News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:More microbursts are coming by taliesinb on Sunday July 31, 2016 @01:25PM (#12197832)
Reminds me of this essay I read yesterday, which painted a pretty startling picture of how insane things could get:

http://www.flassbeck-economics.com/how-climate-change-is-rap...

Here's a snippet showing how rapidly predictions are escalating:

* Late 2007: The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) announces that the planet will see a one degree Celsius temperature increase due to climate change by 2100.

* Late 2008: The Hadley Centre for Meteorological Research predicts a 2C increase by 2100.

* Mid-2009: The U.N. Environment Programme predicts a 3.5C increase by 2100. Such an increase would remove habitat for human beings on this planet, as nearly all the plankton in the oceans would be destroyed, and associated temperature swings would kill off many land plants. Humans have never lived on a planet at 3.5C above baseline.

* October 2009: The Hadley Centre for Meteorological Research releases an updated prediction, suggesting a 4C temperature increase by 2060.

* November 2009: The Global Carbon Project, which monitors the global carbon cycle, and the Copenhagen Diagnosis, a climate science report, predict 6C and 7C temperature increases, respectively, by 2100.

* December 2010: The U.N. Environment Programme predicts up to a 5C increase by 2050.

* 2012: The conservative International Energy Agency’s World Energy Outlook report for that year states that we are on track to reach a 2C increase by 2017.

* November 2013: The International Energy Agency predicts a 3.5C increase by 2035.

Re:More microbursts are coming by learc83 on Sunday July 31, 2016 @02:42PM (#12198230)
Picking and choosing predictions in this manner to make it look like they have all been steadily increasing is misleading.

Some of the initial predictions in the late 80s were for up to 6c by 2100.

The last IPCC report I saw predicted an increase of between 0.3C and 0.7C by 2035 with around 0.4C being the most likely. There is little support for numbers anywhere near as high as 3.5C by 2035.

Re:More microbursts are coming by taliesinb on Sunday July 31, 2016 @03:00PM (#12198325)
> Picking and choosing predictions in this manner to make it look like they have all been steadily increasing is misleading.

Those predictions are all sourced in the original article. As you say, though, pointing out a trend in the predictions from a set of scenarios doesn't on its own tell you anything.

> The last IPCC report I read predicted an increase of between 0.3C and 0.7C by 2035 with around 0.4C being the most likely. Nowhere near the the 3.5C by 2035. There is very little consensus for numbers that high.

Was that the fifth assessment report?

And where does the consensus 'currently' cluster for 2035? What climate models would be included? Under what emissions scenarios? I'm not too familiar with the state of the current literature.

Re:More microbursts are coming by semi-extrinsic on Sunday July 31, 2016 @03:58PM (#12198555)
Here is a graph with various model predictions towards 2100, under a "business as usual" scenario. As you can see, even the most pessimistic models are below 2C by 2050. I have no idea where 3.5C by 2035 came from, no models predict such a shocking rate. (We were only up ~0.7C over the last century.) Also note that none of these models reproduce the last decade's global warming hiatus; given that constraint, temperature predictions for 2100 will be slightly cooler.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Global_Warming_Predicti...

Re:More microbursts are coming by marvin on Sunday July 31, 2016 @04:59PM (#12198824)
This discussion just confuses me completely. I'm a scientist (of the mathematical variety) and absolutely of the thought that human-made climate change is the largest current threat to human civilization.

But here we have at least seven different claims that vary wildly, from "catastrophe practically guaranteed" to "this problem can be handled in a straightforward way if we focus".

Given that I'm not a climate scientist, who should I listen to?

