News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by eadz on Sunday September 18, 2016 @01:03PM (#12526054)
This is an important article and adds some real context to Washington Post's editorial. This quote sums it up.

  But still, if the Post editorial page editors now want to
  denounce these revelations, and even call for the 
  imprisonment of their paper’s own source on this ground,
  then they should at least have the courage to acknowledge
  that it was The Washington Post — not Edward Snowden — who
  made the editorial and institutional choice to expose those
  programs to the public.
The Washington Post's editors decided these stories were in the public interest and should be published, not Snowden.
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by lisper on Sunday September 18, 2016 @01:41PM (#12526223)
Indeed, it must be emphasized that Snowden deliberately did not disclose any of the information he had collected publicly. He specifically wanted someone else to make the decision about what (if anything) should be disclosed, and he specifically wanted journalists to make that decision.

For the Post to stab Snowden in the back this way is the worst treachery, cowardice, and hypocrisy that I have ever witnessed.

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by rayiner on Sunday September 18, 2016 @08:26PM (#12527963)
> treachery, cowardice, and hypocrisy

WaPo is D.C.'s paper after all. That describes business as usual here.

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by 20yrs_no_equity on Sunday September 18, 2016 @02:20PM (#12526398)
I worked at Amazon, I interacted with Jeff Bezos, the Washington Post doing this does not surprise me. It is effectively his political blog, where he gets to push his agenda while being abstracted away from responsibility. (EG: Amazon PR can continue its campaign of BS propaganda without WashPo articles hurting them or Bezos.)
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by benregenspan on Sunday September 18, 2016 @07:26PM (#12527741)
Fred Hiatt has run the Washington Post editorial page since 2000 and this editorial is entirely consistent with his past work. He's always pushed neoconservative positions and taken the word of sources like the House intelligence committee at face value. Amazon might well have financial interests in US intelligence, but it's very easy to imagine this same editorial being written with or without Bezos as the owner of the paper.
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by dnautics on Sunday September 18, 2016 @08:03PM (#12527879)
Hasn't Bezos officially come out against government intrusion into online privacy? E.g.:

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-switch/wp/2016/05/18...

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by ReadingInBed on Sunday September 18, 2016 @03:22PM (#12526726)
This is a good point. As far as I remember Amazon had/has a contract with the CIA for 100s of millions. When the rich own the media there is always a risk that they will hire those that push their agenda. Amazon could greatly profit from government contracts. I wouldn't argue one article proves a conspiracy, but it's so incredibly hypocritical that you have to wonder why WaPo would publish it. Especially when it means future leakers might not want to go to them for fear they will work with the govt to imprison them.
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by SixSigma on Monday September 19, 2016 @06:36PM (#12535349)
$600m over 10 years

I bet Bezos isn't too comfortable about the Trump presidency after the way WaPo has behaved

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by SixSigma on Monday September 19, 2016 @07:13AM (#12530408)
No wonder the are anti-Trumping, the gravy train is pulling into the station
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by nhebb on Sunday September 18, 2016 @03:08PM (#12526646)
From what I can tell searching relevant dates, I believe the Washington Post published the PRISM piece before Bezos purchased the newspaper.
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by nekopa on Sunday September 18, 2016 @03:48PM (#12526850)
I believe that's the point. Before Bezos the paper thought Snowden was great, after Besoz they want him thrown in jail.
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by nhebb on Sunday September 18, 2016 @09:54PM (#12528284)
Mea culpa. I did miss the point.
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by johansch on Sunday September 18, 2016 @03:49PM (#12526855)
You're kinda missing the point here.
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by nitrogen on Sunday September 18, 2016 @02:41PM (#12526530)
What does Amazon gain from an anti-Snowden article? Should we be worried about the privacy of our purchase history and AWS instances even more than we already were?
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by my-cowardly-alt on Sunday September 18, 2016 @04:21PM (#12527046)
Not Amazon, but Bezos' startup Blue Origin is a defense contractor, currently bidding to supply the rocket engines for US national security launches (Air Force, NRO). He's one of two finalists (with Aerojet Rocketdyne), with a decision expected in 2016 or 2017.

http://www.wsj.com/articles/boeing-lockheed-venture-developi...

I think it's reasonable to say it's a conflict of interest, trying to be both a newspaper reporting on the intelligence industry, and a major contractor for that industry at the same time.

(I apologize for creating a throwaway to post this; I'd prefer not to annoy AWS).

