you need it" tree for years, but it hasn't really made a difference.

Bottom line seems to be that people love the way Flash sites look. If we can achieve that differently, bully for us, but most people probably won't notice.

Re:Why the iPad isn't for me by buster on Tuesday April 13, 2010 @01:48PM (#1262768)
Also people tend to forget that Adobe pretty much owns the whole creativity/content creation chain. Magazines, Books, Websites, Images, HTML, CSS, JS, Flash, whatnot. All those things are currently done pretty well with Adobes products alone. Granted, i'm no magazine editor and i don't do flash. I wouldn't use Dreamweaver for writing websites, but i can understand quite well when designers like to use Adobes tools as they provide them with pretty much everything they need.
Re:Why the iPad isn't for me by blhack on Tuesday April 13, 2010 @02:30PM (#1262916)
And this is something that I cannot believe apple seems to have overlooked. They haven't just pissed on some little obscure software company, they've pissed on the software company that the people they need to win over (content creators, designers) use for everything.
Re:Why the iPad isn't for me by Tichy on Tuesday April 13, 2010 @11:53AM (#1262357)
Funny you mention your 3-year-old. I have been thinking exactly that, that there might be a way to create fun apps for babies and kids.

I am firmly against wooden toys and want to give my kid a computer asap (OK, nothing against wooden toys, but you get the idea).

So I wondered if the iPad is durable enough for a kid. Ultimately I expect cheaper variants to appear, with special kids durability (of course not from Apple, but maybe Android or sth like that).

Would be interested in hearing more stories about kids on pads.

Re:Why the iPad isn't for me by Psyonic on Tuesday April 13, 2010 @12:54PM (#1262572)
As is, $500 for a 3-year old's toy seems a little crazy. By her a leap-frog instead? But cheaper, more durable options would make a lot of sense.
Re:Why the iPad isn't for me by briancooley on Tuesday April 13, 2010 @02:04PM (#1262822)
My kid has a leapfrog, but that doesn't curb her curiosity about other devices.

I don't know how it is with others, but my kid is fascinated with all my computers. My netbook, my MBP, my Droid, my Touch, and now my iPad. I don't discourage her curiosity. We had a VIC-20 when I was a kid and later a Commodore 64, and that's probably the reason I love programming to this day.

What she wants most of all is for her parents to sit with her as she discovers. The iPad is really good for that - the best computer I own for that use case, I think. I can't stand the Leapfrog for long, but watching her with the iPad is fun. It helps that I have the chops to build little apps to distribute on my own devices.

Re:Why the iPad isn't for me by Psyonic on Tuesday April 13, 2010 @04:07PM (#1263204)
I don't have kids, but I'd feel exactly the same about letting her explore and try out things.

What I was saying was that if it was a disappointment for you, but your 3 year old loved it, it's probably not worth keeping. Child curiosity can be appeased for less than $500.

Now if you loved it as well, it's a different story.

Re:Why the iPad isn't for me by Splines on Tuesday April 13, 2010 @06:20PM (#1263525)
> Child curiosity can be appeased for less than $50

Definitely. My daughter loves play-acting with her toys (most of which are just cheap plastic things from Toys R Us). Pencils and crayons with reams of paper last for quite some time. Blocks, balls, and mini versions of adult things (e.g., toy phones, kitchen appliances) that let them play pretend, are all great hits.

In my experience, the specific toys (i.e., the ones that have clearly defined "play" scenarios) are the ones that get great attention for an hour, and then are left at the back of the closet until we get rid of them.

Computer software is similar - my son loves any building/open world type game (simcity, bridge builder, the sims, harvest moon), but usually loses interest at games that have very specific goals (most platform type games, although mario and the lego games seem to be exceptions).

Re:Why the iPad isn't for me by pohl on Tuesday April 13, 2010 @01:28PM (#1262696)
Isn't it more likely that the pad would belong to the parents and a $1.99 app would be the child's toy?
Re:Why the iPad isn't for me by Psyonic on Tuesday April 13, 2010 @04:05PM (#1263194)
You'd think so, but this is the 3rd review I've read where the adult was relatively disappointed in the iPad, but OH BOY does his child love it. It's starting to make me think its for kids.
Re:Why the iPad isn't for me by briancooley on Tuesday April 13, 2010 @05:27PM (#1263413)
That's not my personal review. It's a review from the perspective of my wife and in-laws. They don't use smartphones and are the kind of users that like to do things in familiar ways.

I think it's interesting that kids take to the device more easily than adults. Part of that is simpler usage, but part of it is not having preconceived notions about how to use the device. It also makes me think that a certain class of users is going to have to take some time with the iPad. My wife hated our netbook when I bought it; now I have to pry it from her hands.

I'm not disappointed at all in the iPad, but then again my expectations weren't extremely high. I knew typing would be a chore. I knew that there were going to be ergonomic challenges. I wasn't expecting the browser to be on par with the desktop. Also, I mostly bought it to develop for.

Re:Why the iPad isn't for me by pyre on Tuesday April 13, 2010 @06:53PM (#1263617)
> Part of that is simpler usage, but part of it is not having preconceived notions about how to use the device.

I'm thinking that most of it is simpler usage. Unless you're qualifying "I can't access my favorite websites because they use flash" under 'preconceived notions.' At least for me, I would be disappointed where the functionality was lacking (i.e. "it can't be done" vs "it can only be done in a different way"), and that is something that a child wouldn't suffer from as much.

Re:Why the iPad isn't for me by ZeroGravitas on Tuesday April 13, 2010 @01:43PM (#1262751)
Maybe Apple should think about making a smaller version might work for kids? It would be kind of like an iPod Touch except... actually it would be an iPod Touch.

Seriously, my 2 year old kid enjoys my iPhone. I'm just annoyed that they don't support HTML5 audio to the degree that I (and others) could be building the type of simple interaction apps he enjoys with HTML.

Re:Why the iPad isn't for me by jimbokun on Tuesday April 13, 2010 @12:05PM (#1262403)
"I am firmly against wooden toys and want to give my kid a computer asap"

Less chance of splinters.

Re:Why the iPad isn't for me by mikepurvis on Tuesday April 13, 2010 @02:04PM (#1262823)
Is that actually a concern? I can't tell if you're being flippant or serious...
Re:Why the iPad isn't for me by jimbokun on Tuesday April 13, 2010 @03:15PM (#1263040)
Flippant.
Re:Why the iPad isn't for me by briancooley on Tuesday April 13, 2010 @02:07PM (#1262833)
It feels solid, but wouldn't call it durable. It definitely feels like the kind of thing you wouldn't want to drop. I'm constantly worried about the screen getting scratched, though I know it is inevitable.
Re:Why the iPad isn't for me by skeletonjelly on Tuesday April 13, 2010 @06:55PM (#1263623)
"She can get to her favorite apps and watch her videos in a flash. "

Pun intended?

Re:Why the iPad isn't for me by revorad on Tuesday April 13, 2010 @11:44AM (#1262321)
That's a very interesting experience.

and watch her videos in a flash.

Delicious irony.