News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Vim GIFs by kartD on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @02:57PM (#12123943)
Great idea, vim is intuitive ( -ish?) once you understand what each character means ( y for yank being a simple example ). If anyone is looking to learn vim or any IDE really, check this place out. https://www.shortcutfoo.com/app/dojos/vim
Re:Vim GIFs by wodenokoto on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @03:42PM (#12124278)
It seems to me there is a lot of VIM vocabulary that is very different from what is common on the desktop today. I don't know what yank means. I don't think I have a desktop app that has a yank function.

The current front page example is using 'z' to "redraw the cursor". I know what all those words means, but put together they are complete jibberish. Looking at the gif, it appears that redraw is VIM-speak for scrolling.

Also "z doesn't do anything on it's own. But it pairs with a number of other things. It is used for redrawing the screen, saving and quitting, as well as manipulating folds." doesn't sound intuitive at all.

Re:Vim GIFs by DSMan195276 on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @06:43PM (#12125514)
As a Vim user I would agree with what you've said. I would add that a lot of the terminology would have made more sense back when it was introduced, and at that time the other now-common versions weren't nearly as common. I think an effort to use both the Vim terminology, and the common terminology that people would be most-familiar with would be good. If it said "yanking (copying)" and "redraw the cursor (scroll the screen relative to the cursor)" it would be obvious.

Also, I think `z` is a fairly bad example, because nothing really starts with `z` and in some ways it's just a hodgepodge of different things that needed keys (`z` is of course not the only key like this).

`y` for example is used for everything related to yanking. `p` for everything related to pasting. `i` for insert mode. `v` for visual mode. `c` for change, `d` for delete, `w` for word. There's other various examples I'm sure, but most of the basic usage of Vim (besides, perhaps, `hjkl`) all maps to fairly easy to remember keys once you do it a few times and understand what they stand for.

Re:Vim GIFs by jzymbaluk on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @03:49PM (#12124325)
It's intuitive once you already know what it means and have sunk dozens of hours into memorizing what the shortcuts do /s
Re:Vim GIFs by MichaelGG on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @07:10PM (#12125654)
I did VIM Adventures. Then I installed VsVim for day to day work. A while later, it just makes sense. I'm so fast, it's like magic. Vim macros alone make it worth it.

At any rate, I never spent much time memorizing keys. I'd look up a thing or two, apply it, and it'd just sink in.

Re:Vim GIFs by cpdean on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @11:25PM (#12126658)
Actually it takes more like 2 months for the Stockholm Syndrome of vim to sink in and then you don't want to use anything else ever again.
Re:Vim GIFs by Spivak on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @11:45PM (#12126731)
And that's not a bad thing. I don't think it's right to call Vim intuitive unless you're used to reading a book to understand 35% of the features of an editor.

But Vim isn't about being intuitive, it's about being efficient. Once it 'clicks' you will be able to express incredibly complex text manipulations in only a few keystrokes. And with configuration you'll build the most powerful but comfortable environment that you'll miss anywhere else.

Re:Vim GIFs by TeMPOraL on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @02:26AM (#12127236)
In other words, Vim is a professional tool, not a toy for causal user. It offsets steeper learning curve for much more powerful and efficient way of editing text. It's a feature.
Re:Vim GIFs by Asooka on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @04:38AM (#12127602)
That said, it would benefit A LOT from having a more discoverable interface. See what kakoune is doing in that space: http://kakoune.org/
Re:Vim GIFs by moosingin3space on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @01:56PM (#12131048)
When it comes to discoverability, I really like what Spacemacs is doing with its continuous suggestions UI.
Re:Vim GIFs by cpdean on Friday July 22, 2016 @01:15PM (#12144960)
Yeah vim isn't intuitive to beginners, but "intuitive" to people that have the context of knowing how the parts fit together.
Re:Vim GIFs by HiroshiSan on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @04:50PM (#12124790)
Next you're going to tell me you don't know quantum physics...
Re:Vim GIFs by numeromancer on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @10:47AM (#12129405)
Vim is not built for quickness of learning, but for the learning of quickness.
Re:Vim GIFs by TeMPOraL on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @02:25AM (#12127233)
> It seems to me there is a lot of VIM vocabulary that is very different from what is common on the desktop today.

