News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by pas on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @12:40PM (#12444817)
Knowing a few friends and other acquaintances with PhDs, all they have common is endurance and focus. They were not exceptionally creative, or apparently breathtakingly genius.

And I guess that's why Google et al. likes to hire PhDs. They can take all kinds of shit, and endure. Get to the bottom of those problems even in the face of internal politics/bureaucracy.

Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by pmoriarty on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @01:32PM (#12445354)
"Godlike genius.. Godlike nothing! Sticking to it is the genius! I've failed my way to success."

  -- Thomas Edison
"Let me tell you the secret that has led me to my goal. My strength lives solely in my tenacity."

  -- Louis Pasteur
"Men give me credit for genius; but all the genius I have lies in this: When I have a subject on hand I study it profoundly."

  -- Alexander Hamilton
Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by balabaster on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @02:42PM (#12445907)
I can't believe that it's coincidence that every person I've ever come across that has been proclaimed a genius at whatever has had this very same sentiment to express.

There was a grain of talent and a moment of inspiration that led to a dogged pursuit of their interest.

People are quick to write it off as "oh, they had talent" or "oh they were a genius", but I'm reasonably confident given the number of amazing people I've met in this industry, everyone (well, everyone that's not an egotist) that's ever had this label attributed to them will attest: The talent comes from the countless hours of work, effort and frustration put into realizing that talent. It's only once we've overcome this effort and frustration and others think we make it look easy that they say "Oh, but you had talent"... sure, but I didn't have any to start with. Now after 10,000 hours of practice, of countless nights of going to bed frustrated that I couldn't understand something or make my fingers work right, of the number of times I played until my fingers and lips bled all in the pursuit of mastering whatever it is I'm trying to master. Only then does everyone see this talent. I don't see talent, all I see is the hard work to get where I am now and how far I still have left to go to consider myself part of the circle I still think are better or more accomplished than me. Any "talent" I may exhibit is the product of the pursuit of my interest.

My talent, my genius if you will is nothing more than this. I am not a genius. I am no more intelligent than has the capacity of any other that has the tenacity to stick with it through the basics and learn the fundamentals and go through the mental and physical pain that I have endured to get here.

Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by imgabe on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @05:00PM (#12447623)
Nobody ever mentions the counterexample, assuming it exists - the person who spends thousands of hours practicing but never gets anywhere. How many Salieris are there for each Mozart?

There's definitely a need for hard work in order to have success, but perhaps there's something necessary that has to be present for the hard work to build upon. Maybe that something is "genius".

Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by michaelcampbell on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @10:08PM (#12449697)
> How many Salieris are there for each Mozart?

And if Mozart hadn't been there, at that time; would we not be speaking of Salieri as the genius? Perhaps.

Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by mrcactu5 on Thursday September 08, 2016 @10:00AM (#12453056)
What about Lady Gaga? (Stefani Germanotta)

Article says she was part of this study.

Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by ZenoArrow on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @05:58PM (#12448216)
Hard work is overrated. What you really want is curiosity. You can refine something with hard work, but broadening your horizons comes from a desire to see what can be done. Basically, do you want to create a refined version of what's already been done, or do you want to explore what's possible. You can alternate between them to push in both directions, but the mindset is different.
Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by AStellersSeaCow on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @06:52PM (#12448681)
>Hard work is overrated. What you really want is curiosity.

This is BS, and the kind of BS that results in lazy entitled adults expecting the world to be their oyster because they have kept their dreamer curiosity intact.

Out of the people I've know who are internationally-recognized academics and/or world-class engineers, many are both hard working and creative. Probably the majority of them, in fact. But many more are hard working and not especially creative: they doggedly pursue single lines of inquiry or development, and possibilities for truly new ideas or techniques - not just refinements - are exposed through the intellectual equivalent of brute force.

I don't know any internationally-recognized academics or world-class engineers who are creative but not hard working.

Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by ZenoArrow on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @08:11PM (#12449153)
> "they doggedly pursue single lines of inquiry or development, and possibilities for truly new ideas or techniques"

This could easily be attributed to curiosity. Don't dismiss curiosity as something wishy-washy.

