News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:The Last Florida Indians Will Now Die: The Westward Pligh... by dang on Sunday July 31, 2016 @02:09PM (#12198055)
We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12194863 and marked it off-topic.
Re:The Last Florida Indians Will Now Die: The Westward Pligh... by karmajunkie on Saturday July 30, 2016 @06:19PM (#12194902)
1) Please cite your statistical evidence.

2) Non-christian does not mean non-religious. Indigenous communities the world over have their own religions.

Re:The Last Florida Indians Will Now Die: The Westward Pligh... by reitanqild on Saturday July 30, 2016 @06:25PM (#12194915)
> 1) Please cite your statistical evidence.

Mao, Stalin, Lenin, Pol Pot; all of them worse than everything even the Catholic church ever did.

Re:The Last Florida Indians Will Now Die: The Westward Pligh... by enraged_camel on Saturday July 30, 2016 @09:53PM (#12195384)
Counterpoint 1: Christian Crusades. There were seven major ones and a bunch of minor ones. All of them resulted in untold amounts of death and misery, all in the name of religion.

Counterpoint 2: On the side of Islam, there were an equal amount of major wars conducted in the name of religion, both against polytheists but also other monotheists. The Ottoman Empire by itself conquered large parts of three continents in the name of Islam and subjugated tens of millions of people.

Mao, Stalin, Lenin and Pol Pot may have killed a greater number of people at the aggregate, but that's only because the world's population was a lot larger by that point and there were more people to kill. That doesn't mean that religion is somehow a pacifying factor against violence.

Re:The Last Florida Indians Will Now Die: The Westward Pligh... by fennecfoxen on Sunday July 31, 2016 @06:15AM (#12196330)
The Christian Crusades were primarily a consequence of a complex geopolitical situation, a multi-century of clash of empires (in particular the Ottomans, Ummayads and the Byzantines) across multiple theatres from modern Spain to Jerusalem and beyond.

The real role that Christianity had to play in this clash was as the great unifier for a fractious western Europe wreaked by petty kings squabbling among themselves, turning their violence outward against common geopolitical foes rather than inward against each other. A pagan Europe would still have seen similar wars, it just would have had a harder time unifying to repel the encroachment of the eastern empires.

Re:The Last Florida Indians Will Now Die: The Westward Pligh... by EGreg on Sunday July 31, 2016 @02:17AM (#12195957)
Subjugating people is bad. Outright genocide of massive proportions is even worse. The common factor here is empires, not religion. The Roman Empire for instance brutally killed many people. The Byzantines killed eg nearly all the Samaritans. The Spanish conquistadors brutally killed and destroyed entire civilizations eg Cortez and the Aztecs (who by the way were an empire themselves). The British and French were slightly less destructive than the Spanish but wound up taking the entire North American continent from the natives, whom they either killed by the sword or disease. Same with the aboriginals in Australia and Maori in New Zealand.

True, religion can play a big part. The Ottomans massacred the Greeks and Armenians, together with some Kurdish help. The Crusaders massacred everyone including Christians and Jews.

With Mao, Lenin, Pol Pot etc. you had a Communist revolution that was basically a mind virus which didn't care about the human population nearly as much as its own propagation. Most people died from the collectivization of farms, however many others died from political repression.

So no, it's not just Islam or religions. It's ideologies and empires.

Look today at how ATHEIST China's government persecutes Falun Gong and carries out extrajudicial killins and torture. That's not in Stalin's time, that was a couple years ago. Are you saying atheist governments can't have a terrible human rights record?

