News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by Retric on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @12:27PM (#12498606)
Median household income shows similar growth levels for ’92–’97 (7) and ’10–’15 (6). However, bottom 20 percent income vs. Top 20 percent income looks like 1/2 the growth at the bottom 92–’97 (10) ’10–’15 (5) vs top 92–’97 (20) ’10–’15 (10) for both periods.

So, it might be broader recovery, but the bottom is still failing further behind and the middle is not keeping up with the top.

Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by refurb on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @01:06PM (#12499040)
The people in the bottom, middle and top aren't always the same people.
Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by Retric on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @04:25PM (#12500946)
Going from a medical resident to doctor moves you from one income strata to another. It's not a sign of income mobility.

There is some income mobility in the US. However people generally make more money by changing what they do. Which generally means someone else ends up in the old job. AKA if a janitor goes to night school and becomes a mechanic that does not change what janitors makes.

Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by refurb on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @07:49PM (#12502248)
Looking at the income of individual segments doesn't tell you anything about mobility.

Income could remain static, but people could move from higher to lower segments and vice versa.

Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by Retric on Thursday September 15, 2016 @07:53AM (#12505267)
The normal way to compare mobility is to look at someones income percentile at age X vs parents income percentile at age X. After all most people's income is ~zero as a young teen.
Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by MrTonyD on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @12:50PM (#12498861)
Agreed. I feel like this is a "can't see the forest for the trees" story. A median moving a few percent is pretty much meaningless in the context of the many millions who are struggling and suffering. The fundamental causes of inequality are not being addressed.
Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by tjic on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @01:05PM (#12499021)
Serious question: how do you propose to address

(a) some people can't make meaningful contributions to the economy because they lack the intelligence to compete with machines

(b) some people can't work because globalization means that their potential contributions can be done cheaper by someone in the middle class overseas who is happy to work for less than US minimum wage allows them to work for

(c) some people refuse to work because the benefits safety net (including disability for unverifiable conditions (source: http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2013/03/disabili... ) is more comfortable than work

Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by clavalle on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @02:39PM (#12499975)
>(a) some people can't make meaningful contributions to the economy because they lack the intelligence to compete with machines

The underlying assumptions of this question would require significant justification to accept them as approaching truth.

First it assumes the people are the problem rather then the job. Then, that 'intelligence' is the end all be all of valuable contribution. And add the 'machines will automate value creation away' and we've got a 'blame dumb poor people for not being able to keep up' trifecta.

>(b) some people can't work because globalization means that their potential contributions can be done cheaper by someone in the middle class overseas who is happy to work for less than US minimum wage allows them to work for

Define 'middle class' and 'happy'. This seems to be arguing for a race to the bottom but framing it as government interference keeping the magic of the market from happening while completely ignoring that minimum wage isn't even enough to keep up the cost of human capital in the US and that the 'cheaper' labor might have a lot to do with those wonderful happy low paid workers having no political voice to help protect them from absorbing all of the costs of negative externalities in their countries.

>(c) some people refuse to work because the benefits safety net is more comfortable than work

Again, the underlying assumption that people 'refuse' to work because they are comfortable not working. The hidden alternative being they get no safety net. The mechanism of either working or starve is somehow better? Markets can't work toward efficiency if people are negotiating against loss rather than for gain.

A plausible alternative theory is that low end work is broken rather than the safety net. We allow people to be paid less than their upkeep and keep the threat of pain (starvation, homelessness) just visible so that it motivates them to take jobs that pay less than their time is actually worth to them if weighed outside of that threat to their wellbeing. So, their decision is to work for mere survival or not work for mere survival and many make the rational choice.

Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by toomuchtodo on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @01:59PM (#12499582)
Raise the top marginal tax rates, strengthen social safety nets (social security, welfare, etc). Use Congressional authority to raise wage floors (minimum wage, threshold for overtime), thereby pushing corporate profits into labor's pocket. Perhaps even reduce the work week by 8-16 hours, considering the massive productivity gains over the last 40 years, which has gone primarily to corporate profits.

Scandinavian democratic socialism.

EDIT: This is just to start.

Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by tjic on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @02:06PM (#12499647)
None of this creates new jobs. In fact, it destroys jobs (higher minimum wage, higher taxes).

Do you have any thoughts on how to create jobs?

There are lots of studies that show that welfare dependency is destructive to goodwill; it's not JUST about giving people dollars.

Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by smallnamespace on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @02:13PM (#12499709)
> it destroys jobs

The bedrock of corporate profit is consumer demand.

We're in a vicious cycle where people are unemployed/underemployed -> consumer demand is depressed (because they have no money) -> companies don't hire (because nobody will buy their goods) -> people are unemployed

You have to break the cycle by first propping up consumer demand, and the most direct way to that is by giving consumers money to spend.

Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by mason240 on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @02:40PM (#12499988)
That's exactly what President Hoover tried to prop up the economy after the 1929 stock market crash.
Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by smallnamespace on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @02:43PM (#12500023)
And he would've succeeded if he was willing to blow up the deficit further.

That actually happened with our entry into WW2, sharp increases in spending and hiring, and immediate end to the Great Depression (note that weapons, ships, planes and the like are about useful to a peacetime economy as digging holes in the ground--the key is you need to hire a lot of people to make them)

Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by notfromhere on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @05:09PM (#12501225)
And exactly how the WW2 recovery happened. Government created demand for products, and deficit spent until the economy roared back. Subsequent gov't surpluses from increased tax revenue were then used to pay down deficit.
Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by ianai on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @02:15PM (#12499731)
Uh dropping the Hours for full time work. The DOL made the time and a half for work over 40 hrs per week to increase labor demand. Imagine a world where it's 6 hrs per day or 30 per week. More people would be employed. And since those hours are paid piece wise no ones hourly wage would decrease. That's how the labor force could increase.
Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by thaumasiotes on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @06:14PM (#12501648)
> The DOL made the time and a half for work over 40 hrs per week to increase labor demand.

The only possible effect of this policy is to decrease demand for labor.

Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by rabidrat on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @02:38PM (#12499960)
Reducing the workweek by 20% will create jobs, for those jobs in which output is a result of hours worked.
Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by hx87 on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @03:20PM (#12500364)
It's giving /some/ people money that is destructive to goodwill; giving /everyone/ money doesn't have the same downsides.
Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by ptaipale on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @05:07PM (#12501218)
Your idea of Scandinavian democratic socialism seems to be rather misguided. You probably haven't lived here?

- Top marginal tax rates are not that different -- the difference is more in that the higher tax rates kick in earlier in Scandinavia, which is necessary because average earnings are lower. In the U.S., the high earners pay a larger proportion of tax revenue than Scandinavia. US: the top 2.7 % pays 51.6 % of federal income tax [0] while in Finland, the top 3 % pays 22.4 % of income tax revenue [1]

- Wage floors: Scandinavian countries don't have a legal minimum wage at all [2]. The minimum compensation for each job is negotiated in collective bargaining per sector, and several U.S. states already have higher and more broadly enforced minimum wages than what these per-sector agreements are in Scandinavian countries.

- Corporate profits to labor's pocket: compensation per employee as percentage of GDP at factor cost per person employed is not substantially different in the U.S. from northern EU. [3] Yes, it's somewhat falling because of technological development and increased regulation and taxation everywhere.

Overall, the difference in fact is that in many areas, the Scandinavian countries have less socialism, more market economy - more open competition and less protectionism. It seems that you think the Scandinavian success is socialism, when in fact it is neoliberalism. [4]

[0] http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2016/04/13/high-income-...

[1] http://www.stat.fi/tup/suoluk/suoluk_tulot.html

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_minimum_wages_by_count...

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wage_share#/media/File:Adjuste...

[4] http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1629940

Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by toomuchtodo on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @05:31PM (#12501366)
I'm targeting the same outcome by pulling different levers.
Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by thaumasiotes on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @05:52PM (#12501510)
What is that outcome, and in what sense is it "Scandinavian democratic socialism"?
Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by toomuchtodo on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @05:58PM (#12501549)
Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by ptaipale on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @06:12PM (#12501638)
Again, have you actually understood how we here in Nordic countries have arrived in this model?

Your approach looks like a cargo cult to me: it lacks understanding of the basic mechanisms, and instead focuses on some external insignia and symbols.

Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by toomuchtodo on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @06:20PM (#12501700)
Yes, I've studied the economic principals underlying Nordic socioeconomic success. Again, I believe other methods will need to be undertaken to achieve the same outcome, due to the drastic cultural and economic differences between Nordic countries and the United States.

That's not cargo culting. That's adapting to your circumstances.

Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by basseq on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @03:53PM (#12500656)
At a macro level, labor has benefited alongside productivity—automation and globalization—in the 19th and 20th centuries. So the question becomes how much society should insulate individuals from economic change.

There are no guarantees that one's current skillset will always be relevant, one's current marginal value will increase, or that economic demand will remain in the same geography. Automation and globalization exacerbates these issues, but they're not new issues: textile workers in the 1800s destroyed machinery over concerns it would reduce the need for their labor.

You have no unalienable right to keep your job.

So I take issue with your hypothesis inherent in (a) and (b) that some people "can't work" because the economy has shifted. Opportunity and economic need for labor still exists; people need to adapt.

But there is an issue here, and the solution is (re)skilling. We need programs that help and support people of all ages to gain the skills they need to get a job in high-demand fields. A basic income might help, too—e.g., to avoid the catch-22 of needing money to move to a new town to get a job to get money.

If economic demand is dropping precipitously in certain locations, intervention action is needed in the form of state or county-level policy to retain or attract labor supply and/or economic demand.

If benefits programs are more desirable than an alternative of working a low-wage job, then "refusing to work" is logical. If waste and abuse is egregious, then the programs should be changed. But at the same time, we need to get comfortable with the fact that some people will choose to do the bare minimum.

Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by MrTonyD on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @02:18PM (#12499767)
I think each country should have a first responsibility to its own citizens - getting all of them to some standard of living before allowing immigration or offshoring or importing. This would work for all except a few countries (and then importing/offshoring/exporting by other countries would be able to help them.)

We could simply define jobs for people, and stop importing products in those categories. Need more jobs? Restrict more product importation and offshoring.

I should add that I've worked in factory automation - fully lights-out factories - and we are capable of creating a great quality of life for people. This isn't the early 1900's, we can create all the jobs we want for the people who want jobs.

And there are competing studies about the effect of the safety net - since countries with the best safety nets also usually have the best economies and the most innovation (some think it is tied to the ability to take risks without becoming impoverished if you fail.)

Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by rabidrat on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @02:41PM (#12499998)
> We could simply define jobs for people, and stop importing products in those categories. Need more jobs? Restrict more product importation and offshoring.

It's becoming more common to advocate for scaling back globalization as a solution to local economic problems. It might even work; I wonder if there are any downsides?

Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by Silfen on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @04:36PM (#12501007)
The commonly cited downsides include (a) rent seeking among protected industries and (b) prices of domestically produced goods are higher. How true these are in practice is probably somewhat controversial and difficult to measure.
Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by wincy on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @03:45PM (#12500584)
Why not get rid of minimum wage? We'd open up opportunities for all sorts of new wage deals and payment structures. What's the point of having people on welfare who could be working as a servant or doing some sort of work? It would also disincentive automation when labor prices can be driven down and suddenly everyone becomes employable.
Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by rayiner on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @04:52PM (#12501110)
As someone who immigrated to the US from a country where people have "servants" I'd fight very hard to ensure we never have such a system here.
Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by thaumasiotes on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @06:15PM (#12501654)
Out of curiosity, may I ask which country?
Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by rayiner on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @09:44PM (#12502748)
Bangladesh.
Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by notfromhere on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @05:11PM (#12501241)
That's one way to create a permanent underclass and cause a whole lot of other social issues.
Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by jschwartzi on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @05:42PM (#12501436)
See the 16th, 17th, 18th, and 19th centuries in the US for plenty of examples of what this would look like.
Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by throwaway12938 on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @01:04PM (#12499018)
You mean the transition to an information based society but without author-centric notions of copyright?

Most of the successful companies of the last few decades deal mainly in intellectual properties. Most of the successful companies in technology derive their profits from other people freely giving away their intellectual property.

Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by oldmanjay on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @02:49PM (#12500084)
Once again, I foolishly wonder why the problem people identify boils down to envy and why I should care that people want things they don't have. I get that calling it "inequality" as opposed to "envy" makes it more emotionally resonant but it doesn't provide any actual reasons for me to latch onto.

Is it some sort of attempt to head off a revolution that will never happen?

Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by burkaman on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @04:07PM (#12500788)
Many people cannot afford adequate food, shelter, and healthcare because of the things they don't have. There's nothing wrong with envy when you're in that situation.

> Is it some sort of attempt to head off a revolution that will never happen?

Sort of? I don't think Trump would be doing as well if inequality weren't so high. And as inequality gets worse, I think Trump-like movements will strengthen. I'm not really worried about an armed revolt, but that doesn't mean everything is fine.

Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by eli_gottlieb on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @03:58PM (#12500712)
>The fundamental causes of inequality are not being addressed.

Well of course not! That would require breaking up monopolies and oligopolies, restarting the intellectual property treadmill that moves ideas into the public domain, and fighting rentiering in land, natural resources, and means of production by spreading ownership through the working population.

A society built on rents cannot reduce inequality without re-building their society on actual, useful production.

Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by hx87 on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @01:03PM (#12499010)
Those few percent mean that millions who aren't at the top are moving ahead.
Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by ArkyBeagle on Thursday September 15, 2016 @01:44AM (#12503729)
People are leaving the middle in threes - one goes to the lower bracket, two move up.

It's not like we have wildlife ear tags; these are abstract atoms in an aggregate measure.

Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by m52go on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @01:14PM (#12499128)
Nominal income growth means nothing. Real income is not growing.
Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by smallnamespace on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @01:35PM (#12499339)
From the article:

  inflation-adjusted incomes for the mass of Americans have finally started to rise in a meaningful way
Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by m52go on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @09:25PM (#12502672)
That's encouraging, but the absolute level of real incomes is still lower than it was before the recession.
Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by hga on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @02:45PM (#12500042)
And you believe the government's inflation statistics?

When so much of their spending is automatically tied to them?

Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by smallnamespace on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @03:09PM (#12500256)
Just because there's a potential conflict of interest doesn't mean they're lying. I think this heuristic will quickly lead you astray if you rely on it too heavily.

Here is the same argument, substituted with different groups:

- Do you trust climate scientists, when their prestige is tied to how important their field is?

- Do you trust the science on vaccines, when the public health system relies on people's willingness to be vaccinated?

- Do you trust that Obama isn't lying about being an American, given that was running for President?

- Do you trust yourself, given that psychological research shows that data that contradicts a strong belief tends to reinforce that belief?

If you're going to call someone or some group a liar, I think it takes a lot more evidence than just 'they might have a plausible incentive to lie'.

To answer your question though, I have several technical concerns about how CPI inflation is calculated, but I definitely don't think it's due to someone actively deciding to fudge the figures.

Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by hga on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @03:46PM (#12500596)
The 2nd sentence was just a rhetorical point designed to nudge people into having some doubt about the statistic. I myself came to that conclusion long before appreciating its effect on the government budget, from watching the CPI and what I believed to be "true inflation" starting in the dreadful '70s (yep, I remember Nixon's wage and price controls), when I believe it was a lot more honest, say at least through a good part of the '80s.

Your subpoints aren't quite all the same, a good Upton Sinclair quote that's been bandied about lately "It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it!", so e.g. #2 doesn't apply, the public health system doesn't make much money at all on vaccinations, that's more of a True Believer thing. See e.g. Governor Gardasil.

And I tried real hard in the 1968-80 period, 2nd grade through first year of college, and of course beyond, to seek out the truth at all costs, having decided at the end of 1st grade that science was my calling. And I think I got somewhere, although of course what you cite is always a danger.

Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by m52go on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @06:24PM (#12501721)
> but I definitely don't think it's due to someone actively deciding to fudge the figures.

What they've done instead is change the CPI formula a couple times to avoid it from reflecting price increases.

For example, they replaced steak with hamburger a few years ago when steak got too expensive.

Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by hga on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @06:42PM (#12501827)
There's some legitimacy to the substitution approach, because people do e.g. switch from hamburger to chicken when the former gets more expensive (steak, if it was substituted by hamburger, is fraud), and at least this is a special case of production issues vs. something driven by "secular" inflation (drought really wacked cattle production, as my father's friends who raised them attested at the time).

But it's easy to take too far, and any consumer who nonetheless insist on having some steaks, or more expensive hamburger, you'll not be impressed by this statistical substitution trick.

Re:The Economic Expansion Is Finally Helping the Middle Class by smallnamespace on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @09:54PM (#12502787)
You can't calculate inflation over the long run without changing the components of the basket, and it goes both ways:

http://www.bls.gov/opub/mlr/2014/article/one-hundred-years-o...

For example, the average household no longer purchases coal or firewood to heat their home, and we no longer buy straw hats. That seems completely reasonable to me. People's preferences change.

On the other hand, we've added radios, TVs, cars, etc. to the basket.