News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Say hello to Google Allo: a smarter messaging app by chias on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @01:45AM (#12545709)
I really wish they wouldn't overload terms that they themselves invented. In Chrome, "incognito" means we don't save your local history, but it does not add to the transport security. Here, "incognito" means you've got end-to-end encryption (and presumably also doesn't save local history).

Why on earth would you re-use the same term when naming two things with similar (thus easily confused) consumer-visible attributes but completely different security guarantees?!

Re:Say hello to Google Allo: a smarter messaging app by nl on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @03:24AM (#12546066)
For most people, in both cases "incognito" means "porn mode".

Chrome: "Won't save your (porn) history"

Allo: "features like discreet notifications and message expiration" (ie, for sending naked pics)

The transport layer security is great too, but for a lot of people "message expiration" is the key feature.

Re:Say hello to Google Allo: a smarter messaging app by drdaeman on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @09:30AM (#12547946)
I believe it's a bit different.

It could be different for shared computers, but, I think, for porn browsing on one's own hardware, incognito mode is more about having a separate (ephemeral) browser profile, so you aren't accidentally sharing your kinks on Facebook and Google won't (visibly, at least) associate it with your main browsing profile and won't show you relevant ads there.

A comparable feature for the IM world would be "alter ego"/pseudonymous mode, where your contacts aren't provided with your identity information (google account/phone numbers/etc - not even your "normal" name or nickname), but a throw-away identities, yet you still have a convenience of using a single app. Not really private in a sense your favorite TLA won't know you, but good enough in a sense your peers won't know you. I don't think any IM system does that, without setting up separate accounts.

I mean, "self-destructing" messages weren't there in a lot of systems, and users perfectly know how to delete SMS or emails they don't want to keep - and saving the ones they do. Not to say "message expiration" is a myth (haven't they learned it with Snapchat already?)

Maybe that's just my view of things, though.

Re:Say hello to Google Allo: a smarter messaging app by hbharadwaj on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @07:28AM (#12547152)
I read this and then I read this -

Google backs off on previously announced Allo privacy feature (http://www.theverge.com/2016/9/21/12994362/allo-privacy-mess...)

Performance for privacy - LOL

Re:Say hello to Google Allo: a smarter messaging app by jug on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @08:14AM (#12547434)
I would have shrugged if the performance over privacy idea had to do with just some random app, but this is a messaging app where privacy will for many reasons be paramount. :S
Re:Say hello to Google Allo: a smarter messaging app by dovdov on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @02:03AM (#12545780)
End-to-end encryption from your phone to Google's server, where neural networks now analyze all your data, Super cute! Lovely Labrador!
Re:Say hello to Google Allo: a smarter messaging app by jjcm on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @02:09AM (#12545803)
From their FAQ:

"Your chats are end-to-end encrypted and can only be seen by you and the person you're chatting with. Google can't read any of your messages, so you won't see any Smart Reply or Google Assistant features."

https://support.google.com/allo/answer/6383724?ref_topic=637...

Re:Say hello to Google Allo: a smarter messaging app by Twisell on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @04:20AM (#12546330)
Meanwhile with iMessages encryption is standard and "quick reply" + "App interactions" are available...

So basically at Google encryption is a separate feature and come at the cost of the others cool features. This combined with the confusion between "incognito mode" and "porn mode" may contribute to a slow adoption of crypto-features in Allo IMHO...

Re:Say hello to Google Allo: a smarter messaging app by pjmlp on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @03:15AM (#12546030)
Who validates that that statement is indeed true, we in our naivety should just plain believe it?
Re:Say hello to Google Allo: a smarter messaging app by matt4077 on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @05:37AM (#12546658)
As much as people like a good conspiracy, that would be a pretty pointless one. There are tens of thousands people at google who could look at the source code, many of them with a left-wing/civil liberties attitude.

To get all of them to stay silent, and to evade analysis of the binary is, if not impossible, simply not worth whatever they could get out of reading my messages (esp. considering their uninterrupted stream of emails to read).

It's also why the concept of "brands" makes more sense than may are willing to admit: a blatant lie such as this would probably be worse for google than VWs little problem. Reading someone's private stuff is just bound to rouse more emotions than whatever comes out of the back of your car.

Re:Say hello to Google Allo: a smarter messaging app by lucb1e on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @08:53AM (#12547696)
> many of them with a left-wing/civil liberties attitude.

Well they seem awfully quiet about all the privacy invading stuff Google does, considering the number you claim they're in.

Re:Say hello to Google Allo: a smarter messaging app by pyre on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @02:40PM (#12551014)
It's probably easy to dismiss/justify some of those things when you can view the code yourself to see that nothing "bad" is happening (at least at the current time). It's a little harder to rectify Google blatantly lying about something e2e encryption even if nothing "bad" is happening with it.
Re:Say hello to Google Allo: a smarter messaging app by pjmlp on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @08:27AM (#12547536)
Yeah right.

http://www.theverge.com/2016/9/21/12994362/allo-privacy-mess...

"Allo messages will still be encrypted between the device and Google servers, and stored on servers using encryption that leaves the messages accessible to Google’s algorithms."

