News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by a3_nm on Saturday August 27, 2016 @05:47PM (#12374327)
The comparison with Napster is troubling, because it gives the impression that the balance of right and wrong is the same for science and for music.

The main difference with Napster is that, in the case of music, there was some argument to be made that piracy was harmful to music, because some (tiny) part of music sales benefited the artists (and, as we all know, every pirate download was a lost sale...).

In the case of science publishers, the money simply never goes from publishers to researchers. Scientists are paid by entirely different actors (who ironically also end up paying publishers, for subscription fees to access papers). So the only possible argument left is that publishers are somehow beneficial to the science publishing process, which is a much weaker argument.

Imagine if music sales did not bring any money to artists at all, but the music industry argued: "sure, music would get composed and recorded without us, but how could it be distributed without us?" This is the situation science is currently into. The only explanation to the current state of affairs is history (pre-Internet science distribution was complicated) and the unimaginable inertia of prestige.

Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by bloaf on Saturday August 27, 2016 @06:18PM (#12374414)
The other difference is that you can make a much better argument that free and open access to the scientific literature is a public good. Music piracy could be argued to be obtaining a luxury item for free, and that people have no right to do this. However, you can make a case that the public has some right to access the scientific literature, especially when that literature is funded in part by their tax dollars.
Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by ChristianBundy on Saturday August 27, 2016 @06:57PM (#12374550)
> Music piracy could be argued to be obtaining a luxury item for free, and that people have no right to do this.

The obvious counter-argument being that there's absolutely no moral or philosophical justification for the ownership of information. Intellectual property is nothing but a racket.

Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by tashi on Saturday August 27, 2016 @07:29PM (#12374639)
One moral justification is that the ability to own and profit from intellectual property gives people a powerful incentive to create and share new things.

You seem to be making a statement from first principles: ownership of ideas is absurd. Which, of course, it is. But on the same level of abstraction, who can own land or water or sky? No one.

But of course, to "own" these things is an abstraction for a contract created by the societies we're born into, about what you're permitted to do and what happens to people who break the contract. And in that sense, the argument needs to be about what costs and benefits to society, collectively and individually, come with that contract.

Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by nerdponx on Saturday August 27, 2016 @07:43PM (#12374671)
I would tack onto this argument that, in the case of scientific research, the assignment of research intellectual property to journal publishers is a backwards and inappropriate use of intellectual property anyway.
Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by a3_nm on Saturday August 27, 2016 @08:16PM (#12374744)
Exactly. Research articles are produced with public money, and scientists do not profit financially from their sale, in fact both scientists and the public want scientific articles to be as widely circulated as possible.

It then seems completely backwards to use intellectual property to limit "unauthorized" redistribution of articles, in the hope that this would help the "authorized" publisher to circulate the articles...

Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by TheOtherHobbes on Sunday August 28, 2016 @07:11AM (#12376093)
It's worse than that. The sole contribution of the "publishers" is to make content hard to access - both practically, because you need a university library or a private login, and financially, because either your library has to pay a lot of money, or you do. ($45 for a three page PDF? Please...)

While some people try to conflate this with other kinds of IP, this is a completely different process, because research already funded by public money is being kept from the public.

Which means anyone who may be interested in research outside of academia - including startups, corporations, and private entrepreneurs - has to pay through the nose for official access.

And that simply removes money from the ecosystem and puts it in the pocket of the publishers. It doesn't fund new research, it doesn't increase publishing standards, it doesn't keep food on the table for struggling researchers.

It costs a fortune, but adds no social or scientific value at all.

Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by digi_owl on Sunday August 28, 2016 @04:32AM (#12375803)
> One moral justification is that the ability to own and profit from intellectual property gives people a powerful incentive to create and share new things.

Very little is new in the tabula rasa sense. Just look at Disney movies. I'm hard pressed to think of any of them that is not derived from something in either contemporary popular culture, or ancient stories.

the notion may have held up when it covered written stories in printed books, and only for a limited (20 years, iirc) period. This because the time window was relatively short, and because the number of book printers were low and thus easily policed.

In this day and age, i can produce a million digital copies of the bible in a second.

Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by astazangasta on Sunday August 28, 2016 @12:33AM (#12375318)
> One moral justification is that the ability to own and profit from intellectual property gives people a powerful incentive to create and share new things.

People who own intellectual property are rarely the people who created it. Those people usually get nothing for their efforts beyond a wage.

Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by collyw on Sunday August 28, 2016 @08:53AM (#12376292)
Agreed. When I worked for a big name mobile phone manufacturer, they offered us £200 or £300 pounds for ideas that got patented. I never gave them my ideas as it seemed so stingy (and getting my own patents would have been time consuming and costly).
Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by EGreg on Sunday August 28, 2016 @01:41AM (#12375444)
Well to make the obvious counterpoint: why is a government-granted monopoly moral just because a perverse business model can be made on it? And it's not even clear peopel woildn't have even greater incentives to share if things weren't locked up in articial silos with all that wasted money to sue people for "stealing" ideas. For example, open source, most science etc has been a gift economy and tremendous progress has been made without the incentives of owning the ideas.
Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by collyw on Sunday August 28, 2016 @08:50AM (#12376282)
>One moral justification is that the ability to own and profit from intellectual property gives people a powerful incentive to create and share new things.

The free software movement weakens that argument quite a lot.

Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by colejohnson66 on Saturday August 27, 2016 @07:22PM (#12374626)
> Intellectual property is nothing but a racket.

It's easy to diregard IP when you don't own any, but if IP didn't exist the big, bad, evil corporations could steal ideas from people with no recourse. In fact, that's exactly what happened with Robert Kearns[0]. He invented the intermittent windshield wiper and attempted to license it to motor companies. They told him no and later implemented intermittent wipers themselves.

Sure, you can disregard it as "why does Kearns need to own that idea?" But if it werent for Kearns, we probably wouldn't have intermittenent wipers nowadays. Also, if companies could just steal ideas from other people instead of investing in R&D, why wouldn't they?

Sure, IP can be abused, but like the majority of laws, was created with good intentions. Killing IP instead of closing loopholes that allow abuse is attacking the problem, not the cause. Without getting too political, that's the problem the left has with guns and the right has with encryption.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Kearns

Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by a3_nm on Saturday August 27, 2016 @08:23PM (#12374757)
> But if it werent for Kearns, we probably wouldn't have intermittenent wipers nowadays.

Probably not the best example, because you could make a strong case that, with intermittent wipers being such a simple invention, probably someone else than Robert Kearns would have thought about it between 1969 and today.

It's a balance, of course... However, under today's excessive intellectual property laws, even assuming that Kearns could have successfully protected his idea (because it's not like IP usually favors the small players...), would society really have benefited by limiting the use of this idea (or having everyone pay royalties to Kearns)? Wouldn't plenty of other people, in particular motor companies, come up with the idea "for free" in the 20 years of a patent term anyway?

Also, relevant to the original discussion is the fact that the general lack of IP protection for ideas is an important component of free scientific discourse. So science is another situation where the lack of IP laws is arguably a good thing. In this light, when you ask:

> if companies could just steal ideas from other people instead of investing in R&D, why wouldn't they?

I ask in turn: given that countries can use the research produced by other countries instead of funding their own researchers, why do they do it today?

Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by saltyBuck on Saturday August 27, 2016 @11:08PM (#12375129)
> probably someone else than Robert Kearns would have thought about it between 1969 and today.

Don't be so sure - delays existed for decades prior, and windshield wipers existed since horse&buggy days - yet nobody realized the importance of combining the two. There is a reason to the saying "everything is obvious in hindsight".

Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by BurningFrog on Saturday August 27, 2016 @09:06PM (#12374853)
> probably someone else than Robert Kearns would have thought about it between 1969 and today.

Yeah, most great inventions would have been made within a year anyway. The truly great ones maybe in 5 years. That doesn't mean big rewards for the first inventor are wrong. The incentives from that is why so many push for these inventions.

The argument that if it wasn't for unions 100 years ago, we'd all still be working 14 hour days is based on a similar fallacy.

Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by PhasmaFelis on Saturday August 27, 2016 @10:09PM (#12375005)
I don't understand what you mean with the union thing. The innovation that brought about better employer practices was employees discovering collective action, not employers discovering the benefits of being nice.
Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by BurningFrog on Sunday August 28, 2016 @02:05AM (#12375489)
What brought on higher wages and other more employee friendly practices was economic growth. As it becomes more profitable to have employees, businesses have to pay more to get them. They pay in money but also in other benefits, like shorter working hours.

Now, if unions demand improvements during times of economic growth, and get them, they will of course claim they caused them.

You're probably not convinced, but that's enough for now :)

Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by Kalium on Saturday August 27, 2016 @10:13PM (#12375019)
> It's easy to diregard IP when you don't own any, but if IP didn't exist the big, bad, evil corporations could steal ideas from people with no recourse.

