News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:American truck drivers could lose their jobs to robots by golemotron on Sunday August 07, 2016 @06:05PM (#12243947)
Maybe it's just me but I'm getting tired of UBI being put forward as a realistic answer to technological displacement of workers. The most immediate problem would be getting it through legislatures without loopholes that undercut its purpose as a replacement for all other redistributions. That simply never happens, particularly in the US.

The next problem is that no one seems to appreciate how incompatible it is with open borders in a world of nation-states. The latter is particularly telling since advocates of UBI are often advocates of less restrictive immigration across the world, yet they don't seem to see the problem. It's an indication of how ungrounded the discussion about UBI is right now.

Re:American truck drivers could lose their jobs to robots by k__ on Sunday August 07, 2016 @06:11PM (#12243977)
I have the feeling, alle the counter arguments simply boil down to "all humans are lazy and won't work anymore if we don't force them" which is a pretty dull view on humanity.
Re:American truck drivers could lose their jobs to robots by JumpCrisscross on Sunday August 07, 2016 @07:39PM (#12244402)
> a pretty dull view on [sic] humanity

Matter can't travel faster than c. Thermodynamics is a bitch.

These theories are as intractable as they are annoying. They are not proven beyond doubt. But before launching a venture in contradiction to them, evidence must be mounted. "It feels right" isn't a scientific basis for policy.