News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:PC-BSD Evolves into TrueOS by karma_vaccum123 on Thursday September 01, 2016 @06:57PM (#12409474)
Hire a designer to make Lumina less ugly. Sorry I know that sounds harsh, but it looks very 2005.

Make this install on modern laptops. I'm tired of being recommended five year-old Thinkpads.

Fix those and I would consider overwriting my Ubuntu installation

Re:PC-BSD Evolves into TrueOS by cm3 on Thursday September 01, 2016 @07:17PM (#12409553)
> Hire a designer to make Lumina less ugly. Sorry I know that sounds harsh, but it looks very 2005.

I'm not trying to sound harsh and just have to respectfully disagree.

I don't use Lumina because I don't use DEs, but the looks of it are just right. It's not a regression like most "styles" these days where it's impossible to know half the time what's an interactive widget, or why suddenly the designers think large empty white spaces and large widgets and titlebars are a feature. If I'm at a desktop, I need a desktop environment, not a tablet experience.

Re:PC-BSD Evolves into TrueOS by Osmium on Friday September 02, 2016 @02:00AM (#12411162)
> I don't use Lumina because I don't use DEs [...]

In fairness, that probably means your preferences will be very different from those people who actually do use desktop environments.

I also think a lot of people (myself included) have a certain nostalgia for older, leaner desktop environments. That doesn't mean they can't be designed better, with more polish, using those same older design cues.

Re:PC-BSD Evolves into TrueOS by wruza on Friday September 02, 2016 @03:25AM (#12411478)
I failed to see how control panel was any better in each 95/xp/7/10, except that my enemies can't find anything in it just like me. I also fail to see how w7 explorer became more 'convenient' without up button (and changing backspace key to back) but with annoying Libraries that are not even folders. Or removal of quick launch, so that icons on our taskbars now float and you search for a button to start that app.

What you call polishing is just breaking familiar old-simple and building new-super-innovated-final-solution each year. Leave us power users alone, you hipsters!

Re:PC-BSD Evolves into TrueOS by creshal on Friday September 02, 2016 @04:45AM (#12411768)
> What you call polishing is just breaking familiar old-simple and building new-super-innovated-final-solution each year. Leave us power users alone, you hipsters!

I wish it was only confusing to power users. If it was actually intuitive to end users, it would have a justification. But no. I've yet to see a single user who can wrap their head around Windows 7's virtual libraries and why they're sometimes not acting like a real folder but most of the time do.

Re:PC-BSD Evolves into TrueOS by fnj on Friday September 02, 2016 @06:01AM (#12411971)
Well, I do use a DE (MATE), and I think the appearance of Lumina DE is just fine. What kind of "polish" do you find missing?
Re:PC-BSD Evolves into TrueOS by Gracana on Thursday September 01, 2016 @07:50PM (#12409703)
I don't want it to look like modern stuff, but it could use some tweaking and usability consistency improvements here and there. It's the whole 'papercuts' thing, nothing terrible, just a bunch of small issues (font sizes, click target issues, etc.)
Re:PC-BSD Evolves into TrueOS by cm3 on Thursday September 01, 2016 @08:08PM (#12409797)
Polish is probably what you're missing then.
Re:PC-BSD Evolves into TrueOS by buu700 on Thursday September 01, 2016 @08:54PM (#12410001)
My first language is English, and from the screenshots in the TrueOS handbook I'd also agree that it looks a little dated (although not particularly more so than most other open source desktop environments).
Re:PC-BSD Evolves into TrueOS by asveikau on Thursday September 01, 2016 @08:57PM (#12410017)
>> Polish is probably what you're missing then.

> My first language is English,

Did you just mix up polish, as in "polished ui", with Polish, the language of Poland?

Re:PC-BSD Evolves into TrueOS by type0 on Friday September 02, 2016 @07:25AM (#12412253)
Also, we all need to be using polish notation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polish_notation for better good
Re:PC-BSD Evolves into TrueOS by buu700 on Thursday September 01, 2016 @09:39PM (#12410199)
Yes.
Re:PC-BSD Evolves into TrueOS by mrSugar on Friday September 02, 2016 @02:41AM (#12411314)
Hopefully he doesn't also think that a totem pole is a guy from Poland who looks after a totem. :-)
Re:PC-BSD Evolves into TrueOS by DashRattlesnake on Thursday September 01, 2016 @07:16PM (#12409549)
> it looks very 2005

I have literally no knowledge or opinion about Limina, but kinda with desktop UIs would attempt to be timeless rather than trying to follow the latest style fads.

