In the Bay Area, you see what happens when the supply runs out: the middle class becomes renters for life.
...Real estate has been a boon for some in the middle class, but it's important to consider the wider implications of speculation in land values as a source of wealth-- it's ultimately unsustainable and highly regressive.
It's a bubble that will burst.
http://www.economist.com/blogs/graphicdetail/2016/08/daily-c...
A $400k home in NYC is within reasonable reach of a dual income professional couple.
Prices are high generally because capital is cheap and monetary policy has made other traditional "safe" investments useless.
The income ratio based numbers reflect how the "middle class" is getting the proverbial shaft.
When wages are stagnant for 30 years and property appreciates, you need to accept the fact that you're not capable of supporting a circa 1986 middle class standard of living. My grandfather owned a home in NYC, kept new cars, and had a summer camp in the mountains on a blue-collar city government income and second job as a boilerman in the 1960s. That's no longer achievable. I personally barely have that level of buying power as a IT executive.
The average US price in real terms is up like 10% since 1980. The average SFO price is 400% above that. The average NYC price is 200% more. That's a real estate bubble.
Lots of factors influence what's happening. Between Tech workers who make too much, Chinese capital flight liking for a home and stupid bank underwriting practices, demand is wacky in a few cities.
For instance, consider John Arrillaga[0]. Land in the Silicon Valley made him billions. But does that make this a sensible system?
Silicon Valley would exist whether or not people speculated in land, and yet we consider fishing for gains to be a noble pursuit. I think it actively holds back actual improvements in communities.
Thank god for democracy.