News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why it's time to accept the fact that Brexit may never ac... by dudul on Friday July 22, 2016 @10:31AM (#12143722)
Sure, what a better move from an organization that is more and more compared to the USSR than completely ignore the result of a direct consultation of the citizens. Especially when anti-EU parties are gaining traction is a lot of other countries.

If the UK does not leave the EU despite the will of the people, it will be the clearest message ever sent to everybody in Europe that they have basically lost the right to decide for themselves. That would probably not be without consequences.

Re:Why it's time to accept the fact that Brexit may never ac... by Kurtz79 on Friday July 22, 2016 @12:19PM (#12144487)
"Sure, what a better move from an organization that is more and more compared to the USSR"

By whom, exactly ?

Geniuses like Farage ? By The Sun and the Daily Mail?

Re:Why it's time to accept the fact that Brexit may never ac... by timrichard on Friday July 22, 2016 @04:05PM (#12146385)
I believe the poster is referring to Mikhail Gorbachev, who said “The most puzzling development in politics during the last decade is the apparent determination of Western European leaders to re-create the Soviet Union in Western Europe.”

But who knows; perhaps Mikhail read something in the Daily Mail.

Re:Why it's time to accept the fact that Brexit may never ac... by polotics on Friday July 22, 2016 @03:51PM (#12146300)
count me in. You know what too-low interest rates did to southern europe's economies starting from the late 90's
Re:Why it's time to accept the fact that Brexit may never ac... by Kurtz79 on Monday July 25, 2016 @05:09AM (#12157385)
No. I know what endemic corruption, tax evasion, abuses to the social state, refusal of investing in economies beyond tourism and construction, have done to Southern Europe's economies, which have the same low interest rates than the healthy economies in the EU.
Re:Why it's time to accept the fact that Brexit may never ac... by cortesoft on Friday July 22, 2016 @12:31PM (#12144611)
I think most people accept that it isn't the best idea to allow a simple majority to have unlimited power. Just because you can get 50.01% of the people to vote for something doesn't mean it is 'undemocratic' to not do it.

In the United States, for example, we have a constitution that explicitly sets out rules for what a majority can't do. I don't think setting limits on what the majority can do means that people have 'lost the right to decide for themselves'.

If the British Parliament decides to drag their feet on brexit, that doesn't mean they are preventing people from deciding for themselves; the people decided to vote those MPs into office!

Re:Why it's time to accept the fact that Brexit may never ac... by jboydyhacker on Friday July 22, 2016 @11:56AM (#12144323)
Democracy is not a right, it's a responsibility. That means if you want to decide for yourself you have to actually educate yourself on the ramifications of the decisions.

Nobody on the Brexit camp even had a plan on how to leave. That's not democracy that's just a tantrum.

Re:Why it's time to accept the fact that Brexit may never ac... by kadabra9 on Friday July 22, 2016 @12:10PM (#12144423)
Ah yes, the classic "My side lost, so the other side must be uneducated" argument.

Democracy is great up until the point people dont vote the way you want them to vote.

Re:Why it's time to accept the fact that Brexit may never ac... by parenthephobia on Friday July 22, 2016 @07:52PM (#12147609)
Leave voters were unavoidably uneducated "on the ramifications of the decisions", because Leave had no post-vote plan.

The referendum wasn't a choice between two courses of action. It was a choice between carrying on as normal, and "leaving the EU", where the specifics were undefined. Nobody could educate themselves as to the ramifications, because it wasn't - and still isn't - possible to know what they would be.

Leave voters might claim they voted for restored sovereignty, or reduced immigration, or not sending the EU £350MM/week, but they didn't, because none of those things were on the ballot.

