News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I Used to Be a Human Being by Torgo on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @12:51PM (#12549948)
This is the daily reminder that technology is not politically or socially "neutral".
Re:I Used to Be a Human Being by cushychicken on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @01:20PM (#12550235)
What was the origin of that quote? I mentioned it offhand in conversation the other day but couldn't remember where I'd heard it.
Re:I Used to Be a Human Being by dredmorbius on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @03:37PM (#12551501)
I'm familar with it from Jerry Mander, Neil Postman, and Joyce and Michael Heusemann, who address it specifically and at length in their book Techno-Fix. Also in Marshall McLuhan (of whom Postman was a student).

I think you'll find a philosophical basis in Jaques Ellul among others (Foucalt is also mentioned).

From Postman:

[E]very technology has an inherent bias. It has within its physical form a predisposition toward being used in certain ways and not others. Only those who know nothing of the history of technology believe that a technology is entirely neutral.

French philosopher Jacques Ellul, who...

...cautions that technology brings with it a great number of unforeseen effects [4]. This is because “technology leads a double life, one which conforms to the intentions of designers and interests of power and another which contradicts them—proceeding behind the backs of their architects to yield unintended consequences and unintended possibilities” [5]. It is difficult then for us to control what we cannot always see.

http://www.helwyssocietyforum.com/?p=1360

There's a related concept of Technological Determinism, originating with Thorstein Veblen:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Technological_determinism

More reading:

http://www.worldcat.org/title/techno-fix-why-technology-wont...

http://www.worldcat.org/title/four-arguments-for-the-elimina...

http://www.worldcat.org/title/technopoly-the-surrender-of-cu...

http://www.worldcat.org/title/this-is-marshall-mcluhan-the-m...

Re:I Used to Be a Human Being by tome on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @02:41PM (#12551024)
Are you perhaps thinking of "Technology is neither good nor bad; nor is it neutral"?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Melvin_Kranzberg

Re:I Used to Be a Human Being by Torgo on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @01:51PM (#12550545)
I improvised it from Michel Foucault.
Re:I Used to Be a Human Being by marmot777 on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @02:23PM (#12550867)
Technology is neutral, though. It's the people using the technology that are not neutral or am I missing something?
Re:I Used to Be a Human Being by mcphage on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @02:36PM (#12550980)
It's not, because technology is a product of the people and processes that created it. And since people and processes aren't neutral (who is, after all), the technology they create won't be, either.
Re:I Used to Be a Human Being by npsimons on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @04:27PM (#12551908)
> because technology is a product of the people and processes that created it. And since people and processes aren't neutral (who is, after all), the technology they create won't be, either.

Karl Schroeder expounds upon this idea (albeit via science fiction) in "Lady of Mazes", and a little near the end of the Virga series. I highly recommend them.

Re:I Used to Be a Human Being by marmot777 on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @02:42PM (#12551036)
I may come off as disagreeing but I question to understand. Do you have some tangible examples?
Re:I Used to Be a Human Being by germinalphrase on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @03:13PM (#12551285)
Accessibility is often offered as an example here.

When we create a technology that requires certain abilities (the ability to use a qwerty keyboard, for instance) we have inadvertently made a technology that can't be utilized by people that lack that ability level. Likewise, for stairs, visual public signage, color use, etc.

Other examples include accessibility not based on physical difference, but social or economic difference. If you can't afford a smart phone or other computer, it can become prohibitively difficult to apply for jobs (or seek services, etc.) that only accept online applications. Or - famously - the standard IQ test used to ask what color the keys on a piano were long ago. This test was used for employment, military services, etc.; however, that question was inadvertently biased towards middle/upper class people who had experience with musical instruments.

These designs are not created with exclusion in mine, but there are often accessibility issues in one form or another because of our blind spots.

Other times, we create designs that actively mimic our biases - for instance, a bias towards rationalism led the military to design airplane cockpits back in the 1930's+ around an "ideal standard" of human physiology without any adjustability. Because no one is actually average, once you get beyond a one or two physiological measurements (maybe), these cockpits didn't really fit anyone and many US pilots died unnecessarily because they couldn't properly operate the airplane. Once the military overcame that bias they were able to make cockpits that fit many more sizes/shapes of people and our pilot deaths dropped significantly.

Re:I Used to Be a Human Being by mcphage on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @04:35PM (#12551978)
A simple example is, think of a car. Cars are uncomfortable for people who are very tall, or very short. Now, you may say, "it's pretty much impossible to design a car to fit everyone!" which is absolutely true—and that's my point. Car makers can't design a car that fits everyone comfortably, so the car maker has to decide—based on the tradeoffs of cost, complexity, and audience size—who to size the car for. Is it uncomfortable for people over 6'3"? Is it uncomfortable for people over 6'10"? That's where the creator's views creep in, and there's no way to avoid it. It's not the end of the world; decisions do need to be made, and we make do. We just need to recognize that technology reflects the biases of its creator, and take that into account when seeking to understand technology and its impact.
Re:I Used to Be a Human Being by dredmorbius on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @03:59PM (#12551697)
From Michael and Joyce Heusemann, Techno-Fix (mentioned in a prior comment):

"In addition to cost-effectiveness, efficiency and marketability, a wide range of other values are commonly embedded in many modern technologies. These are, for example, power, control, exploitation and violence, with respect to both people and nature (Chapter 3), profit-maximization, speed, mass-production, uniformity, repetitiveness, quantification, precision, standardization, dependency, materialism, consumerism and individualism.854 In general, the more specifically a technology has been designed for a particular use, the more completely it will embody the values of the designers, and the less it will be of use for purposes reflecting different values. Thus, the more specific the design, the less human choice and control there will be regarding the final use of the respective technology."

The passage continues to quote Robert Proctor in Value-Free Science? Purity and Power in Modern Knowledge.

To give another example, virtually the entire infrastrure of the modern Web and information technology system is oriented around the interests of advertisers, and against those of content creators. I'm typing this on a tablet which will faithfully suppor all requests by advertisers to cram their content, and surveillance requests, down my throat, but which routinely discards my own content (I've watched this comment disappear multiple times as I toggle to the book viewer application from which I'm pulling quotes). The tools for organising content of specific interest to me is exceptionally poor.

Even putatively user-oriented systems such as GNU/Linux have been increasingly falling victim to this, a distressing trend that's been accellerating over my 20+ year use of it.

Re:I Used to Be a Human Being by marmot777 on Saturday September 24, 2016 @02:33PM (#12571984)
I get your point as some of the most articulate posts on here were by you and the others who responded on this topic. Wow, some passion behind this. Do you think it's ever political in the left, right, etc., since of the word?

What's wrong with Linux? Are you referring to RHEL and things like that?

Re:I Used to Be a Human Being by crpatino on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @09:14PM (#12553596)
> Technology is neutral, though.

The abstract concept of "Technology" is neutral, along with the majority of embodiments of such concept.

It is the particular technologies the OP is talking about, - smartphones, social media, etc - which are not neutral. Those have been specifically engineered by their creators to further the creator's goals indetriment of the consumers they supposedly server.

It is one thing to say "guns don't kill people, people do". But if a manufacturer started making guns that fired themselves at random so the gun owner had to purchase extra ammo, the NRA would be the first ones to go all ballistic over it. But somehow our customers think that's normal business practice.