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by wallace_f on Sunday September 18, 2016 @11:38PM (#12528699)
Years ago I reserved this kind of level of paranoia for the tin foil hat types, but to me now, it seems not only reasonable, but prudent.
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by jacquesm on Monday September 19, 2016 @01:17AM (#12529124)
It's a sobering thought that we are still thinking about some as 'tin foil hat types', which makes you wonder what we'll think of them years from now.
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by nitrogen on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @05:01PM (#12552202)
I realize this is an old thread, but it occurs to me that one of the problems is that implausible conspiracies are lumped together with plausible, likely operations and dismissed as a group with a single label.
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by wallace_f on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @10:08PM (#12553813)
I agree wholeheartedly.

Apparently the CIA popularized the term 'conspiracy theory,' in the 60s, though I don't have knowledge on the veracity of that claim. It's clear that at least a non-pejorative term would be useful.

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by tomc1985 on Sunday September 18, 2016 @03:35PM (#12526783)
Snowden's revelations did a lot of damage to trust in American servers and internet services internationally. (Bezos/Amazon probably stands to lose much in this way.) Many other parts of the world actually care for their privacy; Germany for example is still wary of excess data collection because of the Stasi and the problems they created.

News of PRISM et al is probably one of a few root causes behind underpinning this newfound federation of internet authority

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by lolc on Sunday September 18, 2016 @04:14PM (#12527006)
> Snowden's revelations did a lot of damage to trust in American servers and internet services internationally. (Bezos/Amazon probably stands to lose much in this way.)

By attacking the messenger they show how little they care about their users.

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by rodgerd on Sunday September 18, 2016 @03:57PM (#12526904)
Bezos kicked Wikileaks from Amazon's infrastructure with nothing more than a few senators expressing displeasure at WL's actions.

Whether Bezos is a True Believer in the American empire, or whether he just wants to curry favour with the government to make money is beside the point: Amazon is definitely a partisan in these things. It will be interesting how that fact will play out in Europe and Asia over time.

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by dalke on Sunday September 18, 2016 @03:06PM (#12526633)
I think it's more about the political influence Bezos might get by showing that he supports the established political system.
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by jackmott on Sunday September 18, 2016 @06:25PM (#12527522)
I would wager it is just that this is what Bezos believes is right.
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by 20yrs_no_equity on Sunday September 18, 2016 @09:09PM (#12528149)
What Jeff believes is right is what accrues to Jeff more power. The founders of Google, Bill Gates and Steve Balmer, Jobs and Wozniak, the early Sun people, they all made mistakes and might have done bad things. Generally I think people running businesses are doing so because they want to make a dent in the universe. I don't buy the idea that CEOs are sociopaths (which seems to be a common perception). But if you told me you believed Bezos was a sociopath I would suspect you were right.

I only worked there a couple years but I had more interaction with him than I would like (though he never chewed me out) and usually, I'm eager to get close to the CEO and learn what I can.

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by wallace_f on Sunday September 18, 2016 @11:40PM (#12528703)
>Bezos was a sociopath

Can you elaborate, please, on why you feel this way?

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by jacquesm on Monday September 19, 2016 @01:19AM (#12529131)
You've quoted that so out of context it now has a different meaning.
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by wallace_f on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:23PM (#12536263)
What? I am not intending to morph the author's meaning. He said:

>If you told me you thought Bezo's was a sociopath I'd suspect you're right

How and what did I take out of context and what was the intended meaning that I transformed into something else?

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by dforrestwilson1 on Sunday September 18, 2016 @04:17PM (#12527024)
I can't believe this was down-voted when it is so obviously true. Thank you for posting.
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by tptacek on Sunday September 18, 2016 @01:52PM (#12526271)
The worst. Really? Are you sure you don't mean "the most cognitively available"?
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by lisper on Sunday September 18, 2016 @02:27PM (#12526438)
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by tptacek on Sunday September 18, 2016 @02:39PM (#12526514)
Can you simultaneously be a traitor and correct in both your original, faithful actions and your later, treacherous ones? Could Baron have done the right thing given the ambit of the Post's newsroom, and the Editorial Page also the right thing in putting forward the argument against blanket clemency?

Clearly, the Post's Editorial has quietly excused a lot of its own conduct. I'm less interested in the argument about the Post's hypocrisy --- because I'm sure I'll end up agreeing with you about that.

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by lisper on Sunday September 18, 2016 @03:19PM (#12526713)
I have no idea what it can possibly mean to be "correct in your ... later treacherous [actions]."

Do you mean: is it possible that the Post is correct that Snowden should not be pardoned? Yes, that's possible. There are reasonable arguments to be advanced against a pardon. IMHO these arguments are wrong, but as I said in my blog post, reasonable people can disagree.