The operating word here being "today". Vim - and Emacs - are relics from the era when computing was much more saner than it is today. They're old, older than most of us here. It's not that hard to learn their vocabulary once you understand all those words are not weird, it's how things were called back before the industry did another circle and reinvented some wheels again.

Re:Vim GIFs by mrzool on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @07:44AM (#12128252)

    :s/Vim/Unix/
Re:Vim GIFs by TeMPOraL on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @08:40AM (#12128508)
Not really. Unix is the archetypical virus on the history of computing. Whether a cause or just a symptom, it's part of the problem of the current state of computing industry.
Re:Vim GIFs by somebehemoth on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @04:10PM (#12124475)
You definitely picked two examples that fit your theory. I am not sure that fully proves your point though because counter examples:

b - move cursor back

w - move cursor forward one word

p - paste from buffer

u - undo

etc.

I would not argue vim is intuitive as a whole. However, there are certain parts of vim that are extremely intuitive.

Re:Vim GIFs by kartD on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @04:14PM (#12124515)
Also,

d: delete

c: change

y: yank (copy)

v: visually select (V for line vs. character)

It's also why I added the -ish to my comment (editors can be very polarising), but I feel many of vim's basic editing features are very intuitive

Edit: https://danielmiessler.com/study/vim/ It's where I learned the command meanings and started to understand vim in a more intuitive manner

Re:Vim GIFs by akerro on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @03:31AM (#12127407)
You can also do:

:10d - to delete line 10

d99d - to delete next 99 lines

:10,99d - to delete lines between 10 and 99

:-4,.d - delete from 4 lines above to current line

this also works with other commands

Anyone fancy playing vimgolf? http://www.vimgolf.com/

Re:Vim GIFs by J_Darnley on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @07:18PM (#12125683)
Don't forget ctrl-v for column selection.
Re:Vim GIFs by elcapitan on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @02:46AM (#12127282)
i - insert

being the obvious one..

Re:Vim GIFs by akerro on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @03:28AM (#12127395)
or A also insert, but at the end of a line.
Re:Vim GIFs by darfs on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @04:01AM (#12127490)
How about 'append'? :-)
Re:Vim GIFs by a3n on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @05:12PM (#12124949)
I've never liked the term yank, to me it means take something out of there. But it's really "copy this into a buffer," for use later.

That said, I had my annoying fifteen seconds when I first learned it, then just used it as intended. Honestly, my fingertips do the how-to thinking these days, and my brain does the what-I-want thinking.

Re:Vim GIFs by dmix on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @06:20PM (#12125389)
I see yank as copy but with a history, like a copy plus undo/redo state. Because that's how the functionality was introduced to me with Vim. I can cycle through previous 'yank' buffers, yet on my OS I'm limited to a single 'copy/cut' buffer so I remembered them as distinct terms.
Re:Vim GIFs by johncoltrane on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @01:56AM (#12127154)
Think of Vim as a foreign language. It's gibberish and unintuitive until you start to learn it and then it all makes sense.

Not being interested by learning a language doesn't make it suck.

Re:Vim GIFs by ChuckMcM on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @08:53PM (#12126109)
VIM's names for things make a lot more sense when you know TECO [1]

[1] http://www.livingcomputermuseum.org/Online-Systems/User-Docu...

Re:Vim GIFs by beachstartup on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @08:08PM (#12125904)
of course vim isn't intuitive. it's extremely hard to learn, cryptic, confusing, and in some cases deliberately obtuse, but is very fast and powerful once you've learned it.

i don't evangelize vim at all. it's a very difficult tool used only by people who need its functionality and have the patience and intelligence to learn it. don't like it? not sold? then don't learn it. use something easier.

