News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The decline of Stack Overflow (2015) by grecy on Sunday September 25, 2016 @02:11PM (#12576500)
I agree.

For the first time in a while, I've picked up a language I have not used for almost 15 years.

Google is helping immensely, and I've been shocked at how often (>95%) of the time the first result is SO, and that answer is perfect. So much so I've stopped searching google, I've just got a lot of SO tabs open.

It might not be perfect, though I'd say it's the best by a massive margin.

Re:The decline of Stack Overflow (2015) by SiVal on Sunday September 25, 2016 @04:25PM (#12577238)
Sorry, but I disagree. While, yes, I've found that Google searches often led me to answers on SO, I've also lost count of the number of times Google has decided that a question on a StackOverflow page was the MOST RELEVANT to the question I was asking, but SO mods had put a big, fat stamp at the top from moderators announcing that THEY weren't going to permit anyone to answer it.

I don't know how many times I've scanned down a SO page hoping, hoping, hoping that someone managed to smuggle in the answer to my question before the red guards noticed and put a stop to it.

Google simply wants to find the best answer it can to my question, while StackOverflow would rather try to find reasons to prevent it being answered.

I don't want a forum where answering my question is a last resort, and their highest priority is finding a justification for not only not answering, but actually preventing anyone else who was willing to answer from answering.

What we need is a developer forum that is totally open to questions, but with the amazing addition of Google-like search to do ranked prioritization of all answers instead of old-fashioned red guards to prevent answers they didn't like from ever existing, whether you needed those answers or not. You could ask anything you wanted, as long as you were polite, and the worst that could happen would be that your question would be re-tagged (ex: that's actually a DELPHI question, not PASCAL language, because it's not about the language.)

People would then be free to answer or not, as they wished, with votes for answer quality and links to other answers that add to the quality measures. They could express opinions (horrors! opinions from people with experience that you lack! who would EVER want that) or quote the docs, or insert a link to another answer that (in their opinion only) probably answers your question, too, but they do so without preventing anyone else from going ahead and offering their own answer.

Google manages to sort through an entire web full of comments that are "possible duplicates" or "primarily opinion based" and it's amazingly useful. A mini version of that is what we need for software Q%A.

Re:The decline of Stack Overflow (2015) by jakobegger on Sunday September 25, 2016 @05:17PM (#12577505)
A thousand times yes. Stack Overflow has such a high page rank, that closed questions are often at the top of Google Search results. Keeping closed questions available for Google to find is a massive waste of time. On the Google result page it looks like this is exactly the right question -- but just like Experts Exchange, the page doesn't tell you the solution.

If Stack Overflow really wanted to make life easier for people, they would delete closed questions, or move them to a directory that is excluded from search engines. Closed questions are basically bait-and-switch for searchers; they show the question, but don't have an answer.

Re:The decline of Stack Overflow (2015) by intrasight on Sunday September 25, 2016 @08:34PM (#12578322)
I always Google with the timeframe set to "last year"
Re:The decline of Stack Overflow (2015) by kbart on Monday September 26, 2016 @01:41AM (#12579485)
What's the quickest way to do that?
Re:The decline of Stack Overflow (2015) by jungletek on Monday September 26, 2016 @07:54PM (#12586613)
Search Tools button->Last Year
Re:The decline of Stack Overflow (2015) by pbhjpbhj on Sunday September 25, 2016 @05:04PM (#12577428)
The biggest problem for me is which SO site to search. If I've a problem with a bit of bash script to control KDE on Ubuntu then is that Superuser, Unix, SO, AskUbuntu, or ... I don't understand why the site is split up in that manner.

So whilst I'll often choose an SO site I can't use their search.

Try "KDE notifications from bash scripts" for example. Google will show that there are answers on SO and Unix.stackexchange - searching at AskUbuntu (I use Ubuntu with KDE on top) will return zero results and won't even suggest results from other SO sites. SO itself has the best result but seems the least appropriate of the silos to place that search in.

Then there's having to register at each of the different sites on the network. The siloing of the site is PITA IMO. The only reason to do it this way I can think of is to separate computing resources, it seems there are probably better ways around that issue too? Why not a unified site with hierarchical tags such that you can choose a tag as a preferential search term?

Re:The decline of Stack Overflow (2015) by sireat on Sunday September 25, 2016 @05:48PM (#12577634)
This is my problem too, why did SO decide to split the site into so many silos?

I have 10+ memberships at Stack Exchange network most of them math/programming related and it seems so silly.

Sure, keep the multiple brands if that is what your investors want but make it searchable and taggable across sites.

Often I will see a question posted on main SO that would have been perfect by the Stack Exchange rules on some other stack exchange site.

Instead it just gets closed and whoever asked must feel quite dispirited of asking again.

Re:The decline of Stack Overflow (2015) by smsm42 on Sunday September 25, 2016 @06:34PM (#12577819)
Yes, fragmentation is a real problem. Can be probably solved by integrating the search indexes to some measure without integrating the sites themselves. It's not easy, but it can be done IMHO.
Re:The decline of Stack Overflow (2015) by Latty on Friday September 30, 2016 @05:53AM (#12611462)
There is already an integrated search. Google. Seriously, SO would be foolish to try and do what Google already does better.
Re:The decline of Stack Overflow (2015) by MichaelMoser123 on Sunday September 25, 2016 @02:31PM (#12576617)
> So much so I've stopped searching google, I've just got a lot of SO tabs open.

with all due respect but SO search isn't quite stellar.

Re:The decline of Stack Overflow (2015) by dgregd on Sunday September 25, 2016 @03:14PM (#12576861)
Yes, SO search is average quality. Therefore I add site:stackoverflow.com to all my google searches.
Re:The decline of Stack Overflow (2015) by atultherajput on Sunday September 25, 2016 @06:04PM (#12577708)
My SO experience is similar to yours.