No one is claiming that there isn't engineering that needs to happen to make a digital signal reliably travel from the source to the receiver.
There is a reason why every single TIA/EIA 568 cable plant is carefully tested for things like Near End Cross Talk (NEXT), Latency, Skew, etc..
There is also a reason why there is an entire _discipline_ dedicated to ensuring that the "Digital" signal not only has a channel, but a meticulously crafted one. (See: http://www.linktionary.com/t/tia_cabling.html for details)
To reiterates the OP - there is no "Digital Signal" - signals are analog in nature, and they need an analog channel to transmit them. That analog channel needs to be engineered carefully to get the lowest EBR (Error Bit Rate) possible.
What's interesting is the Failure case of the Digital CODEC on the other end - some may reduce transmit rate in the presence of an increased EBR resulting from dropped packets. Or some may seize up and cease to function. In the degraded case, having a pristine analog channel from the transmitter to the receiver will certainly result in a better digital signal.
There is also the issue of future proofing - We're installing an entire plant of Category 6a cable right now in one of our data centers for a gigabit environment - Category 6a is like the "Monster" version of Category 5e/6 - It seems like a douchey way to do a network install, except when you consider the following - (1) this cable plant will be in use for 10-15 years, (2) We're testing a bunch of Nexus 5010s that will likely make good use of that 6a for 10 Gigabit. So, in addition to passing _today's_ signal flawlessly, it will also pass tomorrow's. This might be an important factor if your HDMI cable is being run through hard to access cabinets/walls.
Now, with all that said, it is still probably the case that the $150 Monster Cables (under normal circumstances) don't have a lower EBR than a $10 cable, but, in the face of RF interference, It may actually be a better performer. I don't know, but I wouldn't discard the possibility without a bit of research and education.
The signal running over HDMI is not packet-based. You don't have any mechanism like with TCP where packets can get dropped and resent later. So if interference causes bits to flip on an HDMI connection, you will immediately see the interference on your TV, and it won't be pretty; it would probably look something like an HDTV antenna signal that loses reception--missing or discolored chunks of the screen or sparkly pixels. The effect is immediate and disruptive.
The end result is that Monster Cable might do a better job of keeping your picture intact during a freak electrical storm, but there is no practical difference otherwise. If you are able to see a picture with HDMI, and you don't expect any wildly varying levels of RF interference in your environment, your cable is as good as anything else.
It's just a lot less likely.
A $10 cable wont fail 25 times within the lifespan of the technology it's attached to. HDMI won't exist before you get 25 failures, unless you enjoy hammering nails into you cables or some other bizarre behaviour.
One has to wonder if Monster and their retail partners would make just as much money selling them at $50, due to higher volume, with the added bonus of people not totally misleading everyone with the value proposition.
You are right, people will pay more for better quality but misleading people into believing something is better quality by outright lies actually violates most consumer protection laws. I've seen no $250 monster cables at best buy here in ontario, the most expensive I saw was a $60 10ft cable by monster, however the consumer protection act is very strong and very strict here. Best Buy has screwed me over before and the mention of the CPA to a manager gets the problem resolved quickly. It appears they know they're in the wrong in many cases, but people let them get away with it - this is usually on their extended warranties from my experience.
I'm not sure why you brought ethernet into the mix, but generally you're talking about much longer runs than HDMI and it's often not as easy to see when your are losing packets without specifically checking if you are dropping packets (IMHO poor network performance IS failing outright, but not as easily seen as a bunch of blocks on the TV). Even then, the cable you use is either delivering all the packets or it isn't (up to an acceptable level of errors/loss for the length you are running). Delivering a stronger 1/0 isn't going to change anything as long as it's strong enough for the receiver to differentiate. That's where it either works or it doesn't comes from.
Presumably on ethernet you have to decide if you want the Tx or Rx signal to have the extra digital nuance?