Re:Why it's time to accept the fact that Brexit may never ac... by cortesoft on Friday July 22, 2016 @12:33PM (#12144625)
No, democracy is great when you place limits on what the majority can do. The majority does not get free reign to do whatever they want; there is a reason most democratic countries place limits on the majorities ability to enact their will; the US constitution is designed explicitly to limit the power of the majority, so as to prevent the abuse of the minority.
Re:Why it's time to accept the fact that Brexit may never ac... by kadabra9 on Friday July 22, 2016 @12:43PM (#12144719)
And none of that I would disagree with. We're not discussing whether or not the population should have ability to leave the EU via referendum, however.

I was referring to the tendencies of some to cry out that democracy doesn't work when people don't vote the way they want them to, or to portray the other side as "undecuated or "racist" just because your side lost.

Re:Why it's time to accept the fact that Brexit may never ac... by epistasis on Friday July 22, 2016 @03:39PM (#12146207)
Well you didn't finish his comment, it wasn't "because your side lost," he had a very specific reason:

>Nobody on the Brexit camp even had a plan on how to leave. That's not democracy that's just a tantrum.

You're being just as prejudiced as you claim he is if you don't even bother to acknowledge what he said and merely assume its do to his prejudice.

Re:Why it's time to accept the fact that Brexit may never ac... by lotyrin on Friday July 22, 2016 @12:25PM (#12144536)
Can the majority not be wrong?

It seems like they are in a number of states, on a number of issues, should we not desire a correct government over a popular one? Whether it's a majority that is wrong, or a representative class that is wrong, or a despot that is wrong, should we not have a voice to point out what we see as errors?

Re:Why it's time to accept the fact that Brexit may never ac... by dudul on Friday July 22, 2016 @12:32PM (#12144616)
Who is to decide what a correct government is then?

How do you define "wrong"?

You are obviously free to point out what you see as errors, but if you can't convince the majority, then what else is there to do?

Re:Why it's time to accept the fact that Brexit may never ac... by lotyrin on Friday July 22, 2016 @12:51PM (#12144784)
You probably don't actually believe that popular opinion constitutes truth, it's just convenient pretense for your argument. If you really do, pick up a history book or some modern polls.

When the majority decides that a minority should be mistreated, is that justice?

If the majority is misinformed by a powerful minority, will they not act against even their own best interests?

When the majority is short sighted, is disgracing the future the proper thing to do?

An ideal government is one that uses the truth to optimize according to some anthropic value system in the short and long terms. These do not arise from popular opinion, just as they don't form under the force of authority. Unfortunately, they are probably impossible to form at all.

People are selfish, stupid, and short-sighted and that doesn't go away once you reach any particular number or proportion of them making the decisions.

Democracy can (arguably) produce morally just decisions, but that isn't the same as producing factually correct ones.

Re:Why it's time to accept the fact that Brexit may never ac... by dudul on Friday July 22, 2016 @01:17PM (#12144980)
The fallacy is that you keep talking about "truth" as if it was such a simple thing to identify.

Where is the truth between legalizing marijuana or not? Where is the truth between allowing somebody who is 20 years and 11 month old to drink or not? And I'm not even getting near real controversial topics such as gay marriage, abortion, polygamy and co.

There is no truth, just what the majority considers "good" or "desirable" at a given point in time.

And yes, sometimes we realize decades later that it was dumb. or rather, we like to judge with our eyes what people did 100 years before us and want to pretend we would have known better, that they were just morons.

Re:Why it's time to accept the fact that Brexit may never ac... by lotyrin on Friday July 22, 2016 @01:32PM (#12145135)
Here's the crux. We currently decide both values and facts by deciding for actions and policies, and decisions using popular opinion will therefore make errors about facts. How we negotiate facts and values should be different.

We could define what our values are, decide if it is just to use potentially violent force to enforce laws that forbid substances that have detrimental health effects and flesh out what we mean by a detrimental effect, what the threshold of that is for different age groups -- these are things that are pretty anthropic, can't be decided otherwise.

We can then collect facts about which substances fit into our decided categories, and avoid making mistakes that fail to serve the values we chose.

