News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:D-Wave Founder's New Startup Combines AI, Robots, and Mon... by _qc3o on Saturday September 24, 2016 @01:34PM (#12571771)
These d-wave guys are the greatest scam geniuses in history. First they make a "quantum computer" and now they're building trainable exo-suits. I don't even know where they come up with this stuff.
Re:D-Wave Founder's New Startup Combines AI, Robots, and Mon... by kensai on Saturday September 24, 2016 @02:47PM (#12572038)
So the high profile customers (US government among them) have fallen for some tech con artists, right?
Re:D-Wave Founder's New Startup Combines AI, Robots, and Mon... by dkarapetyan on Saturday September 24, 2016 @02:54PM (#12572065)
This is a common fallacy. The US government is not that great at decision making actually. Mistakes abound and not just tiny mistakes but mistakes that consistently cost billions. The history of the fighter jet program is quite interesting in that regard. The healthcare.gov debacle is another recent example. I mean this isn't a ding against the government. Any large enough organization is terrible at making good decisions consistently. So just because the government and some other high profile people have invested in d-wave doesn't lend them any more credibility in my opinion.

The other high profile guys I'm assuming you mean are Google and IBM. It would be interesting to know how d-wave "quantum computers" have actually made any kind of dent in their respective companies other than pure marketing hype so that they can say they have "quantum computers".

Re:D-Wave Founder's New Startup Combines AI, Robots, and Mon... by gumby on Saturday September 24, 2016 @04:20PM (#12572478)
It's perfectly reasonable for a large organization like some part of the USG or Google or IBM to simply buy one to see what it's like. If there actually is a there there (perhaps even one not known to the developers) they can learn something. And if there's something real (even if not useful) they can gain a leg up on users of the next generation system, perhaps from a different company who actually does know what they're doing.

And if it is a flop, well, the marginal cost is pretty minor. When I was at MIT we bought all sorts of crazy things some of which turned out to be useful in unexpected ways once you actually had the equipment in your hands.

A good example of this was the EmDrive which really seemed like a scam to me but might have a there there. I wouldn't have believed it at all except that NASA, a seemingly independent organization where this is concerned, saw enough that it's apparently worth looking further. If it had been the 100% scam I assumed (and that's still not clear) I'd still be OK with the money spent.

At the moment I still don't believe D-Wave and dinnertime discussions with friends at Google have not caused me to change my opinion.

Re:D-Wave Founder's New Startup Combines AI, Robots, and Mon... by dkarapetyan on Saturday September 24, 2016 @04:28PM (#12572507)
That's fine. I don't disagree with that approach. What I find faulty is the incorrect reasoning applied based on that behavior. It is suspiciously close to appealing to authority type of argument. Just because a large organization takes a chance on something doesn't mean there was actual planning involved in the process other than as you said "let's just see how this pans out".
Re:D-Wave Founder's New Startup Combines AI, Robots, and Mon... by im4w1l on Saturday September 24, 2016 @04:40PM (#12572554)
If they actually made that policy, that they will buy any <500k widget that promises the world, then I bet the market could churn out pseudoscience at astonishing rates.
Re:D-Wave Founder's New Startup Combines AI, Robots, and Mon... by dkarapetyan on Saturday September 24, 2016 @05:03PM (#12572639)
The market already churns out an astonishing amount of pseudoscience. You don't need any special policies from big corporations for that. Magical thinking is one of those human things that seems to be deeply ingrained and requires sustained effort, practice, and training to avoid. Science and scientific thinking does not happen on its own. No one is born a scientist.
Re:D-Wave Founder's New Startup Combines AI, Robots, and Mon... by eghad on Saturday September 24, 2016 @04:12PM (#12572428)
Whenever D-Wave comes up on HN I'm always impressed to see how many posters who casually read one Scott Aaronson blog (not even the most recent ones mind you) think they're more qualified than legions of classically trained engineers and physicists from Los Alamos, Lawrence Berkeley, ETH Zurich, MIT Lincoln Lab, NASA, Lockheed Martin, Google, et. al.

D-wave isn't selling a "universal" quantum computer, but the platform they are and have continued to deliver has shown real, tangible progress with respect to quantum tunneling (even though their coverage has been typically questionable, the best layman's explanation of their most recent results happens to be from Ars [0]). No we're not getting a "universal" quantum computer anytime soon and no they're never going to be accessible to average consumers (so remain skeptical of anyone who says otherwise) but those claiming D-Wave is a scam/con are absurd.

[0] http://arstechnica.com/science/2016/02/is-d-waves-quantum-pr...

Re:D-Wave Founder's New Startup Combines AI, Robots, and Mon... by Retric on Saturday September 24, 2016 @04:18PM (#12572462)
All modern computers are based on quantum effects, but Intel does not call it's i7 CPU a quantum computer. The D-Wave really does not fit the established criteria for a quantum computer.

However, they really want the publicity from calling it a quantum computer so they continue to do so.

