Re:MacBook Pros updated today - Good time to buy
by holygoat on Tuesday February 26, 2008 @02:52PM
(#124084)
That's one POV.
Another: if you wait 6 months, there'll be another significant bump 6 months after that. (WiMax!) The sensible thing to do is to wait a year. Sorry, 18 months. Oh no, 2 years.
Re:MacBook Pros updated today - Good time to buy
by papersmith on Tuesday February 26, 2008 @02:48PM
(#124079)
As an Emacs user, it's one of the things I look for when I buy a laptop. Right now the right ctrl key on my HP laptop is directly underneath the slash key, and the left ctrl key is mapped to caps lock, so both my pinkies only have to move slightly.
For the Mac users, how are you guys dealing with this? I've used 10.4 and the re-mapping feature in the preferences panel seems fairly limited.
Re:MacBook Pros updated today - Good time to buy
by ken on Tuesday February 26, 2008 @03:29PM
(#124109)
Same thing I've always done, on every platform: make sure the key to the left of A is mapped to control, and only use that. Even when I'm on a keyboard with 3 control keys, I only ever use the one.
I don't think any laptop has a good key layout. Just pick one and try to get used to it.
Re:MacBook Pros updated today - Good time to buy
by pivo on Tuesday February 26, 2008 @07:46PM
(#124368)
I don't have any problem with the control key position, I just swap it with caps lock.
The real pain for me is the meta key mapping. If I'm using Carbon Emacs I use one mapping, if I'm using emacs in a terminal I have to switch to another mapping. Things work a little differently with my external keyboard v.s. the built in one. I find the whole thing really irritating, almost enough to make me switch back to Linux on my laptop.
Re:MacBook Pros updated today - Good time to buy
by mc on Tuesday February 26, 2008 @09:49PM
(#124459)
Thanks for the link. I thought it was just me going crazy with Emacs/Apple keyboard bindings.
I do the Capslock/Ctrl swap, but I really want to make the Apple key my meta command, since that's the location of the Alt button on every other keyboard I've used
Re:MacBook Pros updated today - Good time to buy
by mironathetin on Wednesday February 27, 2008 @06:12AM
(#124651)
Exactly, you are wasting your money.
The main reason for me to use macs is mac os. While the features of the apple hardware are nice, and they look good and all that, the most important thing to have is a commandline and a set of decent apps like photoshop, bbedit etc, on one machine. Most linux applications are crap compared to os x apps!!!!
If you want to run linux and are not on a tight budget, I recommend Thinkpads. Although not all features are perfectly easy to activate (power management, bluetooth, wireless :o|), the hardware is superior to macs.
I paid the price for Powerbooks since ever. But now I have decided to go with a MacBook (as soon as they come with LED backlit screens). I think the value for the money is much better. I'd rather pump them up with the largest and fastest drive and memory.
Re:MacBook Pros updated today - Good time to buy
by mrtron on Tuesday February 26, 2008 @02:02PM
(#124040)
Some additional facts that are highly relevant to price point:
3MB shared L2 on the MB, 2x512 on the HP
Macbooks, let alone the pro, have dvi out, which is a must for most people, and the HP doesn't.
The HP is about the size of 2 macbook pros in terms of thickness.
The HP's horrible vid card and screen gives it a resolution of 1280x800 on a 15 inch screen. The Pro you are comparing has 1440x900 on the same sized screen.
I realize I am coming off as sounding fanboyish, but that is not my intention. I fully realize Macs are not priced very low, but these crappy HPs and Dells are nowhere near the quality of components.
Re:MacBook Pros updated today - Good time to buy
by mrtron on Wednesday February 27, 2008 @09:28AM
(#124723)
Most laptops don't have a good video card.
Macbooks have the small connector because the large connector is too large in form factor for a laptop (well maybe not that huge HP :P). So other laptops would have to do something similar, but perhaps apple patented the mini-dvi port?
Re:MacBook Pros updated today - Good time to buy
by neilc on Wednesday February 27, 2008 @01:39PM
(#124896)
I guess form factor could be a major part of it, although the 15" MBP does support DVI. And there are lots of laptops with decent non-integrated video cards but no DVI support -- support for DVI isn't exactly a high-end video card feature, after al.
Re:MacBook Pros updated today - Good time to buy
by alaskamiller on Tuesday February 26, 2008 @01:46PM
(#124031)
1. Apple doesn't make machines that fit into feature tables.
2. Even then, the HP is not similar to the MacBook PRo, it's missing a comparable CPU, 802.11n, backlit LED screen, multitouch mousepad, backlit keyboard, and most importantly software: Mac OS X and iLife.
