News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Steve Jobs’ response on Section 3.3.1 by lispm on Saturday April 10, 2010 @07:19PM (#1255908)
When Steve Jobs got a demo of the graphical user interface and object-oriented software at Xerox PARC, he saw a computer that could be interactively programmed. In Smalltalk.

When Steve Jobs started with NeXT in the mid 80s he got a demo of a novel program that can be used to interactively design general user interfaces - the first program of its kind.

It was written in Lisp by Jean-Marie Hullot. It was called SOS Interface, marketed also as Action! by the company Expertelligence.

Steve Jobs hired him and Jean-Marie created the Interface Builder - which became one of the most important tool on NeXT OS. Then for Mac OS X and now for iPhone OS.

This innovation is now hindered by Apple. The innovative software may not be written in Lisp anymore, but it is not necessarily Objective-C either.

With the Mac everybody got a copy of HyperCard - everybody could write and design programs in a simple way - using the built-in HyperTalk. Xerox had such a software years before - called NoteCards and written in InterLisp-D.

With the iPad, which is much more capable than the Mac where SOS Interface and HyperCard were developed, everybody is degraded to be a consumer. The goal is no longer to be a maker, a creator, a programmer. You can't even use a shell to connect to your own iPad.

There is huge domain of visual programming and end user programming to be explored on touch screen devices. Maybe Apple is working on that and hiding this (like Jobs claimed that 'nobody reads anymore' and some time later Apple now sells iBooks) - from what we see now Apple hinders innovation and innovators in these areas.

I want a 'DynaBook' and not a media player.

Steve Jobs did not really understand what he saw at Xerox PARC when he got the demos of the Smalltalk system. He got the idea of the graphical user interface. But what he overlooked was the concept of object-oriented programming. He later with NeXT understood that. But what he never really got was the importance of interactive programming, end-user programming - the role of the user being able to program his computer in a straight-forward way. The cultural importance of being able to write, understand and change software.

Re:Steve Jobs’ response on Section 3.3.1 by rimantas on Saturday April 10, 2010 @07:51PM (#1255971)

  With the Mac everybody got a copy of HyperCard 
Here we go again. I got a free copy of Xcode, IB and Dashcode with every release of OS X I had. I can code in C, C++, Objective-C (with a choice of compilers gcc or clang), PHP, Perl, Python, Ruby (including RoR), Java right out of the box. SQLite is also there and maybe some stuff I don't even know I have.

Existence of iPad (and iPhone) does not hinder innovation — it fosters it. Three years ago there was no iPhone, no iPhone OS, no App Store. Now we have a new platform with not far from 200 000 (just think about it) applications written for it. iPad gives an opportunity truly explore what's possible on multitouch device with dedicated UI.

I am a web developer, but I do not complain that I cannot easily write my code in the browser itself. Nor do I want to.

Just think about it: if there were no iPad you could not code for it even in Obj-C.

Re:Steve Jobs’ response on Section 3.3.1 by lispm on Saturday April 10, 2010 @07:58PM (#1255982)
I'm not talking about programming on the Mac, I'm talking about the iPhone OS and devices like the iPad.

I need a Mac to program the iPad? Why?

We needed a LISA to program the Mac in 1984. The Mac had 128kbyte of RAM and couldn't do much.

The iPad has 256MB RAM, a multitasking OS based on Unix - I want to see end-user programming on the touch screen. Not a generation of link clickers.

We have 2010.

I want a better EMAIL program for my iPhone (or something like the iPad). I don't get it. Apple does not allow that. WHY? It can't even filter mails. We had that twenty years ago.

Re:Steve Jobs’ response on Section 3.3.1 by alanthonyc on Saturday April 10, 2010 @10:11PM (#1256181)
"I need a Mac to program th iPad. Why?"

Holy moly! Are you mad because a TV isn't a video camera? Are you mad because a plate isn't a frying pan?

