News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by rasur on Sunday September 25, 2016 @11:17AM (#12575684)
I think it really boils down to not enough people understanding the issues and the problems. I had seen (once or twice) people out on the streets campaigning against it to raise awareness on the weekends, but honestly, it was not enough. Only the hard-core techies understood (or appeared to understand) the issue - at least around the area of Zürich where I work I can't think of anyone who thought it was a good idea.

Not pleased.

Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by DannyBee on Sunday September 25, 2016 @12:00PM (#12575853)
"I think it really boils down to not enough people understanding the issues and the problems."

FWIW: This is literally the retort everyone has to anything they disagree with that gets approved.

It's unrelated to surveillance.

People always assume "if only people knew what i knew, they would have agreed with me". This is a really bad assumption.

In fact, most of the time, i'd argue exactly the opposite:

People understood fine, they just disagree.

Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by sgift on Sunday September 25, 2016 @01:24PM (#12576243)
It probably boils down to your trust in people. Given many discussions with many people on many topics I tend to stay on the opposite side. Most peoples understanding is about as deep as the most popular news magazines headline, which is not enough for me to consider that they "understood fine, they just disagree" - they understood fine what they've bothered to inform themselves about. So, basically nothing.
Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by mk89 on Sunday September 25, 2016 @05:11PM (#12577470)
>Most peoples understanding is about as deep as the most popular news magazines headline

exactly!which is why, however you put it, with parliaments or with referendums, or with any other kind of "democratic" tool, the basis of democracy is information. When people/media have advantages in something, they will be biased, making democracy actually an oligarchy. If I was Swiss, I would try to understand who is selling me this information. Who is behind this wanted "misinformation"? Most of the time it boils down to people having interests in certain companies. Can it be that, let's say, that most newspapers are "getting convinced" by authorities? Just saying, of course.

Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by Annatar on Monday September 26, 2016 @05:14AM (#12580378)
People understood fine, they just disagree.

They had a public debate, as is the tradition before every referendum, and the assertions and assumptions being presented by both the head of the secret service and the politicians backing it up were incorrect. Technical assumptions were incorrect. The technical capability was misrepresented.

One of the main arguments for this initiative was that the secret service would only be allowed to look at the packet traffic of the affected target, but the reality is that in order to capture just that traffic, all packets are captured and filtered out first; also, there is no technology in existence to prevent the secret service to packet capturing everything.

This, however, was never stated or addressed in the public debate.

Also asserted was that the secret service has and will have good oversight of all activities. The committee consists of only five people. And these people are all politicians currently in the government. If you just look at checking which TCP/IP packets were captured, that's already way too much work for five politicians in the oversight committee. This was not addressed at all either.

Using encryption was not addressed. The fact that the secret service would be legally allowed to break into people's systems was not addressed in the public debate. Most of the debate revolved around whether the government spying on its citizens is correct in principle.

Technical capability and what is possible today were never discussed.

How the suspects would be identified was declared secret, with nobody except the oversight committee of those five politicians being allowed an insight into it.

So, I stand with the previous poster that people did not know what we know, and they voted based on incorrect assumptions and misrepresentation or outright omission, whether unintentional or intentional, of technical capability and facts.

Benjamin Franklin's quote seems very appropriate in this case:

those who would trade liberty for little personal safety deserve neither liberty nor safety.

Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by rasur on Monday September 26, 2016 @05:46AM (#12580495)
I cannot up-vote you enough for your response. Thanks for filling in the gaps.
Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by DannyBee on Tuesday September 27, 2016 @03:47PM (#12592484)
"Technical assumptions were incorrect. The technical capability was misrepresented."

Your response really doesn't say this. It's just a bunch of opinion and says "i wish they had presented additional info i believe matters". That falls squarely within the studies i pasted, which show both that people always think this would change result, and that people are pretty much always wrong when they think this, and that it does not change results.

"One of the main arguments for this initiative was that the secret service would only be allowed to look at the packet traffic of the affected target, but the reality is that in order to capture just that traffic, all packets are captured and filtered out first;"

This is not necessarily true of course. You can, in fact, filter on the fly if you want to. Deep packet inspection at link speed is a thing.

"also, there is no technology in existence to prevent the secret service to packet capturing everything."

In what sense, exactly?

You can make this happen at the level that any such thing would be noticed immediately, and would require incredible numbers of people to conspire. You can make it audited by as many independent people as you want.

