For existing owners, they will get a huge payout because their land becomes MUCH more valuable. The downside is that certain neighborhoods where supply is most suppressed will change very much, very fast, and the people that don't sell and leave will probably not like that.
Preferences aside, this cannot be done without hugely disrupting municipal finance, primarily the provision of public schools. Residential property and services are subsidized by commercial/industrial tax revenues, and there is no linkage between assessed value of property and number of school-age children (e.g. two empty-nesters in a mansion pay multiples of the property tax of a family of 5 renting an apartment). And that's just operations! Building lots of new school capacity, when land has just become very expensive, is not something existing cities/school districts are equipped to do.
However, Americans are tough and smart and can figure stuff out. These are just the current obstacles that exist.
That's what we've been doing here in Australia to deal with a housing crisis; now there's a looming oversupply of apartments [1], and a lot of them are barely habitable "dog boxes" [2][3] built as investment assets (rather than, you know, for living in) while house prices are still sky high.
[1] http://www.domain.com.au/news/australia-to-have-too-many-hom...
[2] http://www.abc.net.au/news/2016-08-14/melbourne-dog-box-apar...
[3] http://www.macrobusiness.com.au/2016/03/melbournes-dog-boxes...
But these very same owners are the ones blocking such construction, even despite being the same people that will receive a financial windfall; they prefer to keep the neighborhoods as is even at this tremendous opportunity cost.
So, it still requires some eminent domain or overriding local government.
Really? You'd prefer that over working remotely, or staffing remote offices?
UNLESS: The municipality becomes the 'building'. If you have parking silos at the edges (or in dedicated locations within), and excellent human scale transit (like people mover belts through commercial areas) between there and housing then I'm more for /centralized/ parking.
America is simply built on cars, and no matter how much you get rid of the need for a car in the city (and PLEASE reduce that as much as possible!) the car is /the/ interface for accessing the rest of the world, where families, lower density industrial, and other aspects live.
If you want to go out and access parks and other features that involve more trees, more natural animals, and less people that is also a requirement.
Imagine if every room (not just bedrooms) was required to have a walk-in closet, because the American way is for people to have a lot of stuff and there's simply no way to provide for space if it's not mandated to be included in the cost and construction of every dwelling. It's be very convenient to have the space, but not everyone needs it, it would encourage people to buy and keep more stuff than they would choose if they had to pay, and it would reduce the amount of space available for anything besides closets.
But this is silly - people buy less, rent storage units, change habits, etc. Parking and transportation is the same. If your condo is $35K cheaper because there's no parking, and you forego a $35K car, then you save ~$1K/mo which pays for a lot of Ubers, delivery fees, and vacation cars. And if you want to have your own car, then you can always buy/rent a space!
The key problem is that these zoning decisions are occurring at the local level, where petty biases and NIMBYism plays out - shoving externalities at the neighboring cities is par for the course.
We could call it, "The great leap forward." Or maybe, a "Five-year plan".
Certainly the locals shouldn't have a say in what the feds do to their own cities.
In fact, zoning is what is keeping people from building the kinds of buildings that people who can't currently afford living in city $X from living in city $X. Does one particular unit of government deserve more respect than all others?
So, no, as a non-resident you don't have much of a say. Although, if you're working in a city, your company that is making you "stuck" working there presumably has some sway as a taxpayer.
Washington already exerts too much influence on far-flung localities. This is the last thing I want to see - people who live in a place should be the ones who set the rules for that place.
I lost all sympathy for that argument when it was part of the key rationales for redlining and keeping the blacks out of town in the 1940s & 1950s.
Thank god for democracy.
In the Bay Area, you see what happens when the supply runs out: the middle class becomes renters for life.
...Real estate has been a boon for some in the middle class, but it's important to consider the wider implications of speculation in land values as a source of wealth-- it's ultimately unsustainable and highly regressive.
It's a bubble that will burst.
http://www.economist.com/blogs/graphicdetail/2016/08/daily-c...
A $400k home in NYC is within reasonable reach of a dual income professional couple.
