News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by swalsh on Thursday August 25, 2016 @04:44PM (#12362348)
This is incremental progress, it's just one school. But a crazy step in the right direction. For-Profit institutions are a plague on our nation (high-cost low-value educations) allowed to rise up out of the failings of our strained public institutions (not enough capacity to meet demand).

What really blows my mind is that this seems to come after the justice department discontinues for profit federal prisons. It's like all that "change" we were hoping for with Obama seems to be coming at once.

Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by nradov on Thursday August 25, 2016 @05:03PM (#12362482)
In principle there's nothing wrong with for-profit schools which train people on specific job skills or certification programs. There are some valuable skills that non-profit community colleges can't practically teach. But still the federal government should only support financial aid for such schools if they demonstrate a high rate of job placement for students who complete the program.
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by FireBeyond on Thursday August 25, 2016 @07:16PM (#12363218)
Absolutely - if you can be both regionally and nationally accredited go for it.

But most of these schools are in the "credits earned may not transfer" class, at which point the only thing you have going for you is vocational (which has merit). But if you're a hybrid or a degree awarding institution that no other schools recognize, then that's a problem and there's near zero value to what you're offering (which isn't to make it sound cliquey, but still).

Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by ics on Thursday August 25, 2016 @08:39PM (#12363547)
I agree with what you and others are saying in general but "credits earned may not transfer" might as well apply anywhere. Between state/city university system, community college, and top-tier private college I had a hell of a time getting any credits to go anywhere. (Including for very run-of-the-mill, non-"core", non-specialized subjects.)
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by FireBeyond on Thursday August 25, 2016 @10:45PM (#12363985)
I had a hard time convincing a Community College here that they should accept my VCE from Australia as being equivalent to a high school diploma (it is) and not making me sit an equivalency exam... only made more ironic by the Bachelor's degree that I also had.
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by swalsh on Thursday August 25, 2016 @05:11PM (#12362549)
You're right, there are many examples of great for-profit institutions. The problem is there's little differentiating them from "predator" schools. One issue is information asymmetry.
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by nickff on Thursday August 25, 2016 @05:45PM (#12362745)
There is informational asymmetry in every transaction (as well as in non-profit schools); this is a red herring (unless you can show that it is causing a specific, large, unsolved problem). The current administration has repeatedly demonstrated hostility towards for-profit schools, and has chosen to use discretionary enforcement of rules against them rather than enforcing standards universally, because they know that the standards would hit many non-profit schools as well. I am not sure about the specifics of this case, but the Department of Education has been looking at for-profit schools much harder than non-profits.
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by TulliusCicero on Thursday August 25, 2016 @07:54PM (#12363374)
>There is informational asymmetry in every transaction

Yes, but informational asymmetry is a much bigger problem for larger, less frequent decisions, like buying a house, or going to college.

With small, frequent decisions, like buying groceries, you can quickly learn from your mistakes and the harm done from potentially choosing an inferior/overly expensive grocer a few times is small.

With college, if you don't figure out that the educational provider was poor until after you've graduated, you're already wasted tens of thousands of dollars and years of your life for a useless degree. That's a much bigger issue.

Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by WalterBright on Friday August 26, 2016 @12:26AM (#12364231)
> if you don't figure out that the educational provider was poor until after you've graduated

Is using google that difficult?

After all, I went to college before the internet, and didn't have any trouble finding reviews of the various options, and used that to form a list to apply to. With google it's a few minutes' job.

There's never been less information asymmetry.

Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by eecc on Friday August 26, 2016 @02:54AM (#12364689)
So you base your life-changing decisions on Google?! That's smart, go on, you'll go far...
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by WalterBright on Friday August 26, 2016 @04:24AM (#12364953)
What source of information do you suggest starting with when researching which colleges to attend?
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by ethbro on Thursday August 25, 2016 @10:17PM (#12363906)
> I am not sure about the specifics of this case, but the Department of Education has been looking at for-profit schools much harder than non-profits.

This seems fair to me. You can argue that wasted money at NFP schools ends up in someone's pocket, but bald faced "every buck not spent educating you" going into the pocket of capital seems worse.

If the outcomes at FP higeher education aren't better, why not avoid funneling federal money (in the form of no interest loans, etc) directly in private profits?

Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by nickff on Friday August 26, 2016 @12:08AM (#12364181)
Non-profits are often compared by examining their overhead as a percentage of total spending, rather than their efficacy per dollar (or overall). This holds back many great charities, and benefits others which consistently waste money on doomed projects with low overheads. It seems to be just as wrong to assume that retained earnings or dividends are wasted overhead and compare organizations on that basis alone.
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by coredog64 on Thursday August 25, 2016 @07:44PM (#12363330)
No doubt ITT's problem is that Kaplan University had already hired Anita Dunn and there wasn't another White House staffer ready to transition to the private sector.
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by Animats on Friday August 26, 2016 @03:17AM (#12364752)
Kaplan University? Somehow affiliated with the test prep company?
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by ajkjk on Thursday August 25, 2016 @07:04PM (#12363165)
The existence of information asymmetry isn't per se the problem, no, of course not. But it's not a red herring to mention if we can look at the world and see the information asymmetry doing active harm, which I think most commenters here would agree with. The opinion that large numbers of for-profit schools are convincing people to give them money and then providing almost nothing useful in return is so widespread now that I'd assume it to be everyone's default unless they specifically mention otherwise.
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by nickff on Thursday August 25, 2016 @07:26PM (#12363268)
I would agree that "[t]he opinion that large numbers of... schools are convincing people to give them money and then providing almost nothing useful in return is so widespread now that I'd assume it to be everyone's default unless they specifically mention otherwise." According to the signalling theory of education and the opinion of many commenters here, a great deal (possibly a strong majority) of post-secondary education is a complete waste of time and money. It's not that I think these schools are providing useless experience and knowledge, I just think the non-profits are doing about the same.
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by dangerlibrary on Thursday August 25, 2016 @07:52PM (#12363366)
Graduation rates at non profit schools are appalling. University of Pheonix routinely graduates less than 20% of its students within six years. Even if all of the benefit is signaling, which I disagree with, the students at many for profit institutions aren't even getting that benefit.
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by tmptmp on Friday August 26, 2016 @12:26AM (#12364230)
>>Graduation rates at non profit schools are appalling. University of Pheonix routinely graduates less than 20% of its students within six years.

I am talking about both (for and not-for profit) universities.

Isn't graduation a responsibility of a student too? If a student is not graduating, isn't there a chance that he/she is not sufficiently working for it?

or

If a student is not graduating, isn't there a chance that he/she does not have what it takes to learn a subject?

The students should do a little bit of homework before joining any university: does the university seem suitable for me? do I seem suitable for the university? do I think I am capable of handling the study work? what is the quality of the faculty? what the almuni are saying about this university? what the other academics are saying about this university?

If a student cannot or will not do this little bit of homework, then I guess he/she deserves to be surprised (may get a good surprise if lucky else bad surprise).

Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by nickff on Thursday August 25, 2016 @08:40PM (#12363550)
Many state colleges have low 6 year graduation rates too (as they vary widely), should they be shut down too? Is there any reason 25% or 30% are unacceptable, but 50% is fine?[1]

[1] http://collegecompletion.chronicle.com/

Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by makomk on Thursday August 25, 2016 @09:39PM (#12363792)
A 50% graduation rate is literally double a 25% graduation rate. You're arguing that the only reason for the US government to care about the fact that students at for-profit institutions are half as likely to graduate is because they've got a grudge against them, as though this is some minor difference that no-one should care about.
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by ajkjk on Friday August 26, 2016 @01:31AM (#12364405)
And, sure, a 50% graduation rate at a state college is a big problem that should be investigated as well. But it's definitely not true that "all of the state colleges" have this problem, whereas it (as least seems to be) ubiquitous among for-profit schools.
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by gertef on Thursday August 25, 2016 @07:54PM (#12363373)
"Department officials say they are acting out of concerns raised by the for-profit chain’s accreditor, the Accrediting Council for Independent Colleges and Schools, that ITT is not living up to the demands of its accreditation. ITT is under threat of having its accreditation revoked"
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by nickff on Thursday August 25, 2016 @08:32PM (#12363524)
Thanks, but I read the article. Do you have any additional insight?
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by copperx on Thursday August 25, 2016 @11:46PM (#12364129)
Honest question: what are some examples of great for-profit institutions?
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by wpietri on Friday August 26, 2016 @01:18AM (#12364371)
I get what you're saying, but I think there is in principle something wrong.

