Not true. Instead of burning fuel, you can use electricity (something like an arc welder) to generate heat. And the efficiency with which that heat is turned into mechanical power will be dependent on the compression ratio, regardless of whether the thermal energy is coming from electricity or burning fuel.
Thermal energy in chemical fuel and the potential energy in a battery or a raised weight have the same units, but there's actually a difference. You can turn energy in a battery or a raised weight into mechanical energy with 100% efficiency - not achieved in practice, but there's no theoretical limit.
When you turn thermal energy into mechanical energy (via Otto cycle in a car or Brayton cycle in a jet), the peak efficiency you can achieve has a theoretical limit based on how much you can compress the working fluid (air) before injecting thermal energy (burning fuel or an electric arc).
So if you've got electic energy that you can turn into mechanical energy in a fan with 100% efficiency, why would you take the thermodynamic losses of "burning" that electricity? Because we don't know how to go supersonic speeds with a fan or propeller - the only way we know how, for now, is with a jet running on the brayton cycle. And all the advances we've made in high compression fuel-burning jets would apply to electric jets just as well.
If you're okay limiting your top speed to ~Mach 0.7, then you're correct spinning a large propeller using electricity is absolutely a better way to go, and you can make that propeller a lot bigger if you're able to tilt it.
Karem Aircraft has done extremely interesting work on figuring out how to tilt rotors, and much of their research would apply to electric motors as well: http://karemaircraft.com/
Egads, no. Please get out of the business of being limited by thermodynamics in your engines. The Carnot cycle is a hard stop whenever heat is being coaxed into doing mechanical work. You don't want that.
Just convert electricity into mechanical work directly.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gas_turbine#/media/File:J85_ge...
In the engine pictured, which has 8 compressors in a row, the energy which those fans are able to put into the flow is miniscule compared to the energy that you can dump in by burning fuel (or electricity) in the tiny combustion chamber.
F-16 in afterburner is consuming 64,000 pounds of fuel per hour = 18 pounds per second A pound of Jet-A has 20 MJ per pound.
So that's 360 MW of thermal power. Even if you're only turning 10% of that into usable thrust, that's 36MW of power.
Here's what a 35MW power plant looks like: http://www.power-technology.com/projects/ctds_chp/ctds_chp5....
The people working on electric jets are well aware of the Carnot limit, and it's true that they don't want that. But for now, we'd need a lot of new tech to put 35MW of thrust power into a flow using electric motors and fans. Heck, we need a lot of new tech to put 350MW of power electronics onto an airplane!! My only point is that I don't think we should look down our noses at the people working on thermodynamic machinery. Until we can do better, they're the best we've got :)
Turning chemical energy (low entropy energy) into electrical energy (low-medium entropy) into thermal energy (high entropy) to make mechanical energy (of intermediate) would be incredibly inefficient. Combustible fuels are much better than batteries at making things hot; I don't have the time to run the numbers right now, but what you are saying is incredibly wasteful. Please take a thermodynamics course.
Fans are commonly used on supersonic aircraft. Most modern fighter aircraft use medium or low bypass turbofans, which are using fans to go supersonic. Turbofans are less efficient than turbojets over Mach ~1.6-1.8 (or in reheat), but a ducted fan could probably do better.
But if you are getting electric energy for free from solar panels, and you're getting chemical energy by pumping taxed dinosaur carbon into the air, then you might find that the electric energy could be more efficient.
You're absolutely correct that it's wildly inefficient by any metric now. But if clean electric energy became wildly abundant, that would change.
In computing, there are all kinds of wildly wasteful things (web browsers) that are the best way to do things because computation is extremely cheap. It's very interesting to think about what kinds of devices would make economic sense if electric energy had the same price collapse that computation has done.
The fact that we "burn electricity" in electric water heaters, stoves, and toasters rather than only using high-entropy energy sources like gas water heaters and gas stoves is an example where present-day electric energy supply chains have beaten out the theoretical advantages of only using high-entropy energy sources when it is possible to do so.