Prices are high generally because capital is cheap and monetary policy has made other traditional "safe" investments useless.
The income ratio based numbers reflect how the "middle class" is getting the proverbial shaft.
When wages are stagnant for 30 years and property appreciates, you need to accept the fact that you're not capable of supporting a circa 1986 middle class standard of living. My grandfather owned a home in NYC, kept new cars, and had a summer camp in the mountains on a blue-collar city government income and second job as a boilerman in the 1960s. That's no longer achievable. I personally barely have that level of buying power as a IT executive.
The average US price in real terms is up like 10% since 1980. The average SFO price is 400% above that. The average NYC price is 200% more. That's a real estate bubble.
Lots of factors influence what's happening. Between Tech workers who make too much, Chinese capital flight liking for a home and stupid bank underwriting practices, demand is wacky in a few cities.
For instance, consider John Arrillaga[0]. Land in the Silicon Valley made him billions. But does that make this a sensible system?
Silicon Valley would exist whether or not people speculated in land, and yet we consider fishing for gains to be a noble pursuit. I think it actively holds back actual improvements in communities.
If it's genuine, how the heck would you get support for something like this? It'd be the ultimate NIMBY.
YIMBY, actually: NIMBYs are the folks who don't want to have development nearby.
League of Urban Voters: we would work together to draw up a workable plan for the next 12 election cycles (or so) - the LUV would accept members and donations from all who support the goal of increasing density and urbanization. Key congress people supporting the goals would be identified, along with professional city planners and professionals at universities. Supporting cast members would be industry groups and other coalitions that we find common cause with. We would collaborate with them to develop talking points and in-depth policy wonk analyses, policies, and plans.
After we had hammered out the key policy points and major reasons to shut down the pro-single-occupancy house policies & pro-suburb policies, we'd go onto the campaign path, understanding that it'd be a 48-60 year battle. There'd be a blog, a forum, probably eventually a think tank and a journal. Given a careful orchestration over the timespan of two generations, a reasonable success would be had.
There's no God-given right to live in your own home on an acre of land in the US. Or in a 120-story skyscraper. These capabilities are hammered out through politics, engineering, and money. If the sociopolitical scene is tuned to have cheap houses, it'll have cheap houses. If it's tuned for condos in skyscrapers, it'll be condos in skyscrapers. This genuinely is malleable stuff here.
N.b., this is not unique to housing policy. You can define the same general game plan for any particular issue you like.
(which just to be clear, I'm not saying that to anyone here, I'm putting it in the mouths of mortgage holders who like their tax deduction)
At least many of them started valuing a yard, easy access to a car, and better public schools after they had children.
"The federal government will no longer provide security for single occupancy house mortgages"
"The federal government finds that policies preferring in any sense single-occupancy homes gives clear rise to racism. The Equal Housing authority will be auditing all sales and rentals of single housing homes; landlord violators will be fined severely; mortgage lenders who violate will be fined severely".
Also, with the demographic shifts in the US and how they affect urban areas, it's absolutely relevant to the nation's commerce.
Anyways, you can tie HUD/DOT/etc grants to the conditions. Don't play ball = no funding.
I wouldn't call moving into a place being forced to live under the rules and regulations of that place.
Changing the rules and regulations on people who already live there, though, I'd say is forcing because it can be a major effort to move somewhere else, especially if they are an owner rather than a renter.
I know the real answer is because they can vote for things that preserve it, and I can't vote for things that erode it.
People complain that millenials aren't buying into the american way of life while simultaneously making it so unaffordable as to be roughly financial suicide to participate.
So while you have a point from a purely anarchist point of view (and that's not a slur on you, ok? anarchists have a great critique of existing systems), that ship has sailed so long ago in the first world that I don't think there's any meaningful point in trying to recall it.
I would like to see this, at the national level: federally strip all downzoning from urban cities, then increasingly tax single-occupancy houses, focusing on subsidizing and activating high-density housing for all income strata. There's no reason Seattle, San Francisco, LA, etc can't all be turned into high-density high-efficiency Manhattan-esque locations. With the increased density comes a more effective tax base and a better scale for urban services.