The theory of markets is that even if a company is staffed by the greediest sons of bitches, market mechanisms will force them to converge on delivering high customer value. But markets work best when you have savvy customers that purchase frequently, can quickly evaluate results, and can easily try other suppliers.

Unfortunately, none of that is true for education. Most customers purchase just one degree. They are by definition ignorant about the topic. Switching schools is hard. It takes years to find out if the education is really any good in the job market. The barrier to entry for new schools is very large.

So even in principle I think there's good reason to be suspicious of for-profit education.

Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by eecc on Friday August 26, 2016 @02:52AM (#12364680)
And besides what you've already correctly noted, the theory of markets is just that, a theory. A very simplistic, idealized model that very quickly diverges from reality.
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by wpietri on Friday August 26, 2016 @09:18AM (#12365967)
Oh, definitely. In theory, theory and practice are the same. But in practice...
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by merpnderp on Thursday August 25, 2016 @09:15PM (#12363701)
In that same vein why do public schools get to saddle kids with an average of $30k in debt and leave them with the prospect of $8/hour jobs as many degrees do? Where's the outrage over public schools who do the exact same thing?
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by munchbunny on Friday August 26, 2016 @07:48AM (#12365525)
There's plenty of outrage over that too, it's just not in this thread, because the article was about for-profit colleges.
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by copperx on Thursday August 25, 2016 @11:52PM (#12364144)
A school's main objective is not to make you employable.
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by michaelbuddy on Friday August 26, 2016 @01:08AM (#12364336)
A school's main objective is whatever they say at any given moment to you. You've got mission statements, brochure advertisements, orientation presentations, presentations to high schools, whatever is said in private from your guidance advisor. There will be PLENTY of times when you hear that they are focused on "preparing you for the real world" or they talk about growth. Funny as vague a language they might use, I've never once read a university (and I've worked at two of them) say that their main objective ISN'T to make you employable.
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by wanderingjew on Friday August 26, 2016 @06:32AM (#12365330)
An education's main goal is not to make you employable.

A school, on the other hand, charges tuition, and therefore any transaction between the student and the school must be viewed under the lens of a financial transaction.

Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by nogbit on Friday August 26, 2016 @01:18AM (#12364372)
No, but many do have full time employees in their "career services" center working to place you with an employer.

http://foster.uw.edu/careers/career-services/

Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by welterde on Friday August 26, 2016 @12:48AM (#12364291)
> There are some valuable skills that non-profit community colleges can't practically teach.

For example? Out of hand I can't think of anything obvious - but I only really knows how the system works in Germany, which is quite different indeed to the US system.. so that might be the reason why I can't.

Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by legulere on Thursday August 25, 2016 @07:15PM (#12363210)
There are options beside for-profit and non-profits founded out of academic interest. For instance companies can get together and found institutions of higher education to ensure the education of the future workforce for them.
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by awt on Thursday August 25, 2016 @07:40PM (#12363319)
How about let individuals decide if a school is good, and not the federal government? AKA Capitalism.
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by nyargh on Thursday August 25, 2016 @08:07PM (#12363428)
Sounds good to me! No more federal student loans!
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by awt on Friday August 26, 2016 @12:31PM (#12367347)
Precisely.
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by dragonwriter on Thursday August 25, 2016 @05:17PM (#12362580)
> What really blows my mind is that this seems to come after the justice department discontinues for profit federal prisons.

The Administration has been heightening scrutiny of colleges receiving federal aid money, particularly for-profit institutions, for some time. The ITT action echoes the prior action against Corinthian.

Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by Shivetya on Thursday August 25, 2016 @07:05PM (#12363168)
I see little difference between large state schools and for profits. Plus there are plenty of "NON-PROFITS" which are soaking up the aid as well; its just a convenient classification; worse they are so to protect their endowments from taxation and such. So why excuse schools like them when non-profit can exploit the tax payer more than for-profits?

Old article http://nymag.com/daily/intelligencer/2014/09/take-away-harva...

Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by schmidty on Thursday August 25, 2016 @07:23PM (#12363250)
> For-Profit institutions are a plague on our nation

I dont understand. ANY for profit? Like Apple or Ford?

Or just educational institutions? If just educational institutions, what is special about that sector that makes them a plague?

Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by munchbunny on Thursday August 25, 2016 @07:33PM (#12363295)
The decision is specifically targeting for-profit degree mills.

The problem is that these institutions provide expensive educations, paid for by people taking out student loans (which the institutions actively encourage). However, these same institutions don't provide any sort of education that would give their students even a remote chance of paying off the student loans on any reasonable timeframe.

This creates a system of perverse incentives where the degree mill is essentially farming student loan money, screwing over both the student and the government in the process.

My read on the news is that the policy is supposed to stop exactly this phenomenon.

Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by imjustsaying on Thursday August 25, 2016 @09:35PM (#12363779)
I'm just going to go out on a limb and say that most of the people going to ITT-esque schools are getting Pell Grants (free money, not loans) first and foremost to cover their costs.

I didn't even know this was a thing until after I graduated (I never got a Pell Grant because my parents made too much money).

Some schools have over 90% of their students funding their entire costs through Pell Grants (look at University of Puerto Rico or Interamerican University of Puerto Rico for some extreme examples).

Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by saalweachter on Friday August 26, 2016 @08:04AM (#12365597)
It looks like ITT does/did have a large proportion of students with Pell Grants -- 23,500 out of 57,000 students. The tuition figures I can find for ITT are $18,000 / year, while the average Pell Grant to an ITT student was $1800 / year.

So 40% of ITT students got 10% of their tuition from ITT, and ITT got 4% of its revenue from Pell Grants.

Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by munchbunny on Friday August 26, 2016 @04:12PM (#12368982)
The 10% number is really interesting, where are these students getting the other 90%?

To me it feels like it can't have just been paid in cash, because if you have $16,000 per year just lying around... you are probably in a situation where you can find better options than ITT.

Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by saalweachter on Friday August 26, 2016 @07:57AM (#12365565)
The reason for-profit educational institutions are a plague is that the US government provides for a special class of loans to allow people to go to college without having the cash up front.

This special class of loans has both a relatively low interest rate (making them appealing for consumers) and cannot be defaulted on, an important feature when there is no collateral for a loan. (This feature is not needed, for instance, when you buy a home, because if you default on your mortgage they can take your home, which you put up as collateral.)

This created the opportunity for investors to create educational institutions with a thin veneer of respectability, suck in any student who could qualify for loans, and funnel that money back to the investors. Which many did.

Removing the eligibility for this special class of loan for (all, or just the known offenders) for-profit universities removes this opportunity without actually outlawing for-profit universities. This opportunity only existed because of the federal government meddling in the free market, so everyone should be happy.

Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by 20yrs_no_equity on Thursday August 25, 2016 @07:28PM (#12363277)
Plus anyone who thinks that "Public" schools are not for profit hasn't looked too closely.

My "Public" University was basically a football program which had classes to try and justify its existence.

Think Stanford isn't for profit? Harvard? University of California?

The only difference is who is making the profit an what their incentives are.

ITT doesn't make money if its students don't get jobs. Does UC Santa Cruz really care more?

[dead]
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by sctb on Friday August 26, 2016 @01:18PM (#12367725)
This comment violates the HN guidelines, and we ban accounts that do so repeatedly. Please stop.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by munchbunny on Friday August 26, 2016 @07:30AM (#12365480)
I can't tell how serious you are, but I'll assume you are.

There parent poster didn't get voted down because people disagree with him/her. The parent poster got voted down because he/she clearly didn't understand the problem the article was talking about.

Nothing to do with leftism.

Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by Unbeliever69 on Thursday August 25, 2016 @04:47PM (#12362370)
When the discontinuation of federal prison article came up on hacker news I commented, "Now if we could only outlaw for-profit schools!"
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by dangero on Thursday August 25, 2016 @04:57PM (#12362446)
What's wrong with someone educating people and making a profit while doing it?
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by swalsh on Thursday August 25, 2016 @05:07PM (#12362523)
The issue is that the profit comes before the education. These institutions prey on low-income people who for whatever reason couldn't get into public institutions. When the students graduate they have huge debts, typically larger than those that went to public institutions, but worse their degrees are often worthless. The accreditation for these institutions often come from companies owned by the same corporation. The accreditation means nothing so your credits can't transfer. Do a google search, you'll find article after article about students who went to these schools trying to get a better life and just made their lives worse. They went from poor, to hopelessly poor. Whereas before they were poor with bad job prospects they're now poor with bad job prospects and HUGE debts. They often just stop paying them. It's one of the biggest contributors to our student debt problem.
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by SilasX on Thursday August 25, 2016 @08:21PM (#12363474)
>The issue is that the profit comes before the education. ...

