Re:Why swearing is good for you
by Al-Khwarizmi on Friday August 05, 2016 @05:07AM
(#12230900)
It's as if it had just been reduced to a sequence of syllables
And for all practical purposes, it has. Sometimes, sentences used very often lose their meaning and become interjections. "Goodbye" comes from "God be with ye", and of course it's used by atheists as well.
>'Oh My God' was insanely popular in the 1990s even amongst people who had no belief in a deity, which really annoyed me even though I don't identify as a Christian
OMG is not a swear word though -- it's just an expression of awe/amazement/surprise/etc.
It's an oath, isn't it? So literally, at least, it is swearing.
http://images-cdn.9gag.com/photo/a5PmrLq_700b.jpg
(Or that would be, if it even was an oath. But "Oh my god" is NOT an oath. "On my God", or "In the name of my god" would be that).
Oh, really? I thought it was the "_my_ God" part that was swearing an oath.
Not every phrase with "my god" in it is an oath.
Unless if you swear (promise to do something) to your god (or on your god's name).
OMG is not that different from "oh man!" in use. It's for surprise. How does "swearing an oath" would be related to being surprised?
I see "Oh, _my_ God" as a statement of allegiance, as opposed to just, say, "Oh, God."
I see. I see it more as kind of call (in a "vocative case").
In the sense that you find something surprising, and ask for your God (as when you fear something, etc).
I sometimes think we need religion to make sure our words keep their meaning. And I am not religious.
Re:Why swearing is good for you
by wastedhours on Friday August 05, 2016 @07:38AM
(#12231450)
Why? Language evolves naturally over time, trying to hold back that process seems a little regressive. The obvious example is the word "cool". I'm not sure there's any real benefit in holding its meaning to be "something that's cold".
I even remember the non-Human character Kira in Deep Space 9 being assigned it in dialogue, it was really jarring. It's as if it had just been reduced to a sequence of syllables and the writers didn't think about what it meant.