News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by david927 on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @03:59PM (#1248280)
Woz has always about being open and modular and extensible. Jobs has always been about the opposite -- and for good reason; the early Macs were typically more stable and functioned better simply because of that lock-in.

But history has played this over and over again, and Woz always wins. Vendors work out standards; the user experience consolidates.

If you give people the freedom and trust them, they'll work it out. Or you can trust a benevolent dictator to work it out for you. Most Apple afficianados will say the most people don't want that freedom; I'm here to tell you that they do.

We don't have to debate. Let's just tune in and watch the sales of the iPad starting next month, after the faithful have all bought theirs. Woz will win. Woz always wins.

Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by crux on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @04:25PM (#1248347)
What's with this constant invoking of the 'faithful'? I work at a place that sells the iPad and I've had a lot of people ask me about it. The people who are buying the iPad aren't exactly fanboys, who have been slavering over anything that Apple would put out. They're normal folks. A lot of them don't know any real specifics about the iPad, but they have the feeling that it would really be more enjoyable to use than their netbook. The notion that these Apple products only have niche appeal (because normal people value functionality and openness over prettiness) is kind of bonkers in the face of the extremely strong mainstream popularity of the various iPods as well as the iPhone.
Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by xiaoma on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @05:27PM (#1248489)
The iPhone is really open and functional compared to the phones that preceded it. Just downloading a ringtone for most prior phones was more expensive than full-fledged games on the iPhone. The app store is far from perfect, but it's a very open market compared to anything I've seen out of Nokia or any of the Japanese handset makers.
Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by rjurney on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @07:12PM (#1248686)
Its funny how easily people forget this - Apple created the first MARKET for mobile apps. Thats openness. Before the iPhone the mobile game was one big scam, with someone reaching into your pocket at each and every step in a long chain.
Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by rbanffy on Thursday April 08, 2010 @09:36AM (#1249789)
> Apple created the first MARKET for mobile apps. Thats openness.

I distinctly remember being able to install software I downloaded (or made) on my Sony Ericsson P-800 a good couple years before the iPhone was announced. In fact, digging a little back, I am sure you could install PalmOS apps on your Treos since the first day they were launched.

And anyone could develop for both platforms (actually, there was Java ME too), anyone could host the file you would have to download to install and specify how, and if, you would pay for the download. In fact, many application stores appeared hosting zillions of smartphone apps you could download and install.

Apple's market is not open at all. Apple decides if you will be able to sell the fruits of your development work.

What Apple did is to corner both users and developers. And that's bad.

Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by rjurney on Thursday April 08, 2010 @02:21PM (#1250436)
How many people did? Why so few? No market to speak of.

They made things one level free-er, which is the best they could have done given the constraints of the market and the technology. There are issues. They aren't villains for having issues.

Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by netcan on Thursday April 08, 2010 @02:15AM (#1249261)
Compared to the various carriers, Apple's a peach.
Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by whatusername on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @06:20PM (#1248594)
You lost me at ringtone.

My 3210 (10 years ago!) you were able to program your own ringtones (in the little beeps that it could produce)

Most other nokia's (my 6110) - to use a ringtone it was a case of put an mp3 file on the phone - then select the mp3 as the ringtone.

Do you know what you have to do to get a ringtone on the iPhone?

Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by pyre on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @06:56PM (#1248649)
A lot of carrier-branded phones have features like that disabled in favor of only allowing the user to purchase ringtones from the carrier's marketplace where you pay upwards of $3-$4 per ringtone (i.e. ringtones, at 30s or less, cost more than buying the entire song on iTunes). It is/was vendor lock-in at it's worst: create a captive audience, and then price gouge them because they don't know any better (i.e. "My old phone didn't have ringtones, but now I can buy ringtones from Verizon! Yay!"; without realizing that the phone itself supports user-created ringtones that you don't have to pay for).

It's sort of the same for the iPhone now. People think it's great because they are used to phones with limited functionality, openness and usability. Compared to those phones that iPhone is a breath of fresh air. Apple's just playing a game of, "what they don't know can't hurt them." People don't sit down and think about exactly what their ideal device is like. They see the iPhone/iPad and thing that it's neat and mold their expectation around what they see (especially if their expectations were lower to begin with).

Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by GeneralMaximus on Thursday April 08, 2010 @12:43AM (#1249153)
A lot of carrier-branded phones have features like that disabled in favor of only allowing the user to purchase ringtones from the carrier's marketplace where you pay upwards of $3-$4 per ringtone (i.e. ringtones, at 30s or less, cost more than buying the entire song on iTunes).

I would like to point out this is an American phenomenon. At least in India, the mobile market is completely open.

Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by benwerd on Thursday April 08, 2010 @06:51AM (#1249577)
This. I think the iPhone was a complete boon to the US mobile market, which was suffering and locked down. In America, the iPhone is one of the most open handsets out there. However, everywhere else, where carriers have less of an ability to be quite as locked-down and evil, they're one of the least open.
Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by rbanffy on Thursday April 08, 2010 @09:39AM (#1249796)
> I would like to point out this is an American phenomenon

And this explains why the iPhone was somewhat underwhelming for the rest of the world. It's a great phone, sure, but no revolution.

Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by xiaoma on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @07:12PM (#1248684)
>Do you know what you have to do to get a ringtone on the iPhone?

Yep. They're free. Just download them as podcasts. http://macmost.com/free-iphone-ringtones

Or even use iTunes to make them out of music on your computer: http://www.ehow.com/how_2160460_custom-iphone-ringtones-free...

Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by whatusername on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @09:05PM (#1248856)
So if someone pre-generates a strange file-format for you - it's almost as simple as my 5 year old nokia.

Or there's a 17 step process.

The way the iPhone handles it's ringtones is a step back from how most normal phones did. (// Note to American readers - if your carrier blocks a function - it means you have a bad carrier - not a bad phone)

The iPhone excelled in having a great browser. And looking gorgeous. As far as Phone parts go (crap reception/quality, struggles with group sms, ringtones, etc) it was a step backwards from most phones on the market. Now that might be an acceptable trade-off, but it still needs to be stated.

Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by xiaoma on Thursday April 08, 2010 @09:40AM (#1249798)
I've never bought or owned a cellphone in America. My only basis for comparison is previous phones in Taiwan and Japan.
Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by houseabsolute on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @04:04PM (#1248287)
> Let's just tune in and watch the sales of the iPad starting next month

We already watched the sales of the iPhone, and we saw how that went. Same type of device, same type of complaints by openness advocate, and what was the result? Are you guys going to just keep on saying this stuff until some closed Apple product fails, then say that's proof that people want openness, ignoring the litany of preceding closed devices that succeeded? I'm here to tell you that this is not a very good argument.

Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by abstractbill on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @04:16PM (#1248320)
Android gained 5.2% of the US smartphone market between December 2009 and February 2010, while the iPhone lost 0.1% (http://www.mobileburn.com/news.jsp?Id=9184).

Of course I'm not going to declare the iPhone a failure - it's clearly done very well. But I think it's still a little early to call it a winner.

Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by houseabsolute on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @04:27PM (#1248355)
In all likelihood both will continue to be part of the mobile ecosystem for some time, or until Google gets tired of throwing money at the problem.

But as I said to another responder, the iPhone is one device on one carrier per country, and Android is many devices on all carriers. They are hardly on equal footing for a purely numerical battle for superiority, but still iPhone is winning.

Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by Daishiman on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @09:02PM (#1248852)
Google is making real money with Android, and even if it's a loss leader it's just another medium to expand their search business. They can afford to lose the millions in Android develoment and they still come out winning.
Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by houseabsolute on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @11:08PM (#1249026)
What money do you suppose they are making? It's probably cheaper to pay Apple to maintain Google as the default search engine on the phone than to make their own. It's unlikely that a whole lot more internet searches are happening because of Android that wouldn't have happened in any other arrangement of the ecosystem, so I still don't see how Google benefits.
Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by GeneralMaximus on Thursday April 08, 2010 @12:46AM (#1249160)
Yes, that's an option. But consider this: the iPhone becomes the number one smartphone out there -> Mobile Safari has the highest mobile marketshare of any web browser -> Apple controls the mobile web. What Google ultimately want is an open web so they keep making money from AdSense/AdWords.
Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by CoryMathews on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @05:21PM (#1248478)
"They are hardly on equal footing for a purely numerical battle for superiority"

Thats Apples choice. Those chose to lock in with AT&T they could have not locked in and sold many MANY more. So yes it equal if anything its less equal for the android because it came in later.

Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by steveklabnik on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @05:45PM (#1248526)
It's not about choices. If a phone that's available on multiple carriers doesn't sell more than a device that's on one, something is wrong.
Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by Hagelin on Thursday April 08, 2010 @10:23AM (#1249867)
the iPhone is one device on one carrier per country

One carrier per country isn't true here in Sweden, and I'm guessing we're not a unique case. All the major carriers sell it here.

Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by ryanhuff on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @06:08PM (#1248573)
Considering that the Android product options prior to November were pretty weak, the momentum in Android is partially based on decent products finally being available to consumers. Unfortunately, I think Google's N1 distribution strategy isn't helping matters.
Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by rimantas on Thursday April 08, 2010 @03:47AM (#1249390)
Comparing Android to iPhone is like comparing copies of Windows 7 sold to the number of Macbook Pro 15".
Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by RyanMcGreal on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @04:23PM (#1248343)
iPhone market share is respectable but hardly dominant:

http://www.macobserver.com/tmo/article/the_truth_about_apple...

Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by houseabsolute on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @04:25PM (#1248351)
Granted, but irrelevant to the claim I was making. Also I'd like to point out that that's one device on (normally) one carrier per country, being pushed by only one company. The others are all being pushed by consortiums or multiple phone companies and are available normally on all carriers yet they still lag behind.
Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by david927 on Thursday April 08, 2010 @05:24AM (#1249486)
Mobile phones and tablet computers are completely different markets.

The trajectory of the iPad will be quite different than that of the iPhone. Wait. You'll see.

Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by samd on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @04:11PM (#1248308)
The consumer isn't choosing the iPhone or iPad because it is closed, they are choosing it because it is easy to use, sexy, and supported by lots of apps. You can still have those things and be open, and Android is proving it.
Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by houseabsolute on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @04:19PM (#1248331)
Android is neither as easy to use or as sexy as the iPhone. The dismal sales of the nexus one despite it's superior spec sheet and androidness are proof of this.

But I do agree with you, most people buy things out of which they get the most utility, and ease of use an sexiness are a big part of that. But the person I was responding to mad the claim that people won't buy the ipad because it is closed. It would only be possible to believe this if your head was buried deep in the sand.

Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by orangecat on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @04:31PM (#1248362)
Android is neither as easy to use or as sexy as the iPhone. The dismal sales of the nexus one despite it's superior spec sheet and androidness are proof of this.

It's silly to use Nexus One sales as proof of anything because it's had almost no marketing. The Droid has sold far better: http://blog.flurry.com/bid/31410/Day-74-Sales-Apple-iPhone-v...

Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by houseabsolute on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @04:42PM (#1248394)
True. But if you compared those numbers to the sales of the iPhone 3G or 3GS, they would look less rosy. What you've got there is a non-smartphone without an app store on a smaller carrier being compared with a smartphone with an app store on a larger carrier that's famous of not having many options in the phones you can select because of its CDMA network.

Anyway, the whole discussion of which is doing better is completely unrelated to my original objection to the top-level poster.

Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by CamperBob on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @09:53PM (#1248928)
It's silly to use Nexus One sales as proof of anything because it's had almost no marketing.

It had a hell of a lot more marketing than the iPad did, and was still trounced by the latter's preorders alone.

Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by copenja on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @10:24PM (#1248969)
Sales don't prove sexiness or ease of use.

Consider sales of the Droid. In it's first 74 days it sold more units than the original iPhone did in it's first 74 days.

http://mashable.com/2010/03/16/nexus-one-sales-poor/

But I'm not going to say that proves that the Droid is sexier than the iPhone.

Hell, there both great phones.

Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by houseabsolute on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @10:30PM (#1248981)
You should especially not say that since the comparison is not really fair, considering the iPhone OS was an unknown quantity, and iPhone lacked an app store, was on a smaller carrier, and was not launched during the holiday season.

Sales are not complete proof of sexiness, but they are evidence. It strikes me that if the iPhone on a single carrier can win out against an entire ecosystem of phones on many carriers, it probably has something they do not.

Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by copenja on Thursday April 08, 2010 @04:03AM (#1249411)
If sales were a sign of sexiness OS X would have outsold Windows.
Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by rbanffy on Thursday April 08, 2010 @09:44AM (#1249804)
> The dismal sales of the nexus one despite it's superior spec sheet and androidness are proof of this.

In a carrier-locked-down market like the US, where the norm is to buy phones that are married to a given carrier, it only proves Apple has better marketing and carrier relations than other companies.

Also, Android is not a phone - it's a platform. The Nexus One is only one of many competing offerings - that compete not only with iPhones, but between themselves.

Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by abstractbill on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @04:25PM (#1248352)
I think the effect is real, but of course it's not as direct as this. Now that the iPhone has a viable competitor that's more developer friendly, it seems likely that apps will start to appear first on Android, and then only later on the iPhone. I think that might effect consumers' perception of which is the sexier device.
Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by Lazlo_Nibble on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @04:53PM (#1248419)
Having a platform that's easier to develop, publish and distribute software for is only half of the "developer friendly" equation. The other half is having a user community that's willing to spend money on that software.

Are there many Android developers who've been able to quit their day jobs and make a living from app sales? (That's a serious question, not a snarky one -- I don't follow the market closely.)

Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by houseabsolute on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @04:28PM (#1248356)
Seems like if that were going to happen it would have happened already, or we'd at least have seen some sign of a sea-change. Yet the ports still flow in the opposite direction (when developers even bother). Maybe because Android appeals to the spendthrift, and iPhone to people more open with their wallets?

The other explanation is that iPhone is plenty open to developers who make the types of apps people want to buy, and closed only to the tinkerers who would not have been making salable apps anyway.

Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by btilly on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @06:44PM (#1248635)
Is the Android really more developer friendly? A very profitable application category on the iPhone are audible applications. That category is a nonstarter on the Android because Java latency causes noticeable sound artifacts.
Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by jsz0 on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @04:54PM (#1248422)
Keep in mind it's not 1976 or 1984. Things are different today. Technology is no longer reserved for the technical elite to enjoy or fetishize over exclusively. If you want to draw a line in the sand to figure out when things changed I'd say 2001 and the introduction of the iPod -- an incredibly closed but amazingly compelling and easy to use mainstream device that smashed its open competition with no mercy. This was about the same time we saw the rise of the cell phone in every pocket which was similarly closed and restricted. Around the same time we saw the release of the Playstation 2 which, again, is a closed and restricted platform that has gone on to be the best selling gaming console in history. 3 years later we see the release of the Nintendo DS -- one of the most successful mobile electronic devices in history. Closed & restricted.
Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by eru on Thursday April 08, 2010 @05:09AM (#1249463)
What about the original game boy? And numerous other devices.
Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by copenja on Thursday April 08, 2010 @04:13AM (#1249421)
Relax. Neither open or closed equals total domination.
Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by ja27 on Wednesday April 07, 2010 @09:08PM (#1248862)
What doesn't fit the "Jobs = closed platform" paradigm is NeXT. It came after the Mac, yet was a comparatively open platform.
Re:IPad is Steve Jobs’ final victory over Steve Wozniak by netcan on Thursday April 08, 2010 @02:14AM (#1249260)
I want both. People are getting anxious about the iphone/pad but overall, look at recent history. It's good to have several approaches gong at once. Linux/OSX/Windows is a good example. Go back in time and remove any of those from the game and you get a less good present.

I think Apple is largely less capable then MS of holding a problematic monopoly for long (at least with their current m.o.). That would require being every thing for every person to plug all potential competition holes. That comes with hairy compromises that Apple probably won't want to make.

So far, Apple hasn't done any net damage. They are getting things done and moving things along fast. It will take either a real slow down in their innovation or some serious damage to flip that balance.