News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:For a Long Life, Retire in Manhattan by jkot on Monday September 05, 2016 @04:05PM (#12431990)
I think most people would have very short retirement in Manhattan. They would run out of savings.
Re:For a Long Life, Retire in Manhattan by smacktoward on Monday September 05, 2016 @04:49PM (#12432173)
You're looking down this telescope from the wrong end. It's not that living in Manhattan itself somehow extends your life, it's that only very wealthy people can afford to live in Manhattan -- especially in retirement, when most people are living on a fixed income. And in American society, having great wealth means you also have access to things like high-quality food, great medical care, assistive technologies, all of which are things that really can extend your life.

So if Manhattan suddenly became affordable and hordes of ordinary retirees moved in there, you wouldn't see all those ordinary retirees suddenly start living longer, you'd see the average life expectancy for retired Manhattanites drop as the crappy food and medical care the proles get drag the numbers down.

Re:For a Long Life, Retire in Manhattan by msandford on Monday September 05, 2016 @05:13PM (#12432269)
Article might as well be titled "to live long, be rich"

How they managed to completely overlook the "hidden" confounding of being very wealthy and retiring in Manhattan is rather impressive.

Re:For a Long Life, Retire in Manhattan by Chinjut on Monday September 05, 2016 @05:41PM (#12432363)
The article isn't making any claims about retiring to Manhattan causing increased lifespan. It isn't even intended as a scientific article at all. I suspect many here only read the headline? It's one man's personal essay on their decision to retire to Manhattan and their enjoyment of it.

[Tl;dr: The use of "long life" in the title (probably not even chosen by the author) is figurative, not literal.]

Re:For a Long Life, Retire in Manhattan by dwaltrip on Tuesday September 06, 2016 @12:02AM (#12433589)
It's a lifestyle piece, not a societal analysis.
Re:For a Long Life, Retire in Manhattan by donretag on Monday September 05, 2016 @05:47PM (#12432394)
You are forgetting the hundreds of thousands that have a rent controlled/stabilized apartment.
Re:For a Long Life, Retire in Manhattan by otoburb on Monday September 05, 2016 @09:40PM (#12433178)
I thought that "hundreds of thousands" living in a rent controlled or stabilized apartment in Manhattan was too high, but came away surprised.

From a 2015 article only a tiny percentage of units are rent-controlled, but around 47% of rental units on the market are rent-stabilized.[1] The problem is that the statistics refer to the entire city (all five boroughs), and may not necessarily be specific to Manhattan itself.

EDIT: Found a Furman Center report from 2011 on rent-regulated units[2]. The key table is on page 2 broken down by borough, where Manhattan rent-regulated units account for 48% of the total rental units. The same table shows a breakdown by neighborhood too.

[1] http://citylimits.org/2015/03/09/nycs-endangered-species-a-r...

[2] http://furmancenter.org/files/publications/HVS_Rent_Stabiliz...

Re:For a Long Life, Retire in Manhattan by yodsanklai on Monday September 05, 2016 @04:24PM (#12432050)
Actually, I've always wondered how they manage to pay their bills. Of course, there are tons of super wealthy people in Manhattan, but there are also many elderlies that don't look particularly well-off. I suspect they've owned their apartment for a long time, or that they pay little rent. Maybe they receive social benefits from the city...
Re:For a Long Life, Retire in Manhattan by sotojuan on Monday September 05, 2016 @05:45PM (#12432378)
As imgabe said, a lot of older families (both in age and amount of time living in Manhattan), at least in the Upper West Side, have rent control, are in low income housing, or something similar.

If you ever walk around the Upper West Side, farther away from the park, you'll see a ton big, tall apartment complexes. Huge ones with hundreds of families, if not more. I doubt everyone there makes the mid or high $100ks it takes to rent an apartment there now as a new resident.

Re:For a Long Life, Retire in Manhattan by yodsanklai on Monday September 05, 2016 @06:25PM (#12432555)
Actually, a friend of mine lives in such a building. His building is in very poor condition (various problems such as bed bugs infestation, defective heater...). Most tenants there prefer to keep a low profile and don't complain to the landlord. The rent is not controlled, but pretty low ($600 for a small crappy room with shared bathroom).

It seems most tenants are middle-aged hispanics. No retired people there.

Re:For a Long Life, Retire in Manhattan by sotojuan on Monday September 05, 2016 @06:28PM (#12432569)
Ah interesting. Yeah, they never looked like nice buildings to me. I always wondered who lived there.
Re:For a Long Life, Retire in Manhattan by awareBrah on Monday September 05, 2016 @08:50PM (#12433046)
Can someone explain to me, why this exists. How come, as a new resident I need to pay 3x the amount of rent compared to someone who has been there for a while. As a landlord wouldn't I be mad that the going rate is much higher? Can someone explain to me as I've never understood how come this happens or why it is the default. Why not just have free market? Forgive if it's obvious, I would love a lay-mans explanation
Re:For a Long Life, Retire in Manhattan by yolesaber on Monday September 05, 2016 @10:22PM (#12433296)
Rent controls, such as those built in to the amount which a landlord can raise the rent per annum, are often specific to the tenant and their lease. Thus when the tenants die or are able to get booted off the lease / kicked out of the apartment (NYC has very pro-tenant housing laws), the apartments go for the market rate and the cycle begins anew.
Re:For a Long Life, Retire in Manhattan by rincebrain on Monday September 05, 2016 @09:25PM (#12433144)
Rent control, as it exists in NYC, is a damper on how fast rent can rise (both when you're in a lease, and during vacancies of a property between tenants), for people and properties whose income/rent are below certain thresholds where the government considers them to be either paying for or capable of paying for luxury apartments.

