News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dyson sphere by TheOtherHobbes on Tuesday August 09, 2016 @10:08PM (#12259056)
I can imagine a Dyson Swarm, although intuitively I wouldn't be surprised if there's some kind of computational limit created by the fact that the bigger a swarm gets, the more computation is needed to keep it gravitationally stable

But I think a Dyson Sphere - something as solid as a planet, but with a radius the size of a planetary orbit - is physically impossible, even with unimagined magic alien super-materials.

The physical configuration of a Dyson sphere is inherently unstable. It's the astronomical equivalent of balancing a pencil on its tip. Any asymmetry at all - including proper motion and radiational asymmetry from the star - would need active correction. Without it, the entire structure will fall apart catastrophically. (It might take a while, but there's not much point building something that big unless it lasts.)

Active correction implies movement, which is not what you want on an inhabitable surface, or even on a computing machine.

And it probably wouldn't be much use as a computing machine. The bigger the system, the longer it takes information to propagate across it. A system with propagation delays on the order of minutes isn't going to run nearly as fast as its energy budget might suggest.

That's still true even if you imagine some kind of ultimate limit system where the computation happens directly on a spherical spacetime shell instead of on tangible hardware.

I suppose it's possible that if it turns out that KIC 8462852 is showing evidence of alien action, the aliens are somehow dimming the star directly instead of by building screens around it.

Re:Dyson sphere by pierrec on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @12:32AM (#12259515)
This is adressed directly in TFA:

In fictional accounts, the Dyson-sphere concept is often interpreted as an artificial hollow sphere of matter around a star. This perception is based on a literal interpretation of Dyson's original short paper introducing the concept. In response to letters prompted by this paper, Dyson replied, "A solid shell or ring surrounding a star is mechanically impossible. The form of 'biosphere' which I envisaged consists of a loose collection or swarm of objects traveling on independent orbits around the star."

As I see it, "Dyson sphere" designates the broader category of such devices. You're saying a literal Dyson sphere would be in a perfectly metastable configuration, which is true, though I suppose a solid structure resembling a sphere might be engineered to be in a stable configuration and have some tolerance to perturbation (unlikely though it may be).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metastability

And in the case of a computer, there's no reason to assume that the processing would take place all over the sphere, which is just an energy harvesting tool. The energy would be directed to wherever it's needed, for example an AMD graphics card. I also like the idea of dimming the star directly, though I can't begin to imagine the processes involved. Or rather, I can begin to imagine them but I can't come up with something that holds together even remotely.

Re:Dyson sphere by Aeolun on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @12:32AM (#12259514)
Seems to me that if you have the energy output of an entire star, you have quite enough energy to keep your shell balanced around the center of it.

Even with those magic reaction-less engines they are working on now you could keep the thing in place by just spacing engines on the outside at the correct distance.

I imagine the movement would have to be insanely slow to prevent the entire structure from collapsing though, and I wonder whether a solar flare wouldn't put out so much energy/movement that you'd spent years correcting it.

Re:Dyson sphere by XorNot on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @06:31AM (#12260634)
You don't need engines. You have a giant fusion reactor. You just need exhaust vents you can open asymmetrically.
Re:Dyson sphere by fizx on Tuesday August 09, 2016 @10:50PM (#12259208)
> The physical configuration of a Dyson sphere is inherently unstable. It's the astronomical equivalent of balancing a pencil on its tip.

No, it's neutral--the equivalent of keeping a ball on a table.

Re:Dyson sphere by traviscj on Wednesday August 10, 2016 @09:42AM (#12261623)
No. Consider a small perturbation (i.e. Poking) the ball on your table. At least for a small enough poke and/or a big enough table, friction slows down the ball again, and it stops.

Now consider a small poke on a Dyson sphere that was (before the poke) perfectly balanced. The part that got poked is slightly closer to the sun, and the point opposite is slightly further away. So the closer part has some gravitational force acting on it, and the opposite part has a lower gravitational force acting on it: O(1/(r-e)^2) vs O(1/(r+e)^2). The imbalance causes a net gravitational force in the direction of the poke, which eventually crashes into the sun.