In practice, they already can, because enforcement is ruinously expensive for individuals. The big, bad, evil corporations abuse IP to shut down individuals and smaller companies. Or just things they don't like competing with them. Witness Samsung and Apple.

> Sure, IP can be abused, but like the majority of laws, was created with good intentions.

A lot of things start with good intentions. However, we have to concern ourselves with results rather than intents.

Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by bloatisgood on Sunday August 28, 2016 @04:23AM (#12375775)
I would argue that if his IP was protected he would sit on a temporary monpoly and only a handful of car manufacturers that directly license the wipers from him directly could build them. Instead every car manufacturer build them benefiting everyone.

Developing IP is expensive but protecting it is even more expensive. Imagine a company invents a cancer curing drug but it cost them 10 billion dollars in R&D. They get their patent but then their competitor spends another 10 billion dollars in R&D to make their own cancer cure that doesn't infringe the previous patent.

I think we should have a patent system where when a company creates a patent and it sets the price of the patent to the cost of the R&D (plus some profit) and all buyers will own the patent collectively. The cost is evenly divided across all buyers. Initially the first company that buys the patent pays 10 billion dollars covering the R&D costs. If a competitor buys the patent they will only have to pay 5 billion dollars which then are used to reimburse the first buyer so both only have to pay 5 billion dollars. The third pays 3.33 billion dollars which again are redistributed across the previous buyers. And so on.

Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by CamperBob2 on Saturday August 27, 2016 @09:30PM (#12374912)
But if it werent for Kearns, we probably wouldn't have intermittenent wipers nowadays

What would be your reason for believing this?

Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by qbrass on Sunday August 28, 2016 @01:13AM (#12375390)
Especially since it had already been invented in the UK before Kearns started working on it.
Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by tzs on Sunday August 28, 2016 @12:06AM (#12375262)
> The obvious counter-argument being that there's absolutely no moral or philosophical justification for the ownership of information.

Could you elaborate a bit, because on the face of it that seems to be kind of a ridiculous statement. There is extensive literature on the philosophical justifications for almost all parts of the law, including intellectual property. For IP, there are two or three major philosophical justifications. In Erupoe, an approach based on Hegel's theories of personality is common. In the US, Locke's theories of ownership of one's labor is often used as a justification.

Did you mean to say that you do not think that these philosophical justifications are sufficient, rather than that they do not exist?

Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by eggy on Saturday August 27, 2016 @09:05PM (#12374849)
Does this apply to artwork? I ask because a lot of people were upset when Zara, the retail clothing manufacturer, apparently 'pirated' an indie artist's artworks as seen on little appliques on their apparel.

It was most likely one of their thousands of graphic designers making squat who found it on the internet, their design manager didn't catch it as a copy of something, and it wound up on their clothing.

A fury storm on Twitter with very strong suggestions to take against Zara was being proposed by many. I am sure there were some 'IP is a racket' people among them, but the argument seemed to be a one-way street: IP is free, except if you're a company who profits from it and we don't get our cut.

Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by mtgx on Saturday August 27, 2016 @09:59PM (#12374984)
No. The fashion industry doesn't have copyrights or patents, only trademarks (the brands).

This was a great TED talk about it, and about why IP laws in general are bad and how they limit creativity:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gLUzgWAEGjY

You may also be interested in the Everything Is A Remix video series, if you haven't seen it already:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d9ryPC8bxqE

Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by shandor on Sunday August 28, 2016 @01:35AM (#12375433)
>there's absolutely no moral or philosophical justification for the ownership of information

Are you sure that the whole thing is really that simple? If information cannot be owned in any way, in any case, then don't the Udemy-using pirates from the othe HN story[1] have all the right in the world to do what they are doing? And surely it also means that for example all so called pirate version "China copies" of brands like Nike etc are also completely fine?

And it goes deeper than the megacorps. If no one "owns" any information, then no one can dictate how any single piece of it is used. So you don't get to say that NSA/Facebook/some random hacker has "no right" to hack into your emails and sell them to highest bidder. Or if you think you can, please lay out the logic chain leading to that, I wasn't able to come up with one quickly.

Finally, blanket statements lile this don't help anyone. I mean...your bank account and its contents are "info" nowadays, bits on some computers somewhere. Bits just like any other piece of digital information in today's world. I think we can safely say that is some information that is only fair to be owned by some, preferably the individual who earned that money.