Re:Vim GIFs by fbuilesv on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @06:46PM (#12125531)
It seems to me there is a lot of VIM vocabulary that is very different from what is common on the desktop today. I don't know what yank means. I don't think I have a desktop app that has a yank function.

In most Unix systems you should be able to go to the beginning of a line, press Ctrl-k and then Ctrl-y to yank. At the very least your browser and terminal should understand those two commands.

Re:Vim GIFs by kedean on Thursday July 21, 2016 @04:54PM (#12139989)
Conversely, in many windows apps, ctrl+y is the 'redo' command.
Re:Vim GIFs by jcurbo on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @12:25AM (#12126892)
I feel like emacs is the same way. All the talk of buffers, kill rings, yanking, etc always threw me off. I'm used to it now but I feel that audiences that are used to Windows/Mac style 'normal' text editors probably bounce hard off of vim/emacs pretty often because of the different way of doing things.
Re:Vim GIFs by TeMPOraL on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @02:27AM (#12127239)
Hard to fault Emacs for that. It's older than Windows, it's older than the IBM convention of CTRL+C / CTRL+V. And older in this industry usually doesn't mean worse.
Re:Vim GIFs by bluebeard on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @04:23PM (#12124605)
Z could be seen as a visual representation of taking the line on the bottom and moving it to the top.
Re:Vim GIFs by a3n on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @05:04PM (#12124882)
Z looks like a folded piece of paper, edge on.
Re:Vim GIFs by optimuspaul on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @04:04PM (#12124436)
What!?! vim is the most unintuitive application I have ever used. Having to understand that y means yank (and then what yank means) is one of the very reasons it is not intuitive. it's like the masonic editor, don't know the right handshake or password you don't gain entrance to productivity.
Re:Vim GIFs by joemi on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @04:25PM (#12124621)
> vim is intuitive ( -ish?) once you understand what each character means

That is a much different statement than simply saying "vim is intuitive", which is the statement it appears you're arguing against. I doubt there's anyone in the world who would attempt to make such a bold claim as that.

I've found the "vim is intuitive once you understand what each character means" claim to be pretty accurate. Before learning what the keys did, it seemed like a laughably impossible-to-use program, but after learning what the keys do, it feels very natural and composable. Sure, some of that is due to muscle memory, like hjkl for movement, but a lot of that are things like "p for paste", "d for delete", "n for next", and so on. Those, to me, seem like very intuitive mappings.

Re:Vim GIFs by boomlinde on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @10:31PM (#12126474)
That it can be "intuitive once you understand what each character means" seems a bit oxymoronic to me. A design is intuitive or it isn't. That you can figure out a complex and cluttered design and use it to your advantage over time by trawling through manuals and guides doesn't make it intuitive. Your intuitive understanding of the design may improve, but that applies even to the most brain breaking concepts, so it's hardly a useful way to look at it.
Re:Vim GIFs by naibafo on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @04:14AM (#12127533)
Well, some basic commands would be intuitive but aren't anymore, because most applications use very different keys or because our vocabulary changed. I.e. y(ank) and p(aste). However, once you know them they do make more sense then ctrl-v for paste (was that chosen because v is next to c on the keyboard?).

What I think becomes really intuitive once you understand the basic commands however is the combination of them. If you know that 'dd' deletes a line, it is very intuitive to me that '4dd' deletes 4 lines.

Re:Vim GIFs by joemi on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @04:47AM (#12127639)
Others have explained it better in threads near this one than I could, but the short response to this is that intuitiveness is personal and contextual.
Re:Vim GIFs by boomlinde on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @09:27AM (#12128817)
Sure, it's personal to some extent, but have you ever seen anyone sit down with a Vi/Ex/Ed-like for the first time and intuitively figured out how to work it?

It's also contextual for sure, but for the word to be meaningful at all in a UI design sense, one surely must draw the line somewhere before the required context is to know the editor from experience or by having studied its documentation. Otherwise it's an absolutely useless thing to point out for the sake of discussion. Anyone can use complex things intuitively given some exercise. That doesn't make things like theoretical physics particularly intuitive in themselves.

