> (e.g. with millions of cameras and facial recognition)
The vast majority of CCTV in the UK is not networked, and owned by small private companies (e.g. your local corner store), and rarely store data long enough to be of use to anyone unless something sufficiently serious happens to cause a request to be made quickly.
While there are areas covered by networked, government operated cameras, they are not the norm.
They will be once they upgrade to the "Internet of Things".
Many of those camera should be private, I think it's our duty as technicians to protect the users of those devices.
EDIT: Curious how stating a fact is worth downvotes. What am I missing?
> A key finding of our research is that the proportion of cameras controlled by local government is around 1 in 70. [...] Without the help of businesses investing into their privately-owned systems, the Police would only have access to the one publically-owned camera per 1,000 head of population [population of UK/1000 ~= 64000]
[0] http://www.securitynewsdesk.com/bsia-attempts-to-clarify-que...
> The vast majority of CCTV in the
> UK is not networked, and owned by
> small private companies ...
So you say: > UK is being watched by a network
> of 1.85m CCTV cameras.
Your comment adds nothing to the discussion, and is contradicting the parent comment without evidence.Whether you are right or wrong, I suspect that's why you're being downvoted. If you flatly contradict someone without substantially adding to the discussion, that's what happens.
Look at any major incident in the UK recently and the police have CCTV footage from private businesses. Either voluntarily given or subpoenaed.
> UK is being watched by a
> network of 1.85m CCTV cameras.
It's not a network - the comment was not factually correct. I was answering the question and explaining my understanding of a likely cause for the downvotes - I personally did not downvote it.You are assuming security against terrorism etc. was the main goal. I think that's completely not the case. There are no facts that support that mass-surveillance or measures compromising encryption have ever been effective at saving lives.
And, of course, political insurgency, mass disobeyance, etc, etc — just as a side effect.
What the powers that be try to sell us is security without compromises. Security above all, no matter the price (as long as it makes the powers more powerful). I think there is a real value in lower security, when civil rights and mere privacy of millions of people are put above the police's ability so solve a particular crime. You see, keeping everyone in a max security prison would be most efficient in thwarting any crime at all, but we're not doing that, at least yet, at the expense of some crimes being committed. The society already demonstrates that this compromise is acceptable. But the power always tends to push the other way.
"Dangerous hacker arrested, found in possession of illegal hacking tools. An unnamed officer said 'we couldn't have done it without our metadata analysis'"
If the tools for encrypting your data are illegal, they dont need to decrypt your data anymore.
We must do something
This is something
Therefore, we must do this.
Governments will always wage war on law abiding citizens, taking away freedoms in exchange for securities until the citizens are secure but no longer free.
And even then, such a notion of "security" might seem dubious to those who are conscious of having lost said freedoms.
People that really care about privacy, people who need to hide what they do will not be majorly impacted.
* The main threat is metadata anyways, not the data itself. Locating where you are (e.g. with millions of cameras and facial recognition) is a much worse threat.
* They will still use full disk encryption, free software, PGP or AES, etc. outside of the affected apps. That software won't stop to exist, nor the mathematics that powers it will stop working.
The sad part is that the people who will be disproportionally affected will be the common people who have nothing to hide anyways, and do not have the technical means, or the will, to protect themselves.
TLDR: useless and damaging.