If you mean "there are always ways around this if enough people conspire", that is a generally true statement about the world, and people already know this. Again, the fact that you think this matters very heavily, and others do not, does not make everyone else ignorant or misinformed.

"Also asserted was that the secret service has and will have good oversight of all activities. The committee consists of only five people. And these people are all politicians currently in the government. If you just look at checking which TCP/IP packets were captured, that's already way too much work for five politicians in the oversight committee. This was not addressed at all either. "

This is a strong opinion/prediction of yours (along with some casual classism and denigration of "politicians" for no reason), and may or may not turn out to be factually correct. This is not a misrepresentation on anyone's part, and is certainly not falsifiable yet. It sounds like an objective presentation was made of the plan. You disagree with the viability and usefulness of that plan. That, again, is not a misrepresentation or omission. It simply means you have a possible difference of opinion with others as to the viability. I don't even see an argument for what "additional" data was missing here, just that you don't like politicians and think they won't be able to keep up.

"Using encryption was not addressed. The fact that the secret service would be legally allowed to break into people's systems was not addressed in the public debate."

But known and objectively presented from all things i can find. I know you can't believe people would be okay with such a thing, but it's entirely within the realm of possibility that people are indeed okay with such a thing.

"Technical capability and what is possible today were never discussed."

This is an opinion.

"How the suspects would be identified was declared secret, with nobody except the oversight committee of those five politicians being allowed an insight into it."

Where's the misrepresentation or missing data?

"So, I stand with the previous poster that people did not know what we know, and they voted based on incorrect assumptions and misrepresentation or outright omission, whether unintentional or intentional, of technical capability and facts."

I strongly disagree, at least based on what you've presented.

These are not misrepresentations, they are simply "presentations that did not present it from your point of view". That is not misrepresentation, because you are not the source of absolute truth. It's misrepresentation if it wasn't presented objectively false or misleading, not subjectively false or misleading. Pretty much any controversial thing that is voted on that a given set of folks disagree with is considered to have been presented subjectively false or misleading by those people.

You also added "incorrect assumptions". You are basically offering opinions that you think others opinion's are wrong. Certainly you must realize you are not necessarily right? You can't simply say "everyone else's assumptions are wrong, and therefore they are ignorant", when your assumptions are based on opinions about the state of the world.

Past that, IMHO, you've not made an effective case that people were ignorant here.

You've instead made an effective case that the studies i cited are correct, among other things.

Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by ponyfleisch on Monday September 26, 2016 @01:34AM (#12579457)
> People understood fine, they just disagree.

Thanks for this. I couldn't agree more. The way political discourse works at the moment is worrying. America is in the spotlight for this, but it happens in europe too. Entrenched camps diagnosing each other with all kinds of mental deficiencies without discussing the actual topic at hand.

Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by rasur on Sunday September 25, 2016 @12:14PM (#12575910)
Apparently so.
Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by mtgx on Sunday September 25, 2016 @01:30PM (#12576273)
> FWIW: This is literally the retort everyone has to anything they disagree with that gets approved.

Probably because it's true in most cases. Most people don't have a deep understanding of even a single issue, let alone multiple.

This could have very well been another "Brexit-like" vote in Switzerland, where people were just scaremongered into voting for the law without understanding all of the implications.

Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by DannyBee on Sunday September 25, 2016 @03:12PM (#12576848)
"Probably because it's true in most cases. Most people don't have a deep understanding of even a single issue, let alone multiple. " What evidence do you have of this?

As far as i'm aware, research studies basically show that providing more facts one way or the other only makes people's convictions stronger. It doesn't change their minds that often. It's actually incredibly hard to change people's minds.

Now, you are free to argue this is completely irrational, and i'd 100% agree. But it does mean that people know what you know and understand what you understand and still disagree. Whether that makes sense to do so or not.

See, e.g., http://psycnet.apa.org/journals/psp/37/11/2098/ and pretty much every study since.

Another example: http://www.nature.com/nclimate/journal/v2/n10/full/nclimate1...

"Members of the public with the highest degrees of science literacy and technical reasoning capacity were not the most concerned about climate change. Rather, they were the ones among whom cultural polarization was greatest. This result suggests that public divisions over climate change stem not from the public’s incomprehension of science but from a distinctive conflict of interest"

Like I said, i'd strongly argue comprehension is not the problem. Until people realize that is the case, and stop just dismissing anyone who disagrees as ignorant, nothing will change.

Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by rayiner on Sunday September 25, 2016 @02:21PM (#12576559)
What factual information do you think is missing from peoples' understanding. In my experience people assume the government is doing more spying than it is.
Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by Annatar on Monday September 26, 2016 @05:31AM (#12580446)
See my comment above about which factual information was never discussed, and which information was misrepresented, and which was omitted.
Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by ponyfleisch on Monday September 26, 2016 @01:34AM (#12579463)
> This could have very well been another "Brexit-like" vote in Switzerland, where people were just scaremongered into voting for the law without understanding all of the implications.

Or maybe you are wrong about the brexit vote too?

Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by js8 on Sunday September 25, 2016 @11:34AM (#12575737)
Please correct me if I wrong, but it seems to me from the description in the OP that this is nothing compared to mass surveillance in other countries. Notably, it requires a court authorization to put somebody under surveillance, which is something that even Snowden would approve if I recall correctly.
Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by tobltobs on Sunday September 25, 2016 @12:45PM (#12576059)
They would be allowed to intercept any kind of traffic without any court authorization as long as at least one source is coming from a foreign country. Which will be technically true for nearly all IP based communication in Switzerland.
Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by href on Sunday September 25, 2016 @03:58PM (#12577103)
They most certainly do need a court order. See Art. 40 and Art. 41. of the NDG.
Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by jcfrei on Sunday September 25, 2016 @06:22PM (#12577768)
That requirement for a court order is greatly diminished by Art. 30: Verfahren bei Dringlichkeit. It establishes that the federal intelligence service can tap wires without court orders in urgent cases. And let's be honest here, if tapping a wire turns up nothing, do you really expect them to follow the protocol and actually inform the agencies (like the federal administrative court)? I don't have that level of trust in the intelligence service.
Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by href on Monday September 26, 2016 @01:21AM (#12579413)
That's the thing isn't it. If I don't trust my government to follow the law, then it doesn't matter what surveillance law we have. The whole vote was a vote of confidence as a result.
Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by tobltobs on Monday September 26, 2016 @02:40AM (#12579734)
He didn't say, that he does not trust the government, he has problems trusting the intelligence service. The Swiss intelligence service did prove often enough that you can't trust him to respect the law or being especially talented to do his job in a appropriate way.
Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by href on Monday September 26, 2016 @05:18AM (#12580399)
Sure, still a vote about trust though. My point being that you are asking people if they trust a certain government entity or not. Apparently the trust is there.
Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by Annatar on Monday September 26, 2016 @05:33AM (#12580453)
My impression is that it was a vote spurned by desire for security and stability, before anything else.
Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by tobltobs on Monday September 26, 2016 @03:48AM (#12580016)
They most certainly do NOT need a court order. Art. 40. and 41. are only relevant if the sender and receiver are located in Switzerland. What a "sender and receiver" exactly means (User, Website, Server, Router, ...) is not defined, imho by intention.
Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by href on Monday September 26, 2016 @05:33AM (#12580455)
That's not at all how I understand it, though I am not a lawyer.

Art. 38 basically says that the Nachrichtendienst can intercept data, unless sender and receiver are Swiss (those are indeed defined broadly). Paragraph 2 of Art. 38 basically excludes all swiss-to-swiss cable-communication for the remainder of the text.

Art. 39 then says there needs to be a court order (though there are emergency provisions).

It is my understanding of those laws that a Swiss to Swiss sender/receiver connection may never be intercepted, while all other connections may be intercepted by following Art. 40. and 41.

Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by jasonkostempski on Sunday September 25, 2016 @11:56AM (#12575834)
Isn't that what surveillance started as in the U.S.? Give 'em an inch...
Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by ekianjo on Sunday September 25, 2016 @11:44AM (#12575786)
Yup, this was also my understanding. Nothing like what the NSA or other agencies would do.
Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by planetjones on Sunday September 25, 2016 @11:49AM (#12575807)
I also live and work in Zurich in a 'techie' job and almost everyone is happy with the new surveillance laws and powers. They are sensible, needed and have the correct number of safeguards. Why do you think they go too far?
Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by tobltobs on Sunday September 25, 2016 @12:50PM (#12576087)
1.) There have been "safeguards" also at the time of the "Vichen" affair.

2.) The swiss "intelligence service" isn't famous for his intelligence. They should first do their homework on counterintelligence before anything else. Else they will just be used as a Proxy for foreign intelligence services.

Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by nickik on Sunday September 25, 2016 @05:47PM (#12577630)
I also work in Zürich. I hate this. They are interducing survailance and searches without court orders. The security of my device should be valued at least as highly as the security of my apperment.