Re:D-Wave Founder's New Startup Combines AI, Robots, and Mon... by nickpsecurity on Sunday September 25, 2016 @12:19AM (#12573939)
There was also problem where the speedup might have happen with classical computing. They were comparing their algorithm for their architecture against a single CPU implementation done same way in one paper. I've seen FPGA's get 3 digit speedups on problems they could brute force when redone for their architecture. Something the size and cost of D-Wave machine could easily use something like FPGA's, ASIC's, and/or NUMA links. I'm not sure it would achieve the exact results but I'd like it ruled out that they didn't build a MPP of ASIC's for the specific problem.
Re:D-Wave Founder's New Startup Combines AI, Robots, and Mon... by logicallee on Saturday September 24, 2016 @03:35PM (#12572257)
this is gratuitously negative and against HN policies and you should not write comments like this here (especially using the word scam). a neutral phrasing might be "I believe that the D-Wave guys do not themselves believe in their innovations, and are perpetrating what would otherwise be considered scams."

Please bear in mind that Google as well as NASA have bought D-Wave computers. Whether the effect is real or not, they do not exactly transfer money to scammers, and are not easy, unsophisticated "marks" (targets of scammers.)

"Hey Google, it's your cousin!" is not how these sales take place. Use of a word like scam is inappropriate, especially given that sales have been made, and the ordered equipment has been delivered and is being used. (By people who run Google and who send things to space.)

Please be a bit more judicious in your phrasing.

Re:D-Wave Founder's New Startup Combines AI, Robots, and Mon... by dkarapetyan on Saturday September 24, 2016 @04:00PM (#12572370)
Have you ever been involved in an M&A meeting? You'd be surprised how often "Hey Google, it's your cousin!" kinda thing actually happens. I'm surprised by the amount of faith and assumed competence on the part of these organizations among the HN crowd.

The comments I'm seeing as response I agree don't seem to be conducive to an actual discussion so I'll rephrase but the point about the intelligence and infallible decision making abilities of the large organization being used as counterclaims do not really add up. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary proof is the usual bar for claims that go above and beyond current state of the art and science. D-wave has consistently failed in that regard. I find their approach unscientific and unethical for the kinds of claims they are making for whatever technology they have sold to whatever organizations. In the long run no one wins when such tactics are used.

Re:D-Wave Founder's New Startup Combines AI, Robots, and Mon... by logicallee on Saturday September 24, 2016 @04:30PM (#12572519)
Oh, all I meant with my exmaples is that it should be enough for you to pause to phrase judiciously and carefully, for good discussion here.

Unfortunately I think you're outside of the edit window though. the phrasing you just used (in your second, longer paragraph) is fine to me! It should have been your original phrasing (both IMO and by HN guidelines.)

Thanks for following up.

Re:D-Wave Founder's New Startup Combines AI, Robots, and Mon... by zxcvvcxz on Saturday September 24, 2016 @02:23PM (#12571946)
I'm going to have to ask you to expand on this comment and provide some context for why you think they're "scam geniuses"?
Re:D-Wave Founder's New Startup Combines AI, Robots, and Mon... by ThePhysicist on Saturday September 24, 2016 @03:12PM (#12572133)
So far D-Wave has failed to provide any direct or indirect evidence that their "quantum computer" actually achieves quantum speed up. An investigation by a scientist from ETH Zurich who was able to use their machine came to the conclusion that their quantum algorithm does not outperform a classical system.

It's hard to think of a reason to refuse to publicly prove that your quantum computer is actually working if it really is, if it isn't it makes a lot of sense of course.

Concerning the purchases of Google and the US government: These are probably more like research grants for D-Wave, as the buyers expect that at some time there might come a working quantum computer from D-Wave, and buying a prototype (even a faulty one) puts them in a good position to be the first to actually get a working version, while helping the company to stay afloat. By the way, Google invested 200 million USD in a different quantum computing technology endeavour led by a UC Santa Barbara professor, which would make little sense if they already had a working quantum computer.

The value of D-Wave as a company is not only defined by their ability to build a working quantum computer though, as there could be significant value in the patent portfolio they built / acquired and in their expertise in building and assembling superconducting chips and systems, which are both highly non-trivial tasks.

Their way of communicating with the public is of course highly misleading, which is why many people in the scientific community have very little respect for them, as this is viewed as highly unethical and harmful behavior in science (but not necessarily in the business world).

Re:D-Wave Founder's New Startup Combines AI, Robots, and Mon... by blazespin on Saturday September 24, 2016 @06:37PM (#12572951)
What's wrong with doing pure research as a Startup? Why does pure research have to only be the domain of Universities? I think it was a great experiment that failed, but that probably goes for something like 95% of great experiments.

Lots of pure research goes nowhere. It's not like Geordie is defrauding the old and disabled. He's working with really really really smart people with lots of money.

Honestly, we need more of this and less of SnapChat startups.

Re:D-Wave Founder's New Startup Combines AI, Robots, and Mon... by AndrewKemendo on Saturday September 24, 2016 @10:12PM (#12573546)
What's wrong with doing pure research as a Startup?

Because there is no reliable way to fund it. Said another way, the time horizon for repayment is too long and too risky for traditional, non-corporate, non-public investing.

Lets assume you have a breakthrough with research, now you have to make a product to sell. Which means you need to likely build a new market, or even in the best case of an existing market change the team composition to fund product development.