Re:More microbursts are coming by moultano on Sunday July 31, 2016 @05:11PM (#12198888)
Some have criticized the IPCC report as too conservative/optimistic, but it is as close to a consensus document as exists.
Re:More microbursts are coming by marvin on Monday August 01, 2016 @02:36AM (#12200562)
Thanks, that's helpful. Is the IPCC criticism gathered in one place somewhere, or would it require reading a lot of different sources?
Re:More microbursts are coming by int_19h on Sunday July 31, 2016 @05:42PM (#12199030)
My understanding is that there's a fairly wide range of assumptions that can underlie a given model, which depend on what we will actually do about this. For example, how do you estimate CO2 output over the course of the next century? Do you assume that it remains at current levels, or keeps growing at the same rate it has been so far, or that whatever treaties were signed that promise to reduce it actually will?
Re:More microbursts are coming by greydius on Sunday July 31, 2016 @06:03PM (#12199127)
Just listen to whoever says the thing you want to hear.

But keep this in mind: sometimes people say things to advance their own agenda.

Re:More microbursts are coming by yequalsx on Sunday July 31, 2016 @07:43PM (#12199459)
The person you responded to asked a serious question. Your answer is in no way helpful or insightful.
Re:More microbursts are coming by my_first_acct on Sunday July 31, 2016 @04:06PM (#12198589)
There's something odd about the list of escalating predictions, this one in particular:

"November 2013: The International Energy Agency predicts a 3.5C increase by 2035."

If you follow the link, it points to a Christian Science Monitor article from 2010 (not 2013), which confirms that the IEA did make such a prediction, but in 2010.

Also, this line: "2012: The conservative International Energy Agency’s World Energy Outlook report for that year states that we are on track to reach a 2C increase by 2017".

Are we still on track?

Re:More microbursts are coming by taliesinb on Sunday July 31, 2016 @04:44PM (#12198753)
Yup, that is odd. IEA appears to be off the rails here. Making the adjective "conservative" a strange choice.
Re:More microbursts are coming by cryoshon on Sunday July 31, 2016 @01:47PM (#12197942)
humanity in general is in deep shit

and yet, we waste (and make no mistake, it is a complete waste) our best minds and the bulk of our resources on making people click ads or other similar excursions in nihilism

what is needed is a multinational manhattan project for climate change... instead, we move the deck chairs around on the titanic. it's clear we can expect no leadership from governments or corporations on this issue.

Re:More microbursts are coming by sp527 on Sunday July 31, 2016 @02:01PM (#12198004)
I'm a computer scientist and software engineer with experience at some of the largest companies whose businesses are about making people click on ads. I now work as an independent contractor and part time on my own startups. Give me a living wage and tell me how I can help and I'm in. (srs)

I think there are a lot of people who might feel the same way.

Re:More microbursts are coming by taliesinb on Sunday July 31, 2016 @02:18PM (#12198101)
I feel the same way.

As history has shown, when presented with an existential threat to the group, humans are often willing to drop their immediate plans and sign up to fight. Perhaps we're wired that way.

Bring on UBI. And bring on a global 'war economy' to transition us to a zero carbon energy infrastructure.

Re:More microbursts are coming by cryoshon on Sunday July 31, 2016 @02:24PM (#12198130)
>And bring on a global 'war economy' to transition us to a zero carbon energy infrastructure.

yes, this is what is needed. unfortunately, the imaginations of our "leaders" are far too small-- too small to see beyond the horizon of their next election.

if we want to continue existing, they've gotta go.

Re:More microbursts are coming by cel1ne on Sunday July 31, 2016 @03:45PM (#12198498)
> if we want to continue existing, they've gotta go.

what do you mean by that?

Re:More microbursts are coming by cryoshon on Sunday July 31, 2016 @08:32PM (#12199599)
we can't afford bureaucrats prevaricating and ultimately doing nothing on the issue of climate change; they have to be removed from power such that we can effect a future where we survive.
Re:More microbursts are coming by cel1ne on Monday August 01, 2016 @03:45AM (#12200772)
While I understand where that notion comes from, I don't see an answer.

Generally the people who are in favour of "removing people from power" aren't the ones who like to take part in the arduous and complex task of rebuilding governance, which is the real issue.

The overthrowing is easy. The making-it-better-afterwards is so hard, you should skip the overthrowing step and work at that problem right away.

Sadly there are no fire-and-forget answers for issues like this.

