News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by themgt on Saturday August 06, 2016 @11:34AM (#12238420)
I am more and more on board with the Lee Smolin "singular universe" concept. To me it's very analogous to the Darwinian revolution in biology. Physicists are still pre-Darwin, unable to understand why the universe looks so "un-natural". It's the watchmaker analogy for physical laws and constants, and the answer is the laws look so well-tuned because the laws and particles themselves "evolved" and tuned themselves into the stable universe we see.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by justinpombrio on Saturday August 06, 2016 @11:42AM (#12238449)
Evolution depends on a means of variation (in biology, random mutation), and on a measure of fitness (in biology, number of children). What would the means of variation and the measure of fitness be for laws of physics?
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by Retric on Saturday August 06, 2016 @12:11PM (#12238587)
Different abstraction level. Evolution provides a framework for biology which works at every level. EX: Why does the human optic nerve cause a blind spot? At the detail level biology is filled with a huge range of less than optimal solutions, but when 'it worked' is the only limitation things click.

Physics has a lot of data and several models that work really well, but they don't really fit into a single coherent system. QM vs Relativity etc. The density needed to form a black hole decreases linearly with radius, sho why is the universe not one?

Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by Black-Plaid on Sunday August 07, 2016 @04:24AM (#12241474)
> The density needed to form a black hole decreases linearly with radius, sho why is the universe not one?

I feel like this explains it pretty well.

https://medium.com/starts-with-a-bang/ask-ethan-50-why-didnt...

tl;dr: Schwarzschild’s solution is a static one, meaning that the metric of space does not evolve as time progresses.

Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by TeMPOraL on Saturday August 06, 2016 @12:10PM (#12238584)
I think more accurately, a measure of fitness includes a fitness filter (in biology, death). This raises another question - what would be the fitness filter for the universe?
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by tinco on Saturday August 06, 2016 @12:28PM (#12238667)
Instability. Just like in biology, death is not a true optimization, it is greedy for local maximums. How many bacteria have evolved specifically to thrive on you, even though within a couple decades surely you'll be no more, leading them to extinction?

So would universes come in existance with varying degrees of stability. No one has to say 'this is a stable universe'. We can say 'this universe has been stable for quite a long while'. Long enough to spawn us and the very interesting universe around us.

Just like in biology, merely the fact that we could be here, is the reason we're here.

Of course, that's assuming that for some reason big bangs with varying values for universal constants are a constant occurrence. Unfortunately, this is not likely to be something we're ever going to be able to measure/observe. Though there are/have been (theoretical) experiments to see if universal constants really are constant. If they're not, that would be a nice indicator that the universe really is unstable enough to create stability.

Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by ivoras on Saturday August 06, 2016 @12:39PM (#12238719)
As a poster said, the fitness filter may as well be "whatever works" in the sense that it's so rare to stumble upon stable combinations of energy, space and time (if they are at all separate concepts) that whatever works, continues existing, and if circumstances allow, spreads.

It's actually quite a neat concept, if very similar to the anthropic principle. Unfortunately, it offers no predictions.

Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by adrianN on Saturday August 06, 2016 @12:14PM (#12238603)
Entities capable of asking this question?
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by TeMPOraL on Saturday August 06, 2016 @12:24PM (#12238645)
Does lack of such entities kill a universe? If not, then we're just reducing the problem to anthropic principle here.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by ivoras on Saturday August 06, 2016 @12:45PM (#12238744)
It's very likely that there's no higher purpose in any universe's existence - a/the universe could just be a set of random "rules and laws" which happen to not die out as soon as they are randomly created.

Of course verifying this probably requires that we inspect most of our universe directly...

Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by specialist on Saturday August 06, 2016 @12:18PM (#12238622)
Repeating what I've gleened from my extensive reading of sci-fi:

New child universes are spawned with new values for various constants. Stable arrangements (combinations) persist, spawning new grandchildren universes. Unstable arrangements blink out of existence.

Edit: I want to apologize for volunteering an answer to the question of how natural selection might work at a cosmic level with some speculation I've read. I regret the error.

Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by api on Saturday August 06, 2016 @11:50AM (#12238483)
Evolved how? According to what selection criterion? There has to be an environment or you just get a random walk across state space. Evolution is a learning process that transfers information from the environment into the evolving system as such information pertains to an implied goal function.

Selection need not be wholly external. It can be emergent from within the system, as it is with life viewed collectively as it manifests ecology and coevolution. But in the end there is still the basic criterion of mortality and reproductive fitness that serves as a top level goal function to orient the entire system. There is the environment and the implied goal of genetic survival.

What might the top level goal function be for an evolving universe? And where would it come from? How can "all that there is" possess an environment?