That sounds like a fully-general argument against provision of any good by a for-profit business: "The issue with private farms is that the profit comes before the food." "The issue with private semiconductors is the profit comes before the computational efficiency."

True, profits do bring the potential for fraud, abuse, etc., but obviously there are at least some situations where that can all be contained. What's special about education per se?

You cite abuses, but are those artifacts of the for-profit part, or the "students generally don't have good information about what a given school will do for their career"? I mean, there are lots of cases of students at "non-profit" public universities who are drowning in debt from a worthless degree.

Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by commandar on Friday August 26, 2016 @02:30AM (#12364599)
>What's special about education per se?

In the US? The fact that it gets paid for with loans that aren't dischargeable in bankruptcy.

Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by SilasX on Friday August 26, 2016 @02:34AM (#12364612)
I meant, what's special in terms of profits skewing incentives.
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by Goronmon on Friday August 26, 2016 @09:17AM (#12365960)
I would argue it's a combination of the high cost (we aren't talking about people ending up with a few thousand dollars of debt), the fact that it might take years to determine if any given school is actually not terrible, and the fact that "education" itself is given special considerations over many products and services.
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by kosievdmerwe on Thursday August 25, 2016 @05:08PM (#12362525)
The problem with for-profit prisons is the misalignment between what's good for profit and what's good for prisoners. Where the prisoners can't "vote with their wallets" to counter-balance this misalignment.

I don't see a similar issue with for-profit schools. In order to attract students they need to to provide good education and foster a good reputation.

Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by emn13 on Thursday August 25, 2016 @05:37PM (#12362700)
Hmm, is that really true though? If so, ideally, people would choose an institute that teaches them as well as possible for as little as possible money. But that's not at all what people do: they prefer prestigious schools that (hopefully) lead to good job prospects.

Prestige is a funny thing - the fact that a school is hard to get into and expensive may well raise prestige, regardless of educational outcomes.

Don't forget, it's very hard for students and (future) employers/investors/business partners to tell how good an education is. It's quite difficult even for the institutes themselves and any oversight that may exist.

That means incentives aren't as simple as you suggest. Sure, at some very, very long term horizon, better education helps an institute. But that may well be multiple generations away; much too far away to work well in an open market. Especially since there is so much other noise that can be optimized instead.

By constrast, the state's interest in decent education is much more straighforward (not that the politicians making the choices have their incentives straight, but that's another story). In particular, whereas it's clearly in the for-profit institutes interest to milk students no matter how and no matter how unfairly. This is a normal risk in any organisation - but the point is that for-profit organisations aren't magic optimization bullets. These downsides don't need to be a problem, but they do need to be dealt with, and there needs to be some upside to the deal too. What's the upside here?

I think you're clearly right for short-enough courses with clearly demonstrable and measurable outcomes. And I bet you're right in the abstract too, in the sense that "it should be possible to align incentives such that..." - but I'm not sure it holds given the current way education is structured.

Real-world evidence certainly doesn't seem to suggest profit-motive works very well here.

Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by michaelchisari on Thursday August 25, 2016 @06:28PM (#12362991)
Not to mention that for-profit schools appeal to (some would say prey upon) students from blue collar or lower class families for whom ANY degree seems worth whatever you might pay for it.

If you're from generations of laborers who have never gone to college, then taking out a predatory loan to go to a predatory school that gives you a somewhat useless degree seems like a good idea at first glance.

Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by sldivzklhc on Thursday August 25, 2016 @06:43PM (#12363068)
It doesn't seem like the selectivity/prestige effect applies to people who go to for-profit schools. Since prestige is subjective, for-profit schools can market themselves as prestigious while expanding to provide seats to anyone who can obtain a student loan. The government should not be complicit in this deception, hence the action here.
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by twblalock on Thursday August 25, 2016 @07:43PM (#12363327)
> I don't see a similar issue with for-profit schools. In order to attract students they need to to provide good education and foster a good reputation.

Or they just need to dupe people who don't know any better.