Re:More microbursts are coming by jsz0 on Monday August 01, 2016 @12:25AM (#12200191)
Overthrowing democratically elected governments is not a carbon neutral process.
Re:More microbursts are coming by cryoshon on Sunday July 31, 2016 @02:13PM (#12198080)
step one is gaining political power, so find a campaign team and run on the platform of fixing climate change

step one will take a good while

then, step two: carbon tax at a rapacious rate. this will likely cause economic meltdown, which is unavoidable if we want to survive.

step three is developing active methods of scrubbing our atmosphere of the shit we've polluted it with

inventing that will take a while also

anyways, let's get going.

Re:More microbursts are coming by edoceo on Sunday July 31, 2016 @02:22PM (#12198119)
Basic Income Guarantee?
Re:More microbursts are coming by zdkl on Sunday July 31, 2016 @03:30PM (#12198452)
That's a great point for basic income, but I don't think it wouldn't be the main factor, behind a variation on apathy like we currently have.
Re:More microbursts are coming by meddlepal on Sunday July 31, 2016 @01:59PM (#12197991)
The problem is that it's very hard to get people to give a shit about macro problems like climate change. People generally own care about a narrow set of issues between the age of 20 and the 55/60 years most of us survive after that.

Another problem is that democracies are poorly setup for solving this problem. Democracy responds mostly to the needs of now without concern for the future (different politicians problem, different generation etc, kick the football down the field because someone else can deal with it once I've got mine.)

So yea, we're fucked. This along with the coming robot/AI revolution we are likely to see in the middle or later part of the century creates a pretty bleak future for human beings.

Re:More microbursts are coming by int_19h on Sunday July 31, 2016 @05:47PM (#12199059)
Manhattan Project, and similar massive infrastructure/engineering/scientific developments, are possible because there is a single government that can drive them.

To do something like that on a multinational scale, you'll need One World Government. Otherwise you'll just have a bunch of nations bickering over who is paying for what, and who is gaining what in return, without a final arbiter to break up ties and deadlocks and say "okay, you all had a say, now we're doing it this way".

Re:More microbursts are coming by analog31 on Sunday July 31, 2016 @05:42PM (#12199033)
Let's re-think whether those people are really our best minds.
Re:More microbursts are coming by AWildDHHAppears on Sunday July 31, 2016 @01:55PM (#12197970)
America can reduce its carbon footprint by 5%, save 300,000 lives/year, and save about $400 Billion dollars a year without spending a nickel.

If the 66% of the American population that's obese or overweight would just stop overeating, all of the above could happen overnight.

Re:More microbursts are coming by d0mine on Sunday July 31, 2016 @02:23PM (#12198129)
It is a red herring.

It reminds me how soda companies shift blame on their customers: "exercise more, don't blame our sugar water". Actually, what and how much you eat/drink is much more important than the exercise, to fight obesity.

Another (BS) example: "shower less to save water" -- compare the agricultural water consumption (giant) vs. the household needs (negligible by comparison).

If a corporation destroys the planet; its products should include the price today (e.g., via a tax): the problem fixes itself.

Re:More microbursts are coming by AWildDHHAppears on Sunday July 31, 2016 @03:49PM (#12198522)
Nobody ever said exercise more. (That may be bad advice for obese people too, because it will make them hungrier and they may injure their already strained joints). Plus, it won't help the environment. (That's the subject here!)

Just eat less!

Re:More microbursts are coming by d0mine on Sunday July 31, 2016 @04:05PM (#12198584)
In case you are not playing stupid intentionally, my point: blame corporations, not people: tax corporations that contribute to the global warming today (that may have a real effect even if it is almost impossible to implement -- it should be easier with each more frequent natural disaster) instead of suggesting "eat less" to the whole population (that won't have nearly the same effect and it is even more impossible to implement).
Re:More microbursts are coming by rbanffy on Monday August 01, 2016 @04:04AM (#12200829)
He actually has a point. While corporations have their share of responsibility, so do individuals who choose the quick rewards of sugar/sodium/fat.

Not that asking an addict to quit is really helpful...