Of course in an eternal universe model with changing physical laws you could have a random walk across state space, but this amounts to saying the digits of pi contain Shakespeare. They do but it doesn't tell us any more than infinite multiverse theories. In fact we might call this an infinite multiverse theory linearized across time instead of parallelized across dimensions.

Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by thaumasiotes on Saturday August 06, 2016 @11:53AM (#12238500)
> But in the end there is still the basic criterion of mortality and reproductive fitness that serves as a top level goal function to orient the entire system.

Reproductive fitness is necessary to apply the concept of evolution, but mortality isn't.

Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by api on Saturday August 06, 2016 @11:57AM (#12238528)
That is true if you have infinite capacity, such as a hypothetical biology in an infinite environment with infinite resources. Is he proposing infinite universes? In that case I'm not sure I see the difference between this and multiverse theories.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by thaumasiotes on Monday August 08, 2016 @11:59AM (#12248751)
No, it's always true. If you don't have infinite capacity, then you will have mortality, but that's a separate issue.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by ansible on Saturday August 06, 2016 @11:44AM (#12238461)
I'm more inclined to go with the anthropic principle, where we're observing this universe with these particular physical constants because the other universes (with slightly different constants) are a largely undifferentiated soup of basic particles.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by unit91 on Saturday August 06, 2016 @12:06PM (#12238568)
This doesn't really address the core issue, though. The anthropic principle may tell us why we're capable of observing the universe, but it doesn't tell us why there is something to observe (instead of nothing), and why the laws and fundamental constants are the way they are.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by wodenokoto on Saturday August 06, 2016 @12:13PM (#12238600)
Isn't there some basic question in physics that simply can't be answered, similarly to how axioms in math simply can't be proved.

> but it doesn't tell us why there is something to > observe (instead of nothing), and why the laws and > fundamental constants are the way they are.

I'm no physicist, but I simply cannot imagine candidate answers to such questions.

Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by unit91 on Saturday August 06, 2016 @12:59PM (#12238825)
> Isn't there some basic question in physics that simply can't be answered, similarly to how axioms in math simply can't be proved.

See above. My comment was in response to ansible's reply to themgt. themgt was asking why the universe looks the way it does, and ansible responded with the anthropic principle. The problem with ansible's line of thinking is that the anthropic principle tells me a great deal about me (why I can exist and observe), but not much about the universe, which was themgt's question.

In response to your broader objection that there are some basic questions in physics that can't be answered, let me point out that the entire project of physics is to seek material causes for the structure of the universe. So if nature is all that exists, and the universe itself only has material causes, what are those causes? The entire field of cosmology dedicated to answering exactly this question, and many believe it's capable of doing so.

As far as Leibniz's famous question "why is there something rather than nothing?" is concerned: admittedly this is a metaphysical question, not a physical question. Still, I think we owe it to ourselves to answer this question too, and not simply dismiss it out of hand.

> I'm no physicist, but I simply cannot imagine candidate answers to such questions.

Even if this is true, it tells us something about you but not about the universe. By analogy, somehow my body "knew" to put my liver in my torso, not in my neck. I cannot begin to imagine what physical processes led to the proper placement of my liver, but we certainly shouldn't take this to mean there are no reasons.

Moreover, we shouldn't sell ourselves short in these matters. Undoubtedly, given enough study I could discover what others have said about organ placement during embryonic development and have a fairly robust understanding of the best of our knowledge regarding the topic. The same is true of cosmology and philosophy.

Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by ansible on Saturday August 06, 2016 @01:39PM (#12239004)
As far as Leibniz's famous question "why is there something rather than nothing?" is concerned: admittedly this is a metaphysical question, not a physical question. Still, I think we owe it to ourselves to answer this question too, and not simply dismiss it out of hand.

That is the big, big question.

On the one hand, I can easily imaging that there is nothing, nowhere, ever.

But on the other hand, doesn't it necessarily seem the case that there should be something existing somewhere, for at least some time? How can nothing exist... ever?

Even after all this time, I still can't wrap my head around this question.

Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by unit91 on Saturday August 06, 2016 @02:11PM (#12239131)
> But on the other hand, doesn't it necessarily seem the case that there should be something existing somewhere, for at least some time? How can nothing exist... ever?

Funny you mention it, this was Leibniz's exact dilemma. He realized there must be two classes of existence: necessary (things that must exist), and contingent (things that don't have to exist). Not many things must exist, if you really think about it, and he came to the conclusion that God is the most reasonable explanation for why any contingent thing exists at all.

Worth your 5 minutes, if you're interested in this question:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FPCzEP0oD7I

If you're interested enough to dedicate 100 minutes, here's a 3 part discussion with responses to objections.

https://youtu.be/EfpAqqadQVA?list=PLIpO3BUiq2IFMS3AP3Yi2oDfc...

https://youtu.be/NgXML-wI1tQ?list=PLIpO3BUiq2IFMS3AP3Yi2oDfc...

https://youtu.be/Y4J5vR3rgp4?list=PLIpO3BUiq2IFMS3AP3Yi2oDfc...

Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by cauterized on Saturday August 06, 2016 @11:46AM (#12238472)
Why can't it be both?
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by ansible on Saturday August 06, 2016 @11:54AM (#12238502)
Aside from the high temperature of the early universe, we haven't seen evidence that the physical laws are changing over time, much less 'adapting' in some way. What's the pressure for them to change? What's the reward for them to stay stable now?
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by ivoras on Saturday August 06, 2016 @12:50PM (#12238765)
On the other hand, we haven't directly observed the universe for a long enough time (billions of years) to say it's not changing, so we simply don't know. We don't even know if the universe is homogeneous.

For example, all we know about distant stars is complete conjecture and approximation based on testing various ideas to see which one fits. We simply don't know if "gravity" is exactly the same for all of them. Small variations of G would still light them up.

Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by ansible on Saturday August 06, 2016 @01:33PM (#12238968)
We've been looking back in time billions of years, because we look at objects billions of light-years away. If there's anything amiss about how gravity or whatever isn't working like it used to, that's news to me. I haven't heard of even a hint or something like that.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by cauterized on Tuesday August 09, 2016 @03:02PM (#12256980)
I was more asking why the two hypotheses have to be mutually exclusive.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by MOARDONGZPLZ on Saturday August 06, 2016 @11:40AM (#12238444)
Nothing can really be ruled out at this point, and there are all kinds of theories. Most seem to agree at this point that the Level I Multiverse is a thing because it's existence directly flows from the concept of an infinite inflationary universe. That's a theory which would lead to us existing here because we're in a universe where the physical laws worked out in such a way that we could be here. I've never heard of the concept that the laws "evolved" to what they are now, I'll certainly read up on it.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by theprotocol on Saturday August 06, 2016 @11:38AM (#12238439)
Are laws not simply constantly applicable rules, existing outside of spacetime? How would such a thing evolve?
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by brigweofnewub on Saturday August 06, 2016 @12:31PM (#12238678)
in The Singular Universe Smolin argues that we should drop the assumption of unchanging laws outside of time and instead assume that Time is primary and the laws evolve as a function of the state of the Universe
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by brigweofnewub on Saturday August 06, 2016 @03:08PM (#12239425)
(i.e. that the laws of physics are inside the universe)
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by theprotocol on Saturday August 06, 2016 @04:53PM (#12239875)
Interesting, I'll have to read more about this. Thanks for the response.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by bmh_ca on Saturday August 06, 2016 @11:43AM (#12238457)
Survival of the fittest universe.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by blueprint on Saturday August 06, 2016 @01:04PM (#12238854)
Since you seem like a sensible person, I'll tell you what I have to deliver.

This world exists according to a singular, fundamental principle which is that a thing that comes into existence once makes results on the basis of what is inside of itself from the past, and makes itself exist continuously by repeating its activities endlessly. A thing's very activities become the cause through which it makes itself come into being in the future.

So, seeing the world from this principle, we can find two or three laws: The law of cause and effect, and the law of existing by changing through activities (repetition). Rather than coming up with theory and finding evidence, we can take any sample from the entire world and verify this theory as their method of operation.

(If you're wondering about the question of infinitely regressing this statement to the origin of the world, I can say that the same explanation applies. The world itself also repeats (ends and begins again) periodically and also displays the entire process of evolution according to the law of cause and effect.)

When people really understand this principle and see things in the world on the principle, they come to realize the fundamental problem in physics is gravity. People don't really understand what general relativity means. It's sort of like how most people don't know that Schrödinger was joking when he talked about not knowing if the cat would be alive or dead. That's why physics has gone on a massive detour over the last 100 years. Unless physicists solve the problem of gravity, humanity won't be able to recognize the cause of and survive through the collapse of the Earth's ecosystem. Things are more serious than people realize - even after all these years. It sounds fantastical to people who haven't confirmed, but what I point out here is undeniable after confirmation of facts. So, from one perspective, it's as if physicists don't have the willpower or courage to admit the reality of the situation today, which is what fundamentally prevents them from pursuing the way to confirm about gravity - it would result in them confronting today's reality. Realistically, it's a hard burden for anyone to bear. That's one of the reasons why a person who says what I say here is rarely welcomed.

Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by mcguire on Saturday August 06, 2016 @06:01PM (#12240098)
"...a thing that comes into existence once makes results on the basis of what is inside of itself from the past, and makes itself exist continuously by repeating its activities endlessly. A thing's very activities become the cause through which it makes itself come into being in the future."

Are you saying that a thing exists before it comes into existence?

Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by blueprint on Saturday August 06, 2016 @06:16PM (#12240139)
No. It means that the world contains the meaning, like an encoding, for something that can come into existence according to the law of cause and effect.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by blueprint on Saturday August 06, 2016 @01:13PM (#12238881)
Downvotes prove my point. ;) People who told the truth to awaken humanity were always treated terribly. Anyone who is able to claim differently has never studied the most fundamental and important aspects of human history and can be confirmed to be a person who isn't actually able to understand the very truth.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by gjm11 on Saturday August 06, 2016 @02:21PM (#12239209)
> Downvotes prove my point.

"They laughed at Columbus, they laughed at Fulton, they laughed at the Wright brothers. But they also laughed at Bozo the Clown."

Yeah, maybe you're getting downvoted because the sheeple here can't cope with the audacity of your message. But maybe, just maybe, you're getting downvoted for making grandiose claims with nothing to back them up.

Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by blueprint on Saturday August 06, 2016 @02:25PM (#12239233)
You've suggested that I made a claim with nothing to back it up. I challenge you to name just one thing from what I said that you can show has no proof.

Funny enough, the article itself was about how physicists cannot find the proof to sustain their development of further theory. Doesn't it seem even slightly suspicious to you that the person who points out that fact about those scientists is being accused of the very thing they do?

You intimate that I do the same kinds of things as a clown. The only reason you can suggest that is that you exclude everything I said aside from a few words. That's quite obviously a deception tactic and if you included actual proof in your own words, you would have had to reference the rest of my words. But you can't do that because it won't support your point.

In fact, if you can disprove anything I said, I'll wire you all of my money immediately. Furthermore, if you can show that anything I've said cannot be verified, I'll do the same. Or if you prefer, you can take my head. But I'm quite certain that will never happen.

By the way, your reaction is also the proof of what I say. The problem is you don't understand what I said. It would be better to admit that instead of attacking one of the people who can solve your questions.

Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by CJefferson on Saturday August 06, 2016 @04:03PM (#12239650)
> I challenge you to name just one thing from what I said that you can show has no proof.

Do you mean you want me to say you haven't proved it here (which is obvious, you proved nothing), or that you don't have proof you aren't showing us?

I can't show you don't have a hidden proof. You can't show I don't have a unicorn.

The quote about clowns he gave you is a general quote. basically, just because people disagree with you / call you a fool / downvote you doesn't make you right. Sometimes it means you are right, but more often it means you are wrong.

When you say you will wire me all your money if I can prove anything you said wrong, what would convince you something you said was wrong?

I can imagine what a disproof of Newtown's laws of physics, or quantum mechanics, or general relativity wrong would look like. These are well-defined mathematical models, so just show something in the real world not following those mathematical rules. I'm not sure how I could prove your system is "wrong", as it doesn't predict anything.

I can use Newtown's laws to predict how my car behaves. I can use quantum physics to predict how my CPU will behave. I can use general relativity to predict mercury's orbit. What does your system allow me to predict accurately?

Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by blueprint on Saturday August 06, 2016 @04:17PM (#12239704)
Like I said, it explains the entire world of phenomena. I can say you didn't understand my explanation if you assert it makes no predictive claims.

Are you open-minded enough to consider places where you're mistaken? You contradict yourself a few times. This is not intended as ad hominem but as an indicator that you may want to reconsider whether your judgement can be correct. One example of a few: In the beginning of your comment you said that someone calling me a fool doesn't make me right. Agreed. But you contradict yourself by saying that it does sometimes make me right. That's definitely not true.

I'm going to skip replying to the rest of what you said because I know it was not based on having understood what I said. I'm ready to weather the obvious conclusion you're going to draw from that.

Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by CJefferson on Saturday August 06, 2016 @04:31PM (#12239761)
Honestly, if you want people to take your claims seriously, you are going to have to get better at explaining them.

I clearly am going to decide you are talking nonsense, as you suggest, as you have still never said anything understandable. You say "you didn't understand my explanation if you assert it makes no predictive claims.".

Why don't you just make a predictive claim that could be tested?

Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by dc2 on Saturday August 06, 2016 @04:00PM (#12239626)
People like you are toxic, and cannot be argued with.
Re:The LHC “nightmare scenario” has come true by blueprint on Saturday August 06, 2016 @04:19PM (#12239709)
The only things you know are that you (a) can't disprove what I said but that (b) you also don't find enough through which to prove it. The latter can be caused by me spouting nonsense, but it can also be caused by you not understanding what I said well enough. Nevertheless, you make judgements and indictments without admitting that you don't actually have any intention to (a) check and improve your understanding of what I said and (b) check the veracity of what I said.

In other words, you're acting on the basis of what you do not know and informing others of your feelings. That tells me all I need to know about your ability to judge toxicity from teaching. It's never easy for people to learn something new. But you are only aware of how it feels to you, and you don't have the ability to distinguish whether it makes you change for the better or worse.