A natural feeling of "saturation" that comes with it doesn't really seem surprising, racist or anything like that.
It's about 25%. If you look into the results of the original popular initiative you will see that the cantons with the highest levels of immigration voted the most strongly against the initiative: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swiss_immigration_referendum,_...
You might think that makes sense, but consider that if you are not Swiss you do not get a vote. The path to naturalisation in Switzerland takes at least ten years, which in some way explains the high relative level of foreigners in the country. There are second and third generation immigrants here who are still not Swiss due to the nature of the process.
Switzerland needs its Ausländer/Étrangers/Stranieri/Esters, a large part of the economy here would collapse otherwise.
This appears to be the pattern most places, including Brittain and the US. If this indicates that people learn to live with each other, then it's probably a good sign.
The odd country out seems to be Sweden, where the "not much immigrated to" countryside seems to be more positive towards immigration than the urban areas. I'm still not quite sure why. Maybe they haven't been as good at distributing the immigration across the country?
My personal opinion, possibly misjudged given my age (mid thirties), is that the problems the UK is seeing (especially in the areas that voted leave) stem from the actions of the Thatcher government and have little to do with any of the arguments that passport-waving Farage and his ilk put forward.
The ripples from the destruction of industry in the north, the deregulation of the financial markets, and the tearing down of the unions are felt strongly thirty years later, especially in those areas that voted to leave.
I'm just flabbergasted that a generation that was screwed over thirty years ago would repeat the same mistake, and potentially screw over their own offspring's future. They ate up the arguments that somehow the local problems are all the fault of an external entity, and seemed to suffer from acute memory loss.
[1] https://leejo.github.io/2016/06/22/two_weeks_to_decide/ (the title is a lie, i was always going to vote remain).
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Labour_Party_(UK)#Internal_con...
Yes, because now the ability to control that program lies with the UE. That's how it works.
>The Swiss people voted for something, it would be unconstitutional and even illegal not to do it now.
Nobody is saying they shouldn't be allowed to do it, it's just that doing it violates an agreement Switzerland made with the EU and there are consequences for that. Consequences that were clear to people who bothered to learn about the issue before voting. This isn't some crazy contrived plot to exert control over the Swiss by the EU, it's just the Swiss having to face the consequences of their actions.
Look, just because someone has the ability and legal foundation to do something doesn't mean they aren't a complete douche if they do it. If I was the hackernews admin and would delete all your posts because I disagree with you, that would be a douche thing to do but I would have every right to do it. Similarly, I don't claim the EU does something that is forbidden, but everyone should unite and stand up to manipulative bullying strategies like that.
However, I do want to point out something peculiar, an assumption underlying your opinion.
> "every single shred of independence and autonomy".
> "The issue is that the EU bullies and pushes everyone in Europe around at its whim"
Why is that a problem? Are the people who govern the EU (or any large government structure) not the same as you are? Do you think they are malicious and exploitive? The loss of your independence is just arbitrary lines. It has happened before, it will happen again. Pushing policy is what it means to govern, people in the opposition will always decry the decisions of those currently behind the wheel by definition.
Maybe there is something to be said about undemocratic properties in the current EU structure, I wouldn't know.
A governing body could just as easily be ignorant or wasteful and the country ends up in the same position. Either way, you get rid of the cancer.
Also, pardon my ignorance on the topic, but other than the free movement treaty (and the others) that Switzerland signed itself, how does the EU control the country of Switzerland?
As a swiss this saddens me but I think the EU is right to use the big guns because free movement is the foundation of the EU. If the swiss get an exception it would be hard to deny it to other states. "Unfair ! I also want to restrict the number of polish going in my country"
I think that the swiss government should focus on punishing salary-dumping because that's what most people are afraid of when they think of foreigners: he's going to do my job for less money. I heard it's a big problem in Tessin.
Firms should be able to hire anyone they want but they should give them a swiss salary, swiss or not and pay a big fine if they don't.
How exactly would you "punish" this (or otherwise prevent it)? I mean, it happens due to market dynamics, so it's either salary dumping, no free movement of people, or no capitalism!
This. I hope all countries will take this challenge seriously. It ties in with the whole challenge of inequality splitting our societies.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erasmus_Programme
Ironically, "the programme is named after the Dutch philosopher Desiderius Erasmus of Rotterdam, known as an opponent of dogmatism, who lived and worked in many places in Europe to expand his knowledge and gain new insights, and who left his fortune to the University of Basel in Switzerland.[1] At the same time, ERASMUS is a backronym meaning European Region Action Scheme for the Mobility of University Students.[1]"
Is Switzerland wants to take part in an exchange program with different rules, it should negotiate one with the interested parties (EU and others).
And don't get me started on respecting the EU rules. Let's talk about that once Germany starts paying big fines to the EU for violating its rules on running trade surpluses, shall we?
I quite agree that Switzerland and other countries should start bypassing the EU though. Erasmus is, at least, not one of those things where the EU demands exclusivity.
Actually, the EU is happy to negotiate treaties with countries outside the EU. Conditions usually include free movement of people. If the country negotiating does not agree with these terms, the treaty is void. It can try to negatiate a special treaty, but the EU is not usually inclined to do that, for multiple reasons, not least to avoid setting precedents, to avoid effort duplicity, etc
EDIT: I forgot the main reason, from my point of view. The EU has been built with the person, the human being, at its center, with the idea that we all have the same rights. And one important right is freedom of movement. A union were goods, money and services can freely move, but people are forbidden to do so is not worth the trouble.
Look at CETA or TTIP.
Not sure what your point is, but anyway it seems that the EU has already made up his mind on this matter and requires free movement of people for Switzerland to get access to the economic area.
But no, that's not what happens. The EU uses this as another bargaining chip, so it has the students and university faculty in its pockets. The strategy is obvious, and anyone who does not look through it is blind. No, don't sell Switzerland out. Autonomy is much more valuable than a couple of financial and contractual bribes.
Therefore, no, keeping the exchange program without EU membership and free movement is not easy, if possible at all.
The people voted to restrict the number of foreigners that can go in the country which is against the treaty of free movement that Switzerland signed with the EU which probably (it has been a while since I looked up the consequences) make lots if not all the other treaties that Switzerland and the EU signed invalid. For example the EU is threatening to cut research funding among other stuff like partnership in space exploration...
The people that were against the law didn't think it would pass and didn't really fight against it and now Switzerland and the EU have until the end of year to agree on something. I wonder how it will pan out... Maybe a revote ? You probably didn't understand the consequences of this law. Are you sure you want this ?