But even if one suspends disbelief and concedes for the sake of argument that Snowden should not be pardoned (is that what you meant?) that in no way excuses what the Post did. The Post is not an disinterested observer here, it is an active participant in the events, at best a co-conspirator, and at worst the actual culpable party. The editorial is entirely self-serving, and worse (because this is supposed to be a newspaper) it doesn't acknowledge that it is entirely self-serving. And it is self-serving at the expense of a man who (and there can be no reasonable dispute over this) has taken great personal risk to bring wrong-doing by the government to light.

So no, I don't see any possibility of any kind of redemption here. There are only two possibilities: either the release of the information was a crime that should be punished, or it was not. If the former, then the Post is at least as culpable as Snowden if not more so, and it needs to turn over the people who made the decision to publish for prosecution (or at least advance an argument as to why they should not be prosecuted while Snowden should be -- I can't wait to hear that argument), and it probably needs to close its doors like the News of the World did. On the assumption that releasing the Snowden documents was illegal, what the Post did was much worse than what NoW did.

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by tptacek on Sunday September 18, 2016 @03:24PM (#12526738)
So the way you see this --- and let's just stipulate whatever needs to be stipulated to keep this simple --- regardless of the genuinely held opinions of the Editorial Page editors about clemency for Snowden, their paper's previous role in the Snowden story obligates them not to relate those opinions in an editorial?

Maybe another way to put this is: is there an editorial they could have written that would advance their opinion about clemency and not been treacherous?

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by lisper on Sunday September 18, 2016 @03:42PM (#12526820)
> their paper's previous role in the Snowden story obligates them not to relate those opinions in an editorial?

It obligates them not to do it as an isolated act. If they want to reverse course now they certainly can (it's always OK to admit you were wrong). But then they need to admit that they are culpable along with Snowden, submit the responsible parties (some of whom are surely on the editorial board) for prosecution, return the Pulitzer, and close up shop (or at the very least resign and turn over control to a completely new set of people).

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by tptacek on Sunday September 18, 2016 @03:56PM (#12526892)
It's not exactly the role of a newspaper to "submit people for prosecution", is it? Could you flesh out a little bit what you mean by the WaPo taking an active role in arranging prosecutions? There's a difference between taking a position on clemency and a position on prosecution, isn't there?

At any rate: am I adequately summarizing your belief by saying that regardless of what they write, if the Washington Post Editorial Page genuinely believes that Snowden shouldn't be given clemency, then they should also believe that the Washington Post itself should be shuttered (or turned over to a different team)?

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by lisper on Sunday September 18, 2016 @04:40PM (#12527122)
> There's a difference between taking a position on clemency and a position on prosecution, isn't there?

Suppose the U.S. manages to exfiltrate Snowden from Russia somehow. Do you seriously believe that, in the absence of clemency, there is less than a 100% chance he'll be prosecuted? Being against clemency without taking a position on prosecution is kind of like advocating jumping off a cliff but not taking a position on whether or not you fall to the ground. There may be a semantic distinction, but no practical one.

> am I adequately summarizing your belief by saying that regardless of what they write, if the Washington Post Editorial Page genuinely believes that Snowden shouldn't be given clemency, then they should also believe that the Washington Post itself should be shuttered (or turned over to a different team)?

And that they should also be charged and prosecuted as Snowden's willing accomplices. Yes. At least if they want to be honorable (and logically consistent).

Look at the Post's justification for opposing clemency:

"The complication is that Mr. Snowden did more than that. He also pilfered, and leaked, information about a separate overseas NSA Internet-monitoring program, PRISM, that was both clearly legal and not clearly threatening to privacy. (It was also not permanent; the law authorizing it expires next year.) Worse — far worse — he also leaked details of basically defensible international intelligence operations: cooperation with Scandinavian services against Russia; spying on the wife of an Osama bin Laden associate; and certain offensive cyber operations in China."

It was the Post (and the Guardian) who made the decisions to publish these documents, not Snowden! He had neither the time not the inclination to make these kinds of editorial decisions. He grabbed what he could and ran. (And let's not forget that before he did this, he tried to address the problem -- which everyone concedes was a real and very serious problem -- through the "proper channels" and was smacked down.) He then relied on others, including the Post, to filter what he had and decide what should be published and what should remain secret. If things were published that should not have been, then the Post is at least as culpable as Snowden if not more so.

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by tptacek on Sunday September 18, 2016 @07:14PM (#12527691)
For at least the next 4 years (barring impeachment), there is no chance that Snowden can set foot in the US without being immediately arrested and prosecuted.