The iPad is a consumption device. It's a new thing. I've had it for a week now. I know that it's not going to replace a real computer. But it is absoulutely great for what it is. I wouldn't want to program on it (as things stand). It's acceptable for writing short texts, that's about it for now.

And this has nothing to do with the 3.3.1 controversy. There are a number of things that you can take Apple to task for, but this isn't one of them.

Re:Steve Jobs’ response on Section 3.3.1 by Zak on Sunday April 11, 2010 @07:17AM (#1256692)
Making a traditional TV in to a video camera would require adding hardware (capture, storage) at significant cost. Incidentally, Apple did turn the TV in to a video camera[0].

Turning the iPad in to a platform where children could explore programming with Squeak, eToys or some as-yet unreleased environment would only require that Apple not actively prevent it.

[0] http://www.apple.com/ipodnano/

Re:Steve Jobs’ response on Section 3.3.1 by nooneelse on Saturday April 10, 2010 @11:54PM (#1256301)
"I wouldn't want to program on it (as things stand). It's acceptable for writing short texts, that's about it for now."

There seems to be an presupposition there that programming must involve lots of typing. If so, it is a false one.

Re:Steve Jobs’ response on Section 3.3.1 by veemjeem on Sunday April 11, 2010 @04:34AM (#1256573)
I haven't seen a good 5th generation language that does visual programming well yet. Even the wonderful morphic libraries on Squeak or the ALICE virtual world still require lots of typing.
Re:Steve Jobs’ response on Section 3.3.1 by nooneelse on Sunday April 11, 2010 @10:49AM (#1256925)
Why did the goal posts for my point in the conversation suddenly get moved to 5GL? That feels like a bit of a disingenuous reply.
Re:Steve Jobs’ response on Section 3.3.1 by wallflower on Saturday April 10, 2010 @08:30PM (#1256047)
Technically, yes you can have a better mail program. You just might not be approved to sell it once you create it using XCode. If you are serious about this, start with reMail. reMail has implemented a lot of features and solved a lot of thorny email client implementation issues.

"As someone who is passionate about mobile email, my hope is that developers interested in making email-related apps can use reMail code as a starting point. Part of the reason email apps are hard is because you have to pay the tax of figuring out how to download email via IMAP, parse MIME messages, handle attachments, and store data. reMail has already solved these problems. If you have a great mobile email idea, I hope you will find reMail's source code helpful in your quest."

http://www.remail.com/blog/

http://code.google.com/p/remail-iphone

Re:Steve Jobs’ response on Section 3.3.1 by lispm on Saturday April 10, 2010 @09:06PM (#1256098)
http://gizmodo.com/5053232/apple-rejects-mailwrangler-app-fo...

'… Your application duplicates the functionality of the built-in iPhone application Mail without providing sufficient differentiation or added functionality, which will lead to user confusion. …'

Re:Steve Jobs’ response on Section 3.3.1 by tptacek on Saturday April 10, 2010 @08:27PM (#1256039)
Twenty years ago you did not have a handheld device that read your emails.
Re:Steve Jobs’ response on Section 3.3.1 by lispm on Saturday April 10, 2010 @08:51PM (#1256082)
Depends what you call a handheld device. The Osborne-1 from 1981, one of the first portable computers had an email program. Handheld computers started in the early 90s and some had email capabilities. For Apple's own Newton there was a bunch of email clients.
Re:Steve Jobs’ response on Section 3.3.1 by dionysiac on Sunday April 11, 2010 @01:33AM (#1256419)
"I need a Mac to program the iPad? Why?"

You need a computer to transfer data to it, so why not to program it? Yes, the toolchain is not available for windows, but that's at least understandable. The iPad is not currently marketed as a stand-alone device.