Those are all risks that Banks and Venture Money (except in very rare cases) aren't willing to take.

Re:D-Wave Founder's New Startup Combines AI, Robots, and Mon... by ThePhysicist on Sunday September 25, 2016 @03:11AM (#12574316)
There's nothing wrong with doing pure research as a startup, in fact I'd love to see more of these kind of startups and I'm thinking about starting one myself!

What's harmful (IMHO) is making spectacular claims (look we have a working quantum computer!) and then not back them up by evidence. It is of course okay to sell your product aggressively as a startup, and sometimes to oversell it as well (fake it until you can make it), but I really have my doubts that D-Wave can "make it" in the near future, as there are just so many difficult problems to solve for which we don't even have a viabe approach yet (e.g building large scale qubit coupling schemes), and trust me most quantum computing research groups have people that are at least as smart and dedicated as the people working at D-Wave.

Re:D-Wave Founder's New Startup Combines AI, Robots, and Mon... by eghad on Saturday September 24, 2016 @04:38PM (#12572548)
The UCSB professor you're referring to is John Martinis [0] and though the physical structure differs (they're using small arrays of "Xmons" instead of typical transmons qubits to minimize decoherence and thus error) they're still working within the realm of adiabatic quantum computing/quantum annealing, the same general avenue D-Wave is pursuing (with a "digital" twist) which is why Google invested in both of them.

[0] http://web.physics.ucsb.edu/~martinisgroup/publications.shtm... [1] https://research.googleblog.com/2016/06/quantum-annealing-wi...

Re:D-Wave Founder's New Startup Combines AI, Robots, and Mon... by ThePhysicist on Saturday September 24, 2016 @05:15PM (#12572688)
Sorry that's just not correct (to my knowledge at least), as John was always working on gate-based quantum computing and is currently pursuing designs based on resonator-coupled Transmon qubits (the X-mon refers to the geometry of the qubits, which provide four capacitive ports to couple them to resonators and fast flux lines). The next milestone for their collaboration is the demonstration of "quantum superiority" using a 40(-ish) qubit processor to perform an algorithm that is beyond the reach of current supercomputers. The real effort comes afterwards though as the system needs to be scaled up in order to be useful in any real-world task.

The quantum annealing example from the Google research blog seems to use normal quantum gates to simulate the nearest-neighbor interactions in a spin chain. The nature article is currently down but it seems they use "Trotterization" to simulate the spin chain using one- and two-qubits gates.

Re:D-Wave Founder's New Startup Combines AI, Robots, and Mon... by eghad on Saturday September 24, 2016 @06:48PM (#12572982)
It is indeed, correct. The annealing example I linked is from his team (here's another one with full citation with Martinis at the end there [0]). And if you want further proof that Martinis and the Google Quantum team are pursing quantum annealing look no further than the Adiabtic Quantum Computing Conference that was held this summer where their team held several talks including "Building Quantum Annealer v2.0" [1].

And I didn't touch on your earlier (erroneous) comment on the scientific community's perception of D-Wave, but I think it needs to be said that in actual professional circles the research they're performing isn't met with as much derision as they seem to garner in these more causally informed settings. It's hyped and a difficult subject to understand, so that's fair, but I suggest really informing yourself if you're going to go out there and make the claims you're making.

[0] http://research.google.com/pubs/pub44292.html [1] https://aqccreg2016.eventfarm.com/events/index/7fff5387-0000... http://1qbit.com/insights-inside-googles-annual-adiabatic-qu... [2] (Another article reviewing QA with Martinis and team) http://arxiv.org/abs/1512.02206

Re:D-Wave Founder's New Startup Combines AI, Robots, and Mon... by ThePhysicist on Sunday September 25, 2016 @02:58AM (#12574304)
I actually did my PhD on superconducting quantum computing with Transmon qubits, so I really wouldn't say that I'm only "casually informed" about the subject.

Again, their digital adiabatic quantum computing relies on a gate-based quantum processor, which provides a universal set of qubits gates and thus can in principle simulate any Hamiltonian, quantum annealing is just an algorithm that runs on it.

And I don't want to be overly negative, but the perception of D-Wave in "more professional" circles was not very enthusiastic in my experience, which to a large extent is also D-Waves fault.

Re:D-Wave Founder's New Startup Combines AI, Robots, and Mon... by gone35 on Sunday September 25, 2016 @03:35AM (#12574353)
[...]in actual professional circles the research they're performing isn't met with as much derision[...]

Yes it is.

Re:D-Wave Founder's New Startup Combines AI, Robots, and Mon... by dkarapetyan on Saturday September 24, 2016 @03:12PM (#12572132)
They have consistently dodged providing any kind of real evidence and managed to survive this far purely on marketing hype. I think someone recently posted about the Bogdanov affair. D-wave is the analog of the Bogdanov affair for quantum computers.
Re:D-Wave Founder's New Startup Combines AI, Robots, and Mon... by zazen on Saturday September 24, 2016 @02:43PM (#12572025)
There is more-thoughtful discussion of the D-wave controversy in this thread - look for dsacco's comments.