News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Linus Torvalds still wants Linux to take over the desktop by ivoras on Saturday August 13, 2016 @08:45AM (#12281253)
> Despite the fact that I'm known for sometimes not being very polite to some of the desktop UI people, because I want to get my work done. Pretty is not my primary thing. I actually am very happy with the Linux desktop, and I started the project for my own needs, and my needs are very much fulfilled.

Pretty much sums up why it won't happen until someone starts imitating Steve Jobs and DICTATING how The Desktop should look like. And that means more pretty than functional.

Re:Linus Torvalds still wants Linux to take over the desktop by afarrell on Saturday August 13, 2016 @09:18AM (#12281353)
> that means more pretty than functional.

Nope. I left the Linux desktop for OSX not because of aesthetics but because of the freedom from frustration that OS X gave me. Design isn't about making things more pretty, it is about improving the way a system works where the human part of it meets the machine part of it.

Linux distros just haven't put in the man-hours to make it a functional desktop for many.

Re:Linus Torvalds still wants Linux to take over the desktop by ywecur on Saturday August 13, 2016 @09:27AM (#12281399)
I don't think this is the problem at all. Ubuntu, for example, is perfectly usable and a very good alternative to Windows.

The main problem, I'd say, is that there really isn't much of a reason to switch. People who buy a computer don't have any incentive to go through the with hassle.

If computers came with Ubuntu pre-installed I'm sure people would use those without a second thought.

Re:Linus Torvalds still wants Linux to take over the desktop by afarrell on Saturday August 13, 2016 @09:39AM (#12281450)
Perhaps desktop Ubuntu has indeed gotten significantly better over the past 3 years since I switched to OSX?
Re:Linus Torvalds still wants Linux to take over the desktop by ywecur on Saturday August 13, 2016 @09:42AM (#12281463)
Install Virtualbox and try it out. I'd say it's gotten way better.
Re:Linus Torvalds still wants Linux to take over the desktop by 0xmohit on Saturday August 13, 2016 @11:58AM (#12281915)
Yes, it has gotten much better without a doubt.

However, the package management still needs to improve. One realizes that upon upgrading from one Ubuntu release to the other particularly if you have a bunch of software installed from PPAs. It would be unreasonable to expect a typical user to be able to fix the problems that it leads to.

While `apt-get` is great, you realize the limitations when you need to resort to `dpkg` when the package management is left in a broken state due to the occasional mess created upon removing a package.

I wish somebody from Canonical were looking at this thread.

Re:Linus Torvalds still wants Linux to take over the desktop by Shivetya on Saturday August 13, 2016 @09:24AM (#12281382)
a while back, years ago, I looked at switching to Linux but too many times instead of implementing a consistent interface and action set they would ape another OS (usually Windows) but only partially which leads to frustration as it almost works...

I am not sure the desktop needs conquering, we have more than one option and Linux won't make it unless it can get apps that people just have to have

Re:Linus Torvalds still wants Linux to take over the desktop by afarrell on Saturday August 13, 2016 @09:28AM (#12281404)
> unless it can get apps that people just have to have.

Which is hard for it to get. Developing an app for desktop Linux means targeting a small group of people who are willing to endure frustration in order to run code whose source is available. Unless you are have some other revenue stream besides your customer, you can't make it more than a hobby.

Re:Linus Torvalds still wants Linux to take over the desktop by vanderZwan on Saturday August 13, 2016 @08:54AM (#12281276)
> Pretty much sums up why it won't happen until someone starts imitating Steve Jobs and DICTATING how The Desktop should look like.

But we have plenty of distros where the people behind it do just that?

Re:Linus Torvalds still wants Linux to take over the desktop by melling on Saturday August 13, 2016 @09:10AM (#12281321)
They all suck. Maybe we need another distro?

