News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It is time to unlink the “Backspace” – Browser Back short... by ww520 on Saturday August 20, 2016 @07:08PM (#12328683)
Is that why the Backspace key suddenly doesn't work on Chrome anymore? Annoying as hell. Who made this stupid decision?

Android has back key and home key that users hit accidentally all the times. That doesn't cause much problem. Why can't the Web apps save their state to better handle the accidental exit of the app? It's not just the backspace, Ctrl-R and Ctrl-W all exit the app.

Don't break existing functionality!!

Re:It is time to unlink the “Backspace” – Browser Back short... by galacticpony on Saturday August 20, 2016 @07:22PM (#12328735)
Overloading backspace with "go back" was a stupid decision. Undoing it was way overdue.

"Android has back key and home key that users hit accidentally all the times."

The back and home buttons are not overloaded with other meaning based on context. Android applications tend to handle accidental "back" presses gracefully. Accidental "home" presses are usually of no consequence whatsoever.

"Why can't the Web apps save their state to better handle the accidental exit of the app?"

Who cares? They don't and they won't.

"It's not just the backspace, Ctrl-R and Ctrl-W all exit the app."

It's way less likely to accidentally hit those combinations. For backspace, it happens all the time.

"Don't break existing functionality!!"

The functionality isn't broken, it's just that the few people who actually use this shortcut will have to use another shortcut now. Big Deal.

Re:It is time to unlink the “Backspace” – Browser Back short... by DHowett on Saturday August 20, 2016 @07:41PM (#12328804)
The back and home buttons are not overloaded with other meaning based on context.

Surely you jest. The back button has seen significant overhaul in the time since it was introduced; it changed from activity-to-activity navigation along the single "back stack" to a confusing, circuitous path walk between applications, their "up" stacks, their "back" stacks, and everything else under the sun. It's difficult to determine when it will take you to the previous activity or to a page you haven't seen in the days since you last launched the application you just ended up on.

If you're in a browser, the back hardware key takes you back -- until it determines that you've reached a navigation root (which might not be the earliest page in the chain), and it pops you back to the previous application or the home screen. Perhaps it closes the tab?

If the keyboard is up, it dismisses it -- unless you're in an autocorrect action (* on certain phones). Maybe it opens the keyboard, too, because it took you back to a previously focused field.

It's far from "not overloaded with other meaning based on context". It is, in fact, "entirely overloaded with other meaning; much of which is based solely on context."

Re:It is time to unlink the “Backspace” – Browser Back short... by galacticpony on Saturday August 20, 2016 @07:54PM (#12328836)
It may be confusing, but that confusing "back behavior" is the one behavior it has, even if it has changed over time.

It is not overloaded. It doesn't start deleting characters depending on where your last tap may have (accidentally) been. Well, maybe some app does that, but I hope you get my point.

Re:It is time to unlink the “Backspace” – Browser Back short... by DonHopkins on Sunday August 21, 2016 @06:46AM (#12330343)
One feature Android's back button is NOT overloaded with yet is deleting the character before the cursor, and let's keep it that way, please.
Re:It is time to unlink the “Backspace” – Browser Back short... by ww520 on Saturday August 20, 2016 @07:25PM (#12328748)
Or people can stop using Chrome.
Re:It is time to unlink the “Backspace” – Browser Back short... by Narishma on Saturday August 20, 2016 @07:33PM (#12328783)
That's what I did. I switched to Firefox when they made this change.
Re:It is time to unlink the “Backspace” – Browser Back short... by userbinator on Saturday August 20, 2016 @07:46PM (#12328814)
What happens when Firefox makes this change too? Will you move to IE or Opera? Then what if those also follow?