Rent control lets you have some reasonable expectation that you can plan expenses for more than a single lease term, as well as attempting to limit how much damage to the economics of the surrounding area real estate prices are going to do (it's a commodity that is hard to increase the supply of in any great quantity, and demand far outstrips supply...this probably would eventually stabilize, but it'd be quite messy in between, and probably not in a net positive way for the city).

Absent rent control, the lower bound of prices would go up, the ceiling would not go down.

Re:For a Long Life, Retire in Manhattan by hueving on Tuesday September 06, 2016 @02:36AM (#12433993)
>Absent rent control, the lower bound of prices would go up, the ceiling would not go down.

Pretty vapid statement. The ceiling is whatever the arbitrary asking price is for something overlooking central park on the 100th floor of some high rise. Nobody cares about the ceiling.

The question is what does it do to the market price in general for a specific size apartment. It will cause a price decline because so many more apartments will actually be on the market. The current price is where supply is meeting demand so if you increase the supply the price will decline.

Of course it will screw up the people on rent control since they likely won't be able to afford it.

Re:For a Long Life, Retire in Manhattan by sodpaw on Tuesday September 06, 2016 @12:17PM (#12437077)
The main reason rent controls exist is so that families are not priced out of their homes. Most low-income families are renters, so without rent control they could see their home of the past few decades become unaffordable. Especially in areas like NYC where the value of land can skyrocket, these long-term residents can easily become the “unfortunate” side effect of all this exciting economic activity. So yes, the landlord would definitely like to be able to sell their units for a higher rate if they could. Without legal protections low-income families can easily lose their homes due to market forces.

Many economists (and intro econ textbooks where this is a very popular example) find that rent controls are destructive and a distortionary influence on the housing market, and you’ve already identified one of the downsides in the increased difficulty for new residents to find a dwelling where rent control exist. However, this approach ignores the human and economic impact of home instability. Joshua Mason, an econ professor at Roosevelt University who studies the effects of rent control, puts it pretty well. "Long-term tenants who contributed to this being a desirable place to live have a legitimate interest in staying in their apartments. If we think that income diverse, stable neighborhoods, where people are not forced to move every few years, [are worth preserving] then we collectively have an interest in stabilizing the neighborhood.”[0]

[0]https://psmag.com/in-defense-of-rent-control-3cb453119116#.k...

Re:For a Long Life, Retire in Manhattan by tacostakohashi on Monday September 05, 2016 @09:07PM (#12433101)
Because politics.

Yes, the landlord will be mad, but for every one of them there are dozens of happy tenants.

The tenants getting a preferential rate will live there and vote/lobby to protect the system for generations. The new guy paying 3x probably came from elsewhere, and will return there shortly.

Re:For a Long Life, Retire in Manhattan by 35bge57dtjku on Tuesday September 06, 2016 @12:30AM (#12433665)
You can just have free market, but then you get tons of renters who complain about both the high rents and any higher capacity buildings being built nearby, as if there's some simple way to prevent new buildings and to keep rent from going up at the same time.
Re:For a Long Life, Retire in Manhattan by hueving on Tuesday September 06, 2016 @02:27AM (#12433967)
Renters don't complain about new housing supply. That's owners who think it will impact their property value.
Re:For a Long Life, Retire in Manhattan by 35bge57dtjku on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @06:16AM (#12442062)
They definitely complain when the new housing supply is a new apartment building next door that ruins their view!
Re:For a Long Life, Retire in Manhattan by Spooky23 on Monday September 05, 2016 @09:42PM (#12433187)
Rent control. My great aunt paid something like $180/month for her apartment when she died in 2003. She had lived there since circa 1940 and raised 6 kids in it!

The key is to have a support network so that you can remain in your home. Nursing homes and homecare in NYC are a horror show for a variety of reasons.

Re:For a Long Life, Retire in Manhattan by imgabe on Monday September 05, 2016 @04:27PM (#12432075)
Rent control is probably a big part of it.
Re:For a Long Life, Retire in Manhattan by sndean on Monday September 05, 2016 @04:36PM (#12432108)
Or, I wonder, could their running out of money keep them working (in some small capacity, part-time, etc.)?

And if they keep working in some small way, does that allow them to avoid the rapid decline in life expectancy that normally follows retirement? http://www.webmd.com/healthy-aging/news/20051020/early-retir...

Re:For a Long Life, Retire in Manhattan by pavlov on Monday September 05, 2016 @04:20PM (#12432035)
Also, fitting most people on a small island is difficult.