Re:More microbursts are coming by honkhonkpants on Sunday July 31, 2016 @01:59PM (#12197990)
Such a great idea. There was also a recent proposal to just breed humans to be smaller: http://www.smatthewliao.com/2012/02/09/human-engineering-and...
Re:More microbursts are coming by AWildDHHAppears on Sunday July 31, 2016 @02:02PM (#12198008)
You missed the point. The majority of Americans _eat too much_. Why can't they just eat less and save the planet?
Re:More microbursts are coming by dpark on Sunday July 31, 2016 @02:21PM (#12198115)
Yeah, because eating less is easy. If only overweight people knew that it would have a small impact on global warming, I'm sure they'd suddenly be able to cut back, even though personal health, physical attractiveness, and day to day comfort haven't been enough to get them to eat less. But yeah, a small potential impact on global warming will probably do it.
Re:More microbursts are coming by honkhonkpants on Sunday July 31, 2016 @03:28PM (#12198444)
There's lots of "modest proposals" out there that would be just as effective as yours. Want to cut 5% of human energy consumption? Round up 1% of Americans and just shoot them. Mission accomplished! And why stop at only 5%? If we identified the 10% most intelligent existing humans and euthanize the rest, all our problems (aside from moral and ethical topics) are solved.
Re:More microbursts are coming by AWildDHHAppears on Sunday July 31, 2016 @03:48PM (#12198513)
Wow! So telling people not to overeat--to save resources--is the same as rounding up people and shooting them! You YCombinator people sure are nuts!

Yet you'll gladly tell people to drive less, or to change their lightbulbs to LEDs, things that could either greatly inconvenience people or cost money. Eating less is free!

Re:More microbursts are coming by gnaritas on Sunday July 31, 2016 @06:04PM (#12199130)
> So telling people not to overeat--to save resources--is the same as rounding up people and shooting them

Yes, they're both equally ridiculous impractical and unrealistic solutions to a problem. That's the point he's making, you seem to be missing it.

Re:More microbursts are coming by FeepingCreature on Sunday July 31, 2016 @02:20PM (#12198107)
Well, why can't they?

(That's not rhetorical.)

Re:More microbursts are coming by IanCal on Sunday July 31, 2016 @03:04PM (#12198346)
[reading before posting, apologies for a rambling reply]

Personally, I see it as a very similar question as "why don't people just stop taking drug X" (to avoid side arguments, substitute X for a drug you see significantly altering people's lives for what you see as negatively).

Weight loss is typically very simple, but that gets confused with easy. really quite minor behavioural differences can result in fairly extreme weight changes over time.

Perhaps it's simply that people are prioritising short term things over long term. Short term the beer I'm drinking is nice, relaxing and great. Long term it's negative since it's at least taking me over my calorie limit for the day.

The risks are vague and hard to intrinsically grasp, the benefits are simple and local.

I think there are also significant effects of what people expect. With so many people overweight, what people expect has changed. I don't have statistics, but I've heard a large number of people complain about their families declaring them "anorexic" while still being quite overweight or even obese. If you're surrounded by people telling you to have more, having an expectation that people should be larger, and many external sources telling you that losing weight is complex (requiring weird and extreme approaches)

Fundamentally, we've not really evolved to deal with an environment of near infinite food available through very little activity (not suggesting work isn't hard for many, but we can sit down all day and easily get several times our required calorie intake). We have evolved in environments where we needed to get as much as we could from our surroundings, and it was hard to come by.

Re:More microbursts are coming by vertex-four on Sunday July 31, 2016 @03:56PM (#12198544)
Food is also one of the most common ways of dealing with stress, depression, or all sorts of mental disorders, minor and major. It's readily available and socially acceptable, and most people associate good feelings with many foods that are particularly high in calories. For some people, it's one of the only consistently rewarding things in their day.
Re:More microbursts are coming by trav4225 on Sunday July 31, 2016 @02:46PM (#12198252)
How much is too much? Not everybody prioritizes health, enjoyment, etc. in the same way. It's easy to fall into the trap of assuming that our personal values are shared by all.

If you were simply expressing your opinion, that's perfectly fine. I only wrote this because it appeared to me as through you were attempting to portray what you said as an objective fact -- which it is not.