[....]

"The decision will also have significant consequences for law enforcement access to Allo messages. By default, Allo messages will now be accessible to lawful warrant requests, the same as message data in Gmail and Hangouts and location data collected by Android. "

Re:Say hello to Google Allo: a smarter messaging app by pyre on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @02:37PM (#12550988)
> The version of Allo rolling out today will store all non-incognito messages by default — a clear change from Google’s earlier statements that the app would only store messages transiently and in non-identifiable form. The records will now persist until the user actively deletes them, giving Google default access to a full history of conversations in the app. Users can also avoid the logging by using Allo’s Incognito Mode, which is still fully end-to-end encrypted and unchanged from the initial announcement.

> Like Hangouts and Gmail, Allo messages will still be encrypted between the device and Google servers, and stored on servers using encryption that leaves the messages accessible to Google’s algorithms.

Translation:

- Incognito messages will not be logged, and will be encrypted end-to-end.

- Non-incognito messages will transit over SSL, and be stored on Google's servers in an encrypted form that they will have access to (presumably this "encryption" is to prevent hackers gaining a DB dump from getting everything in plaintext).

- Non-incognito messages will be logged indefinitely, unless a user explicitly deletes them. (This is a change from what was previously announced at Google I/O)

Correct me if I'm missing something.

Re:Say hello to Google Allo: a smarter messaging app by losvedir on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @10:02AM (#12548211)
> all non-incognito messages
Re:Say hello to Google Allo: a smarter messaging app by oneeyedpigeon on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @03:20AM (#12546044)
As much as you would any other company - Apple, for example - unless someone trawls through the source code to verify the claim.
Re:Say hello to Google Allo: a smarter messaging app by pjmlp on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @03:40AM (#12546148)
Exactly, but somehow many seem to believe Google is different.
Re:Say hello to Google Allo: a smarter messaging app by kuschku on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @02:16AM (#12545831)
The encryption for incognito actually is Moxie’s protocol, as used in Signal and WhatsApp. The one single good thing about allo.
Re:Say hello to Google Allo: a smarter messaging app by pimeys on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @03:40AM (#12546146)
Just recently there was a HN post about security bugs in Signal. Signal is open source and the bugs will be fixed at some point, but I wouldn't trust all these proprietary apps will follow the lead so fast.
Re:Say hello to Google Allo: a smarter messaging app by uph on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @04:42AM (#12546449)
"We've released an update to the Android app (3.19.0) which includes a fix. Signal for iOS and Desktop were not affected, nor were other consumers of Signal Protocol. Non-attachment message confidentiality and integrity was not affected. We're publishing our analysis to make as much information available as possible, but given both the limited impact of this bug and the set of circumstances necessary to exploit it, we consider this to have been of low risk to Signal for Android users."

https://whispersystems.org/blog/signal-android-attachment-bu...

Re:Say hello to Google Allo: a smarter messaging app by ithkuil on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @04:05AM (#12546270)
If there is one think I'd trust about Google is them to be serious about security vulnerability.
Re:Say hello to Google Allo: a smarter messaging app by nannal on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @02:10AM (#12545805)
But that's end to middle encryption!
Re:Say hello to Google Allo: a smarter messaging app by jakobloekke on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @02:32AM (#12545883)
Middle-out encryption ...? :)
Re:Say hello to Google Allo: a smarter messaging app by dx034 on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @02:32AM (#12545882)
But perhaps middle out compression?
Re:Say hello to Google Allo: a smarter messaging app by toephu2 on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @02:22AM (#12545848)
You must live in a bubble or have never worked at a large company before. There are two totally different teams building these products. Is it really that inconceivable for them (yes, even Google) to make this oversight?
Re:Say hello to Google Allo: a smarter messaging app by hueving on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @02:45AM (#12545936)
Are you trying to suggest there are employees at Google that don't know what incognito mode is in chrome? More specifically, every employee that worked on this project?
Re:Say hello to Google Allo: a smarter messaging app by Mao_Zedang on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @02:25AM (#12545859)
I feel like incognito mode has been around long enough that this isnt a valid excuse.
Re:Say hello to Google Allo: a smarter messaging app by huckyaus on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @03:38AM (#12546137)
If you read the blog post you might have noticed that they specifically mention Chrome's Incognito mode.

> But we went a step beyond this and we created a mode within Google Allo called Incognito (h/t Chrome).

Re:Say hello to Google Allo: a smarter messaging app by pqhwan on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @02:15AM (#12545828)
I guess overloading a term with similarly-themed features ~= branding.
Re:Say hello to Google Allo: a smarter messaging app by Mizza on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @01:59AM (#12545762)
The worst was "Off the Record", which, for an XMPP service, didn't mean the "Off the Record" encryption protocol, it means "we don't log messages to your own email inbox."

It's another dark pattern from an unscrupulous company.

Re:Say hello to Google Allo: a smarter messaging app by Sargos on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @01:21PM (#12550246)
I doubt anyone has ever confused the two. "Off the record" is a well known phrase in our culture. The "off the record" protocol is not very well known.