The graduate student was George Dantzig. While I think Dantzig is certainly an example of extraordinary natural talent, if your parent comment was looking for examples of talent manifesting itself before any training at all, I don't think this qualifies. As a grad student in math, Dantzig had already spent years studying mathematics by this point.
On Dantzig: there's training, and there's the capability to come on a problem cold, treat it as an ordinary exam question, and find a solution within a day or so, to something which had dogged the rest of the maths world for years or decades.
I'm not denying that Dantzig had had formal training by this point. But he'd also accomplished in small time what others hadn't in big.
Gauss
> * The UC Berkeley Graduate student who solved 2-3 "extra credit" final exam questions ... only to discover they were previously unsolved proofs.
George Bernard Dantzig
* The schoolboy who realised the algorithm for adding the integers 1 - 100.
* The UC Berkeley Graduate student who solved 2-3 "extra credit" final exam questions ... only to discover they were previously unsolved proofs.
Chess isn't an area I'm closely familiar with, but there absolutely have been prodigies there as well. Many in music.