(Data source: writing my own code to decrypt the backups about a month ago, or rather adapting my previous implementation to the new backup format.)
Wonder how did that slip through
Is it already possible?...
It's obviously much faster to brute force SHA256(dictionary_word) than a 128-bit key.
Apple was previously using 10,000 rounds of SHA-1 (with PBKDF1) as a KDF. This is much slower than one round of SHA-2 they've switched to by orders of magnitude.
To brute force successfully SHA256, you don't necessarily need to brute force 2^256 possibilities, you need to brute force a much smaller list of likely passwords, and this might just be enough.
I don't know if iTunes uses a salt to encrypt the backup.
If it's just iTunes being crappy with iOS 10 backups, then reasonably this is an easy patch, correct? And the change is perhaps a bit more understandable (trying to improve performance of actions from the already bloated iTunes); it's not a good reason at all to weaken the encryption method, but it at least provides a plausible explanation that doesn't have government interests as an impetus.
Maybe it is time to take a step back and question to what extent it is wise to trust iTunes. Could the encryption not be handled on the device? Then when the PC/Mac is compromised the backup would be still safe.
(Though perhaps it ought not to.)
The way the article is worded makes me think that you wouldn't normally be able to use the token to get the data without this bug, which means that it can't be an iTunes issue.
Also, the fact that it's only iOS 10 implies the same.
If it's only related to iTunes then why does it only apply to iOS10?
It's a bit annoying considering macOS can also use FileVault for full-disk encryption, which helps if the machine is locked/off. I guess it doesn't help against your macOS user account being compromised via a browser or anything.
Makes me wonder if anyone has taken a fresh new look at the FDE passphrase algorithms in macOS 10.12...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_Active_Management_Techno...
and its potential.