Re:D-Wave Founder's New Startup Combines AI, Robots, and Mon...
by dkarapetyan on Saturday September 24, 2016 @04:28PM
(#12572507)
That's fine. I don't disagree with that approach. What I find faulty is the incorrect reasoning applied based on that behavior. It is suspiciously close to appealing to authority type of argument. Just because a large organization takes a chance on something doesn't mean there was actual planning involved in the process other than as you said "let's just see how this pans out".
Re:D-Wave Founder's New Startup Combines AI, Robots, and Mon...
by im4w1l on Saturday September 24, 2016 @04:40PM
(#12572554)
If they actually made that policy, that they will buy any <500k widget that promises the world, then I bet the market could churn out pseudoscience at astonishing rates.
Re:D-Wave Founder's New Startup Combines AI, Robots, and Mon...
by dkarapetyan on Saturday September 24, 2016 @05:03PM
(#12572639)
The market already churns out an astonishing amount of pseudoscience. You don't need any special policies from big corporations for that. Magical thinking is one of those human things that seems to be deeply ingrained and requires sustained effort, practice, and training to avoid. Science and scientific thinking does not happen on its own. No one is born a scientist.
And if it is a flop, well, the marginal cost is pretty minor. When I was at MIT we bought all sorts of crazy things some of which turned out to be useful in unexpected ways once you actually had the equipment in your hands.
A good example of this was the EmDrive which really seemed like a scam to me but might have a there there. I wouldn't have believed it at all except that NASA, a seemingly independent organization where this is concerned, saw enough that it's apparently worth looking further. If it had been the 100% scam I assumed (and that's still not clear) I'd still be OK with the money spent.
At the moment I still don't believe D-Wave and dinnertime discussions with friends at Google have not caused me to change my opinion.