Re:Steve Jobs’ response on Section 3.3.1 by invisible on Sunday April 11, 2010 @10:17AM (#1256857)
From what I can tell, you MUST connect it to iTunes before it even allows you pass the "Connect me to iTunes on your computer" screen. I thought it was unneeded and should have had a "remind me later" at the very least (I didn't buy one, just set one up). Regardless, almost anyone that wants an iPad will have a computer - and the benefit of having a "import everything" option is huge.
Re:Steve Jobs’ response on Section 3.3.1 by krainboltgreene on Saturday April 10, 2010 @08:29PM (#1256044)
You are a very small minority.
Re:Steve Jobs’ response on Section 3.3.1 by david927 on Sunday April 11, 2010 @05:12AM (#1256598)
You are in a very small minority... of people who get it.

I have nothing against consumer electronics devices, but they're about consuming. The promise of computers is in creation.

Steve Jobs took Alan Kay's work, but not his ideas. The promise of the Dynabook isn't about hardware, but a change in how we create software. That change is coming, and that's the change to get excited about.

Re:Steve Jobs’ response on Section 3.3.1 by krainboltgreene on Sunday April 11, 2010 @05:34AM (#1256613)
You're not presenting any amount of believable evidence here to prove your point. Your quip of "You don't get it!" doesn't pass the muster.

Yes, computers promise creation. But this creation isn't always developing software. A device can simply create entertainment.

I hate to break it to you, buddy, but you've become saturated in your community. It's very hard from that point to see how very small your pool is.

Re:Steve Jobs’ response on Section 3.3.1 by david927 on Sunday April 11, 2010 @11:56AM (#1257065)
A device can simply create entertainment. No, a device shows entertainment. And people consume it. Creation means that the end user has something new when they're done. Not that they've just passed the time.

And you're ad hominem attack on being saturated in your community was most likely a projection, buddy.

Re:Steve Jobs’ response on Section 3.3.1 by steve19 on Saturday April 10, 2010 @09:57PM (#1256163)
You don't need a Mac. You can write web apps for it on any platform.
Re:Steve Jobs’ response on Section 3.3.1 by stromhold on Saturday April 10, 2010 @08:31PM (#1256048)
And this is exactly what Apple wants us to think; be in awe of the favor that they are doing developers. This is an abusive relationship to say the least.
Re:Steve Jobs’ response on Section 3.3.1 by rimantas on Saturday April 10, 2010 @08:51PM (#1256080)
[citation needed]
Re:Steve Jobs’ response on Section 3.3.1 by jrockway on Sunday April 11, 2010 @01:25AM (#1256411)
I believe the grandparent's post is clearly an opinion, and therefore does not need a citation to be relevant.
Re:Steve Jobs’ response on Section 3.3.1 by raganwald on Saturday April 10, 2010 @08:48PM (#1256076)
The false dichotomy is the assumption that since Apple makes two portable devices, one that creates content (Macbook) and another that consumes it (iPhone/iPad), that there must be two kinds of people, content creators and content consumers.

There is no reason not to own a laptop and a tablet for much teh same reason that many people own an iPod and an iPhone and a laptop.

In my own case, I own a laptop for development, a mini for displaying media on my 37" display at home, an iPhone for calls and portable content consumption, and an iPod Classic for music in my car.

All of these together cost less than my first development system. I think that people who want to create content and programs will do so, and the iPad does nothing to hinder them.

Re:Steve Jobs’ response on Section 3.3.1 by Tycho on Saturday April 10, 2010 @07:51PM (#1255972)
Don't you think the fact that iPad SDKs and programming tutorials are readily available from Apple, plus the fact that Apple still sell Macs which interface with the iPad (but which they obviously don't want the iPad to render obsolete), contradicts your vision of the present trend? I mean the iPhone surely spurned a HUGE number of people to become (in your terms) 'creators' - and that was before non-Apple developer tools were even on the table.
Re:Steve Jobs’ response on Section 3.3.1 by lispm on Saturday April 10, 2010 @07:59PM (#1255989)
The effect is that people are divided into developers/content providers/media providers and consumers.
Re:Steve Jobs’ response on Section 3.3.1 by rimantas on Saturday April 10, 2010 @08:04PM (#1255994)
It is not (D),(C); it is (C (D)). We are all consumers, just some happen to be developers.
Re:Steve Jobs’ response on Section 3.3.1 by lispm on Saturday April 10, 2010 @08:16PM (#1256021)
No, consumers are not developers on the iPad.