Re:Vim GIFs by city41 on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @07:08PM (#12125642)
vim has an initial hurdle of being extremely unintuitive. But once you start learning the vim "language", you find it builds on itself and intuitiveness increases a lot.

For example d is the delete command and w is the "move by word" command, so dw is "delete word". / is the search command, so /foo searches for the first instance of foo in the document. You can intuitively figure out that d/foo is "delete everything until the first found foo", and that is exactly what it does.

Re:Vim GIFs by Arnavion on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @09:47PM (#12126321)
>You can intuitively figure out that d/foo is

"delete the first found foo"

Makes more sense to me than "delete everything until the first found foo" at any rate.

Intuitiveness is subjective.

Re:Vim GIFs by city41 on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @10:04PM (#12126381)
You wouldn't think that if you used vim. I don't want to turn these comments into a vim tutorial so I simplified it a bit. But in the framework of vim, d/foo and what it does is totally intuitive and easy to figure out on your own. With vim when you learn a new command it applies to all the movements you know and vice versa.

EDIT: rereading my comment, I should have said "/foo moves to the first instance of foo in the document" to correlate how / is a movement just like w is a movement (w is "move by one word")

Re:Vim GIFs by Arnavion on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @10:48PM (#12126529)
>EDIT: rereading my comment, I should have said "/foo moves to the first instance of foo in the document" to correlate how / is a movement just like w is a movement (w is "move by one word")

Yes, then it makes much more sense.

Re:Vim GIFs by CaptSpify on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @04:08PM (#12124457)
I love vim, but it really is the anti-thesis of intuitive design. I think that's actually it's strength, in a weird way.
Re:Vim GIFs by cgag on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @04:14PM (#12124506)
Yeah, I'm not here for intuitive, I'm here for power.
Re:Vim GIFs by beefield on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @05:10PM (#12124925)
I find it somehow odd that often many people equal good UI with easy to learn UI. They _can_ be the same, if we have an application that is rarely used more than once, but for an application that is used often and a lot, they typically seem to be very different animals. Notepad has probably the easiest UI to learn while being as probably the crappiest text editor for any serious use with any significant installation base ever created. Vim is the other way round. It is extremely easy to do something with data using Excel. For any serious data management you are doing much better working with a database.
Re:Vim GIFs by TeMPOraL on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @02:29AM (#12127241)
"Intuitive" is anything that happens to fit into the preconceptions you have. Vim is older than most software you've ever used, therefore seems unintuitive. If you were born 20 years earlier, it would be perfectly intuitive to you.
Re:Vim GIFs by weavie on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @05:17AM (#12127727)
Indeed. Vim is a lot more intuitive than Ed.
Re:Vim GIFs by chongli on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @12:51AM (#12126971)
Eh, the cockpit of a 747 isn't intuitive either. Intuitive is orthogonal to powerful.
Re:Vim GIFs by randomdrake on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @06:33PM (#12125450)
Understanding what each character means isn't necessarily the goal, however. They're the basic words and commands to manipulate text, but really you should be learning how to speak to Vim to get it to do what you want. You need to string together multiple words to make a sentence sometimes. Vim lets you do that. If you're not willing to take the time to do this: you're right, Vim isn't for you. It definitely takes more effort and practice than a lot of other editors.

Intuitiveness becomes more clear once you realize you need to learn the language to make things intuitive.

You can't just start speaking Spanish to someone and expect to get them to do what you're asking if you don't know how to speak Spanish, yet. You can poke and prod at words here and there (memorizing what each character means) but you still aren't very effective at that point. Can you ask where the bathroom is? Sure. But can you effectively tell someone where the correct bathroom is? Probably not.

"I want to yank those two lines, paste them over there, select them, and replace all instances of 'foo' with 'bar'."

Vim:

> 2YjjpVj:s/foo/bar/pg

Like speaking other languages, there are a number of ways you could tell Vim to to do what you want.