Re:PC-BSD Evolves into TrueOS by walrus01 on Thursday September 01, 2016 @09:52PM (#12410256)
> it looks very 2005

I want things to look very 2005 (or even 2001), which is why I use XFCE4 as a desktop environment on xorg / debian, and not a modern "fancy" thing like the latest gnome or KDE.

Re:PC-BSD Evolves into TrueOS by gnarbarian on Friday September 02, 2016 @04:54AM (#12411789)
Cheers! I liked gnome 2, I can't stand unity, gnome 3 or the latest KDE. LXDE was too minimalist. XFCE was just right.
Re:PC-BSD Evolves into TrueOS by wruza on Friday September 02, 2016 @09:31AM (#12412880)
Xfce was just perfect. Sadly, xfce 4.6 unintroduced manual context-menu in favor of autogenerated one (from cryptic sources). It also introduced many good, but menu changes broke my workflow. I was so disappointed that I left entire Linux/FreeBSD after years of using it. Now I have mac, and it is just great for years.
Re:PC-BSD Evolves into TrueOS by fnj on Friday September 02, 2016 @06:03AM (#12411979)
I liked GNOME2 also, and I found MATE to be the perfect recreation of it.
Re:PC-BSD Evolves into TrueOS by rtpg on Friday September 02, 2016 @05:02AM (#12411815)
I guess the question is whether this thing that follows 2005's style is timeless... I suppose from the reaction of people that it doesn't?

Though the only interface that I can qualify as timeless is maybe the PS2/3/4 interface XMB (10+ years and still basically the same).

Re:PC-BSD Evolves into TrueOS by GFK_of_xmaspast on Thursday September 01, 2016 @07:52PM (#12409712)
> timeless

What does that even mean in this context.

Re:PC-BSD Evolves into TrueOS by sedachv on Thursday September 01, 2016 @08:18PM (#12409837)
Re:PC-BSD Evolves into TrueOS by cwyers on Friday September 02, 2016 @01:25AM (#12411030)
That's not timeless, that's very very timed.
Re:PC-BSD Evolves into TrueOS by IncRnd on Thursday September 01, 2016 @10:26PM (#12410401)
As a registered NS developer, I had a NS Turbo Color. What about NS do you find superior to OS X?
Re:PC-BSD Evolves into TrueOS by protomyth on Thursday September 01, 2016 @10:52PM (#12410490)
Not OP but also a NS developer (custom built Pentium), and I must say like the menu system, digital librarian, workspace manager, and eof much better. A separate interface builder was much better, but that's more a developer tool thing.

[edit: left side scroll bar also]

Re:PC-BSD Evolves into TrueOS by IncRnd on Thursday September 01, 2016 @11:06PM (#12410545)
For sure I liked the separate IB/PB. Good call! It was faster to develop in NS than in anything else for me.

At the time, I loved the digital librarian and menu system. After leaving and going back a few years later the WS seemed a little too dated for me. I use the context menus in BlackBox on my linux box. OS X seems to be my comfort zone now, which tends to color memory. Though I also found the IB/PB split much faster to work with. That's for sure.

You've got me fired up. I'm installing 4.2 ent in virtualbox now, which will be the newest version I've used :) Thank you!

Re:PC-BSD Evolves into TrueOS by protomyth on Friday September 02, 2016 @11:24AM (#12413636)
I still have my 3.3 discs and the 4.x discs with the wall of documentation. I'm tempted to install it again, if for nothing else to get at some very old e-mail I sent.

I think some of the "dated" is that it wasn't very high resolution, or put another way, it really didn't get to evolve into the high resolution / anti-aliased world we live in today. I've seen multiple attempts at redoing the icons in a modern setting and many of them look great. I particularly like the old folders. The menus suffer from the same problem, but more from a modern font choice scenario.