A lot of the people who end up at these places are poor, don't have friends or relatives with college degrees, didn't get good advice, and simply don't know how to recognize a scam. Now they have six figures of student loan debt they can't get rid of, and a low-prestige degree that many employers won't even consider.

Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by SilasX on Thursday August 25, 2016 @08:15PM (#12363451)
I can't rigorously prove it, but I'm pretty sure the people complaining about for-profit prisons wouldn't change their minds even if there were a system of "staple $N/month to every prisoner and they can go to whatever private prison will have them".

After all, we have basically that system for for-profit schools and ...

Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by chillwaves on Friday August 26, 2016 @02:03AM (#12364516)
All for profit schools are pretty terrible. I am assuming this is true of for profit prisons as well. Having to choose among different terrible choices doesn't seem like a solution.
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by SilasX on Friday August 26, 2016 @02:32AM (#12364610)
Typically, it's the potential to choose that leads to improvement, across a wide range of goods. To claim that it's all different for schools, you'd need to demonstrate a general model of the dynamics.

And FWIW, the coding bootcamp I went to (for profit) did more for my career than my non-profit university.

Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by nyargh on Thursday August 25, 2016 @08:00PM (#12363404)
Nothing, if they also accept the downside risk of financing a crap education. The default rates for many private universities are astounding - and the taxpayer helps backstop them from losses via federal student loans.
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by ulkram on Thursday August 25, 2016 @04:59PM (#12362460)
Exactly, there are a lot of good private universities.
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by ng12 on Thursday August 25, 2016 @05:06PM (#12362509)
In the USA, private does not mean for-profit. The good private universities are still non-profit.

There's nothing wrong with for-profit schools in theory. It's a socio-economic problem. There's already so much money flowing through the US university system that the vast majority of for-profit schools are predatory institutions targeting lower-class, under-educated people. Their primary business model is to convince students to take out loans to pay for a white-collar education that won't make them any more employable.

Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by cpr on Thursday August 25, 2016 @06:13PM (#12362906)
The "good private universities" may be "non-profit" in some strict sense, but in the case of the big Ivies (e.g., Harvard, my alma mater), they could be described as a hedge fund with, oh, yes, by the way, a school attached, or, alternatively, as a huge Federally-funded research institution.

The educational part seems to be a facade for the big money/big institution part.

(Bitter much? Sure. ;-)

Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by vonmoltke on Thursday August 25, 2016 @06:46PM (#12363082)
What good is a "hedge fund" you can't take the money out of? The Ivies have massive endowments, but that money can only be spent on the school.
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by sldivzklhc on Thursday August 25, 2016 @06:46PM (#12363083)
I went to a school like that. They provided grant-only aid to cover tuition and living expenses for students from most of the US income distribution. I think you will have a harder time finding sob stories about my classmates (at least since the no-loan policies were enacted).
Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by mywittyname on Thursday August 25, 2016 @06:20PM (#12362947)
> There's nothing wrong with for-profit schools in theory.

Absolutely.

The problem is our university system as it stands is now really structured for profitability. The system was originally designed to cater to wealthy students and when public universities came to be, they kept the same model, and used tax subsidies to maintain it.

An effective for-profit education system would look nothing like our current university system. But a higher education system that doesn't match our current system isn't useful for students because the majority of them are looking for degrees, not necessarily an education.

Theoretically there's nothing wrong with for-profit schools, but the current educational climate prevent them from working. For now, for-profit education really only has a place in domains that can be taught adequately in less than a year and where the student's outcome can be readily assessed.

Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by crazy1van on Thursday August 25, 2016 @06:55PM (#12363124)
> Their primary business model is to convince students to take out loans to pay for a white-collar education that won't make them any more employable.

I think this applies to far more schools than just private for-profits like ITT. There are many recent graduates from non-profit public schools that have mountains of debt and very little job prospects.

Re:ITT is no longer allowed to enroll students who rely on f... by naravara on Thursday August 25, 2016 @07:06PM (#12363169)
The announcements are all coming at once, but decisions like these take a long long LONG time to percolate through the federal bureaucracy. Not quite 8 years, but I would expect they've had contingencies for going down this road kicking around for at least a year or so. I don't think they're just impulsively scrambling to fulfill all their whims, they're just striking now while they have the political capital and the opposition is too distracted and demoralized to make a fuss.