I think I understand where you're coming from.

I don't agree: I don't think the Post's culpability in spreading Snowden's leak controls the appropriateness of charging Snowden. I think the two are separable issues. I understand why you don't.

Further, I'm closer to the Post editorial's position on clemency for Snowden than to the ACLU's (absent substantial new information about what Snowden did, I'd be unhappy if he spent time in prison). While I could quibble with the examples the Post chose to illustrate their position, I find the logic mostly agreeable.

Regardless of what they've reported, I think it's incumbent on the Post's editorial team to publish their genuinely held opinions on public policy issues. If they believe what they wrote, I think it's important that they published it, instead of pretending that their opinion is different to retain consistency.

But after reading everything you've written, I've come to the conclusion that regardless of the Post's position, it's a badly written editorial:

* It uses dumb examples (like PRISM) that don't fully support its argument and so you can't really reach an informed conclusion about it without a lot of previous context.

* By failing to mention the Post's own role in the story, the Post loses more or less all its credibility, which make the Editorial toothless.

Like I said, I get why we disagree. Thanks for taking the time to talk about this!

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by lisper on Sunday September 18, 2016 @08:10PM (#12527901)
> Thanks for taking the time to talk about this!

You're welcome.

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by ScottBurson on Sunday September 18, 2016 @04:18PM (#12527032)
Let's leave aside the question of what actions should be taken. The important question is this: Does the Post bear any responsibility for the decisions of its news editors to run the PRISM stories?
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by maldeh on Sunday September 18, 2016 @04:20PM (#12527041)
is there an editorial they could have written that would advance their opinion about clemency and not been treacherous?

I think the nature of the opinion itself makes it an unavoidable binary of betrayal / non-betrayal here, since to say now that the leaks were unjustified, is a complete reversal from their prior implicit stance.

Given that Snowden approached them for editorial oversight, and they made the executive decisions to publish some documents, to declare later that those same reports were illegal would have to be a betrayal of their source's trust by definition, regardless of whether it is justified, moral or correct.

I agree that hypocrisy is an independent dimension. They could do a complete moral cleansing by taking responsibility for their actions, but even that wouldn't negate the betrayal.

As an aside, I am not put off by the treachery or disloyalty as much (since that can be inevitable at times - Snowden himself betrayed his employers out of his moral convictions), just WaPo's intellectual dishonesty as they went about it.

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by tptacek on Sunday September 18, 2016 @04:23PM (#12527055)
Apart from outing an anonymous one or altering the information they provide, what does it mean to "betray" a source? I keep asking this and not getting a clear response. In accepting documents from Snowden and profiting from them, did the Post assume an obligation never to advocate against Snowden's interests? If you believe that to be the case, could you support that argument with evidence? Is this a rule of journalism I'm not acquainted with?
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by maldeh on Sunday September 18, 2016 @05:20PM (#12527262)
You're right that they don't have a bunch of obligations to stick by Snowden through legal challenges. Yes, it is ethically acceptable to publish public-interest excerpts from a source they believe is intrinsically illegal. They can also loudly have problems with the way he engaged with other media actors (a la publishing overly sensitive information) and still have a relationship with their source. Their contract with him is purely "do your best to mine and publish what you believe to be in the public interest from this trove of (possibly illegal) data".

Simply put, you can say WaPo initially betrayed Snowden by (in their mind) publishing sensitive info (betrayal by incompetence). If their present thesis is correct, then they were intimately involved in increasing public harm from the leaks. At this juncture they had a number of options to make things right by their perception, but the one they chose was to attribute all blame to him (betrayal by deception).

Not that Snowden had some special right not to be betrayed. He engaged with a lot of media actors, laid a lot of trust by their sense of journalistic ethics, and had to have accepted the risk of whatever fallout could happen from some of the outlets not acting in a trustworthy manner (mitigated by how selectively he involved people). That one of them "betrayed" him by not doing their job well, or pointing fingers at him is not really interesting. Again, I find the WaPo's dishonesty about their own role more interesting.

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by ScottBurson on Sunday September 18, 2016 @05:57PM (#12527403)
> In accepting documents from Snowden and profiting from them, did the Post assume an obligation never to advocate against Snowden's interests?

That's too broad. The question is whether the Post assumed an obligation not to advocate for Snowden to be prosecuted for leaking the specific material they chose to publish.

I don't know what "evidence" would apply to a moral argument, but it seems like common sense to me. If I help you commit a crime, what moral standing do I have to publicly call for your prosecution?