If (because the fact process, being human, is imperfect) we find new values for facts, we can adjust policy and actions without readjusting the values side of decision making.

Re:Why it's time to accept the fact that Brexit may never ac... by lotyrin on Friday July 22, 2016 @01:57PM (#12145354)
There is such a thing as truth, and while we can't have a perfect method of arriving at it, we have methods better than polls.

People legislate taste, they ignore big problems because "we've always done it like that", etc. This is plain to see. Nobody benefits when a state fails to live up to its purpose, provides both insufficient freedoms with insufficient controls.

Sure, an unfeeling despotic utilitarian robot would be an immoral form of government -- we have to take into account anthropic value systems (which will not converge, and require consensus-making in some form) -- but to accept there's no one true system of mores doesn't require assuming there's no single truth.

Re:Why it's time to accept the fact that Brexit may never ac... by tomp on Friday July 22, 2016 @12:35PM (#12144645)
Poliyics is not math. There's no right or wrong. There are just priorities.
Re:Why it's time to accept the fact that Brexit may never ac... by makomk on Sunday July 24, 2016 @01:26PM (#12153925)
The Brexit referendum didn't offer people a choice of priorities. It offered them a binary in vs out decision where the differences between different ways of implementing each choice were arguably wider than the difference between the choices. Then voters had to try and map their actual priorities onto this decision based on dubious information from media and politicians who had their own interests at heart.
Re:Why it's time to accept the fact that Brexit may never ac... by lotyrin on Friday July 22, 2016 @12:53PM (#12144796)
There certainly are decisions which are wrong, and the majority can certainly make those.
Re:Why it's time to accept the fact that Brexit may never ac... by bllguo on Friday July 22, 2016 @12:25PM (#12144538)
What? Nothing you say has anything to do with his point.
Re:Why it's time to accept the fact that Brexit may never ac... by Rylinks on Friday July 22, 2016 @12:11PM (#12144431)
Here is a plan:

  1. Invoke article 50
  2. Wait two years
This might not be a good plan, but that's for the voters to decide.
Re:Why it's time to accept the fact that Brexit may never ac... by dingaling on Friday July 22, 2016 @12:36PM (#12144650)
> Nobody on the Brexit camp even had a plan on how to leave.

That's not my job - that's what civil servants and politicians are paid considerable amounts of money to determine.

Just like a marketing director doesn't expect to have to present the dev team with the architecture of the latest web app; he or she states the requirements, we execute it.

Re:Why it's time to accept the fact that Brexit may never ac... by Daishiman on Friday July 22, 2016 @12:47PM (#12144752)
Well, executing according to the plan will lead to political suicide because the Leave voters couldn't be bothered to understand the economic ramifications, so they're going to be out of a vote anyway.

If a customer asks for you to build a building that will collapse, do you go for it or do you steadfastedly refuse your customer's idiocy.

Re:Why it's time to accept the fact that Brexit may never ac... by sbmassey on Friday July 22, 2016 @04:20PM (#12146483)
If they want a building that will collapse, you should build it, of course. Doing otherwise would be negligent, and assuming your customers are stupid for wanting such a thing is unprofessional at best.
Re:Why it's time to accept the fact that Brexit may never ac... by falsestprophet on Friday July 22, 2016 @12:06PM (#12144402)
>Democracy is not a right, it's a responsibility.

In the United Kingdom parliament is dissolved every five years or sooner and elections are called to elect a new parliament.

Representative democracy is manifestly a right of the British people.

Re:Why it's time to accept the fact that Brexit may never ac... by cortesoft on Friday July 22, 2016 @12:35PM (#12144641)
Right, but a direct vote on brexit is not 'representative democracy'.

British citizens voted for their MPs, and if those MPs drag their feet on brexit, it is still a representation of the will of the people.