:)

Re:More microbursts are coming by cmarschner on Sunday July 31, 2016 @03:32PM (#12198457)
An easy measure would be: if all people on the planet would consume resources just like the people in a particular country, the number of planets needed to feed and entertain them should still be less than one. By that measure, I think Europe is somewhere between 2 and 3 and the US is beyond 4.
Re:More microbursts are coming by pitay on Monday August 01, 2016 @12:19AM (#12200169)
That measure doesn't deal with over population, which is a huge thing, and more likely to run out of control than consumption per person in a country. Although individual consumption is important as well.

For instance New Delhi is far more polluted than any US city, although energy consumption per capita may be 16 times more in the US than India.

In my opinion a measure like energy or resource use per square kilometer of land is a much better measure. Although it has its problems as well, such as land quality varying greatly between different areas, which would change the number of people an area of land could support in a sustainable way.

Sources: Population and energy usage per country http://www.worldpopulationbalance.org/population_energy . This uses Population Reference Bureau; 2012 World Population Data Sheet for population information and uses U.S. Energy Information Administration 2012 for energy use information. This is on the bottom of the page linked. For the Pollution index, it is Pollution Index 2016 Mid Year http://www.numbeo.com/pollution/rankings.jsp .

Disclaimer: I am not an expert in the slightest.

Re:More microbursts are coming by trav4225 on Monday August 01, 2016 @11:42AM (#12203265)
I wonder if those estimates attempt to account for supply and demand...
Re:More microbursts are coming by bcook on Sunday July 31, 2016 @02:43PM (#12198234)
and why don't all (other) addicts just stop being addicts?

Given the chance, humanity naturally overuses... which is a problem, but not a wholly American problem.

Re:More microbursts are coming by nerdponx on Sunday July 31, 2016 @02:23PM (#12198123)
Because the commercial food business is all-powerful in Washington.
Re:More microbursts are coming by mark_l_watson on Sunday July 31, 2016 @03:56PM (#12198546)
Agree! Also raising beef uses a huge amount of water and energy compared to supporting a vegetarian diet. Also, cow and pig farts might have an adverse affect.
Re:More microbursts are coming by tzs on Sunday July 31, 2016 @10:10PM (#12199863)
When you lose weight, guess where the "lost" weight goes? Most people guess incorrectly that you lose it via urination, defecation, or sweat.

Where it actually goes is into exhaled CO2.

So your proposal is that to fight global warming, fat Americans should massively release CO2 into the atmosphere? :-)

Re:More microbursts are coming by refurb on Sunday July 31, 2016 @11:20PM (#12200026)
You raise an interesting point! How much carbon could be captured by obese humans? Assuming they don't decompose? It would be some interesting math!
Re:More microbursts are coming by WorldMaker on Monday August 01, 2016 @12:01PM (#12203455)
Reminds me that there have been some strange studies looking at the correlation of obesity and climate change. There was at least one presumably quack study that implied the obesity epidemic across all species could be a very weird natural reaction to increased carbon in the atmosphere and that carbon capture could actually be the real subconscious intent and that it may be a causal relationship.

(I don't think that is actually the case, but it's a fun weird theory to think about. Much like the FSM theory that lack of pirates has driven global warming.)