Now let's look at other editors when you want to tell it what to do. Other editors:

> Remove right hand from keyboard and put it on mouse

> Move cursor to appropriate position

> Click the button down, and drag it until the two lines are highlighted

> Crtl+C

> Move the mouse cursor

> or move your right hand again to the arrow keys

> Ctrl+V

> Ensure your text is still highlighted in some way

> (May require repeating previous steps)

> Ctrl+F or Ctrl+R or something, depending on the app

> Get into one box and enter "foo"

> Get into another box and enter "bar"

> Ensure you have selected "selected text" so everything doesn't get replaced

> Hit <enter> or click

The infamous Stack Overflow answer, "Your problem with Vim is that you don't grok vi," is an oldy but a goody.

http://stackoverflow.com/a/1220118

Re:Vim GIFs by aninhumer on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @06:59PM (#12125591)
Of course, if you expand every input out to a full line, it's going to look worse than a string of keypresses. However if we compare more fairly:

vim: 2YjjpVj:s/foo/bar/pg

Sublime: ^L^L^C↓↓^V↓^Ffoo<Esc>^Dbar

(This assumes there are only 2 instances of "foo", but you'd just have to press ^D a few more times otherwise.)

And sure moving your hand to ↓ takes slightly more time, but it's still no where near as bad as your screed makes out. And if you really care, you can make new shortcuts for movement (by editing a simple JSON file).

Personally, my experience is of using vim for several years, and then becoming approximately as proficient in Sublime in a matter of weeks, and then much more productive in a matter of months. And sure, I wasn't putting that much effort into learning vim, but then, I wasn't putting that much effort into learning Sublime either.

Re:Vim GIFs by flukus on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @11:22PM (#12126650)
>Of course, if you expand every input out to a full line, it's going to look worse than a string of keypresses. However if we compare more fairly:

Expanding them into new lines outlines the time spent though. ^L is no where near as fast as 2Y.

Re:Vim GIFs by drewgross on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @11:56PM (#12126786)
I would say it's faster since with 2Y you have to lift your finger off the 2 before you can press the Y, but with ^L you leave your finger on the ^ while you press the L so it doesn't even really count as 2 full key strokes. (not to mention you have to press ESC half the time in Vim to even get to the mode where "2" is what you want to do)
Re:Vim GIFs by flukus on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @12:23AM (#12126889)
You're right, I completely misread the post I replied to.

A minor nitpick though, in vim you aren't pressing escape to get to that mode, it's the normal mode, it's where you should always be.

Re:Vim GIFs by drewgross on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @03:46AM (#12127446)
I usually use Sublime but when I'm ssh'ed to a machine I use vim, so I have some experience. I find that I need to exit insert mode to run commands about half the time, or maybe a little less than half the time, in order to run commands. Maybe thats just due to the type of thing I usually edit though. I don't have enough vim foo to know how to do this, but maybe you do: can you record a session and see how often you pressed escape? I'd be interested to know how often various people press escape.
Re:Vim GIFs by flukus on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @07:33PM (#12133397)
We press escape a lot, many even map it to something more convenient like caps.

The point I was making though is that with vim you don't exit insert mode to run commands, you enter insert mode to write text and then immediately exit to normal mode.

It may sound pedantic, but it's a core part of understanding vim. Insert mode is the mode you should spend very little time in.

Re:Vim GIFs by aninhumer on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @04:12AM (#12127529)
I suspect vim users don't notice because they instinctively press Esc as soon as they're done using insert mode, so they don't think of that as part of the next command. And I think that's fair tbh, it's just something your fingers do while you're thinking about what to do next.
Re:Vim GIFs by klue07 on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @04:01PM (#12124406)
Call me old fashioned, but I still think the best way to learn Vim is vimtutor. Then just google whatever you might need or consult :help.
Re:Vim GIFs by ycitm on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @05:26PM (#12125050)
Some nice intuitive stuff in the help, too.