Re:The Last Florida Indians Will Now Die: The Westward Pligh... by vacri on Sunday July 31, 2016 @03:36AM (#12196099)
The Maori in New Zealand fought the English to a standstill, and forced them into a treaty which still stands today.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treaty_of_Waitangi

Re:The Last Florida Indians Will Now Die: The Westward Pligh... by EGreg on Sunday July 31, 2016 @11:09AM (#12197282)
Thanks! You learn something new every day.
Re:The Last Florida Indians Will Now Die: The Westward Pligh... by karmajunkie on Sunday July 31, 2016 @01:04PM (#12197731)
I don't think anyone's saying atheist governments are incapable of committing crimes against humanity. What I was getting at originally was that religion or lack thereof is at best merely a pretext for geopolitical conflict, which you seem to agree with. The original comment I was responding to seems to want to promote the myth that somehow specifically Christian people and nations are somehow more ethical than atheists (and apparently non-Christian as he failed to recognize indigenous religions as such.)
Re:The Last Florida Indians Will Now Die: The Westward Pligh... by didibus on Sunday July 31, 2016 @03:52PM (#12198536)
That's a pretty small sample of examples, and they all pretty much could be considered to relate to the same set of beliefs, communism.

So maybe communist ideologies have been used for as bad crimes as religion. But that doesn't prove for all lack of religion. In fact there's another example that proves a great many good to the lack of religion, that of democratic ideologies.

Now if I hypothesize, it seems I see a pattern, any time power is given absolutly to a fixed, non changing group of leaders, whose only mean of overthrowing is through force, it seems to cause atrocious violence. Such as when religion governs, or single ideologies such as communism or fascism governs, or when a single person in the form of a dictator does. Hence why democracy does slightly better.

On that note, ideologies that have as a goal to reign absolutly and supremely, which almost all religion have, and some other non religious ones, like communism and fascism have, then you can probably predict a long term negative impact of society, overshadowing all short terms benefits the ideologies might at first demonstrate.

It's also possible to attribute the harshness of communism to having to overthrow another entrenched great power, that of religion. So it should be considered, would a democratic state transition without atrocities to a communist one? Probably. Similarly, a democratic one would probably transition without atrocities to a religious one also. And this all goes back to having a way to transition that is alternate then simply through force. Any transition from a religious state, or a absolute ideology state, like communism, will require atrocious acts, because such state have no other means of self-adapting or correcting themselves. They're not agile in any way.

Re:The Last Florida Indians Will Now Die: The Westward Pligh... by leemailll on Saturday July 30, 2016 @07:49PM (#12195130)
At least the four of them didn't invade a land and massacre locals.
Re:The Last Florida Indians Will Now Die: The Westward Pligh... by true_religion on Sunday July 31, 2016 @03:34AM (#12196096)
I think its fairly interesting that historically the Catholic Church was intertwined with the political system of various European countries.

Yet someone when this comes up, those countries are absolved of all guilt despite the fact it was their armies that were doing the deed, and their citizens who would largely receive the benefits.

Is this because the countries have changed their names? Or perhaps because the system of government has changed from monarchy to something else, thus people think having a new dynasty or new governmental type has broken ties with the old regime?

Re:The Last Florida Indians Will Now Die: The Westward Pligh... by panzagl on Saturday July 30, 2016 @08:21PM (#12195209)
Yeah, Stalin was a sweetheart to the neighbors.
Re:The Last Florida Indians Will Now Die: The Westward Pligh... by douche on Saturday July 30, 2016 @08:46PM (#12195257)
Stalin tried awful hard - unfortunately the Finns ended up being tenacious enough to forestall the Red invasion. The Poles and Hungarians were not so lucky...
Re:The Last Florida Indians Will Now Die: The Westward Pligh... by ktRolster on Saturday July 30, 2016 @11:15PM (#12195586)
Ukrainians
Re:The Last Florida Indians Will Now Die: The Westward Pligh... by barrkel on Sunday July 31, 2016 @03:21AM (#12196076)
Communism is a form of religion too, IMO. Many fascist leaders have been at the centre of personality cults. When people take on mindsets based on faith rather than evidence, and hold their truth based on feelings rather than facts, they can no longer be reached by reason: they can be capable of great acts and monstrous ones, from unity of purpose and lack of dissent. This is the biggest evil, or our greatest asset in times of great need. Depends on the purpose people are put to when united irrationally. Little to do with God, very much to do with leaders.