Re:Why it's time to accept the fact that Brexit may never ac... by dudul on Friday July 22, 2016 @12:41PM (#12144694)
Some countries favor direct democracy and think representative democracy is not democratic enough. Are they wrong? Please american overlord, show us the way, we so want to be right.
Re:Why it's time to accept the fact that Brexit may never ac... by cortesoft on Friday July 22, 2016 @12:45PM (#12144736)
Personally, I think they are wrong for very clear and real reasons.

I think protecting the minority is important. I don't think something magically happens at 50.01% that makes that idea suddenly better than at 49.99%. The majority does NOT have the right to abuse the minority.

Re:Why it's time to accept the fact that Brexit may never ac... by fao_ on Friday July 22, 2016 @12:41PM (#12144699)
Except we don't have that, we have First Past the Post :)
Re:Why it's time to accept the fact that Brexit may never ac... by dudul on Friday July 22, 2016 @12:21PM (#12144504)
I see, so when people don't vote "the right way" it's because they are stupid, or throwing a tantrum. Good, that makes for good debates. The media and the "elite" in the UK tried that for a year and we saw the outcome.

There is an article in the constitution to allow a country to leave the union, so it is a right the people have.

Re:Why it's time to accept the fact that Brexit may never ac... by knowaveragejoe on Friday July 22, 2016 @12:23PM (#12144526)
The question is whether it's a right they should exercise on so little information.
Re:Why it's time to accept the fact that Brexit may never ac... by tomp on Friday July 22, 2016 @12:37PM (#12144660)
What do you mean, little information?! There's plenty of information on how bad EU is (occupation of Greece, austerity, one country deciding to invite millions of migrants then forcing others to help them, wasting money supporting 2 parliaments, "unelected" leaders, the failure that is Euro, ...).
Re:Why it's time to accept the fact that Brexit may never ac... by Daishiman on Friday July 22, 2016 @12:49PM (#12144771)
You're not really proving that these, or worse, things wouldn't happen without a EU.

Structural economic issues that span a whole continent happen regardless of whether it's in a single coordinated economic bloc or not.

Re:Why it's time to accept the fact that Brexit may never ac... by sbmassey on Friday July 22, 2016 @04:06PM (#12146389)
If it is in a single coordinated economic block, then you don't get the positive effects of different countries trying different things, and the good ideas being copied when proven successful. i.e. the same competition that actually made Europe such a successful part of the world over the last few centuries. The EU is anti-European.
Re:Why it's time to accept the fact that Brexit may never ac... by Daishiman on Friday July 22, 2016 @06:58PM (#12147368)
And you don't get the negative effects of, say, war, or uncoordinated action against external events, and a myriad other things.

Those truism by themselves are completely meaningless unless you can show that what they're missing out on is better than a unified free market.

Re:Why it's time to accept the fact that Brexit may never ac... by dudul on Friday July 22, 2016 @12:29PM (#12144584)
Well, then we should maybe change the rules of elections. Maybe before people are allowed to vote they should take a test to make sure they know what they are doing. Or we can simplify and say that you need a master's degree to be allowed to vote, organizing the test may be too involved.

Also, maybe old people should not be allowed to vote since they're gonna die soon anyway, what do they care?

Also, maybe only land owners should be allowed to vote, after all, if you don't own land maybe you're not really part of the destiny of the country.

Also, maybe you should have been a citizen for at least 10 years to be allowed to vote, to make sure you've had time to integrate the values of your new country.

How about we stop assuming that just because things didn't play out the way the elites wanted them to it must mean that people are stupid, racist, uneducated? I can only imagine the reactions if the "remain" had won, and we were now talking about the UK leaving anyway.

Re:Why it's time to accept the fact that Brexit may never ac... by Oletros on Friday July 22, 2016 @12:41PM (#12144692)
> Sure, what a better move from an organization that is more and more compared to the USSR than completely ignore the result of a direct consultation of the citizens

Are you talking about UK?