  :help paragraph

  [...] The default is "IPLPPPQPP TPHPLIPpLpItpplpipbp" [...]
(they're nroff macros, but pretty baffling to a beginner)
Re:Vim GIFs by mrb on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @06:29PM (#12125431)
+1 to vimtutor. I learned with it 15 years ago and this was the fastest way for me to memorize many vim features.
Re:Vim GIFs by _virtu on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @05:04PM (#12124886)
Just want to plug that it's worth the money. I mastered all sections of the vim course and it has definitely proven me useful over the last year. I don't normally develop in vim, but IDEAVim for Intellij products seems to be enough functionality to make me happy. Just remember, it takes consistency, lots of consistency.
Re:Vim GIFs by gnaritas on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @04:44PM (#12124753)
> im is intuitive ( -ish?) once you understand what each character means

If you have to understand it first to find it intuitive, then it isn't intuitive.

Re:Vim GIFs by nikki93 on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @05:31PM (#12125089)
Hmm I disagree. At first it isn't intuitive, then it becomes intuitive after practice. I think what the commenter meant by "once you understand" is "once you have practiced." Sort of like how skiing becomes intuitive but isn't at first, or such.
Re:Vim GIFs by gnaritas on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @05:59PM (#12125265)
That's not what intuitive means, especially not in the context of a UI.

> At first it isn't intuitive,

Then it isn't intuitive. An intuitive UI is one that requires little to no instruction because it just works and is discoverable naturally, vi/vim are exactly the opposite, they are the most unintuitive UI practically ever invented. There is nothing remotely intuitive about vi/vim. The barrier to entry is huge and is the main reason people don't use this editor.

> Sort of like how skiing becomes intuitive but isn't at first, or such.

Skiing isn't intuitive either. Getting good requires practice, that you had to practice it to get the feel for it means exactly that it isn't intuitive. Once you're good, it's not because it's intuitive, it's because you practiced and taught yourself new muscle memory.

Re:Vim GIFs by nikki93 on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @06:15PM (#12125359)
No one is said vim is an intuitive UI, or whatever. It's simply the conditional like A => B, where A is "you know what c, a and w" mean, and then B is regarding another feature that becomes intuitive once A is true. Pick anything that you think is intuitive and I'll show you a prerequisite for it, and some times that prerequisite is sort of "bootstrap human knowledge" like "touching things that move."

For a moment, try stepping away from the semantics of what 'intuitive UI' means as a holistic thing, and think of it this way: when you read an angry letter from someone, you are immediately flustered, or something. This happens intuitively. But it only happens if you already know how to read the words and what they mean. It isn't intuitive if you don't know the language. Intuition is perspectivized and based on prior context, etc. The human using the tool is defined by their history, stuff like that. The commenter is just saying, the way I see it, given X in the history of the user, where X is "understands what each character means" (this is now assumed as part of the user's identity), that some other aspects of the entire vim-as-a-text-editor process becomes intuitive.

Yet another example is, an app meant for musicians, like Ableton, where some things are intuitive because they have rhythm and/or melody knowledge or know what filters are, but isn't intuitive if they don't. It's a spectrum. The most interesting questions are often about such nuance. Vim is interesting, and it has stuck around.

I don't know, but I personally care less about semantics than about the human-processes that actually result from the way programs are. Call it 'intuitive' or not, what do you see actually happening? What I see is people making really quick edits (I often see this in myself) that I can't do in other editors that I am able to do as an extension of myself sort of the same way I feel about playing percussion in a band.

Re:Vim GIFs by gnaritas on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @06:28PM (#12125421)
> No one is said vim is an intuitive UI, or whatever.

Yes actually he did say vim is intuitive; don't tell me no one said X when they very well did say X.

You're failing to understand that I perfectly well understand what he's saying and I'm objecting to the use of the word intuitive; yes, that's semantics which I care about.