For me, OS X stripped a lot of the NeXT goodness to appease Mac lovers. I'm just not a fan of a UI designed for a 9" screen that really should have a better menu system. Recently, I've seen some 3rd party software that simulates part of the old NeXTSTEP menu system. Sadly, it doesn't seem to do the tear-offs.

I guess OS X is loads better than Windows, but it sure isn't my favorite. My two big "not working" projects are an agent oriented programing language and some form of modernized NeXTSTEP UI on OpenBSD. Sadly, more likely to do the former rather than the later.

Re:PC-BSD Evolves into TrueOS by IncRnd on Friday September 02, 2016 @12:24PM (#12414147)
I installed it last night, making sure to get the patches in order to use VESA not just SVGA. That gave me color. NS sure is beautiful. My color slab wasn't this good looking, since the slab had 16 bits of color.

The dated part for me is having to setup the OS for some workflows that have come about since NS days. Some things for scroll wheels not getting recognized out of the box and other polish. WS is great, though I'd change the Drag and Drop just a little. My memory of WS must have tarnished or faded some over the years, because it was and is really easy to work with.

I'll likely install the developer cd this weekend.

Thanks, again, for getting me to reinstall.

On a side note, there are commercial projects that use GNUstep. I use Hopper, a disassembler, that uses GNUstep.

From the developer training I still remember one statement in particular, "Even if NS isn't around in a few years, there will be a company that deeply understands what we do and they will do it." I guess that prophetically was OS X (at least in part).

Re:PC-BSD Evolves into TrueOS by protomyth on Friday September 02, 2016 @04:19PM (#12415971)
What guide did you use to do the install?
Re:PC-BSD Evolves into TrueOS by IncRnd on Wednesday September 07, 2016 @10:45PM (#12449882)
This one looks pretty good. http://openstep.bfx.re/

I haven't been able to figure out the networking. I have the ne2k driver, but it doesn't seem to install. I suppose the copy I have is somehow corrupted.

Re:PC-BSD Evolves into TrueOS by sedachv on Friday September 02, 2016 @03:19AM (#12411458)
Less chrome, no shadows, no rounded corners. Scroll bars on the left side. Two button mouse (not three, but good enough).
Re:PC-BSD Evolves into TrueOS by karma_vaccum123 on Thursday September 01, 2016 @08:40PM (#12409928)
You can run a variant of GNUStep today, yet no one does.
Re:PC-BSD Evolves into TrueOS by sedachv on Friday September 02, 2016 @03:26AM (#12411483)
Before switching to Lubuntu a few years ago, Window Maker was all I ran. LXDE is unobtrusive enough that I don't mind it.
Re:PC-BSD Evolves into TrueOS by DashRattlesnake on Friday September 02, 2016 @09:43PM (#12417301)
> What does that even mean in this context.

IMHO: come up with a set of initial will-thought-out UI design choices that follow an internal logic, then evolve thoughtfully (and conservatively) in a way that respects those choices.

That has the added bonus of not constantly invalidating people's investment in learning the desktop environment.

I would expect a environment that follows that would "look" similar in 2005 and 2015, and that wouldn't be a bad thing.

Re:PC-BSD Evolves into TrueOS by ashitlerferad on Friday September 02, 2016 @01:00AM (#12410946)
Motif and CDE!
Re:PC-BSD Evolves into TrueOS by loeg on Thursday September 01, 2016 @08:54PM (#12410007)
> Make this install on modern laptops. I'm tired of being recommended five year-old Thinkpads.

This branch does carry the (work-in-progress) i915 driver updates that bring support for modern Intel graphics (Haswell, Broadwell, Skylake).

Re:PC-BSD Evolves into TrueOS by drewg123 on Thursday September 01, 2016 @07:49PM (#12409699)
The linux drm compat shims should go a long way toward modern laptop support.
Re:PC-BSD Evolves into TrueOS by stock_toaster on Thursday September 01, 2016 @07:17PM (#12409551)
I think as far as desktops environments go, I imagine the first goal is to make it functional, and only then make it pretty.

Hopefully now after recently hitting 1.0, someone spends some time making it a bit nicer looking (nicer being relative of course -- I tend to like simpler desktop designs).