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by tlb on Sunday September 18, 2016 @05:17PM (#12527245)
Surely not. For instance, the Washington Post published the Unabomber's manifesto, but wouldn't have made any argument against prosecuting him.
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by ScottBurson on Sunday September 18, 2016 @05:50PM (#12527375)
Wellll, that was a very different situation. Ted Kaczynski was not a leaker. They published it in the hope that someone would recognize it and identify him -- which is exactly what happened.
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by tptacek on Sunday September 18, 2016 @07:03PM (#12527645)
That is not why they published the Unibomber Manifesto. They published it because it was news.
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by ScottBurson on Sunday September 18, 2016 @08:00PM (#12527864)
Of course I don't know what was in their hearts when they made the decision, but their public statement was to the contrary:

Donald E. Graham, The Post's publisher, and Arthur O. Sulzberger Jr., publisher of the New York Times, said they jointly decided to publish the document "for public safety reasons" after meeting last Wednesday with Attorney General Janet Reno and FBI Director Louis J. Freeh. [...]

"From the beginning, the two newspapers have consulted closely on the issue of whether to publish under the threat of violence. We have also consulted law enforcement officials," Graham and Sulzberger said in a joint statement. "Both the attorney general and the director of the Federal Bureau of Investigation have now recommended that we print this document for public safety reasons, and we have agreed to do so." [...]

"Neither paper would have printed this document for journalistic reasons," Graham said in an interview. "We thought there was an obvious public safety issue involved and therefore sought the advice of responsible federal officials. We are printing it for public safety reasons, not journalistic reasons." [0]

Okay, this doesn't explicitly support my impression that the possibility of getting a lead in the case was specifically suggested in prospect as a reason to publish, though some Wikipedia editor thinks that was the case ("[Freeh and Reno] recommended publication out of concern for public safety and in hopes that a reader could identify the author" [1]; it's not clear what citation this is based on). But it does seem to indicate that if their motives were as you suggest, they managed to keep that fact to themselves.

[0] http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/national/longterm/unabo...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ted_Kaczynski#Industrial_Socie...

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by blackguardx on Sunday September 18, 2016 @07:31PM (#12527763)
Weren't they asked to do so by the FBI?
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by tptacek on Sunday September 18, 2016 @07:35PM (#12527783)
The FBI recommended they publish it, after the Kaczynski sent it with a note threatening to kill more people if no newspaper published.
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by rdiddly on Sunday September 18, 2016 @04:25PM (#12527065)
They're deploring something they participated in. In the most morally-neutral and non-judgmental terms, that is "inconsistent."

If you do something that you regret either immediately or after a delay, that is customarily communicated by means of an apology. That reconciles the two inconsistent behaviors.

Without an apology, their own participation is what makes it impossible for this to be considered a non-treacherous editorial.

Now add: what the Post did was more severe and "damaging" (assuming you hold that view, which I don't) than what Snowden did. It's like a murderer writing an editorial saying "no clemency for the knife salesman!" Those knife salesmen! They really should be behind bars forever, so innocent and virtuous murderers aren't tempted to use those knives, which of course they must!!!

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by _audakel on Sunday September 18, 2016 @05:27PM (#12527291)
With bezos in charge, all the people responsible for publishing the articles are probably long gone. No way for the post to "turn them over"

Non linear digression - snowden the movie was way better then the rotten tomatoes review.

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by _audakel on Sunday September 18, 2016 @05:25PM (#12527284)
With bezos in charge, all the people responsible for publishing the articles are probably long gone. No way for the post to give them up
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by jsmthrowaway on Sunday September 18, 2016 @03:10PM (#12526663)
> Could Baron have done the right thing given the ambit of the Post's newsroom, and the Editorial Page also the right thing in putting forward the argument against blanket clemency?

No. There is no dissonance here whatsoever.

Editorial just cost WaPo an unfathomable number of sources. If you're playing the right move game and consider solely the masthead's interest, carpetbombing loyalty to sources is an extremely stupid move for a masthead to make. I think this is something Greenwald missed given his characterization of WaPo acting in its own self interest; the editorial is inexplicable in that frame of reference.

There is more to it, without question.

I bet Barton Gellman is having a good day.