You can't program filters for the Email program. The Email program is neither open source nor scriptable. You can't program formulas for the calculator. The people who program for iPhone OS are doing it in a completely different stage and environment. I can't just log into MY iPhone and change a program.

Re:Steve Jobs’ response on Section 3.3.1 by rimantas on Saturday April 10, 2010 @08:49PM (#1256079)
I just don't see the iPad as replacement for anything. And I was not talking about it specifically in my comment.

My personal and work accounts are both using GMail. I don't have the source of it, I cannot just login and change id, but I do not care. You can get a bunch of programmable calculators in App Store, or just get Numbers and use all the formulas it offers. My car probably has a couple dozens of CPU which I have no interest to program for. My TV probably runs linux, but I am not going to hack it. Most likely I will program for iPad, but I'd hate to do it on iPad. I love to eat soup with a spoon, but I'd hate to carve spoon with a spoon.

Re:Steve Jobs’ response on Section 3.3.1 by lispm on Saturday April 10, 2010 @09:19PM (#1256120)
That you don't want to program on the iPad does not mean others don't want that too. It does not even mean that you won't want it in the future.

But there is no choice. You are at the merci of Apple.

Other people want a different entertainment system in their car.

With Apple you can't - you can't replace iTunes on your phone.

Re:Steve Jobs’ response on Section 3.3.1 by zephjc on Sunday April 11, 2010 @01:17AM (#1256407)
I think you are confusing developers (for the platform) and tinkerers
Re:Steve Jobs’ response on Section 3.3.1 by clawrencewenham on Sunday April 11, 2010 @11:24AM (#1257005)
Stop thinking of the iPhone/iPad as if they're just small Macs. They are neither general purpose computers, nor are they RAD platforms. They're consumer devices with restricted capabilities and resources.

No innovation has been hindered, in fact it has been enabled. Smalltalk, SOS and others are tools that make certain kinds of experiment easier.

I remember when RAD tools were only meant for building prototypes, with the assumption that the program would be rewritten in a conventional language afterwards. They only became the delivery environment after consumer machines gained so much RAM and CPU power that the benefits of optimization became negligible.

Well, these are cell phones, batteries with CPUs. We're back in the 80s again. Section 3.3.1 does not prohibit anyone from developing iPhone software with whatever cross-compiler or funky toolkit they like, it only prevents them from deploying the output to consumers through the App Store.

Re:Steve Jobs’ response on Section 3.3.1 by jstevens85 on Sunday April 11, 2010 @06:48AM (#1256664)
>like Jobs claimed that 'nobody reads anymore' and some time later Apple now sells iBooks

The point Jobs was making was that a device used exclusively for reading would never be successful. He wasn't suggesting that it would be pointless to participate in the ebook market, just that it would need to be on a general purpose mobile platform.

Re:Steve Jobs’ response on Section 3.3.1 by lispm on Sunday April 11, 2010 @07:18PM (#1257901)
Jobs on why the Kindle will fail:

“It doesn’t matter how good or bad the product is, the fact is that people don’t read anymore,” he said. “Forty percent of the people in the U.S. read one book or less last year. The whole conception is flawed at the top because people don’t read anymore.”

I'm not sure I can read your interpretation into it.

From what I read, Jobs says that 'people' don't read anymore - even books on paper. So it is useless to bring books in any new ebook form, because the market is not there. Books in general is an outdated concept according to Jobs at that time.

Re:Steve Jobs’ response on Section 3.3.1 by artsrc on Sunday April 11, 2010 @08:14PM (#1258000)
In addition to up voting you I would like to add that this is a pattern. Steve Jobs dishes some use then provides for it. Perhaps the interpretations are:

   1. Misdirection or
   2. Change of mind (being wrong).  
I favour 1.