Re:iOS 10: Security Weakness Discovered, Backup Passwords Mu...
by heisenbit on Friday September 23, 2016 @05:57AM
(#12563433)
I also suspect this is on the iTunes side.
Maybe it is time to take a step back and question to what extent it is wise to trust iTunes. Could the encryption not be handled on the device? Then when the PC/Mac is compromised the backup would be still safe.
Re:iOS 10: Security Weakness Discovered, Backup Passwords Mu...
by TazeTSchnitzel on Friday September 23, 2016 @07:17AM
(#12563707)
Well, it could be done on the device, but doesn't iTunes need unencrypted access to the device to function normally?
(Though perhaps it ought not to.)
Re:iOS 10: Security Weakness Discovered, Backup Passwords Mu...
by ikeboy on Friday September 23, 2016 @08:42AM
(#12564103)
It can't be iTunes' fault only. You're able to extract the data from the devices by sending the right commands, therefore the device is vulnerable.
Re:iOS 10: Security Weakness Discovered, Backup Passwords Mu...
by pfg on Friday September 23, 2016 @09:07AM
(#12564262)
Not necessarily. The article mentions phones being paired with iTunes - I assume this involves entering the passcode on the phone (haven't used iTunes for my phone in years, so I'm not entirely sure, but by my understanding of the iOS security architecture, it wouldn't be possible otherwise). This probably results in some sort of authentication token that iTunes stores and uses to get the device to perform backups. So yes, there's a command to extract data, but it's not unauthenticated or anything like that.
Re:iOS 10: Security Weakness Discovered, Backup Passwords Mu...
by ikeboy on Friday September 23, 2016 @09:31AM
(#12564420)
If iTunes has a token to get complete access to the device, and this attack requires access to that token, then again it's not an iTunes issue.
The way the article is worded makes me think that you wouldn't normally be able to use the token to get the data without this bug, which means that it can't be an iTunes issue.
Also, the fact that it's only iOS 10 implies the same.
Re:iOS 10: Security Weakness Discovered, Backup Passwords Mu...
by pfg on Friday September 23, 2016 @10:02AM
(#12564661)
Good point, that makes more sense.
Re:iOS 10: Security Weakness Discovered, Backup Passwords Mu...
by raverbashing on Friday September 23, 2016 @07:18AM
(#12563716)
It's a good question
If it's only related to iTunes then why does it only apply to iOS10?
If it's just iTunes being crappy with iOS 10 backups, then reasonably this is an easy patch, correct? And the change is perhaps a bit more understandable (trying to improve performance of actions from the already bloated iTunes); it's not a good reason at all to weaken the encryption method, but it at least provides a plausible explanation that doesn't have government interests as an impetus.