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by tptacek on Sunday September 18, 2016 @03:14PM (#12526685)
I'm even less interested in the argument about whether it was in the Post's best interests to publish this.
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by jsmthrowaway on Sunday September 18, 2016 @03:20PM (#12526718)
Editorial exists to advocate for the interests of the paper. That's the key.
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by tptacek on Sunday September 18, 2016 @03:22PM (#12526728)
I disagree that that's the point of the Editorial Page.
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by jsmthrowaway on Sunday September 18, 2016 @03:24PM (#12526732)
Then you're wrong and arguing a definition of 'opinion' that appears in no dictionary of which I am aware. Mine is not a controversial statement within the industry, so I'm rather surprised to run into an argument and pushback outside. What do people think editorials are?

They have this opinion for a reason and were willing to bite a source to advance it. Follow the reason.

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by tptacek on Sunday September 18, 2016 @03:40PM (#12526804)
I have no trouble believing that there are lots of HN people that think this is somehow all about Bezos.
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by jsmthrowaway on Sunday September 18, 2016 @03:40PM (#12526806)
Uh, no, but thanks for feeding me an opinion that I don't have. Jeff Bezos didn't even enter this picture for me. You're better than this, come on.

WaPo considered its network of government-friendly sources against a single, prominent government-unfriendly source. That's the calculus and why they can't advocate his pardon. I'm not writing a Dan Brown novel here and I'm pretty annoyed with you straw manning me to your preferred target. This would be like Barbara Starr biting Defense.

Is this really news to you, that the Washington Post tends to maintain formation with the city in its name?

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by tptacek on Sunday September 18, 2016 @03:59PM (#12526910)
Sorry, I thought you were referring to other comments on this thread about Bezos in solidarity. I took a rhetorical shortcut that didn't work out for me.

I do not understand this cui bono logic.

I think it's the role of an Editorial Page to take positions on matters of current events and public policy, and do so so in good faith (ie, to relate the genuinely held and reasonably informed opinions of the staff). My take on the role of an Editorial Page seems like it's pretty much the opposite of your take, which is that the Editorial Page exists to advance the interests of the paper itself.

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by dvogel on Sunday September 18, 2016 @06:20PM (#12527502)
The point is that the editorial board's denunciation of Snowden is empty, dishonest, and to be ignored unless it comes with an equally contemptuous charge against the WaPo news dept.
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by unethical_ban on Sunday September 18, 2016 @02:14PM (#12526365)
Well, he wasn't there for Caesar, so perhaps.

re-edit: I did originally call it a throwaway comment, which while I still kind of feel to be the case, recanted when I saw he put effort lower in the thread.

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by tptacek on Sunday September 18, 2016 @02:15PM (#12526371)
It's not a throwaway comment. I do think we've lost some perspective about this issue. You're free to disagree with me!
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by engi_nerd on Sunday September 18, 2016 @02:17PM (#12526380)
The parent said it was the worst they had ever witnessed. Perhaps hyperbolic, perhaps not. Who is to say? Certainly not you or I.
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by tptacek on Sunday September 18, 2016 @02:34PM (#12526485)
A point I sneakily acknowledged with punctuation.
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by engi_nerd on Monday September 19, 2016 @03:04PM (#12533853)
A subtle point that was apparently lost on most, unfortunately. I only got that from your post after reading it several times.
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by ramblenode on Sunday September 18, 2016 @06:42PM (#12527582)
I agree, but I also see the situation as more nuanced than Greenwald.

Columnists and staff writers working for the same paper can have divergent opinions, and in the case of WaPost, this editorial was not written by the same group of people responsible for breaking the leaks. With some caveats, journalistic autonomy within a paper is a good thing--it helps push back against top-down bias from editors and owners (although, as others have pointed out, maybe WaPost isn't a good example). So there is a tension between Greenwald's monolithic indictment of WaPost and the ideal of journalistic integrity, where an individual journalist can freely publish an informed opinion without outside influence, including from the paper hierarchy.

But this still doesn't excuse the Washington Post. Publicly disagreeing with a colleague is categorically different from protecting a colleague's source. Usually this means protecting anonymity, but in the case of Snowden it's about protecting his safety and well-being: things indirectly threatened by calling for his prosecution if he returns to US soil. Protecting a source should be considered transitive and inherited by the parent publication, taking precedence over the above-mentioned journalistic autonomy. While maybe not an ethical universal, WaPost being one of four publications to receive the leaks, then publishing them extensively, then winning a Pulitzer for having done so does not make for an exculpatory edge case.

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by timv on Sunday September 18, 2016 @09:00PM (#12528105)
> Publicly disagreeing with a colleague is categorically different from protecting a colleague's source

The infuriating part is that they're not admitting to the fact that they're publicly disagreeing.

Sure, it's obvious if you know the facts - their paper published the details of PRISM. If publishing those details was wrong, then the editors who chose to run that story were wrong.

But they never say that.