Quite honstly, in my apparment their is nothing of interest to be found. However, my hole live is on my phone, my computer and my servers.

I would infact argue that these should have stronger protection. How anybody who supports democracy and the rule of law can agree with things like that, is quite frankly beyond me.

Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by planetjones on Monday September 26, 2016 @12:55AM (#12579328)
Where's your source for this? The enhanced surveillance can only be used if authorised by a court, the defence ministry and cabinet.
Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by raverbashing on Sunday September 25, 2016 @12:46PM (#12576071)
Because some people are either blind or severely minimise existing threats, often while maximising other threats
Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by nitrogen on Sunday September 25, 2016 @01:46PM (#12576360)
Has anybody, ever, in the history of this type of surveillance, provided concrete proof of the effectiveness thereof against the supposed threats that are used to justify it?
Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by raverbashing on Sunday September 25, 2016 @02:07PM (#12576469)
I don't think there is one about mass surveillance, which is not the case.

It seems the case for individual, case-by-case basis is pretty clear (though there seems to be an issue with false positives)

Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by wallace_f on Sunday September 25, 2016 @10:12PM (#12578772)
So your opinion is that they are good, but why? "They have the correct number of safeguards," only provides me enough information to know that you think they are good because there is a number of safeguards (what are they?) greater than 1.

My point is shouldn't the burden be on providing evidence for why they are good? Why do we need them? Why are they sensible? What was wrong before that this will fix? What can go wrong that will be prevented?

Phrasing an opinion like this, to me, raises more questions than it answers.

Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by planetjones on Monday September 26, 2016 @12:59AM (#12579339)
Yes there are three approvals needed before the enhanced surveillance can be used. Also they only expect it to be used about ten times a year. I wonder if you read the article before commenting, or just have an absolute position that anytime surveillance is mentioned you say it's bad.
Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by wallace_f on Monday September 26, 2016 @01:03AM (#12579351)
The irony here is that the point of my comment is that an absolute position without any substantiation, in this case, raised more questions than it answered.
Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by aub3bhat on Sunday September 25, 2016 @12:39PM (#12576041)
Or maybe they do and are okay with the trade offs. Consider that Switzerland requires voting on each citizenship application. Different countries and cultures have different set of norms. E.g. I can see lots of East and South Asian countries adopting a similar approach.
Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by sebgr on Sunday September 25, 2016 @12:50PM (#12576091)
Only some cantons require voting on citizenship, the others have a more formal process.
Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by m_mueller on Sunday September 25, 2016 @11:33AM (#12575731)
Is the article wrong on the requirement of a judge's order for collecting information? As far as I understand they will gather the info nonetheless and have a pro forma judge order to "access" it, correct? So what's the difference to the US - other than vastly inferior technical capabilities and the court in question not being secret?
Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by Pica_soO on Sunday September 25, 2016 @12:40PM (#12576044)
Sorry, the problem is that this is the heart of representational democratic systems. You don't need to be a expert, you trust blindly. To call for education here is to demand for the people to install linux as there government. It is not going to happen, because the strong point of this agreement is the fact that no citizen has to be a expert. The idea, to reeducate anyone into a expert on secret services, measurements and counter-measures is .. interesting.

Im actually by now for a randomly selected secret service jury. People who get selected by the dice, have the right to move freely within the secret service and the right to watch anything going on anytime. If the outside find something disagreeable, it can present the jury a case and the jury will investigate (if necessary) and judge. It is replaced after a term.

Clearly governments bureaucrats ascending to power, can not be entrusted to control the most powerful tool they reach this way.

Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by rasur on Sunday September 25, 2016 @01:44PM (#12576348)
Swiss Democracy is Direct Democracy, not Representative Democracy. EDIT: Meaning similar but not the same, and the power ultimately rests with the people to make the decisions, thus providing some requirement for them to understand the issues, and not just leave it up to their representatives.

It's a subtle difference.

Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by programmarchy on Sunday September 25, 2016 @12:39PM (#12576040)
I keep hearing this line that only techies understand, but I think it's a problem of historical ignorance. The state education system has little incentive to inform people if its past abuses, so it seems people are blind to the history of state surveillance.
Re:Swiss endorse new surveillance powers by benevol on Sunday September 25, 2016 @11:36AM (#12575750)
> it really boils down to not enough people understanding the issues and the problems.

Exactly. The systems we create are now about to become too complex for us to understand (the climax probably being the arrival of "AI"). But understanding the systems we live in is the basis for democracy. Are these the signs that democracy will only have been a transitional solution? And if so, what comes after democracy?