I elaborated more on the fallacy of "switching to another browser" more than 2 years ago, and it's still as relevant as ever: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7678583

Re:It is time to unlink the “Backspace” – Browser Back short... by Narishma on Saturday August 20, 2016 @08:00PM (#12328854)
Firefox has handled this correctly for ages. The Windows version defaults to Backspace to go back, I guess for compatibility with IE, and the Linux version doesn't. But in either case it's possible to change the behavior of the Backspace key in the options.
Re:It is time to unlink the “Backspace” – Browser Back short... by userbinator on Sunday August 21, 2016 @06:05AM (#12330248)
Firefox has removed options before, but this seems to be one of the options they haven't removed:

http://kb.mozillazine.org/Browser.backspace_action

I do wish it was more exposed though, given how many want the non-default behaviour.

Re:It is time to unlink the “Backspace” – Browser Back short... by mSparks on Saturday August 20, 2016 @07:20PM (#12328723)
Very funny seeing so called "powerusers" complain they have to unlearn perhaps the most stupid shortcut key in the history of shortcut keys, and instead use another, much more obvious shortcut key (alt + left)

and as a bonus, I just discovered the windows + left key, which is properly awesome on this shiney new(ish) xps 13 (much better than the old rotate screen functionality).

Re:It is time to unlink the “Backspace” – Browser Back short... by adiabatty on Saturday August 20, 2016 @07:27PM (#12328756)
Backspace seemed like a perfectly good shortcut in Windows Explorer to go up one directory.

Seems like it was misadapted to the browser context when it was recast as "back".

Re:It is time to unlink the “Backspace” – Browser Back short... by ww520 on Saturday August 20, 2016 @07:24PM (#12328742)
It's funny people are unwilling to learn that Alt-right after a Backspace would go back to previous page with state intact.
Re:It is time to unlink the “Backspace” – Browser Back short... by galacticpony on Saturday August 20, 2016 @07:41PM (#12328803)
It's funny that people like you are editing comments to completely change the meaning, invalidating previous replies.

Oh wait, that's not funny. That's sad.

Re:It is time to unlink the “Backspace” – Browser Back short... by ww520 on Saturday August 20, 2016 @07:55PM (#12328837)
Oh, it's accidental hitting of the Tab key and Enter key. You know. Those pesky browser developers mapped those key completely wrong back in the days. If only they unlink the Tab key and the Enter now and force people to only use the mouse click to submit, life would be so much better. /s
Re:It is time to unlink the “Backspace” – Browser Back short... by mSparks on Sunday August 21, 2016 @04:01AM (#12329934)
It's not accidental. its the "unexpected behaviour". Tab, enter etc serve exactly the same purpose all the time. Backspace doing delete one character or delete everything depending on where the mouse is pointing could probably only be beaten for stupidity if pressing the enter key while the mouse is hovering over the close button actually closed the entire browsing session.
Re:It is time to unlink the “Backspace” – Browser Back short... by viraptor on Saturday August 20, 2016 @08:26PM (#12328912)
On some websites. If they rely on loading special display state based on the anchor in the link, your previous state may be lost.
Re:It is time to unlink the “Backspace” – Browser Back short... by galacticpony on Saturday August 20, 2016 @07:26PM (#12328751)
Use the mouse to click on the back button, then.
Re:It is time to unlink the “Backspace” – Browser Back short... by ww520 on Saturday August 20, 2016 @07:28PM (#12328761)
Mouse click on back need to travel long distance.

Why can't you guys just use alt-right after a backspace to restore the previous page?

Re:It is time to unlink the “Backspace” – Browser Back short... by mSparks on Saturday August 20, 2016 @07:38PM (#12328796)
Because, as power users, who use both the keyboard and stateful pages, forward "rarely" restores the state and is technically forbidden from doing so.

So an accidental thumb tap a touchpad + trying to delete a character produces a wait for the entire app to reload and then get back to where you were - which can take minutes assuming you were lucky and said app hadn't decided to wait 30 minutes to autosave.

In fact I had turned off fast tap on the touchpad for exactly this reason, glad I can turn it back on again.