As I said before, the mindset between hardworking and curious is different. That's not to say pursuing curiosity takes no effort. I'll use a musician analogy to explain. A hardworking musician works hard to master their skill and knowledge with an instrument in order to maximise their abilities. A curious musician by contrast is guided by much broader principles, including a greater focus on sound rather than their personal skill. A playing mistake that produces an interesting result is not something to be eliminated by refinement, but instead is the opening of a new avenue of inquiry. It helps to be open to interesting mistakes, and this is not something that is easy to do when you're hyper focused on perfecting yourself.

In other words, spending energy is necessary to get a fuller understanding of something, but what motivates you does have an impact on the end result. Hard work is driven by ego, playful curiosity less so, but it doesn't mean less energy. Work and play are not the same thing, but what separates them is not the activity per se, but rather the mindset of the individual.

Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by balabaster on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @10:56PM (#12449939)
> Hard work is driven by ego

I have a sample size of one that says this is false. For me at least, hard work comes from one of a number of things, none of which are ego.

1. The desire to deliver what I set out to deliver by the deadline I promised. I made a promise and I was raised that a man is only as good as his word. So unless you have a compelling reason why delivery is not an option, you see it through.

2. The desire for the satisfaction of looking at something that will pay future dividends, like learning to grow my own food takes hard work now, but at the end of it, I have a garden full of "free" food. Edit: On reflection, this one may be the most likely candidate for being ego - the ability to stand back and say proudly "I did that"... I will concede, this is probably ego.

3. The desire to master something I haven't yet mastered that either satisfies my fascination or because understanding it will enhance or simplify my life in the future - like small engine repair. I could easily take it to a shop and have them do it, but I'd rather learn how to do it myself because down the road there may be no shop nearby or I may just have to make do and improvise. If I don't work hard and spend the time and effort to understand the fundamentals and principles that make it all work, I wouldn't stand a chance.

So hard work isn't always about ego. The hard work may be fueled by curiosity, or it may be fueled by necessity. Certainly curiosity makes the hard work seem more like play than work, but that doesn't make it any less work. It just means that you don't realize how much effort you're putting in and it really just feels like an amusing way of playing or wasting time, but it's still work.

Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by elcritch on Thursday September 08, 2016 @01:16AM (#12450456)
I notice your edit where you admit point 2 is likely ego. Point 1 is also particularly ego as in the sense of "self-image, as you use it explicitly to define an image of yourself that is distinct from others on a psychological level, as in "I am a man who makes good on promises". So two of your points are pretty ego based.

Now not saying that's a bad thing! I have learned the hard way that we all have egos and that guided properly it's actually a benefit, as it drives you to do valuable things both for yourself _and_ others, as is clear in all of your points.

Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by balabaster on Thursday September 08, 2016 @11:18AM (#12453806)
Point 1 I will agree is about reputation. But to conflict with your perspective, this is less about ego than about contribution to your community and self preservation. If you're not as good as your word, eventually nobody trusts you or wants to work with you... and if nobody trusts you or wants to work with you, then your chances of getting where you need to go are quickly decimated.
Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by ZenoArrow on Thursday September 08, 2016 @03:42AM (#12451029)
> ". Certainly curiosity makes the hard work seem more like play than work, but that doesn't make it any less work. It just means that you don't realize how much effort you're putting in and it really just feels like an amusing way of playing or wasting time, but it's still work."

This is at the core of why we're disagreeing.

I'll make this as clear as I can. I have no problem with putting a lot of energy into something (or in your words, I have no problem with effort).

The reason we disagree is because for you effort = work, and for me the two are distinct. For me the worker mindset is one potential driving force behind putting in effort, and curiosity is another potential driving force behind putting in effort (there are others too; fear, anger, etc...).

The key point I've been trying to make is not about effort at all, but rather the difference between work and play. Whilst I do not deny that work has its place (as you indicated, it can lead to self-reliance, which is a good thing in my opinion), what I do think is that it lets ego get in the way of making things better.