If this editorial said "Snowden should be charged, and those journalists from this paper who chose to publish the details of programs such as PRISM should be fired and be investigated by the relevant authorities" then it would at least be honest (and also a horrible betrayal of both the paper's source and its staff)

But they won't admit that when they claim Snowden caused ' “tremendous damage” to national security', that they need to level that same charge at their own colleagues.

If Snowden acted against the national interest in providing documents to journalists, then an even stronger claim can be brought against the journalists who published those stories to the public. That The Post chooses to ignore that is pure cowardice.

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by wallace_f on Monday September 19, 2016 @12:10AM (#12528819)
>there is a tension between Greenwald's monolithic indictment of WaPost and the ideal of journalistic integrity, where an individual journalist can freely publish an informed opinion without outside influence, including from the paper hierarchy.

You think so? I disagree - I don't see such a problem with Greenwald's indictment of the post. The editorial column was written by the Post's editorial board--not an individual journalist as you wrote.

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by novaleaf on Sunday September 18, 2016 @02:28PM (#12526444)
The Post's Article is saying that Snowden is responsible for leaking legal and secret information.

As you say, the Post is responsible for publishing it, but the Post's actions do not absolve Snowden of his responsibilities.

I didn't know that PRISM was legal, and in that light I guess I'd agree with the Post Editorial.

Howerver, I do respect and admire Snowden for releasing what he did.

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by themartorana on Sunday September 18, 2016 @02:48PM (#12526556)
Your respect and admiration absolve him of his responsibilities.

This is something I'm seeing more and more - "Snowden is a hero, but should stand trial and face his responsibilities." It's an oxymoron as far as I can figure, and I'm deeply disturbed by it. Either we should know what was revealed, and our government needs checking, or not. But if so, outing that information is heroic and extralegal. If you truly want no one to ever take the same risk Snowden took for the citizens of the US, let the citizens be the ones to throw him to the dogs.

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by jcranmer on Sunday September 18, 2016 @04:06PM (#12526958)
When Daniel Ellsberg leaked the Pentagon Papers, he didn't immediately flee to a foreign country to avoid prosecution. Indeed, he willingly submitted to arrest (under the same law that Snowden is charged under).

That Snowden appears to be trying to run away from the consequences of his actions makes him less of a hero in my eyes.

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by RodericDay on Sunday September 18, 2016 @04:19PM (#12527034)
Daniel Ellsberg himself on Edward Snowden:

Yet when I surrendered to arrest in Boston, having given out my last copies of the papers the night before, I was released on personal recognizance bond the same day. Later, when my charges were increased from the original three counts to 12, carrying a possible 115-year sentence, my bond was increased to $50,000. But for the whole two years I was under indictment, I was free to speak to the media and at rallies and public lectures. I was, after all, part of a movement against an ongoing war. Helping to end that war was my preeminent concern. I couldn’t have done that abroad, and leaving the country never entered my mind.

There is no chance that experience could be reproduced today, let alone that a trial could be terminated by the revelation of White House actions against a defendant that were clearly criminal in Richard Nixon’s era — and figured in his resignation in the face of impeachment — but are today all regarded as legal (including an attempt to “incapacitate me totally”).

[...]

He would almost certainly be confined in total isolation, even longer than the more than eight months Manning suffered during his three years of imprisonment before his trial began recently. The United Nations Special Rapporteur for Torture described Manning’s conditions as “cruel, inhuman and degrading.” (That realistic prospect, by itself, is grounds for most countries granting Snowden asylum, if they could withstand bullying and bribery from the United States.)

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by fixermark on Sunday September 18, 2016 @08:58PM (#12528093)
When Daniel Ellsberg leaked the Pentagon Papers, the United States wasn't quite so much in the habit of, among other things, legally justifying torture to extract information as it is apparently today.

The legal and political ecosystem has fundamentally shifted post-9/11, and I don't know it's fair to hold a modern whistleblower to a standard that existed in the '70s.

(That's a long-winded way of saying "I wouldn't trust the government either." ;) )

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by AYBABTME on Sunday September 18, 2016 @04:15PM (#12527012)
It's a weird argument. Not only do US people want a hero, but the hero must suffer.
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by angry_octet on Sunday September 18, 2016 @08:10PM (#12527902)
Is that a surprise in the Christian context?
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by nathan_long on Monday September 19, 2016 @11:32AM (#12532178)
Yes. Christians do not wish to be like Judas, Pilate, etc.
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by angry_octet on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @02:29AM (#12545869)
I was referring to the need for a martyr. Though if you are biblically minded, then by allowing Snowden to be crucified we are bringing a curse upon ourselves, cf Barabbas.
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by eropple on Sunday September 18, 2016 @05:00PM (#12527194)
No, the "hero" (and I don't think Snowden is one, but I am biased from personal experience) should, if he believes himself to be in the right, defend himself in front of a jury of his peers. That's not the same thing as "suffering"; that's how the judicial system works.
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by ScottBurson on Sunday September 18, 2016 @05:25PM (#12527283)
Except, of course, that the law he is charged under -- the Espionage Act of 1917 -- does not permit a public interest defense.