If moving the mouse to the backspace button (seriously, the whole point of keyboard shortcuts is for people typing with both hands and not using the mouse) is such a problem, clean the mouse and turn up its sensitivity.

Or better yet, get a touchscreen, you'll never want to go back to mister mouse.

Re:It is time to unlink the “Backspace” – Browser Back short... by galacticpony on Saturday August 20, 2016 @07:39PM (#12328798)
Because chances are that it doesn't work, for various reasons, some of which are outside the browser vendors control.
Re:It is time to unlink the “Backspace” – Browser Back short... by mSparks on Saturday August 20, 2016 @07:27PM (#12328757)
you mean, like, by clicking/touching the back button?

Wow, never thought that would need explaining here :(

Re:It is time to unlink the “Backspace” – Browser Back short... by jtchang on Saturday August 20, 2016 @07:14PM (#12328697)
Try to view it overall as a product decision. I don't think it is necessarily "stupid". In fact I think a lot of thought went into it. Not just someone saying "oh today I will remove the backspace functionality".

I think your arguments are sounds. Don't break existing functionality is good but you have to take it into context. Sometimes you have to in order to make the product as a whole better.

Re:It is time to unlink the “Backspace” – Browser Back short... by userbinator on Saturday August 20, 2016 @07:55PM (#12328842)
If the intent of your statement was to mimic the sort of uninformative, bland, and completely generic pseudo-palliative doublespeak that often comes from management trying to justify their ridiculous decisions, you've done a great job.

"You don't like it? Too bad, we're doing it anyway" is what such statements are actually saying.

Re:It is time to unlink the “Backspace” – Browser Back short... by viraptor on Saturday August 20, 2016 @08:56PM (#12328981)
I think you're missing the fact that it says both things. Both "we're aware you don't like it; we're doing it anyway" and "it's a product decision".

Emotionless calculation: X% people like it current backspace behaviour, Y% people use it only by accident (they may actually have telemetry to know the percentages). If they change the behaviour, Y% will be happier, which X% will split into "installed extension to revert", "won't care after a month", "switches browser". If the overall change is positive enough, they made a good product decision, even if you and I don't like the new behaviour.

Re:It is time to unlink the “Backspace” – Browser Back short... by ww520 on Saturday August 20, 2016 @07:21PM (#12328730)
It's just a lazy way to fix a perceived problem, and didn't fix it completely. The correct way is to preserve the states, like the phone apps. iOS and Android have solved it for the longest time.
Re:It is time to unlink the “Backspace” – Browser Back short... by galacticpony on Saturday August 20, 2016 @07:37PM (#12328792)
That doesn't work. The shitty web app is going to intercept the "go back" event as "destroy all user data, as intended" and you're fucked.

If this never happened to you, good for you, you lucky bastard. Now get out of the way, this is a quality of life improvement for millions of real people out there. Hard working people. Mothers and Grandmothers. Think of them while you are bothered to work around this slight inconvenience of yours.

Re:It is time to unlink the “Backspace” – Browser Back short... by tajen on Sunday August 21, 2016 @05:17AM (#12330102)
Programmers can buy an awesome mouse with a back and forward button anyway ;) and infinite wheel.
Re:It is time to unlink the “Backspace” – Browser Back short... by dgquintas on Saturday August 20, 2016 @07:16PM (#12328706)
Re:It is time to unlink the “Backspace” – Browser Back short... by DonHopkins on Sunday August 21, 2016 @06:41AM (#12330330)
Android users don't use the back button to edit text.

Some web apps can and do save their state, but not all of them do, and you can't force them to by administrative fiat, filing bugs with mozilla, huffing and puffing, or even holding your breath.

Does your phone or keyboard have dedicated Ctrl-R and Ctrl-W keys?

Re:It is time to unlink the “Backspace” – Browser Back short... by adiabatty on Saturday August 20, 2016 @07:22PM (#12328736)
Sounds like something that could be done using client-side JavaScript and LocalStorage, but I don't know offhand of any libraries that do this.