Going back to a music analogy, let's imagine someone is creating a song. During the creation of the song, they discover a new sound that by chance fits the song perfectly. If the person wants this sound in their new song, they can either sample the existing sound, or learn how to create it from scratch. For someone with a 'hard work' mentality, the sampling option seems like cheating, in the sense of cheating yourself out of creating the song. However, if you're driven by curiosity/playfulness, your involvement in the creation of the song is of less importance, what matters more is the pleasure that comes from listening, and as the sound is identical to the one you wanted to hear there's no cheating of the listener.

Here's another analogy, the hacker vs. the academic. It's possible to become skilled with technology using either approach, but they are different approaches. The hacker lets curiosity guide their learning. The academic lets refinement of existing knowledge guide their learning. The academic appreciates best practices, the hacker looks for whatever works. You could make arguments both for and against both approaches, but IMO the hacker is more likely to be driven to explore, and enjoy doing so.

Hope I've clarified that my points have been about 'work vs. play' instead of 'effort vs. no effort'.

Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by AStellersSeaCow on Friday September 09, 2016 @12:58PM (#12464019)
You seem to be mixing and matching hardworking vs. curious, incremental improvement vs. innovation, and results-oriented vs. process-oriented, all of which are completely different topics.

Saying hard work is ego driven while curiosity has some more noble, ineffable motivation is the exact same sort of BS I was decrying before. Hard work can just as well be driven by a sense of responsibility, a desire for more predictable outcomes, or faith, while curiosity/playfulness can be an ego-saving measure to offset mediocrity that the person can't or won't work past. Neither is more morally right, imo.

But to meander back to the core of the discussion, I don't think it's possible to become notably good at anything without at least some motivation towards self-improvement and foundational skills. People who ride playfulness and curiosity into lasting renown are able to do so because they have some degree of mastery of the fundamentals. Some people manage to earn lasting renown without much curiosity or playfulness, just a single-minded drive towards mastering known techniques.

Few to no people have ever earned lasting renown by noodling around in a field they had zero grounding in until they randomly struck gold. Some have earned infamy with that approach, but that's a different topic.

Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by balabaster on Monday September 12, 2016 @11:47AM (#12480698)
> Some have earned infamy with that approach, but that's a different topic.

Anyone notable? I'd be interested to read about those... and if the striking of gold was truly random or if it was something else.

Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by AStellersSeaCow on Wednesday September 14, 2016 @02:52PM (#12500102)
Mostly thinking the "so noxiously but unusually bad it's briefly popular" type of creative output by people clearly lacking in much grounding or practice in their fields. 'Singers' like William Hung, 'writers' like Gene Ray, 'filmmakers' like Tommy Wiseau, or 'actors' like Robert Coates.
Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by OneSprings2Mind on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @08:06PM (#12449122)
Stanislaw Ulam, Louis de Broglie
Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by hinkley on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @09:05PM (#12449431)
I think it's two sides of a coin here. When someone asks me how I fixed some obscure bug or crazy performance issue, I will say something like 'I was the last one to give up on it'.

You could also say that many other people looked at the same thing and either didn't give a shit, or they weren't willing to continue suffering toward the payoff at some point.

Is that tenacity? Curiosity? Some of each?

Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by balabaster on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @09:42PM (#12449575)
Usually this is a combination of thousands of hours learning to understand how things work and how they break under certain circumstances. Once you get to a certain point, your ability to make the mental leap from the symptom to the cause can just be a feeling in your gut that seems to lead you uncannily to the right place, but you discount what it took to get you there. Is it tenacity that mean you were the last one to give up on it or is that just stubbornness because "fuck this shit, I'm not going to be beaten by a fucking computer!" <- That's me.
Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by _0ffh on Thursday September 08, 2016 @06:13AM (#12451676)
While curiosity might be what causes you to work hard, it's still the work itself that produces the results. Although if you're lucky it might not feel very much like work! :)
Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by balabaster on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @09:35PM (#12449551)
That something usually less genius and more a grain of inspiration followed by a love of the process, followed by a ton of hard work to get to a point that the instrument is an extension of the musician's soul.

