News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by emilsedgh on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @08:48AM (#12128572)
Its not just Erdogan. People of Turkey seem to be supporters of this path. Although its very sad.
Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by fredThrind on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @09:21AM (#12128789)
I've been reading this sort of thing a lot recently. Indeed, I think someone admiringly called Turkey's military "the world's best armed constitutional court". Yet, from what I was able to gather, even the Turkish opposition parties objected to the coup, and comments from ordinary Turks (and interestingly Greeks) were that Turkish coups were very bad for them. Many of us presume to have the right to decide the fates of other nations-it's a weird throwback to the imperialist mindset.

I wonder if we'd be as supportive of the US military taking over, in the interests of National Security if say, Trump, won the election and withdrew from Europe and East Asia? Or if Scotland voted to secede from the UK with the consent of the Commons, and the British Army decided that its duty was to protect the Union, and overthrow an elected government?

There is no excuse for human rights abuses, but if the majority of Turks believe they've been chafing under Kemalism for 90 years, and want to try something different, what right do we have to presume to dictate to them?

In any case, I fear this is all going to be moot. The commentariat is starting to make noises about the Kremlin supporting all manner of extremist candidates and positions in the West, including Brexit, Marine Le Pen, and Trump himself. Putin may have found the soft underbelly of Western democracy: money. I hope this isn't the case as I'll be as much a victim as anyone; but if it is, it will be the first bitter taste of the foreign meddling and sense of imperious entitlement we've been demonstrating for centuries.

Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by denzil_correa on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @09:34AM (#12128862)
> There is no excuse for human rights abuses, but if the majority of Turks believe they've been chafing under Kemalism for 90 years, and want to try something different, what right do we have to presume to dictate to them?

Democracy is not simply the rule of majority. There are certain fundamental aspects of democracy that are sacrilege and can not be broken down even if 99/100 citizens want it.

Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by pabloski on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @09:58AM (#12129033)
Are you serious? Democracy is first and foremost the government of the majority. Whoever defines himself as democratic must respect the will of the majority. Sic et simplicitur.
Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by fredThrind on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @10:31AM (#12129263)
I'm not sure if gp is American, but if he is then I would presume he is, indeed serious. The US Constitution is almost impossible to amend in practice, and a ridiculously small percentage of the American population can block an amendment. Indeed, the late conservative Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia made this point.*

This has may have led to a perception from Americans that constitutions ought to be difficult to amend by their nature, and that is an essential feature of republicanism, since the US Constitution is practically set in stone-hence the immense power of the US Supreme Court justices. In fact, most countries do make it considerably easier to change their constitutions (with a straightforward super-majority, in most cases), and to adapt to the needs of the people. The idea of an unbreakable and sacred tyranny of people who are long dead (The Founders) is something unique to the US, among constitutional democracies.The arguments about things being needing to be set in stone confuse cause and effect.

*http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/view_from_ch...

Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by toyg on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @11:28AM (#12129768)
This is not as clear-cut as you present it though, it's very much a live wound in political science. Is there anything "sacred", in a democracy? If 99 out of 100 representatives voted for a new Holocaust, would that be fine and legal to enact?

Most systems route around the problem by requiring "supermajorities", or majorities with different qualifications, to amend the most criticals bits (constitutions and the likes) or even to progress regular legislation in some cases ("filibustering"). But the problem is still there. If representatives of a constitutional democracy voted to transform it into an absolutist hereditary monarchy, following all necessary constitutional rules, would that be legitimate?

What we often take for granted, in constitutional sciences, is a set of rules that is often less than 100 years old, and which was achieved with much bloodshed. We risk re-learning painful lessons.

Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by adrianratnapala on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @11:08AM (#12129584)
While it is true that the smallest states can club together to block an Amendment, I am not sure that is a real stumbling block in practice.

There have been lots of amendments to the US constitution, and I expect if a solid majority of people wanted something changed, it would not be hard to pass another. This could easily happen if one major party strongly supported something and the other party was merely split.

But in recent decades it has been easier to change the constitution by the back door through getting judgest to give creative interpretations.

Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by zeveb on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @10:38AM (#12129318)
> Democracy is not simply the rule of majority.

Yes, it is: it's the rule of the demos — the mob.

> There are certain fundamental aspects of democracy that are sacrilege and can not be broken down even if 99/100 citizens want it.

Those are the fundamental aspects of a republic, not of a democracy.

I blame Woodrow Wilson and all his nonsense about making the world safe for democracy. I don't actually care about whether I live in a democracy or not: I want to live in a republic, where the fundamental liberties of even the smallest minorities are secured from even the great howling mob.

Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by denzil_correa on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @11:05AM (#12129551)
> Those are the fundamental aspects of a republic, not of a democracy.

I was indeed referring to a republic where majority of modern democracies operate. I assumed given the context of the discussion this was obvious. Turns out, that it is not.

Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by JohnStrange on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @11:54AM (#12129995)
The opposition parties and other opposition only object to the coup, because otherwise they would be arrested or even beaten to death.
Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by pluma on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @08:55AM (#12128621)
Erdogan always had strong support from Turkish expatriates. I had always heard this explained as fundamentalists leaving Turkey because its secular laws were more restrictive (e.g. headscarfs are banned in universities[0] because of the strong separation of church and state) and Erdogan catering towards those fundamentalists.

I don't know what changed in Turkey but it now seems that his support has grown not only outside the country but also within and he seems to be hellbent on exploiting religion to gain political support. I don't know whether he actually holds fundamentalist views himself but he certainly knows how to use them to his advantage.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Headscarf_controversy_in_Turke...

Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by chappi42 on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @09:37AM (#12128875)
I don't find a good link for the following statement but I saw it mentioned a few times lately and it seems that Erdogan was banished from political life because of it.

At a conference in 1998, Erdogan quoted from an Islamic poem: "Democracy is just the train we board to reach our destination. The mosques are our barracks, the minarets our bayonets, the cupolas our helmets and the faithful our soldiers."

Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by usrusr on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @11:14AM (#12129642)
> I had always heard this explained as fundamentalists leaving Turkey because its secular laws were more restrictive

Not so much fundamentalists fleeing from secularism, but people emigrating from the poorest backwater parts of the country, where, coincidence or not, both religious traditions and AKP are much stronger than in well-educated urban regions.

Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by Kareeeeem on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @10:58AM (#12129491)
> Erdogan always had strong support from Turkish expatriates. I had always heard this explained as fundamentalists leaving Turkey because its secular laws were more restrictive

Wanting to practice your religion in it's most basic form makes one a fundamentalist?

Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by adrianratnapala on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @11:04AM (#12129547)
Actually I always thought that is what "fundamentalist" meant. But I never thought of fundemantalism as a bad thing in itself. (Actual bad things are along the lines "militant" and beyond).
Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by finid on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @09:24AM (#12128801)
> I don't know whether he actually holds fundamentalist views himself...

He does, actually. Google what he said about women.

Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by pluma on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @09:27AM (#12128818)
You don't need to believe in religion to be a chauvinist, though.
Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by creshal on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @09:32AM (#12128853)
And don't need to believe in anything to publicly support positions you think will get you votes.
Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by gkya on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @09:52AM (#12128981)
Today's Turkey is the glory of "populism".
Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by finid on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @09:51AM (#12128969)
I agree, but his fundamentalist religious views are well-documented. The only difference between him and the Saudis is he does not wear funny outfits
Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by cdash on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @08:51AM (#12128594)
The people have always been supporters of this path. That is why the reset button had to keep on being pushed by the military.
Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by pluma on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @09:17AM (#12128767)
This isn't entirely wrong. Turkey started out as the remnants of the Ottoman Empire, an Islamic caliphate. Atatürk created a secular republic inspired by modern Western nations and culture. He even went so far as to change the writing system.

It's fairly safe to say that Atatürk's ideals have always been in strong conflict with the will of a certain part of the demographic (e.g. fundamentalists) as well as people from many of the neighboring countries.

Consider the controversies in France and other European countries surrounding (proposed) bans on headscarfs and burkas -- then consider that headscarfs have been banned in Turkish universities for decades (though this ban was not always extended to students).

It's entirely possible to democratically elect a government that reaches majority support while harming the entire nation and the well-being of future generations. This is why certain laws are treated as immutable in most republics -- no matter how much the people want to change it.

Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by pluma on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @04:13PM (#12132111)
In reply to the dead comment: I'm not saying banning scarfs is an example of democracy. I'm saying it's an example of the will of the people being overruled by the founding principle of Laicism. Even though the people want to have it, the constitution prohibits it.
Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by ajmurmann on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @09:29AM (#12128834)
I would be interested to hear from people who are down voting this why they are doing that? On the surface this seems like a reasonable assumption given the role of the Turkish military.
Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by toyg on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @11:35AM (#12129825)
Maybe because "the people" is a dangerous generalisation. I'm pretty sure huge swaths of Turkish citizenry don't really want to live in some Iran-style "democratic theocracy".
Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by virtualritz on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @09:08AM (#12128723)
The people who went to the streets, against the coup, where Erdogan's supporters. The majority of the populace in Ankara & Istanbul stayed in their houses.

I.e. the only people on the streets where those against the coup. We do not know how many of the majority, who didn't take to the streets where for or against its success.

Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by afsina on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @09:16AM (#12128762)
No, people has families and children and for a million other reason they may choose not to go to streets. It is idiotic to think that they are supporting the coup.
Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by icebraining on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @10:28AM (#12129234)
It's not idiotic to think that some support the coup, and the parent poster specifically says we simply don't know how many support it or not.
Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by guard-of-terra on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @08:54AM (#12128618)
> People of Turkey seem to be supporters of this path.

A doubt all of them are. Just as with Brexit, popular opinion might be divided.

Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by emilsedgh on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @08:56AM (#12128629)
Of course not all. But he seems to have the democratic support. As most people prefer it.
Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by toyg on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @11:40AM (#12129865)
Define "democratic". He consistently imprisoned opposition members and journalists, banned parties, fixed elections... Support is there, but let's not pretend it's so overwhelming -- in the last two elections, he failed to reach the supermajorities he craved and was forced to reshuffle an unpopular government. Despite all sorts of shocks, there is a quantifiable amount of people resisting his rule. Hopefully this won't change after these horrifying purges.
Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by guard-of-terra on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @09:25AM (#12128806)
Having democratic support doesn't entitle him with right to dismantle the very system that let him be elected, and in my uneducated opinion that's what he does.

Democracy is playing by the rules, not changing these rules each few years as you see fit, even while quoting "popular support" (but not holding any referendums, definitely).

Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by shabaan on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @09:11AM (#12128735)
Why would they (70%) not support him? - He increased their gdp - He reflects their view - He is merciful to the refugees (settled 2.2 million refugees)

Why does he have to be pleasing to you?

Why do you support hillary.. she killed millions.. Why do you support obama... yest 320 and today 124 (in idp school in syria) dead becasue of him

Why do you support any damn politican in the west? All their pockets and morals are stained.

They compare no where close to Erdogan. But your media has him hating with all kind of funny things.

Anyways, You should be ashamed about the ban of headscarfs .. while claiming the "freedom"-superiority.

Instead you are giving it an example for the "democracy". Guess we should re-define democracy as "bigotcracy"

Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by unethical_ban on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @09:24AM (#12128798)
Do you want the Americans to fight the terrorists in Syria, or no? War is not without collateral damage. Our country gets criticized for not doing enough when we try to stay out of it, or for "murder" when we take violent action and someone innocent gets hurt.

Erdogan jails journalists who don't like him, and has committed a purge of police, judges and teachers who he disagrees with.

If President Obama dissolved police departments, school districts and judgeships on a wide scale, there would be mass protests or a civil war. We expect freedom of speech and freedom of thought, unlike many in Turkey, it seems.

edit: I'd like to leave this here to show what he has done since the "coup". https://www.reddit.com/r/worldnews/comments/4tq4sd/all_turki...

Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by reitanqild on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @09:27AM (#12128821)
Is he merciful to the Kurds that helps fight IS or is he bombing them?

Is he trying to force Germany to punish a comedian?

Is he trying to reintroduce death penalty?

Has he purged more than 2000 judges? Is it reasonable to think he has verified that all of them were bad judges during the two-three last days?

Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by afsina on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @09:38AM (#12128881)
Too much drama?

- PKK is killing your soldiers what do you do? This has nothing to do with IS.

- Ok, he has a temper and does not have a good sense of humor but please, did you find "that" poem funny?

- Oh come on. You know it was not about being bad judges.

Though yes, reintroduction of death penalty is a very bad idea. Also things are being done too hastily. All allegations are need to be verified.

Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by 01923810391 on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @09:54AM (#12128992)
That poem was not meant to be funny, it was a reaction to an earlier attempt by Erdogan to complain about another "insult".

The poem was just saying "THIS is what an actual insult looks like".

In light of the recent events though it appears that goats have been insulted in the poem, not Erdogan.

Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by afsina on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @10:05AM (#12129076)
Oh you are insulting peoples intelligence here. Playing with words like that does not make it less stupid.
Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by pluma on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @10:11AM (#12129114)
Not the OP, but I'm German and I didn't find the poem funny. That wasn't the point of the poem. The poem wasn't the comedy. The comedy was the presentation of the poem.

Saying Erdogan has sex with goats isn't funny. It's crude and it's even potentially racist (considering that sounds more like an ethnic slur than a personal insult). But that was the entire point. The poem actually went out of its way to be so appallingly insulting to drive this point home.

I don't think the performance was particularly good and I think the same point could have been made in a more tasteful way, but it should be protected as satire and I hope the German courts will rule accordingly (as many lawyers are predicting).

The entire point of the performance was a reaction to the ridiculous complaints about the earlier satirical song about Erdogan (which btw was almost entirely factual and only "insulting" because it presented Erdogan unfavourably and ridiculed his eccentricity and blatantly autocratic behaviour). It didn't set out to insult Erdogan, it was explicitly phrased as "That wasn't an insult that is illegal under German law. The following is what an insult that would be illegal under German law would look like".

Taking the poem in isolation is intellectually lazy and dishonest. It's like showcasing a replica of Michelangelo's David's penis and saying David is obscene because it's entirely about genitalia.

Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by unprepare on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @10:52AM (#12129446)
>he has a temper and does not have a good sense of humor but please, did you find "that" poem funny?

solid reasoning behind pursuing a criminal conviction to be sure.

Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by reitanqild on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @03:28PM (#12131766)
Upvoted you for being reasonable. Still disagree though.

But no, I did not find that poem funny, but the fact that he hasn't got a sense of humour, that turned out to be a bit funny.

Re:After the coup, Turkey turns against America by unethical_ban on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @08:35PM (#12133694)
Do you support freedom of speech?