It's really not: the people that hold Kissinger in high regard today (and those that did so then) did so specifically because of things like this, not despite them.
Note, though, that regard for Kissinger is rather mixed; while some hold him in high regard, some think of him as one of America's leading war criminals.
In the quote above, “Yahya hasn’t had such fun since the last Hindu massacre!”, Kissinger seems delight and reveal in about his crimes against humanity. He spent his life chasing the power necessary to perform such crimes and when given such power was happy to use it for hideous purposes.
Kissinger from the Nixon tapes:
“And if they put Jews into gas chambers in the Soviet Union,” he added, “it is not an American concern. Maybe a humanitarian concern.”[0]
In one tape Nixon compares the genocide in Bangladesh to the Holocaust, Kissinger goes along with the comparison but argues that the genocide should still be aided[1].
[0]: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/12/17/nyregion/17nyc.html?_r=0
[1]: http://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/looking-away-from-ge...
Wow, that is just shocking. Originally, I thought he was just another racist like Nixon. But for a Jewish holocaust survivor to make a comment like that... he seems to fit the textbook definition of a psychopath.
If a reader had never heard anything about World War 2 perhaps it wouldn't be the first book to recommend or even number 10. Given the exhaustive pop culture coverage in movies along with endless documentaries and books one would assume reading Human Smoke in context would not leave a reader believing that Hitler was desperately trying to avoid war.
I'm not sure how you regard these as mutually exclusive. Are the events that go into the collection not chosen? Might they not be chosen with an eye toward suggesting conclusions which the one doing the choosing isn't quite bold enough to espouse outright, preferring instead to be able to say "well, that's just your interpretation" in reply to whatever criticism may come?
>I stopped the jeep. Cloth seemed to fall from the bodies, the head was held up by a stick that once might have been a throat. Poles hang from the sides where arms should be, poles are the legs. “What’s your name?” And the man’s eyes cloud and he takes off his hat in anticipation of a blow. “Folek… Folek Sama.” “Don’t take off your hat, you are free now.”
>And as I say it, I look over the camp. I see the huts, I observe the empty faces, the dead eyes. You are free now. I, with my pressed uniform, I have lived in filth and squalor, I haven’t been beaten and kicked. What kind of freedom can I offer? I see my friend enter one of the huts and come out with tears in his eyes. “Don’t go in there. We had to kick them to tell the dead from the living.”
>That is humanity in the 20th century. People reach such a stupor of suffering that life and death, animation or immobility can’t be differentiated any more. And then, who is dead and who is alive, the man whose agonized face stares at me from the cot or Folek Sama, who stands with bowed head and emaciated body? Who was lucky, the man who draws circles in the sand and mumbles “I am free” or the bones that are interred in the hillside?
>Folek Sama, your foot has been crushed so that you can’t run away, your face is 40, your body is ageless, yet all your birth certificate reads is 16. And I stand there with my clean clothes and make a speech to you and your comrades.
>Folek Sama, humanity stands accused in you. I, Joe Smith, human dignity, everybody has failed you. You should be preserved in cement up here on the hillside for future generation[s] to look upon and take stock. Human dignity, objective values have stopped at this barbed wire. What differentiates you and your comrades from animals[?] Why do we in the 20th century countenance you?
>Yet, Folek, you are still human. You stand before me and tears run down your cheek. Hysterical sobbing follows. Go ahead and cry, Folek Sama, because your tears testify to your humanity, because they will be absorbed in this cursed soil, dedicating it.
>As long as conscience exists as a conception in this world you will personify it. Nothing done for you will ever restore you.
>You are eternal in this respect.
That is his own discription[0] that he wrote shortly after being part of a US army group who liberated a concentration camp.
Kissinger lost 13 family members, including his grandmother to the camps.
[0]: http://www.tabletmag.com/scroll/194615/kissinger-on-liberati...
The difference between the two is that I wouldn't let my engineer part win, but Kissinger would.
The people who consider him a war criminal can't do anything about it. For those that don't, he's a national hero, and will be buried with full honors when his time comes. Sadly, that says a lot about the moral compass of this country.
As a youth I was more conservative. But even then, when I thought I liked him, he was pressed by more liberal students of the local college about covert action in Cambodia, or another contentious issue.
His smug response and style, as in history will remember favorably for my GTD style of realpolitik, even then far more conservative than my current self, found that repulsive and alarming.
I expected that from fellow HSers. But then again I was young and did not realize all politicians in the US are welcomed to act like children.
Coming from German Jewish background, how can he himself not cringe on the effectiveness of genocide comment?
The current crop of those running the country worship him. H. Clinton was on the line to him whenever she needed to figure something out.
If you only take advice from nice people, how can you then understand evil?
Do you believe that because of his failure to accomplish much?
Or do you just disagree with his methods?
What do you mean with "just"? The methods employed to reach a goal can have downsides (side effects) that dwarf the benefits of reaching the goal.
What do you think his goals were? What were the side-effects of his methods? How did the latter detract from the former?
For example, if the goal is American hegemony, and only foreign losses were realized in pursuit of that goal, then it's a clear victory from a policy standpoint. Morality doesn't enter into it.
Possibly an even more apt slogan for the gates of an extermination camp than "Arbeit Macht Frei"
Everyone wants to clutch pearls here, and to do so without supporting their positions. This place has gone to shit.
“Among those marked for extinction in addition to the A.L. hierarchy are student leaders and university faculty. …
“Moreover, with the support of the Pak[istani] military, non-Bengali Muslims are systematically attacking poor people’s quarters and murdering Bengalis and Hindus.”
He and 20 diplomats later sent a famous protest telegram in which he called what was occurring “genocide.” Kissinger responded to Blood’s complaints by dismissing him from his post. “The use of power against seeming odds pays off,” Kissinger observed regarding the crackdown.
The death toll is commonly estimated between at 200,000 and 3 million. Kissinger’s tacit support for the massacres in Bangladesh is one of many incidents contributing to his poor record on human rights."
"In July 1971, Kissinger had already secretly flown from Pakistan to Beijing for the first diplomatic meeting between the United States and Communist China. “Yahya hasn’t had such fun since the last Hindu massacre!” Kissinger remarked."
Wow. It's hard to believe that this is the same Kissinger that's still held in high regard today.