3. The "fashion" tax is also the quality tax. Al casing and hundreds of screws is a very real difference.
Re:MacBook Pros updated today - Good time to buy
by chaostheory on Tuesday February 26, 2008 @01:34PM
(#124022)
I just wished they gave an option whether to have the macbook style keyboard or not. I really like the new keyboards compared to what the mac book pros have
Re:MacBook Pros updated today - Good time to buy
by kingnothing on Tuesday February 26, 2008 @07:05PM
(#124322)
I've never had a problem with closed source.
I bet the majority of hackers here don't mind it, as they're all working on their own startups and only a tiny fraction of them are likely to release their source code.
Re:MacBook Pros updated today - Good time to buy
by jgrahamc on Wednesday February 27, 2008 @01:59AM
(#124586)
I tend to agree, but there are some gestures on the MBP that are really handy:
1. Two finger tap: since there's no 'right click' (which is CTRL-click on a Mac) the two finger tap means I don't remove my fingers from the pad to get a context menu.
2. Two fingers to scroll. Very handy on web pages and it works up/down and left/right.
Unless you don't already have a Mac, then anytime is a good time to buy.
Another: if you wait 6 months, there'll be another significant bump 6 months after that. (WiMax!) The sensible thing to do is to wait a year. Sorry, 18 months. Oh no, 2 years.
Always like picking up more hardware - send the specs.
For the Mac users, how are you guys dealing with this? I've used 10.4 and the re-mapping feature in the preferences panel seems fairly limited.
I don't think any laptop has a good key layout. Just pick one and try to get used to it.
The real pain for me is the meta key mapping. If I'm using Carbon Emacs I use one mapping, if I'm using emacs in a terminal I have to switch to another mapping. Things work a little differently with my external keyboard v.s. the built in one. I find the whole thing really irritating, almost enough to make me switch back to Linux on my laptop.
Anyway, I use http://doublecommand.sourceforge.net/ to map keys that aren't handled by the limited built-in mapping choices.
I do the Capslock/Ctrl swap, but I really want to make the Apple key my meta command, since that's the location of the Alt button on every other keyboard I've used
http://www.tigerdirect.com/applications/SearchTools/item-det...
$1050
The "fashion" tax is pretty high on Apple. The only advantage it has on the HP is a superior video card.
some would say the main advantage is the OS (without hacking to make it work with a normal PC)
"It just works" - you just can't really say that for a PC
I certainly appreciate when things work immediately, but my overall curiosity means that even if I use Apple hardware, I put linux on it.
You'll be wasting your money.
The main reason for me to use macs is mac os. While the features of the apple hardware are nice, and they look good and all that, the most important thing to have is a commandline and a set of decent apps like photoshop, bbedit etc, on one machine. Most linux applications are crap compared to os x apps!!!!
If you want to run linux and are not on a tight budget, I recommend Thinkpads. Although not all features are perfectly easy to activate (power management, bluetooth, wireless :o|), the hardware is superior to macs.
I paid the price for Powerbooks since ever. But now I have decided to go with a MacBook (as soon as they come with LED backlit screens). I think the value for the money is much better. I'd rather pump them up with the largest and fastest drive and memory.
That HP machine is in no way comparable to Macbook Pro...
The base Macbook is the same price as that HP machine, and is roughly the same price.
Anyway, the HP actually seems better for most things. The AMD processor seems to cost a bit more than Intel. Aside from that, I won't compare them.
mac:
hp:Macbooks, let alone the pro, have dvi out, which is a must for most people, and the HP doesn't.
The HP is about the size of 2 macbook pros in terms of thickness.
The HP's horrible vid card and screen gives it a resolution of 1280x800 on a 15 inch screen. The Pro you are comparing has 1440x900 on the same sized screen.
I realize I am coming off as sounding fanboyish, but that is not my intention. I fully realize Macs are not priced very low, but these crappy HPs and Dells are nowhere near the quality of components.
Macbooks have the small connector because the large connector is too large in form factor for a laptop (well maybe not that huge HP :P). So other laptops would have to do something similar, but perhaps apple patented the mini-dvi port?
2. Even then, the HP is not similar to the MacBook PRo, it's missing a comparable CPU, 802.11n, backlit LED screen, multitouch mousepad, backlit keyboard, and most importantly software: Mac OS X and iLife.
3. The "fashion" tax is also the quality tax. Al casing and hundreds of screws is a very real difference.
I bet the majority of hackers here don't mind it, as they're all working on their own startups and only a tiny fraction of them are likely to release their source code.
1. Two finger tap: since there's no 'right click' (which is CTRL-click on a Mac) the two finger tap means I don't remove my fingers from the pad to get a context menu.
2. Two fingers to scroll. Very handy on web pages and it works up/down and left/right.