Really? Crap. I've just run the cable down to a back room (for an x360) - and it goes straight alongside a couple of flouro tubes.
For HDMI in particular, there's no error correction at all on the video data (though there is on the audio and control data).
So if one bit gets flipped in the video data as it goes through the cable, you're going to see that wrong bit on screen. You'd have to have an insanely high bit error rate for your eyes to notice it, but it's there, and it gradually gets worse as the error rate increases.
What could flip a bit in a cable? Any number of things. EM interference from outside a badly shielded cable. EM crosstalk between conductors inside a badly designed cable. Signal reflections at badly designed connectors. Basically anything that can happen to any other cable, whether the signal that goes over it is considered to be analog or digital.
I assume the reason HDMI applies EC to the audio and control data is that errors in those channels are more noticeable to the user, whereas errors at reasonable rates in the video will mostly sneak by.
The HDMI spec at http://www.hdmi.org/download/HDMI_Spec_1.3_GM1.pdf is a great source of information about this.
1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transition_Minimized_Differenti...
I was just making the point that there is indeed a progressive degradation in image quality with increasing error rate, even in HDMI.
All signals are analog. Every single one. (Actually, I take that back. With the exception of quantum computers, to date, all signals are analog).
A "digital" cable doesn't just work or not work. It is possible to receive spurious bit errors for many reasons. For example, you turn up the volume to your awesome surround sound speakers, which causes more current to flow through your speaker wires that happen to be running parallel to your horrible HDMI cable. The increased current causes interference in your low-power HDMI cable, causing bit errors in the transmission.
Surely that's why there's error correction layered on top?
Instead of arguing about what might happen, why not find an HDMI device that'll show you how many unrecoverable bit errors it has detected in the stream... Can't be that hard to do.
If my hard disk can send data over a tiny crappy unshielded cheap USB cable without a single bit error, I'd be willing to bet money that an HDMI cable isn't that much different.
> All signals are analog.
I see your reasoning in saying this ("on the wire" etc.); your incorrect though. Not all signals are considered analog (which is important to the point being made)
Analog signals are generally susceptible to noise because they are usually non-recoverable; error checking is hard because it is a non-discrete continuous signal.
>It is possible to receive spurious bit errors for many reasons.
Yes, which is why error checking exists in all these systems. In the context of the wire alone, yes, it is not a case of "it just works". But in the case of the communications subsystem (i.e. the transmitter, medium, receiver) it really does either work or not work :)
Ultimately thought the phrase "it's digital; either it works or it doesnt" is making no comment about the actual signal. It's really saying: an expensive cable is not, due to the digital sub-system, likely to make any difference to error rates (or more succinctly: the performance of the error correction is better than the noise affect of the transport medium)
While a image from a analog signal will only get noisier and noisier as signal quality decreases, images from a digital signal will first show artifacts and then just stop displaying altogether. That’s a rather sudden transition. One second the signal is there, the other it's gone. Something like that just doesn’t happen with analog signals. (I’m basing this on my experience with terrestrial digital broadcasting – could be totally wrong for HDMI connection but I doubt it.)
I would guess that how sudden that transition is has something to do with the error correction and the codec of the signal. How many wrong bits can the error correction reconstruct? And, as soon as the wrong bits get past the error correction, how many wrong bits can the decoder handle and still reconstruct a image (albeit one with artifacts)? It would certainly be interesting to know how that problem was solved for HDMI connections. If you know the maximum bit error rates for your cables figuring out which are the right ones should be easy, given enough testing :)
And your speakers are playing an analog signal. Cable quality matters even more there.
That's why CDs (and cellphones, modems, and countless other digital devices) use channel encoding.[1] That way you don't have to have a perfectly noise-free signal to reconstruct the original information.
I don't know that many specifics of the DVD or Blu-Ray standards, but I'd put money on them using Reed-Solomon or something similar.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reed-Solomon_error_correction#D...
(Edit: forgot footnote)
Yes. Which is why the poorly made cable can be said to not work.
