The claim of the book is that you, as a regular investor, do not have access to better-than-market returns, not that they are not possible. Anyone who can provide better returns will claim the difference for themselves (in fees) rather than pass it on to you. Why would they give you free money?
Re:Are Index Funds Eating the World?
by mysterypie on Saturday August 27, 2016 @05:13AM
(#12371656)
Let's say that funds X, Y, and Z can regularly beat the market. Fund X then passes on better returns to its customers, and therefore gets more customers. Then Y and Z have to do the same thing, otherwise they lose customers. Simple competition.
Are you saying the above won't happen?
Re:Are Index Funds Eating the World?
by drjesusphd on Friday August 26, 2016 @04:52PM
(#12369213)
That doesn't prove a damn thing.
When so many people are playing, there's bound to be some that consistently win, just by chance alone. The book discusses this.
And there are statistics tests one can use to determine if one's performance meets those statistical parameters to be random. Many funds and managers beat it over the long term, such as Warren Buffet, but the vast majority indeed do not.
Warren Buffet usually invests to the extent that he has the power to change how the company is run. He usually uses that power.
In addition to that, there might be an effect due to the media hype around investments of Warren Buffet. People see in the news that Buffet invested in companyXYZ so they think that must be a smart idea and also invest in the same company and therefore driving the price higher...
Does that change my thesis at all?
I was just drawing the distinction between beating the market through passive investing (simple stock picking) vs. what Warren Buffet does.
Over any one year, sure, even over a few years, sure, but when you see consistent winners over decades in numbers that exceed what random chance would expect, it's foolish to still insist the market is random other that it being a good way to sell books. I know what the book discusses, and the book is an unproven hypothesis, it doesn't need to be disproven as it has never been proven in the first place.
That markets are random is a hypothesis only; one lacking sufficient evidence to declare it a theory.
No one has proven markets are random and that's where the burden of proof lies.
Re:Are Index Funds Eating the World?
by drjesusphd on Monday August 29, 2016 @02:04AM
(#12380291)
Show me an example of someone repeatedly beating the market, year after year, for decades.
Besides, even that is "only" a one in a million chance. How many people trade on the stock market?
Re:Are Index Funds Eating the World?
by icebraining on Friday August 26, 2016 @07:09PM
(#12369958)
From what I remember from the book, the claim is not that nobody can beat the market; it's that you can't distinguish them from lucky winners.
By the way, which funds have beaten the market for decades?
Renaissance Tech? Clearly at some level of expenditure you can beat risk/return of the market, but it doesn't necessarily scale either up or down. You need enough money to hire your army of PhDs, but not so much money that it starts to affect the market.
edit: heh, snap.
> it's that you can't distinguish them from lucky winners.
Jim Simmons doesn't agree, see Renaissance Technologies as an example. And time would week out lucky winners; luck isn't consistent over long time periods and this is just one example.
The RenTech Medallion fund is owned entirely by fund employees. It's not accessible to people who are not able to contribute to its success.
It's a real book, but it doesn't prove the market is random, nothing does as the efficient market hypothesis is just that, an unproven hypothesis lacking even enough evidence to become a working theory.
That certain funds consistently beat the market year in and year out for decades is enough to disprove the notion that markets are random; they're not.