[1]https://www.troyhunt.com/the-piracy-paradox-at-udemy/

Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by PhasmaFelis on Saturday August 27, 2016 @10:00PM (#12374988)
I don't think that's right. IP laws are currently under the control of some corrupt and greedy people, but there are clear social benefits to having some sort of IP law.
Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by stdbrouw on Saturday August 27, 2016 @07:14PM (#12374603)
So obvious that you don't even feel the need to make the actual argument, it seems.
Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by amelius on Saturday August 27, 2016 @07:57PM (#12374704)
> Music piracy could be argued to be obtaining a luxury item for free

Another way of looking at this is that music belongs to our culture, and access to it should be free.

Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by saltyBuck on Saturday August 27, 2016 @11:14PM (#12375146)
You are making the rather large assumption that artists would not only still create but more importantly spend resources to record their music. Humans are at least partly driven by incentives - giving artistic creations away for free would at a minimum reduce the number of artists who would want to do this. Some may do it, but you surely would admit that some would not - hence a reduction.
Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by collyw on Sunday August 28, 2016 @08:57AM (#12376305)
I have a feeling that if we got rid of the musicians who were only in it for the money, we would get rid of a hell of a lot of crap manufactured pop music.
Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by lisivka on Sunday August 28, 2016 @05:04AM (#12375869)
There is lot of artists which are not popular at all. Moreover, some of them are so worse, that nobody will listen them even when they are paid. They are still spending resources to record their crap. Are you sure that piracy will stop them?
Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by eggy on Saturday August 27, 2016 @08:58PM (#12374830)
That to me is the justification of Sci-Hub. How did a company get to control product paid for by tax dollars to resell it?

On another note, I do believe information should be free. Where I start to vacillate is with who pays to extract, create or discover the information?

For instance, I know gold is a physical object, but a corollary of saying gold should be free, and yet who's work or money is put up to mine it from the earth? Some private researcher spends 15 years of their life, and discovers or creates something after investing their time, their money. Without a means to capitalize on it, what is the incentive to put in the hard work and money?

And before you say, it is never a sole researcher and their money, extrapolate up to a small shop, mid-sized company, and big company. The gist still holds.

Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by Gibbon1 on Saturday August 27, 2016 @07:54PM (#12374696)
Another argument is that using the publishing houses as a gateway is possibly harmful to science. IE, publishers and the peer review process mostly enforce the current orthodoxy and indirectly limit the areas of research that get funded. If the journal won't publish your research good luck getting anyone to fund it.
Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by swiley on Saturday August 27, 2016 @06:47PM (#12374518)
I know it's not exactly "science" but ACM is part of the general culture.

The other day I was looking for an article my dad had written for the Linux journal and could only find bits and pieces of it (some as gists on github) before I was able to find it on linuxjournal.com I found a page from ACM.org trying to sell it for something like $15. He was completely unaware this had even happened.

Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by voltagex_ on Sunday August 28, 2016 @05:27AM (#12375909)
What rights did he retain as the author? Could he/you have published it in a different place?
Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by auxym on Sunday August 28, 2016 @09:49AM (#12376479)
Some journals allow you to post the manuscript copy (not edited or typeset by the journal) on your personal page. Some give you no rifts at all.
Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by toyg on Saturday August 27, 2016 @06:16PM (#12374410)
To be fair, publishers also act as gatekeepers in a good sense, filtering out the worst crackpots by arranging peer review. That's the only reason they might have to survive in the web age.

Music labels make a difference by marketing bands. Science publishers make a difference by formalizing peer-review. If these actors concentrated on their core differentiators, nobody would grudge them the money they make. The problem is, they don't; because the most vulturish and redundant aspects of their businesses are also the most profitable. For all the techno-utopianism in the world, this state of thing will not correct itself.

Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by a3_nm on Saturday August 27, 2016 @06:25PM (#12374433)
Publishers oversee peer review, but they are not the one performing it: unpaid researchers do. It is incredible, but, by and large, scientific publishers today are utterly ignorant about the science that they publish. (To my knowledge, the only exception to this rule is situations where scientific publishers pay small amounts of money to a scientist to act as an editor: but this only concerns some journals, and still the editor delegates peer review to unpaid reviewers.)

In the music world: "Oh, but we are also necessary, because we choose which music to promote! Or rather, we arrange a room where unpaid critics tell us which ones to pick."

(And of course, peer review can organize without scientific publishers. For instance, many conferences use EasyChair <http://www.easychair.org/>, which is not perfect but at least does not claim copyright on articles. For such conferences, the only role of the publisher (if any) is to obtain a peer-reviewed body of articles, ask authors to sign copyright forms, and sometimes take care of formatting issues.)

Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by Al-Khwarizmi on Saturday August 27, 2016 @06:26PM (#12374438)
Peer review is arranged by each journal's editorial board, which is unpaid in a large majority of the cases. The editor-in-chief is chosen by the publisher at some point, but anyway publishers have a full range of journals from prestigious to total crap. It's not like they only choose the best as editors-in-chief. I don't think "arranging peer review" is a differentiator, in fact there are free society journals and grassroots journals that work just fine.
Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by chriskanan on Saturday August 27, 2016 @07:04PM (#12374573)
Are there any journals that do pay for peer review? I always hear people say that in the majority of cases reviewers are unpaid, but that makes it sound like some actually do pay. I've never received any benefit from a journal for reviewing paper, not even a free access (I usually decline review offers from non-open journals now).
Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by Ar-Curunir on Saturday August 27, 2016 @06:32PM (#12374457)
You don't need publishers for peer review; publishers do not pay reviewers. There are also completely open access electronic journals (like Discrete Analysis in mathematics), that charge a nominal fee ($10-15) for publishing, but these are merely processing costs. Everything else is free, but you get the complete benefit of peer review.
Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by bloaf on Saturday August 27, 2016 @06:22PM (#12374421)
It is true that they do currently provide that service, and that science should employ peer review, but to really defend the publishers you need to say that publishers are the only way that peer review can be arranged. I do not believe that is true.
Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by duaneb on Saturday August 27, 2016 @06:27PM (#12374441)
Doesn't peer review—in its current form—require funding? How would you recommend replacing that institution?
Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by bloaf on Saturday August 27, 2016 @06:29PM (#12374444)
The "peers" in "peer review" are not employees of the publishers.
Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by thisisdave on Saturday August 27, 2016 @06:31PM (#12374451)
Right. And to be even more specific, they are not compensated in any way (except occasionally by perks with zero marginal cost, like a free online subscription).

Some editors, who manage peer review, do get paid, but the reviewers don't.

Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by bbctol on Saturday August 27, 2016 @09:23PM (#12374889)
On the other hand, peer reviewers are generally paid by the same people who pay scientific journals--academic and research institutions--with contributing to peer review usually being an understood part of their duty.
Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by richardw on Sunday August 28, 2016 @12:30AM (#12375310)
Therefore peer review could continue even if the journals didn't exist. And since both are funded by the same source there might be more money for research and review if none went to journals.
Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by Ar-Curunir on Saturday August 27, 2016 @06:30PM (#12374449)
Peer review is done by researchers not affiliated with the publisher. They are not paid for their service.
Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by lvs on Saturday August 27, 2016 @07:15PM (#12374607)
Reviewers are unpaid. Editors and administrative costs exist, but these don't justify the total extraction of copyrights from the authors or the public.
Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by duaneb on Saturday August 27, 2016 @07:31PM (#12374645)
I agree with this, but what else would perform the coordination?
Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by rspeer on Saturday August 27, 2016 @09:37PM (#12374932)
In natural language processing, currently, research is published on arXiv and reviewed on Twitter. This is not how the institutions and funders involved would describe it, but it's what actually happens. If you're waiting for it to show up in a peer-reviewed journal, you're months or years behind.

Conferences are a good way to get caught up by letting the discussion of a number of papers happen in one physical place. The publishing industry is not necessary to organize conferences.

Journals seem to be a formalized mechanism for keeping score of the number of positive, novel results you've produced, in case you're ever up for tenure. Keeping score that way is not great for science anyway, because it biases science against negative results and replications.

When papers are discussed in the open on the Internet, you can see the discussion and choose who to believe. In formal peer review, you get the opinions of a few anonymous, uncompensated people, who would rather be doing something else, aggregated into a single bit.

Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by dgacmu on Saturday August 27, 2016 @07:53PM (#12374695)
In the case of ACM, we don't even have those costs. The conferences and reviewing is entirely community managed. The answer is: it's taxpayer and company funded, in an indirect way, by researchers contributing their time to do it. There are no paid editorial staff. These days, there's increasingly less paper involved, which eliminates the paper printing part of it as well. (those folks were paid, full time printers - but acm typically outsourced it to a printing firm anyway).

Very little remaining justification for copyright assignment to publishers.

Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by lvs on Sunday August 28, 2016 @12:55AM (#12375363)
The actual cost of the coordination is miniscule compared to the profits extracted in perpetuity from copyright. There would be more than enough money in the system to support those logistics if we stopped paying publishers in order to view our own work and that of our colleagues. When I publish, I lose the right to even view my own papers unless an institution pays for it on my behalf!
Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by posterboy on Saturday August 27, 2016 @07:06PM (#12374579)
The second paragraph is a strawman. It's not necessarily about the artists. Therefore your conclusion is flawed:

> So the only possible argument left is that publishers are somehow beneficial

If that argument would turn out to be strong enough, wouldn't it apply to the music industry as well? The comparison of napster and sci-hub would be as just as the comparison of the publishers.

Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by icebraining on Saturday August 27, 2016 @07:32PM (#12374652)
It's not a strawman, it was and is the main argument used, and that's exactly because it's the most meritorious. In fact, I've never seen the argument about protecting the publishers (ie, themselves). For example, from RIAA's website:

Music theft happens everywhere, and it’s important for fans to help look out for illegal activity that damages the creative freedom of the artists you love. If you see pirated music—either online or in person—let us know here so we can better protect artists from illegal music sales.

Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by posterboy on Saturday August 27, 2016 @08:21PM (#12374755)
But that quote is the strawman that you reverberate.

It's not a strawman as much as the selection of artists to publish is creative and artistic in its own right. Then the relative distribution in relation to artistic input is still debatable, but out of scope if the question is, whether the publishers compensation should absolutely be forgone, and whether the publishers compensation alone is blown out of proportion compared to their work.

Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by mirimir on Saturday August 27, 2016 @07:44PM (#12374676)
Except, traditionally, it's publishers who have screwed artists.
Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by aaron695 on Sunday August 28, 2016 @09:05AM (#12376335)
Fact: Science needs peer review. (well...kinda fact, there's arguments against)

Fact: This costs money

Fact: Private industry doing things works well in many markets

Fact: It's arguable art is a human right. It's why we live, compared to science that allows us to live.

Napster and science are similar. You can argue in a better world the markets could be better done, but you seem to me to be denying things we know....

Someone has to pay to organise peer review. Is it crazy the 'cost' of this is so high, perhaps. But it's not "Science isn't Napster".

Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by pessimizer on Sunday August 28, 2016 @09:26AM (#12376409)
Fact: Journals don't pay for peer review
Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by auxym on Sunday August 28, 2016 @09:47AM (#12376471)
Playing devils advocate here:

Reviewers themselves aren't paid, but the publishers do pay editors to do preliminary filtering, select reviewers, collect their comments and decide what to do with them.

Now that is relatively little work for the comparatively extortionate prices they charge.

Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by ska on Sunday August 28, 2016 @01:18PM (#12377372)
I'm pretty sure that is inconsistent also (i.e. editor is not necessarily a paid position). Furthermore, in the cases I know of where the editorial work is paid, it is only a nominal amount - there is no sense in which the time involved is actually covered by the fees.
Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by Ar-Curunir on Sunday August 28, 2016 @03:44PM (#12378148)
Editors are paid a pittance, at most.
Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by stcredzero on Sunday August 28, 2016 @01:58AM (#12375477)
the unimaginable inertia of prestige.

How about, "the entirely imagined inertia of prestige?"

Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by a3_nm on Sunday August 28, 2016 @06:17AM (#12375999)
It is not "imagined", it has very real consequences. If you have no publications in the venues that the scientific community considers "prestigious", you have essentially no hope to ever get a job as a tenured researcher.
Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by stcredzero on Monday August 29, 2016 @02:32PM (#12384046)
It is not "imagined", it has very real consequences.

Just because the consequences are real, doesn't mean the predicates or hypothesis on which those consequences are based are real. For much of the history of the US, opportunities for men of African descent to fight in the armed forces were limited, justified by various notions of racial inferiority. This is not to make a moral equivalence in the two situations. However, it does point out that the reality of the underlying predicate is different from the reality of the consequences. (i.e. "The Map is not the Territory!")

Just because the prestige exists doesn't mean that the prestige itself is based on something real. Prestige is a social construct. A different and better system of disseminating scientific publications could exist. There are a number of compelling reasons to believe a more modern system would serve the public interest far better.

Re:In rich and poor countries, researchers turn to Sci-Hub by auxym on Sunday August 28, 2016 @09:53AM (#12376497)
Or any job at all. It's going to be tough finding a good post doc position if you didn't publish during your phd.

Hell, in Canada you have to do a master's before applying for a PhD, and you won't be getting the good scholarships and will have a hard time convincing the best researchers to take you on if you didn't publish during your master's.