> And your speakers are playing an analog signal.
Huh? I've never heard of HDMI cables capable of carrying analog sound.
My guess is that very few digital A/V systems implement this. Proof of this is the weird sound you may hear on a damaged compact disc, it half works.
Even with an error-detecting code, there comes a point where there's too many errors to know if you received a valid code word or if the errors just "canceled each other". If 000 and 111 are your only valid words, it's still possible that a 111 gets turned into a 000 (3 consecutive errors) and there's no way to know about it...
There are additional protection schemes that can detect and correct bit errors. Those are probably also run during the decoding process. The problem is that you can only detect so many wrong bits in a given word, and beyond that no correction can be made. That is probably why the damaged disc half works.
In my opinion that is just the proof that it's not as simple as "it just works or not" but rather : depending on muptiple factors such as error correction and the way your algorithm works on the receiver it may "half work" no matter what kind of cable you plug in.
I'm not an electrical engineer so I don't know what the threshold of perfection is, but if the consumer reports can't tell the fancy cable apart from the Radio Shack equivalent of two-buck chuck, I'm not going to worry about it.
On an unrelated note: this is a listing on amazon for 6 feet of digital audio cable for over a thousand dollars. Read the comments. Comic gold. http://www.amazon.com/Denon-AKDL1-Dedicated-Link-Cable/dp/B0...
True that's why I reject TVs with a video chipset, I want a TV and a DVD player that uses valves for the video processing.
I wonder how big an MPEG-2 decoder in valves would be?
If the >6 feet cheap cable you bought doesn't work properly then it is faulty and you can get a refund.
No, they are not. And the difference between blue (0026FF) and purple (8026FF) is a 1 bit error.
You will see an image, but not the image your DVD told your TV to display.
edit: This comment makes a lot less sense with the deleted comment removed.
Through the principle of superposition, if you transmit a 0 with X watts, and I transmit a 1 with X watts, our combined signal will be somewhere in the middle, which can cause a bit flip.
I am not talking about voltage drop from end to end, which is a separate issue. I am talking about interference occurring adjacent to any point on the cable that you pick.
Analog is different. The signal is itself the image, so a poor signal = poor image.
MAYBE if you have a projector projecting onto a movie theater screen will a better HDMI cable matter... maybe? because of bandwidth limitations if the sender is smart enough it might send info at a lower resolution. Other than that I can't see theoretically why a good HDMI cable will help.
Also on my 42'' tv, I've yet to be shown a performance improvement when connecting my XBOX 360 via component or hdmi. It looks identical. And if HDMI is better than component, then I don't see a reason why you would ever need a good HDMI cable unless you are a movie theater and the theoretical problem does exist.
Edit regarding bit errors... Lets assume that the cable you bought is a good quality cable. By good quality I mean most seem to be shielded and not cut and no shorts. This is a reasonable expectation. I've yet to see an argument for buying more expensive super gold plated uber network cables. Hey why is your network cable that handles SO MUCH DATA not gold plated shielded etc.?
If you want to operate a faster network, or one in a harsh environment, you will be using shielded cables with gold plates and more twists per inch.
"Digital" signals are analog signals, but the only difference is that they are restricted to being above or below some threshold. But around that threshold there is a gray area where you can't really tell whether your signal will be interpreted as 1 or 0.
I am not defending the need for high-end HDMI cables. But saying "It's digital so don't worry" is wrong.
There are reasons that "digital" cables use twisted pair. Wow, even some "digital" cable standards specify the number of twists per inch required for reliable operation. And wow, some cable standards even specify shielded cable is required. I wonder why.
Here is a fun exercise for those that think "digital" signals don't need engineering steps to protect signal integrity: build all of your cables (or PCBs for that matter) with straight signals and you will have an excellent time trying to debug why your communications don't work. Bonus fun for making the cable length 1/4 of your signal wavelength.