It's important to study that in these cases. I was convicted in a similar case and am actually a chapter in a CERT book, but they never reached out to me for my input, so they're completely oblivious to my motives and missing key facts about the case. I'd write more about it or speak at conferences but I've been able to bury that past and move on. Maybe some day.
I think he had a similar case to mine where he felt he was stuck in a situation with his manager(s) and felt like he had no recourse. HR should be involved in employee reviews and should provide a way for the employee to give feedback on his own review.
Another aspect of it is education about the law. I see case after case where the defendant had no idea he could face federal charges at all, much less one that can result in such stiff penalties. (The penalties he was facing were much, much worse if he had been tried and convicted rather than taking this plea deal.) That could easily be part of any degree program and/or employee orientation.
Still no excuse to take down 90% of a company's connectivity.
I know it's a really out there example, but there are times where outright rebellion, even destructively, is morally acceptable. I don't know the specifics of this example, however.
Destroying a company damages all of that companies customers and employees as well. The difference between a surgical strike of a "bad guy" and carpet bombing a country.
Also, blowing the whistle can mean many things... in this case, it was a temporary disruption, not much different than an organized strike would be.
Yeah, isn't that what I said?
http://www.infoworld.com/article/2653004/misadventures/why-s...
One issue I see here is that HR usually sides with management and tend to label you as a troublemaker whenever you disagree with something or someone. HR should always be neutral and they are usually far from it.
Someone could be a great team member, love their peers, and still react badly to the news they might be fired soon.
I don't think any amount of "people management" can fix someone who is already a bad egg, "configured" to react poorly to bad news. Some people will be out for revenge no matter what.
The more important thing to analyze here might be the technical measures in place to respond to configuration files being wiped out. Sure, an "insider" could maliciously wipe out the files... but couldn't a technical glitch just as easily do the same? The important lesson from this should be including adequate detection measures to immediately know when configuration files have been changed outside of the normal build process, and the ability to rollback when changes are detected.
One person should not be able to do any more damage than a technical glitch.
If he left his review thinking "they're going to fire me" then there was a miscommunication somewhere along the line.
There's a reason employers don't say "We're firing you at the end of the week... so uh... play nice until then, k?"
"They was firing me. I just beat them to it. Nothing personal, the upper management need to see what they guys on the floor is capable of doing when they keep getting mistreated. I took one for the team. Sorry if I made my peers look bad, but sometimes it take something like what I did to wake the upper management up.”
However, you don't go from happy trotting elf in candy rainbow land to martyr by the flip of a switch (at least not that I know of). So regardless I'd still want to understand what contributed to creating an environment that caused someone to retaliate like this.
I'd be interested to hear it too, but in the grand scheme of things, it doesn't matter one iota.
A healthy work environment is as needed as compartmentalization and other schemes to manage abuse.
We do not know the extend and circumstances of the employee and his/her related story and the story of the company, so no judgement on that.
I like to think that even though people see sysadmins are grumpy rage-machines in a basement most are super-decent people caring deeply for the systems under their control. Perhaps I've got a too rosy view of my fellow engineers.
I'd be very curious to hear what went on there on the people side of things. What led to this person feeling so angry that they would take an action like this. I'm also curious how it could even get so far. I have the benefit of being able to regularly talk to my manager so even if we did performance reviews in that way they wouldn't come as a surprise.