I don't need to take a step back or look at it another way because I'm not confused by his message, I'm objecting to his vocabulary. If that doesn't interest you, that's fine, move along. But it interests me because I'm pedantic and I enjoy discussing how a message is conveyed as well as just what's being conveyed. Just because you don't care about semantics doesn't mean others don't. Semantics matter if words are to convey meaning and every reply to a post doesn't have to share what you value about the post. If I want to debate the semantics of a word with the OP then I damn well will and it's not your place to come along and tell me I shouldn't, nor tell me I need to see it another way.

reply to OP below: As you admit the point is debatable, then you can't question my debating it. I understood your intent as well, so what, I wasn't questioning your intent, I'm questioning your choice of words to convey that intent. So no, I don't.

Re:Vim GIFs by nikki93 on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @09:39PM (#12126289)
No they said "vim is intuitive, once X." Which is a different statement. It means "X => vim is intuitive," which can also be true when the antecedent (X) is false if going down the material implication route. Here X is "once you understand the characters."

I think what's happening is that even if we agree on definitions of intuitive, what I'm trying to add is the context around the "vim is intuitive" statement that it is scoped in. It is scoped by the "... once ..." qualifying fragment after it.

Also I'm not really saying what you should or shouldn't do. I'm saying try, because it could be fun; I want to see what happens when you take it there, sort of as a "hmm hey can we try this?" situation. It isn't as much a convincing as a "hey here's how I understand what he said--what do you think of that?" situation. More about going away with things to think about than "cool, I think I'm the person that won this argument." You're welcome to not try this, and I'll walk away, it's totally fine.

FWIW I agree that the unqualified "vim is intuitive" wouldn't be reasonable to say. I'm just trying to explore the nuance.

Re:Vim GIFs by kartD on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @06:38PM (#12125483)
Actually, you do, when I said " vim is intuitive ( -ish?)", the -ish? is meant to convey the point is debatable and not an objective statement (user joemi and nikki93 understood my intent). I think I was right in saying that, seeing the number of replies to my comment.

Edit: funnily enough I added it (the -ish?) 30s after posting because I imagined this scenario, guess I could have been more clear.

Re:Vim GIFs by kartD on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @08:44PM (#12126074)
If we're being so precise about everything, I'd like to point out that unless there is research that can objectively define and measure what intuitive is (we could still argue even after that) there isn't much of a point in debating the contents of my statement, especially when it acknowledges subjectivity.
Re:Vim GIFs by nemetroid on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @05:16PM (#12124978)
Once you understand what c, 2, a and w mean (individually, in context), the command "c2aw" is intuitive.
Re:Vim GIFs by aninhumer on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @06:28PM (#12125419)
Is it? I know what those characters mean, and I used to use vim, but I'm really not sure how they'd compose here. What does it mean to change and append at the same time?

In fact I just tested it and I'm still not clear what c2aw does. It seems to just do the same thing as c2w.

Re:Vim GIFs by jonchang on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @08:42PM (#12126063)
It does something similar to c2w if your cursor is at the beginning of a word. But if your cursor is already in the middle of a word c2aw may be faster / more intuitive than doing bc2w.

"a" can mean "append" but in this context (as the argument to a command) it means to change "a word". See :h aw for details.

Re:Vim GIFs by JetSpiegel on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @03:06AM (#12127336)
It's better to think of it as "all word", as opposed to "iw" as "inner word". It's easier to think about with "it" for "inner XML tag", apply stuff only between the opening and closing tags, of "at" for the whole thing, tags included. So "dat" would delete the tag and its content, while "cit" would change the content of the tag.
Re:Vim GIFs by gnaritas on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @06:08PM (#12125321)
That command might be intuitive to a vim user, but vim itself is anything but intuitive to someone who doesn't already know it. I'm disputing the intuitiveness of vim, which is what was claimed, not the intuitiveness of a key combination to a vim user.
Re:Vim GIFs by tkjef on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @03:04PM (#12123998)
+1 for shortcutfoo.com

been using it since beta. has grown to cover quite a bit more since then.

Re:Vim GIFs by pawelduda on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @04:57AM (#12127673)
+1 for shortcutfoo.com. This is the tool that made my transition into Vim really easy. I cannot recommend it enough.