Re:More microbursts are coming by trentmb on Sunday July 31, 2016 @03:17PM (#12198397)
I propose we eat 300k fat people each year.
Re:More microbursts are coming by mirimir on Sunday July 31, 2016 @02:54PM (#12198299)
I'm not optimistic. As climate becomes less favorable, the rich will focus capital, energy and resources on mitigation. For themselves, I mean. The poor will just starve and die.
Re:More microbursts are coming by cmarschner on Sunday July 31, 2016 @03:28PM (#12198445)
No, they will move towards the rich (and cooler) countries. They already do. what we are seeing on the coastd of Europe is only the humble beginning. Wait until the Arab countries become uninhabitable, then 500 million prople will have to look for a new place.
Re:More microbursts are coming by eatbitseveryday on Sunday July 31, 2016 @11:40PM (#12200067)
These lands aren't already mostly uninhabitable, being deserts? Most people in Egypt live near the river system, and in UAE they live on the coast. These countries are already much hotter than typical western countries, yet many rich live there. I think it would take more than "a little too hot" to make them move out, such as specific business reasons like no more oil.
Re:More microbursts are coming by semi-extrinsic on Sunday July 31, 2016 @03:41PM (#12198487)
How will the climate become less favorable for the rich? The areas most affected are disproportionally third world countries. In the west, food prices might rise some, but the rich won't care. Sea levels will rise, but it will be happening slowly (up to 1000 years for Greenland to melt completely), and governments will be mitigating that, so the rich won't be paying much there either. If you live in London, Paris, Rome, even on Manhattan, the 7 meter sea level rise won't mean anything. It won't do anything. Long Island and Jersey will need significantly mitigation though, as will areas of Palo Alto and Menlo Park, like the Googleplex, but we have hundreds of years to build those dikes, and we will easily be able to predict when and where they are needed.
Re:More microbursts are coming by int_19h on Sunday July 31, 2016 @05:44PM (#12199040)
It's not just water level that affects quality of life. If, say, LA and SF become as hot as Dubai, I would imagine a lot of wealthy people who currently live there would start seeking a more comfortable place to live in. South Europe would be similarly affected.
Re:More microbursts are coming by greydius on Sunday July 31, 2016 @06:08PM (#12199157)
Not disagreeing, but Dubai is not a good example since Dubai is as hot as Dubai, and a lot of extremely wealthy people still live there.
Re:More microbursts are coming by mirimir on Monday August 01, 2016 @05:34AM (#12201113)
True. But they mostly live indoors, except at night. And it takes a lot of energy for air conditioning! See http://gulfnews.com/business/economy/uae-s-per-capita-energy...
Re:More microbursts are coming by int_19h on Tuesday August 02, 2016 @10:20PM (#12215127)
How many of those people are wealthy by virtue of being the citizens there? How many people who are _not_ from UAE choose to live there?
Re:More microbursts are coming by mirimir on Monday August 01, 2016 @05:23AM (#12201077)
Once aquifers are sucked dry, farming in semi-arid areas will crash. Rich will spend more for water, food, air conditioning, security, etc. Maybe they'll decide to move. But yes, they'll be fine.
Re:More microbursts are coming by semi-extrinsic on Monday August 01, 2016 @11:36AM (#12203210)
Why will global warming cause the aquifers to be sucked dry? On the contrary, don't we expect global warming to cause more precipitation, thus less load on aquifers?
Re:More microbursts are coming by mirimir on Monday August 01, 2016 @02:12PM (#12204602)
While it's true that there will be more precipitation overall, models predict that the distribution will change. For example, northern US and Canada will be wetter, especially in winter, but central US will be dryer, especially in summer. The Ogallala aquifer is already depleted.
Re:More microbursts are coming by ams6110 on Sunday July 31, 2016 @03:22PM (#12198417)
Which is no different than how things have worked at any point in the past. And yet civilization advances.
Re:More microbursts are coming by berkeleynerd on Sunday July 31, 2016 @03:29PM (#12198451)
Yes, except thanks to the wild card that is technology, seemingly towards its own destruction.
Re:More microbursts are coming by liviu- on Sunday July 31, 2016 @02:03PM (#12198017)
So the International Energy Agency predicts that by 2035 humans may disappear? What about more recent predictions?
Re:More microbursts are coming by taliesinb on Sunday July 31, 2016 @02:45PM (#12198246)
The IEA may not sure the view of the author that "such an increase would remove habitat for human beings on this planet".

The current https://www.iea.org/publications/scenariosandprojections/ claims that "business as usual" would yield almost 4C by 2100 and 5.5C long term. Not sure how that squares with claim by author or which scenario they were referring to.

The big question I have with many of the scenarios (I think IPCC ones fall into this camp) is how much worse they will get when methane clathrates release is included. I'm not too familiar with the literature, maybe others know how well clathrate release is understood and what contribution it makes under various scenarios.