Wow, this is such a difficult problem. Let's just get back to bragging about how many file systems Linux supports. "And how many file systems do Windows and Mac OS support?" "Yuck, yuck, yuck"

Re:Linus Torvalds still wants Linux to take over the desktop by detaro on Saturday August 13, 2016 @09:21AM (#12281371)
You do realize that's something the author ("thought leader") wrote and not a quote?
Re:Linus Torvalds still wants Linux to take over the desktop by melling on Saturday August 13, 2016 @09:36AM (#12281437)
Yes, i do understand that was written by the author. That's why i used quotes.
Re:Linus Torvalds still wants Linux to take over the desktop by detaro on Saturday August 13, 2016 @09:39AM (#12281451)
ok, I just found it strange that in the discussion about an article about Linus the most-quoted bit is something he didn't say.
Re:Linus Torvalds still wants Linux to take over the desktop by lkiux on Saturday August 13, 2016 @09:17AM (#12281349)
I started with amiga, windows (from 3.1 to 2000) and I've been using Linux as my main development and OS since more than 10 years now. I no longer use any other OS. I consider myself lucky I basically never interact with windows anymore. For the cross-os work that I have to do, python with qt covers me to the point that I just perform final testing. Amazing.

I used OSX around 10.4 for about four years, because it seemed like the best of both worlds: nice UX with an unix backend. That is, indeed, why OSX appealed to most geeks, right?

I became tired of OSX after a couple of years. What apple dictates might look good, but it's far from functional. It's eye candy with little substance. On the surface is pretty, but Finder under OSX was essentially a crapshot. Under Linux I could have virtual desktops, but not under OSX (that only arrived years later). Tweaking, even slightly, any default behavior is hard. That is also the reason why Gnome doesn't appeal to me. The basic OSX desktop doesn't offer anything beyond a current Gnome release. Things change if you need commercial programs, but the desktop itself is not inferior in both behavior, looks and general interaction. Gnome is, performance wise, slower, but the people that use gnome do not seem to notice.

Not to mention that what every developer does on OSX is install an external package manager, and by and large replace every single userland utility and library with an up-to-date variant from Brew, MacPorts, etc. This was a massive burden. Any linux distribution is far superior in that regard.

I don't think that Gnome today is far away from OSX. Sometimes OSX is smoother, sometimes Gnome actually is.

But, my desktop today is nowhere even remotely comparable to what gnome offers. I'm using a tiling window manager with pretty much any program customized to the point of being unrecognizable. It's incredibly efficient compared to a pretty desktop. I'm aggressively disabling eye candy and animations everywhere. I'm often using CLI versions of GUI programs because the actual user interface is superior. Some TUI programs have no rivals in GUI form.

The fact is, is that if you use your computer professionally and switch to linux, you start to understand what user interface efficiency is. At some point, eye candy becomes a second, third, fourth priority. This doesn't mean the program is any less usable though. I still value presentation. I'll take a nice UI any day over a crappy one, given the interaction is the same.

I've witnessed the same happening to many people that I've suggested linux. Many of those still use windows or mac, but with completely different habits.

Re:Linus Torvalds still wants Linux to take over the desktop by stinos on Saturday August 13, 2016 @09:34AM (#12281424)
The fact is, if you use your computer professionally and switch to linux, you start to understand what user interface efficiency is

That highly depends on what you do with your computer professionally though. So it might be a fact for some, but completely false for others.

I'm using a tiling window manager with pretty much any program customized to the point of being unrecognizable.

I played that game for years but gave up afterwards. Maybe I was doing it wrong but I spent just too much time to my liking on it. Now I'm more in a mindest of 'if you can't build me software which I can use almost as-is, I'll look for something else'. Not always ideal either and sometimes there are no alternatives so you'r stuck with crap after all. And yeah maybe I'm not using my computer as efficiently as possible (looking at some collegues though, I'm a wizard compared to their 'let's use a mouse for everything and double-clik to make sure it hits'-style), but I'm getting work done.

Re:Linus Torvalds still wants Linux to take over the desktop by profsnuggles on Saturday August 13, 2016 @12:08PM (#12281949)
Obviously do whatever works best for you. You don't have to spend a lot of time configuring your system to end up with something unrecognizable though. I've been running linux full time since 2003 and my $HOME directory can be traced directly back to then. Things start out as-is but then something would be mildly annoying so I'd spend 5 minutes reading the man page and change a setting. After a decade of that my environment evolved to suit me perfectly and even someone who knows the software I use would have trouble sitting in front of my PC and using it. However I never really spent days configuring anything. It was more of an accident.
Re:Linus Torvalds still wants Linux to take over the desktop by soulbadguy on Saturday August 13, 2016 @12:05PM (#12281936)
>The fact is, is that if you use your computer professionally and switch to linux, you start to understand what user interface efficiency is. At some point, eye candy becomes a second, third, fourth priority. This doesn't mean the program is any less usable though. I still value presentation. I'll take a nice UI any day over a crappy one, given the interaction is the same.