I will concede that this may not always be the case. Of course, there are a thousand Salieris for every Mozart. But when you set out, you don't set out to become Salieri. When you play in an orchestra, you don't spend your life striving to play second fiddle and you certainly don't just get to sit down in the principal violin spot because you're a genius. You work for it, just like the guy who earned his right to be on that podium leading the orchestra.

For everything that's wrong with the movie Whiplash, there is a lot of nuance that it captures really well regarding the personalities in orchestras and what it really takes to get to the top of your game.

Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by Joof on Thursday September 08, 2016 @02:12AM (#12450662)
Not surprising. A lot of us probably qualify or come very close and the deciding factor is how much effort we expend to get there.

Meanwhile, I've got friends that live on welfare and legitimately couldn't understand neural networks (or even algebra) if they spent their whole lives dedicated to it. They are still excellent people, but perhaps mathematics isn't their best subject.

The guy I have in mind is an incredible impressionist and comedian, I wish he had more confidence in his talents.

Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by balabaster on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @10:22PM (#12449771)
also, I've yet to see anyone spending thousands of hours on productive practice and not get anywhere. Conversely, you can spend thousands of hours practicing a shitty golf swing and you're not going to get anywhere but an over-practiced shitty golf swing. Without correction and enforcing good technique and good habits at every practice, you're not going to get anywhere fast if at all.

Music is a bit of a poor example for application to "genius" actually because just like a golf swing much of it is in the practice of your gross and fine motor skills and good technique, which as we all know, if you don't rigorously practice good habits, you may as well not bother practicing at all because you're actively going in the wrong direction.

Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by ThePawnBreak on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @04:07PM (#12447044)
There is always a bell curve. It's more obvious in fields where people start practicing from a tender age, like chess or music, where you start learning when you're around 4. There are many who dedicate their lives to such pursuits, but very few become Kasparov or Mozart. The others still become extremely good, but not the best, and most are forgotten by history.
Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by balabaster on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @10:28PM (#12449797)
But to be honest, you don't need to be Mozart to be considered a musical genius today... There are a dozen orchestral genii alive today that could easily outstrip the genius of Mozart when you compare the body of their orchestral work. Yet when these composers are dead and gone, 30, 40, 50 years from now, everyone will still be talking about Mozart, and todays better-than-Mozarts will be lost to the sands of time. It's quite sad how biased our filters are really.
Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by seizethecheese on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @02:55PM (#12446018)
Perhaps true geniuses know the social value of humility.
Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by balabaster on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @03:00PM (#12446073)
...or perhaps they're totally unaware of the existence of genius. Perhaps if they realized what they were attempting required genius they'd never have attempted it in the first place for fear that they didn't have the genius necessary to succeed.
Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by AStellersSeaCow on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @07:01PM (#12448754)
Haha, no way. I've worked with or met a half dozen MacArthur fellows, and none of them were shy about bringing up that fact. You could argue that MacArthur selects for self-promoting geniuses, but such creatures clearly do exist.
Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by seizethecheese on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @08:45PM (#12449331)
Exception that proves the rule.

How do you know if someone you met went to Harvard? They already told you.

Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by balabaster on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @09:07PM (#12449439)
This I've found over the years is more a product of insecurity than of ego or genius. People quick to tout their alumnus or IQ... or indeed any other measure of intelligence in such a manner are looking for validation and acceptance of their superiority because it satisfies their insecurity.

Though, I would have given my right arm to go to MIT earlier in my life, just for access to MITs professors, forget the degree.

Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by sovietmudkipz on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @04:13PM (#12447112)
> True geniuses know the social value of humility.

Wouldn't you have to be a genius to be able to make such an evaluation?

Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by Retra on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @07:52PM (#12449034)
That's not an evaluation, it's just a statement. Some genius could have just told them that.
Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by ARothfusz on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @04:01PM (#12446974)
Genius does not emerge solely from tenacity. Genius comes from figuring out new things to try in pursuit of a goal over a long period of time.

If you tried something and failed, how many permutations could you go through before you ran out of ideas of what to try? Could you do it for _years_? Could you keep trying, learning from your mistakes for a lifetime, until you reached your goal? Maybe you're a genius then.

Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by balabaster on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @04:09PM (#12447069)
Why not? Anyone could if the pursuit was worth it to them.

All it takes is being able to look at things and wonder "how could I apply this along with what I already know to achieve that goal?" Eventually you'll have some permutation of ideas that work. Even if you put it down and come back to it many years later. Maybe the goal isn't obvious until one day all the ideas come together to solve a problem that you need solved right now that yesterday you'd never even had cause to think about. That doesn't negate the work you did learning those things.

"Everyone is a genius, but if you judge a fish by its ability to climb a tree, it will live its whole life thinking it's stupid." - Einstein

Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by AIMunchkin on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @05:03PM (#12447656)
My favorite Edison quote:

"Opportunity is missed by most people because it is dressed in overalls and looks like work."

Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by KaneMorgan on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @03:27PM (#12446489)
Saying I worked hard is a more comforting story than saying I was lucky. I think people are likely to put more value on hard work than its due.
Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by civilian on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @05:23PM (#12447849)
I think that what successful people tell themselves is not that important of an issue. What's important is the narrative we give people who are not yet successful.

I have a friend who's smart, and is a really good listener. We have really good philosophical conversations, and he kicks my ass at board games. I've been wanting him to get into programming, because right now he's working as an assistant manager at a sandwich shop chain. He absolutely has the talent to understand programming, but he has never put an ounce of effort into it. He really likes the idea of making 50k/yr (which would essentially be a doubling of his salary) so he could be less depressed about finances.

I offer him help... I tell him how I self-trained into programming, without a C.S. degree. And he just has a total lack of effort, and I think that he just tells himself that he can't do it.

When we establish the narrative that the only barrier is hard work, then we ought to be able to motivate people because they'll recognize that most things are within their reach with enough determination.

Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by beachstartup on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @08:23PM (#12449221)
i have friends like this.

trust me, you're not going to convince him.

he's probably going to just do nothing, for a long time, and tell you how lucky you are every time you visit.

Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by pmoriarty on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @09:03PM (#12449420)
I have two counter-examples for you. I had two friends like this. I convinced them to learn programming while they were working menial jobs. Both of them did, and went on to have successful careers in the tech field.

I have a story of failure too. Two other frends expressed interest in learning to program, and I tried to teach them C while I was learning it myself. Big mistake. They quit after the first very intense and long lesson. I think I threw them in to the deep end of the pool, trying to teach them C as their first exposure to programming (when I myself didn't even know C and was learning along with them).

In the successful cases first mentioned above, both of my friends taught themselves languages they were interested in, at their own pace, and in their spare time (what little there was of it). They were also clearly very motivated, which my other two friends may not have been.

Moral of the story: I think it all depends on the student, the teacher, what they're trying to learn, how they're learning, how they're taught, and how motivated they are. You can't just generalize and say it'll work for everyone or not work for everyone.

The successes make me cautiously optimistic and I will personally try to help people again, if given the chance, despite there being no guarantee that it will work. In fact, I'd still try to help even every one of my previous attempts had failed.

Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by civilian on Thursday September 08, 2016 @01:38PM (#12455189)
Awesome to hear! So are you like, 2 for 4 as a mentor? That's much better than my 1 for 5. I have another teaching-inclined buddy who is 0 for 10.

I have remained optimistic, but yeah.. I do my best just to casually mention it to everyone that it's possible to get into, and that I'm always available as a resource.

Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by beachstartup on Thursday September 08, 2016 @01:07PM (#12454869)
OP was talking about repeated attempts to help the same person.
Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by eutectic on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @07:26PM (#12448891)
So we should be willing to lie if it makes a better story?
Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by chillwaves on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @08:08PM (#12449138)
I'm not sure how you got that idea from the post you are responding to.
Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by civilian on Thursday September 08, 2016 @01:36PM (#12455168)
I kind of understand how he got that. I do genuinely believe that hard work is the key to everything (although you do often need a little intelligence), but the way I talked was about what story would best help motivate people. It just helps that the two things match up.