1) Aircraft cost is proportional to empty weight.
2) Range is proportional to total stored energy / drag and drag is proportional to weight. If you have low specific energy, you cannot go far.
And it's true that airliners take off with more weight than they are speced to land with. They have to dump fuel if landing before burning it off.
If you are getting electrical energy for free I have some WAY WAY better uses for it than an airplane.
Let's save hydrocarbon fuel for mobile installation (planes and cars), and use the solar power for fixed installations (houses, industry).
Maybe once you maxed out houses, we can come back to the mobile stuff.
Why go through all the trouble of using electricity as the heat source in a Brayton cycle engine instead of the obvious solution, using electric motors? Your statement that "we don't know how to go supersonic speeds with a fan or propeller" is clearly wrong, since supersonic aircraft have been flying with turbofans and no afterburners for almost five decades now.
At low-mach, the fuel burn is primarily producing torque which turns the fan. This fan could be turned by electricity.
At high-mach, the fuel burn is primarily producing pure thrust, and the fan portion hurts the engine's performance.
Supersonic turbofans are a compromise that have to produce thrust from takeoff through to high speed. I may be incorrect, but I don't believe we have ever built a ducted fan which can use pure torque to generate supersonic thrust, although I guess I don't see why it wouldn't be theoretically possible. We can put megawatts of energy into a fast-moving flow using thermal energy and a brayton cycle. In order to put megawatts of energy into fast-moving flow using rotors would require a totally new design - nothing like the supersonic turbofans currently in production.
No engine (of which I am aware) has air flowing past the fan blades at supersonic speeds, because the trans-sonic transitions tear engines apart. There is one prototype aircraft (a naval derivative of the F-84) which did have a supersonic propeller, but it was very inefficient and loud. All jet engines compress sub-Mach 1 flows, then expand them at the very back of the engine to produce supersonic exhaust.
Exactly. At high mach, almost all of the energy being put into the flow is from expanding combustion gases - not the compressor stage. If you wanted to go at supersonic speeds using only spinning fans, you will need a heck of a lot of fans. Maybe we could do it! But we haven't so far.
But part of a turbofan's thrust is from gasses from burning jet fuel and air expanded by the heat form that isn't it? Nobody has flown supersonic without burning fuel except in a dive, have they?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fastest_propeller-driven_aircr...
So you can have an electric motor to power the fan, but what about the turbine part?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear-powered_aircraft
Some joules are more expensive than others :)
If the end goal is to generate heat, then there's no good reason to add those additional steps.
Could the Same conversion apply to scram jets?
As bad of an idea as using javascript to do addition rather than assembly. You're assuming electric energy is the same order of magnitude cost as electric energy. It's possible that could change some day.
This is all well and good under normal flight conditions, but the glide ratio in the event of motor failure would not lend itself well to commercial flight.
Short wing aircraft are fine for military use where low occupancy and ejector seats provide emergency egress. Passenger aircraft - not so much.
In addition, there is no 'safe' aircraft, and all of them can fall out of the sky; glide ratios don't help you if the wing breaks at the fuselage. If the motors are as reliable as the wings, then making them more critical seems reasonable.
Existing engines are designed to compress air, combust fuel, and recover energy from the exhaust to push air (to propel the aircraft) then compress more (to keep the cycle going). Once you are no longer combusting fuel, all of that compression is simply wasted energy. An electric aircraft is much more likely to have single-stage axial fans, with a much larger diameter than jets like the Concorde (because larger and slower fans are more efficient). This difference in propulsion will probably affect various other elements of airframe design.
As an aside, Elon Musk has mentioned VTOL as a possible feature of electric aircraft, and this makes a lot of sense. If the fans can be tilted (to provide part of the 'lift' for takeoffs and landings), it means that the airplane could have very small wings, which are usually good for efficiency, but cause problems while landing conventionally.