Very true. Before starting my current position, i was a Visual studio die hard.While i still think it's the best single IDE, one thing thing i notice using linux CLI and vim in particular how much faster is it to do thing. And i seem to remember better how to do stuff instead of being lost in menus .

I think the current trend in UX is toward making them more intuitive (which i think linux/CLI could read do a be job at), but sadly we are sacrificing efficiency in the process.

Re:Linus Torvalds still wants Linux to take over the desktop by DanBC on Saturday August 13, 2016 @09:21AM (#12281364)
I agree with your post.

> Tweaking, even slightly, any default behavior is hard.

I understand why they want to restrict tweaking - it makes support easier. Hide the tweaks in config files, make it clear that you're not going to support tweaked systems. But don't ban tweaks.

Re:Linus Torvalds still wants Linux to take over the desktop by K_REY_C on Saturday August 13, 2016 @09:38AM (#12281442)
> I'm often using CLI versions of GUI programs because the actual user interface is superior. Some TUI programs have no rivals in GUI form.

I have my own list here, but I'm curious to hear yours to potentially add to my list. Thanks for the great post.

Re:Linus Torvalds still wants Linux to take over the desktop by open-source-ux on Saturday August 13, 2016 @09:36AM (#12281436)
"And that means more pretty than functional."

You can have aesthetically pleasing and functional at the same time - they aren't mutually exclusive. Making the interface attractive doesn't mean 'dumbing down' the interface either.

Ubuntu is arguably the most popular Linux Desktop distribution and their model of UX development is to have a dedicated UX team designing the Ubuntu desktop experience. Presumably they read feedback from the community of Ubuntu users but ultimately, they make the final call on UX decisions.

The model for open source code contributions just doesn't work for visual and interaction design. (Or if it does, I've yet to see a successful example that wasn't an exception rather than the rule).

When there are too many participants in the visual and interaction design of a program or OS, you end up with a project pulled in every direction and pleasing to no-one. But if you go the opposite route and limit design decisions to a dedicated UX team or sole designer, you end up generating resentment from contributors or users who feel their input is being ignored.

Re:Linus Torvalds still wants Linux to take over the desktop by soulbadguy on Saturday August 13, 2016 @11:48AM (#12281875)
This is a very good point which i think is not really discuss much in the community.

UX/UI work is very different that base dev. work, and maybe should be approach differently.

My other though would that maybe the talent pool of UX designer is just too small in the Open Source world, and that most OSS tend not to treat UX design as a first class requirement.

Re:Linus Torvalds still wants Linux to take over the desktop by addicted on Saturday August 13, 2016 @09:12AM (#12281328)
I'm not sure if that will help. But if the Linux world did want a Steve Jobs like individual, it has one in Mark Shuttleworth.
Re:Linus Torvalds still wants Linux to take over the desktop by rwallace on Saturday August 13, 2016 @09:34AM (#12281425)
> And that means more pretty than functional.

Not really. I mean if you think about it, the original Macintosh looked like shit even compared to its predecessors; what was it, something like a nine inch screen in black and white, even greyscale it could only do with migraine-inducing dithering. But it could do desktop publishing when pretty much nothing else could, and Macintosh programs mostly used a consistent interface so you could figure out how to use them, and these functional advantages got people to buy the computer.

Linux Mint looks as pretty as Windows or Mac OS, and Ubuntu would if they'd change the weird purple color scheme, but what happens when a client sends you an Excel spreadsheet? What happens when you want to plug in a second monitor? What happens when you want to play a triple-A video game? What's the battery life like on a laptop? Those are functional issues that need to be solved.

Re:Linus Torvalds still wants Linux to take over the desktop by Shorel on Sunday August 14, 2016 @11:47AM (#12286012)
> but what happens when a client sends you an Excel spreadsheet?

WPS Office covers me on that area. I use spreadsheets every week.

> What happens when you want to plug in a second monitor?

It works. Beautifully. In fact, I got a Powerpoint presentation, opened it with WPS, and the presentation was shown in the second display, while showing the notes and the rest of the 'WPS Presentation' in the laptop display.

> What happens when you want to play a triple-A video game?

Now this depends more on how many triple-A video games get sold in Steam for Linux than anything else. The technology is already there. The market is still small.

> What's the battery life like on a laptop?

This is a serious issue, and it needs to be solved.