I mean, imagine a world where I talked to my friend and was just like: "oh yeah. You're not smart enough. You never finished any bachelor degree. And I guess you could get into it anyway if you have been born into the upper class, but you weren't. There's no reason to try for anything better, you'll just fail." I'd be a pretty bad friend by modern standards.

Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by replicatorblog on Friday September 09, 2016 @02:27PM (#12464824)
"Nothing in this world can take the place of persistence. Talent will not: nothing is more common than unsuccessful men with talent. Genius will not; unrewarded genius is almost a proverb. Education will not: the world is full of educated derelicts. Persistence and determination alone are omnipotent."—Calvin Coolidge
Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by forgotmysn on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @01:41PM (#12445423)
Sounds like an epic humblebrag by Hamilton. I don't think anyone, then or now, thinks he was a genius.
Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by omginternets on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @02:13PM (#12445670)
I don't think he's using genius to mean "a genius". I think it's instead meant as a term for "a bright idea". i.e.: "to have genius" vs "to be a genius".
Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by pjmorris on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @03:27PM (#12446487)
I am curious about how you come by your view. Have a look at this defense [0] of Hamilton on the $10. I can see from it how many could see him as a genius.

[0] http://www.financialsense.com/contributors/michael-pettis/pl...

Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by cfmcdonald on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @02:34PM (#12445838)
He is saying he has been credited with genius, that is intellectual power or talent, not that he has been credited with being "a genius". The former is now an archaic way of using genius, the latter was pretty new in Hamilton's time.
Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by habitue on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @02:35PM (#12445843)
Alexander Hamilton was definitely super smart. Read his biography, it's nuts how young he was while he was writing treatises that shaped world events
Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by karma_vaccum123 on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @04:15PM (#12447137)
Right...many people seem to confuse genius with being really smart.
Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by wrp on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @01:21PM (#12445252)
I know a Chemistry professor whose favorite remark on this is, "A PhD is a badge of endurance, not intelligence."
Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by TheSpiceIsLife on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @02:51PM (#12445987)
PhD stands for Piled Higher & Deeper. Is a path of learning more and more about less and less.

(of course that isn't necessarily true, but I find it amusing)

Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by Coincoin on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @03:49PM (#12446814)
> Is a path of learning more and more about less and less

...until you know absolutely everything about absolutely nothing.

Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by euyyn on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @09:07PM (#12449442)
Then you become Dirac's delta.
Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by Moshe_Silnorin on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @01:49PM (#12445478)
>A PhD is a badge of endurance, not intelligence

It's very clearly both.

Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by gmarx on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @06:46PM (#12448621)
What those who contradict you above fail to appreciate is just how little IQ difference makes someone seem "dumb". Most people with 140 IQs rarely spend any time having discussion of any depth with anyone who has an IQ below 120. They have not the slightest idea how dense someone with an IQ of 100 seems. When I was training as a physician I routinely needed to explain important things in depth to people with average and below average intelligence. It is shocking. Most of us live in a narrow world and make poor assumptions about life outside
Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by jack9 on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @06:00PM (#12448243)
It is not. The purpose of a PHD is to advance the sphere of human knowledge as it applies to a subset of existing data in a unique way. Getting the PHD by proving something empirically is the point of a PHD. This does not require a great deal of intelligence. Not enough to warrant more than a participation badge, anyway. e.g. Computer Science, where there's tons of data and few people have done the grunt work of organizing it for a statistician.
Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by B1FF_PSUVM on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @02:18PM (#12445706)
Nah, I forgot which top flight physicist (Nobel, I think) wrote in a book that he had explained to his mother that there were indeed very dumb PhDs, thanks to mere "sitzfleisch".

Most anyone in the business knows cases.

Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by Panoramix on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @04:31PM (#12447322)
Smarter than average, for sure. But people tend to over estimate the intelligence of the average PhD.
Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by cubano on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @01:49PM (#12445479)
Almost all of the education system is about signalling your abilty to be told what to do and doing it, and not hardly at all about actually learning things necessary for a successful and productive life.
Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by TheSpiceIsLife on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @02:47PM (#12445953)
Although... Being able to do what your told is fairly necessary for a productive life.