Would you also say that James Clapper should stand trial for perjury?

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by mikeash on Sunday September 18, 2016 @05:23PM (#12527269)
Why? What's the connection between believing one's actions to be right and surrendering to the justice system? Especially if he believes, no doubt correctly, that he would be found guilty and punished severely.
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by timv on Sunday September 18, 2016 @09:03PM (#12528121)
Would you say the same if the hero was from Russia or North Korea or Syria?

Would it be OK to leak documents from there and then flee their judicial systems?

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by themartorana on Monday September 19, 2016 @02:54PM (#12533778)
I would definitely support someone outing and then fleeing Russia. In fact we do it all the time - it's called political asylum.
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by int_19h on Monday September 19, 2016 @01:11AM (#12529096)
An impartial jury would be bound to rule him guilty, because he did break a law.

It doesn't mean that he's not a hero, though, because many people didn't even know it was the law until he did. And that it is a bad law.

But no, he doesn't have an obligation to suffer to prove that he had a point.

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by angry_octet on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:24AM (#12531220)
Juries have many times chosen to take a more holistic view of the law, determining that sometimes prosectution is not in the public interest, known as jury nullification.

See especially the case of a British leaker: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clive_Ponting

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by ethanbond on Monday September 19, 2016 @12:20PM (#12532559)
Juries are in no way bound to find even the most egregiously culpable defendants guilty of committing a crime. Choosing not to do so is not claiming the person did not break the law, but a claim that the law itself was wrong.

It happens every once in a while and is an important feature, not bug of the American judiciary.

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by int_19h on Monday September 19, 2016 @07:10PM (#12535544)
Jury nullification is a right, yes. However, jury instruction will very deliberately claim otherwise, and most people do follow it (and if, during jury selection, anyone hints at understanding what it is, they will almost certainly be excused). So realistically it's a very inefficient check.
Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by ethanbond on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @04:10AM (#12537943)
> An impartial jury would be bound to rule him guilty

Then why are you pushing this lie forward? You should be doing your part to inform Americans of their rights, not mislead and disempower them.

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by int_19h on Tuesday September 20, 2016 @02:54PM (#12542196)
I consider jury nullification to be a right. I don't consider it to be a moral duty. An impartial jury, from that perspective, is the one that rules according to the law as written.

(I wouldn't do so - but I wouldn't consider myself impartial, either.)

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by ethanbond on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @06:44AM (#12546945)
An impartial [1] jury wouldn't immediately accept the word of the law as correct.

In US courts, the letter of the law itself is one of the disputants. It is just as vulnerable to questioning as the prosecutor's case and the defendant's case. That's why court rulings actually do affect the law itself (judicial precedence), they don't only affect a particular case. Again, this is all by design.

Regardless, your response is totally irrelevant. I didn't ask about the morality of anything. Your statement that a jury is obligated to find in any direction is totally false. There is no such obligation in the US, nor will there ever be.

[1] Impartial: Treating all rivals or disputants equally

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by int_19h on Wednesday September 21, 2016 @05:05PM (#12552249)
I believe there's some confusion here between legal and moral obligations. There's no legal obligation for the jury to find in any direction, yes - that is the basis for nullification. However, whether nullification is an intentional feature, or an unavoidable but undesirable side effect of the jury trial system, is very much up for debate. If you look at juror's oaths, they generally tend to embrace the latter approach. For example:

"You must not substitute or follow your own notion or opinion as to what the law is or ought to be. It is your duty to apply the law as I explain it to you, regardless of the consequences"

So when a juror nullifies, they break that oath. Insofar as that oath exists, it sets society's expectations of what the jury does.

"Impartial" was perhaps not the best choice of word for this, I agree.

Re:Washington Post Is First Paper to Call for Prosecution of... by lerpa on Monday September 19, 2016 @09:11AM (#12531128)
An impartial jury would recognize that breaking that law was the right thing to do because the law was wrong and unjust, and therefore should be abolished. It's not like the US legal system came down from heaven.