Don't do drugs, brush your teeth, get a good education, exercise regularly, shower regularly, spend less than you make, eat healthy. Do as your told.

Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by tonyedgecombe on Thursday September 08, 2016 @10:51AM (#12453523)
Don't study CS, Law is where the money is, don't start a business, it will probably fail, don't date that girl, her parents are bumpkins. Do as your told.
Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by jimmaswell on Friday September 09, 2016 @10:22PM (#12467341)
The vast majority of the time, you shouldn't start a tech startup.
Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by collyw on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @12:48PM (#12444928)
I have been working at academic institutes the last few years, where maybe a third of the staff are PhD students. The ones that have gone on to more senior positions are like you describe, but I wouldn't say its the majority. A fair few of them decide to quit science after the PhD.
Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by irrational on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @01:09PM (#12445147)
This reminds me of the old joke that PhD stands for "Pile it on Higher and Deeper".
Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by wrp on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @01:22PM (#12445269)
It goes B.S. => More of Same => Piled Higher and Deeper.
Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by kohanz on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @01:23PM (#12445281)
BS = Bulls---

MS = More s---

PhD = Piled higher and Deeper

Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by mordae on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @02:02PM (#12445585)
I prefer this one: http://matt.might.net/articles/phd-school-in-pictures/

OTOH, I bear neither.

Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by sharemywin on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @02:27PM (#12445781)
My favorite was D stand for Diploma...
Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by clueless123 on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @05:34PM (#12447948)
When you think you know everything you get your BS

When you find out you know nothing, you get your Masters

When you realize no one else knows either you get your PHD

Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by vacri on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @11:47PM (#12450177)
I'll support this with my experience. A PhD means you can do peer-reviewable original research. This means that you can't be too dumb, yes, but mostly that you have the elbow-grease to see it through. Maintaining motivation and stick-to-it-iveness are the most important qualities for doing a PhD.

Disclaimer: dropped out of a PhD program due to lack of interest and elbow-grease.

Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by rsp1984 on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @04:52PM (#12447557)
Really? As a PhD what you do is explore a -- best case: niche, usually: theoretical and worst case: completely made up -- problem thoroughly in absence of workplace realities like deadlines, office politics and backstabbery, and try to come up with a solution that's better in at least some sense than what's been written before, then write a big piece of documentation about it whose total number of individual readers in most cases won't reach double digits.

This does not prepare you well for most workplaces, except for maybe Google, who have enough resources to create an alternate reality for their engineers so they don't have to grow up.

Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by ci5er on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @08:26PM (#12449234)
> in absence of workplace realities like deadlines, office politics and backstabbery

Really? I did not find that to be the case. I don't mind deadlines, but watching the day-to-day life of academics doing academia with their peers is what caused me to drop out of a PhD program and go finish my research project on my own. After seeing it in action, I wanted no part of being one of them for the rest of my career. I expect that I could have been at a rarely political university system, but after some medium-ish number of conferences (i.e. more than two dozen), I doubt that it was much worse than average. I found the whole thing quite "icky". In fact, I found it worse than any commercial environment I've been in (although I've been told I've been lucky in my experiences for failing to find it to such a degree in commercial environments).

Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by pbhjpbhj on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @05:11PM (#12447738)
Not a Ph.D but reports from (UK) doctorate holders suggest there's sometimes a lot of backstabbery, often deadlines (funding), very often lab/department politics.
Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by jsprogrammer on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @12:45PM (#12444889)
A PhD doesn't show that you get to the bottom of problems, but rather that you can influence, and be influenced by, group-think.

Edit:

Looks like it is still a while before my speech ban is up, so I'm pasting my response to kevingwang's response (below) here:

>To a particular degree, anyway. Convincing a University, or being published in peer-journal, for example.

>I think some are more or less ignored, though I guess I can't say that has no influence whatsoever and I'm also not sure that you can entirely avoid the influence of others.

Re:Lessons from a 45-year Study of Super-Smart Children by kevinwang on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @01:29PM (#12445336)
So, the same as every other human being?